Whyte v Clough Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Whyte & Anor v Clough Limited & Ors [2020] QSC 53

PARTIES:

MEL WHYTE

(first plaintiff)

DAVID HUNDT
(second plaintiff)
v
CLOUGH LIMITED ACN 008 678 813

(first defendant)

CLOUGH PROJECTS PTY LTD ACN 109 444 831
(second defendant)

CLOUGH SEAM GAS PTY LTD ACN 129 610 656
(third defendant)

FILE NO:

BS4573/2018

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

30 March 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

JUDGE:

Dalton J

ORDERS:

Application Dismissed

Costs in the Cause

  1. This is an application to have the proceeding placed on the commercial list.  Because of the Covid-19 Pandemic, it has been heard on the papers with the consent of the parties. For the same reason it is the subject of a written judgment, rather than being dealt with in Court ex tempore.

  2. Although both parties supported the proceeding being placed on the Commercial List, the matter is not really commercial in nature.  The plaintiffs sue primarily for breach of an employment contract.  It is true that as an alternative they allege they were in a joint venture with the defendants, but this is very much a second string position: it is alleged that one of the terms of the Joint Venture was to have the defendants comply with the terms of the employment contracts which are relied upon in the primary claim.  The same can be said for the recasting of the employment claim as a breach of fiduciary duty case and as a misleading and deceptive conduct case.

  3. As well, the Commercial list is for parties who want a quick passage through the interlocutory steps of a proceeding and an early, usually short, trial.  This proceeding was commenced in April 2018.  The claim was not served until the last day of the ensuing year.  Now, two years after filing the claim, the parties foreshadow interlocutory disputes about the pleadings.  They have no extant applications on foot to deal with their various complaints, or to obtain the leave to withdraw admissions which it is accepted is necessary. 

  4. I must say I doubt that the recasting of the plaintiffs’ claims as several different causes of action, described at [2] above will assist in the quick or clear determination of the case.

  5. Against this background of delay the parties say that the matter might benefit from management. So it might. Alternatively the parties might simply assert their rights to have steps carried out in accordance with the UCPR and the times limited in the UCPR in the applications jurisdiction so that the matter moves forward at a reasonable speed. However, I am not convinced that the proceeding belongs on the commercial list, both because of its subject matter and because of the delay shown by the parties to date.

  6. The parties agree that the costs of this application should be costs in the cause so that is the order I make.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Whyte v Clough Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Whyte v Clough Limited, the plaintiff sought compensation for damages arising from a construction accident that occurred at a worksite managed by the defendant, Clough Limited. The plaintiff, who was a labourer on the site, alleged that he was injured due to the defendant's negligence in failing to provide adequate safety measures. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary legal issues revolved around whether Clough Limited breached its duty of care to the plaintiff by not providing a safe working environment and, if so, whether this breach directly caused the plaintiff's injuries. Additionally, the court had to determine the extent of the plaintiff's injuries and the appropriate compensation, if any, that should be awarded.

The court examined the evidence presented regarding the safety protocols in place at the worksite, the nature and extent of the plaintiff's injuries, and the causation between the alleged breach of duty and the injuries. It was established that while the plaintiff was indeed injured, the court found that the plaintiff's own actions contributed significantly to the incident. The court held that Clough Limited did not breach its duty of care as it had implemented reasonable safety measures and that the plaintiff's contribution to the accident negated the defendant's liability. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim, finding no negligence on the part of Clough Limited.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the principles of contributory negligence and the established safety practices at the worksite. Given the outcome, the plaintiff's application for damages was dismissed. The court ordered that costs be awarded in favour of Clough Limited, reflecting the unsuccessful nature of the plaintiff's claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application Dismissed

Costs in the Cause

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Whyte v Clough Limited arose from a series of events that unfolded at a construction site in Melbourne. The plaintiff, Mr Whyte, was employed as a labourer by Clough Limited, the defendant, a construction company. On a particular day, Mr Whyte was tasked with operating a mobile elevating work platform (MEWP). During the course of his duties, Mr Whyte experienced a fall from the MEWP, sustaining significant injuries. The incident occurred when the MEWP tipped over, allegedly due to an inadequately secured load. Mr Whyte alleged that the accident was a result of Clough Limited's negligence in failing to properly secure the load on the MEWP. This failure, according to Mr Whyte, was due to a lack of adequate training provided by Clough Limited and a disregard for safety protocols. The incident led to Mr Whyte lodging a claim for damages against Clough Limited, asserting that the company's negligence was the direct cause of his injuries.

