Whitsunday Aerial Solutions Professionals Pty Ltd v Emprja Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Whitsunday Aerial Solutions Professionals Pty Ltd v Emprja Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 1548

File number(s): BRG 603 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE BAIRD  
Date of judgment: 8 July 2021
Catchwords: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – COPYRIGHT – copyright infringement – oral agreement – where third party (Project 64) commissions applicant to shoot certain video footage by drone mounted camera of event at Airlie Beach for 2016 Clipper Round the World Yacht Race – applicant asserts oral agreement to own copyright – Project 64 provides footage to respondent - applicant asserts respondent granted limited permission to use footage for the sole purpose of producing a video for the promotion of the 2016 Clipper Round the World Yacht Race – respondent posts videos containing parts of footage online and provides copies of footage to third parties – applicant asserts respondent infringes its copyright in footage – respondent denies applicant is owner of copyright – respondent denies infringement – respondent asserts licence to copy and use footage in videos not restricted – communication right – deed of assignment – retrospective – s 196(3) and (4) of Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) considered – applicant elects damages and asserts entitlement to additional damages pursuant to s 115(4) of Act – application dismissed
Legislation: Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), ss 86, 98(3), 101(1), 115, 196(3), 196(4)
Cases cited:

ABC v XIVth Commonwealth Games Ltd (1988) 18 NSWLR 540

ACP Machinery Australia Pty Ltd v Aerospace Technologies of Australia (No 3) [2013] FCA 718; (2013) 103 IPR 435

Chhabra v McPherson as Trustee for the McPherson Practice Trust [2018] FCA 1755; (2019) 138 IPR 1

Franklins Pty Ltd v Metcashtrading Ltd [2009] NSWCA 407; (2009)76 NSWLR 603

Microsoft Corporation v PC Club Australia Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1522; (2006) 67 IPR 262

Traderight (NSW) Pty Ltd & Ors v Bank of Queensland Ltd (No 17) and 13 related matters [2014] NSWSC 55

Traderight (NSW) Pty LTD v Bank of Queensland Ltd [2015] NSWCA 94

Number of paragraphs: 300
Date of last submission/s: 28 March 2019
Date of hearing: 11, 12, 14 March 2019
Place: Brisbane
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr B Gardiner
Solicitor for the Applicant: King & Wood Mallesons
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C G C Curtis
Solicitor for the Respondent: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

ORDERS

BRG 603 of 2018
BETWEEN:

WHITSUNDAY AERIAL SOLUTIONS PROFESSIONALS PTY LTD (ACN 602 736 523)

Applicant

AND:

EMPRJA PTY LTD (ACN 135 384 039)

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE BAIRD

DATE OF ORDER:

8 JULY 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.DIRECTS the parties to confer, and within 14 days, provide to the Chambers of Judge Baird proposed short minutes of orders on costs.

3.DIRECTS, if the parties are unable to reach agreement on costs, by 23 July 2021, each party serve and provide to the Chambers of Judge Baird their submissions on costs, limited to 2 pages.

4.STANDS OVER the proceeding to a date to be fixed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Whitsunday Aerial Solutions Professionals Pty Ltd v Emprja P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 1548
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Whitsunday Aerial Solutions Professionals Pty Ltd (WASP) brought proceedings against Emprja Pty Ltd (APM) concerning the copyright and licensing of aerial footage captured during the 2016 Clipper Race stopover at Airlie Beach. WASP, a drone operator, alleged that APM had infringed its copyright by using footage it had provided for purposes beyond the scope of any agreed licence. APM, in turn, contended that its use of the footage was authorised under an agreement with Project 64, which had engaged WASP to capture the footage. The matter came before Baird J.

The court was required to determine several key issues. These included whether WASP or Project 64 owned the copyright in the 2016 Clipper footage. Further, the court had to ascertain the terms of the oral agreement between WASP and Project 64, specifically whether copyright was to be owned by WASP and if Project 64 was granted a limited licence to use the footage for promoting its HeliTaxi business and for APM to produce a promotional video of the event. If copyright was not found to be owned by WASP as a matter of law, the court needed to consider whether Project 64 had granted an unrestricted licence to APM. Finally, the court had to determine the scope of the licence granted by Project 64 to APM, specifically whether it was limited to producing a video promoting the 2016 Clipper Race or permitted broader promotional use without restriction.

Baird J considered the evidence presented by the parties, including witness statements and oral testimony, noting discrepancies in accounts regarding the agreements and conversations. The court examined the nature of the sponsorship agreement between Mr Burfitt (representing Project 64) and APM, and the subsequent engagement of WASP to capture specific footage. The judge analysed the conflicting evidence regarding the terms of the agreement for the footage, particularly concerning any alleged restrictions on its use. The court rejected WASP's characterisation of APM's position as asserting an unrestricted perpetual licence, finding it to be a mischaracterisation of the evidence and a confusion of non-exclusive rights with exclusivity.

The court's final orders and the specific findings on ownership and the scope of the licence were not detailed in the provided text. However, the issues framed indicate that the court was tasked with resolving the dispute over copyright ownership and the extent of APM's licence to use the footage, which would ultimately determine whether any infringement had occurred.

Background

Background to the litigation

Whitsunday Aerial Solutions Professionals Pty Ltd (WASP) is a business that provides aerial photography and aerial cinematography services, primarily in the North Queensland region. WASP is owned and managed by Ms Louise Brown and Mr Plahn, who live and work together. In January 2016, WASP was approached by Mr Burfitt, who wanted footage of the Clipper Race stopover at Airlie Beach for promotional purposes. Mr Burfitt, who operates a helicopter business, initially offered to provide the footage using his helicopters at reduced rates, but later decided to engage WASP to capture the required drone shots due to safety concerns and the short notice. According to Mr Burfitt, he and Mr McCaul from APM (the respondent) had an agreement that the footage provided by WASP would only be used for the purpose of producing a video promoting the 2016 Clipper Race. However, Mr McCaul denies that any such conversation took place or that any such statement was made.

Emprja Pty Ltd (APM) is a respondent in this case and operates a marina in Airlie Beach. APM and WASP's client, Project 64, entered into a sponsorship agreement for the Clipper Race stopover event in January 2016. As part of this agreement, Project 64 provided APM with footage shot by Mr Burfitt and WASP, including footage of the arrival and departure of the Clipper Race fleet. APM contends that it was granted a licence to use this footage for promotional purposes related to the 2016 Clipper Race and the Marina. WASP disputes this and claims that the licence was limited to the production of a single promotional video for the 2016 Clipper Race. WASP further alleges that APM has infringed its copyright by using the footage for various other promotional purposes without authorisation.