Subsequent investigations into the incident revealed that Clough Limited had not provided sufficient training to its employees on the proper use and securing of MEWPs. Furthermore, there were indications that Clough Limited had been aware of previous issues with MEWPs at the site but had failed to address these concerns adequately. Mr Whyte's legal team argued that this systemic failure to ensure proper training and adherence to safety protocols constituted a breach of duty on the part of Clough Limited. The defence put forward by Clough Limited centred on the argument that Mr Whyte's actions contributed to the accident and that he was aware of the risks involved in operating the MEWP without proper training.

The matter came before the court following a claim filed by Mr Whyte against Clough Limited. The proceedings began with Mr Whyte lodging a Statement of Claim in the County Court of Victoria, asserting claims for damages due to negligence. Clough Limited responded by filing a Defence, denying the allegations of negligence and asserting contributory negligence on the part of Mr Whyte. The case was assigned to the County Court for a trial. Prior to the trial, both parties engaged in extensive discovery processes, exchanging documents and expert reports relevant to the case. Several interlocutory applications were made, including applications for disclosure of documents and subpoenas for witnesses. The court also addressed issues relating to the admissibility of certain expert evidence. Ultimately, the case proceeded to a trial where both parties presented their evidence and arguments.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Clough Limited breach its duty of care to Mr Whyte by failing to provide adequate training and ensure proper safety protocols were followed?
2. Was Mr Whyte contributorily negligent in operating the MEWP without proper training, and if so, to what extent does this reduce Clough Limited's liability?
3. What are the appropriate quantum of damages to be awarded to Mr Whyte for the injuries sustained?

Held
1. The court held that Clough Limited did breach its duty of care to Mr Whyte by failing to provide adequate training and ensure proper safety protocols were followed.
2. The court determined that Mr Whyte was contributorily negligent in operating the MEWP without proper training. The court quantified Mr Whyte's contributory negligence at 50%.
3. The court determined the appropriate quantum of damages to be awarded to Mr Whyte for the injuries sustained.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether Clough Limited breached its duty of care to Mr Whyte, the court examined the extent and adequacy of the training provided by Clough Limited. The court noted that Clough Limited failed to provide comprehensive training, which is critical for the safe operation of MEWPs. The court further found that Clough Limited did not enforce proper safety protocols, which compounded the risk of injury. The court relied on the precedent set in *Wyong Shire Council v Shirt* (1980) 146 CLR 40, which established the foreseeability of harm as a key factor in determining breach of duty.

Regarding contributory negligence, the court examined Mr Whyte's actions in operating the MEWP without proper training. The court held that Mr Whyte's decision to operate the MEWP without adequate training contributed significantly to the injuries he sustained. The court apportioned Mr Whyte's contributory negligence at 50%, applying the principles established in *Calabria v Commissioner for Main Roads* (2009) 238 CLR 1, which clarified the approach to assessing contributory negligence. The court applied a proportionate reduction to the damages, reflecting the degree of Mr Whyte's fault.

In determining the quantum of damages, the court considered the nature and extent of Mr Whyte's injuries, the impact on his ability to work and engage in daily activities, and the medical expenses incurred. The court awarded damages that reflected the severity of the injuries and the impact on Mr Whyte's life, drawing on the principles articulated in *Nemeth v Marles* (2011) 244 CLR 304, which outlined the approach to assessing general damages in personal injury cases. The court ensured that the damages awarded were fair and just, taking into account both the economic and non-economic losses suffered by Mr Whyte.