Whitsunday Aerial Solutions Professionals Pty Ltd (WASP) initiated legal proceedings against Emprja Pty Ltd (APM) in the District Court of Queensland, seeking relief for alleged copyright infringement related to aerial footage taken during the 2016 Clipper Race stopover at Airlie Beach. WASP, a business specialising in aerial photography and cinematography using drones, claimed that APM, the operator of Airlie Beach Marina, had infringed on its copyright by using the 2016 Clipper footage in various promotional materials without proper authorisation. The case came before the court following a series of events that included negotiations and agreements between WASP, APM, and Project 64, a company associated with the Clipper Race event. Key to the case was the interpretation of an oral agreement and the scope of a purported licence to use the footage. The matter proceeded through several procedural steps, including the filing of statements of claim and defences, discovery of documents, and witness testimonies. Notably, the court had to consider the credibility and consistency of the parties' evidence, particularly regarding the terms of the alleged agreement and the nature of the licence granted to APM. The case's procedural history is marked by submissions on the admissibility of evidence and the scope of the court's inquiry, focusing on the interpretation of contractual terms and the application of copyright law.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In relation to the October 2018 deed of assignment s196 of the Act is relevant. I refer to it below in my consideration of the deed and its effect. THE EVIDENCE AND CONSIDERATIONParties and participants I refer to the parties, principal witnesses, and other relevant persons as they were in the lead up to, and as at the time of, the 2016 Clipper Race stopover at Airlie Beach in January 2016, unless I state otherwise. In doing so, I observe that in their witness statements Ms Brown and Mr Plahn describe themselves, their experience, and WASP’s business predominantly as at the time of their witness statements in 2018, and not as at January 2016. A different picture emerged at hearing with their, and Mr Burfitt’s oral evidence.WASP WASP is the holder of a remote operator certificate that allows piloting of drones (unmanned aerial vehicles, or UAVs) up to 150kg for commercial purposes. WASP pleads, and APM admits, that at all material times WASP conducted a business which provides aerial photography and aerial cinematography services in the North Queensland region. Mr Plahn’s oral evidence under cross‑examination revealed, however, that for the first year or so from its commencement in 2014, WASP’s business was providing crop spraying services. His evidence was the photography side was started up later. As at January 2016, WASP had not long been operating that latter business. Mr Burfitt in cross‑examination disclosed that he first met Ms Brown and Mr Plahn several years earlier, as he and they were both franchisees of Yamaha R‑MAX aerial drones, which were designed for both obtaining video footage, and agricultural spraying, the latter being Ms Brown’s and Mr Plahn’s intended use. Mr Burfitt moved away from that drone within 3 months because it was not able to hold the camera he wanted it to hold. As at January 2016 WASP’s personnel were Ms Brown and Mr Plahn, who live and work together.Ms Louise Brown Ms Louise Brown is the director of WASP. She claimed to be the sole shareholder. Ms Brown made 3 witness statements in the proceeding, dated 31 August 2018, 26 November 2018, and 7 March 2019. She states that she is an experienced photographer, cinematographer, drone pilot and camera operator. She holds a remote pilot licence up to 150kg helicopters, and up to 25kg multi-rotor, that is, a licence to operate aerial drones commercially. Ms Brown’s witness statements were directed to describing WASP, and its photography and cinematography business, the making of the 2016 Clipper Footage, its delivery to Mr Burfitt, describing the 8 shots comprised in that Footage, and her conduct in 2018 upon finding out about the third party uses in videos posted online of parts of various of those 8 shots. Over the course of her 3 statements she identified the uses WASP claims are infringing. In her written evidence Ms Brown describes Mr Burfitt’s contact with Mr Plahn on 12 January 2016. In her first witness statement she also sought to give evidence of conversations to which she was not party, and summarised what she said was the agreement reached as to ownership of copyright in the footage before shooting in January 2016. Her witness statement contained key and other passages in nearly identical terms to those contained in the witness statements made by Mr Plahn and Mr Burfitt. I consider this aspect of their evidence later in these reasons.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Brown gave evidence that after the dispute arose WASP licensed both Whitsunday Regional Council and Tourism Whitsunday regarding certain of the alleged third party infringements for a once off fee of $500, and no fee, respectively. Parties’ positions on alleged infringements at conclusion of hearing In closing submissions, referring to descriptions or titles of videos it alleged infringed, WASP contended that the promotion licence plainly does not extend to the use of the Footage in a video produced for the promotion of the 2018 Clipper Race, or any other event such as the superyacht rendezvous, nor to use in relation to APM’s accreditation as a 5 Gold Anchor marina, or the promotion of the Marina’s progressive lunch, or to promote its ability to host superyachts at its Marina. WASP pressed its contentions that in addition APM authorised infringing publications of the 2016 Clipper Footage by Whitsundays Regional Council and Tourism Whitsundays. I have summarised APM’s principal denial of infringement earlier in these reasons (see at [27]‑[28] above). In short it says the provision of the 2016 Clipper Footage was further to the sponsorship agreement Project 64 entered into with APM, that Project 64 provided the 2016 Clipper Footage and other footage shot by Mr Burfitt for the purposes previously agreed, and without the alleged restrictions on use that WASP asserts, and that all the uses it made of any of the 2016 Clipper Footage were licensed. In written closing submissions WASP’s counsel characterised APM’s position as asserting “in effect an unrestricted perpetual licence to use for whatever purpose APM requires and even extends to provision to third parties if it is for the promotion of the region”, and submitted that “this was almost indistinguishable from ownership”. This submission must be rejected. It is not what APM contends, it is to mischaracterise Mr McCaul’s evidence, and to confuse non‑exclusive rights with exclusivity. APM did not contend that it had sole and exclusive rights. It did not contend it could prevent WASP, Project 64 or any other person from using the Footage. It did not contend its licence was “for whatever purpose APM requires”.Schedule A – infringements With the use of the parties’ agreed statement of facts, and both counsel’s closing submissions, the alleged infringements pressed by the conclusion of the hearing are identified in Schedule A annexed to these reasons.THE ISSUES The parties were agreed that the issues of ownership and scope of the licence to use for determination are:[1]whether the copyright in the 2016 Clipper footage is owned by WASP or Project 64 at all material times;[2]whether the [oral] agreement between WASP and Project 64 included terms that:(a)copyright in the 2016 Clipper Footage would be owned by WASP; and(b)Project 64 was granted a limited licence to use the 2016 Clipper Footage for the purposes of promoting the HeliTaxi business, and providing it to APM to produce a video of the welcome party and the media for promotion of the 2016 Clipper Race;[3]if I find that no, the agreement did not include terms that WASP owned copyright, then:(a)whether copyright in the 2016 Clipper Footage is owned by WASP as a matter of law; and(b)whether Project 64 granted an unrestricted licence to APM which authorised the conduct alleged to be acts of infringement in the proceeding;[4]whether the agreement between Project 64 and APM included a term that APM was granted a limited licence to use the 2016 Clipper Footage for the sole purpose of producing a video promoting the 2016 Clipper Race, or whether instead the licence permitted APM to use the 2016 Clipper Footage to promote the 2016 Clipper Race without restriction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Gordon was not required for cross‑examination.CONSIDERATION The sponsorship agreement Mr Burfitt’s evidence under cross‑examination is that at the start of 2016 Mr Burfitt saw the success of the Marina as a good thing because the more popular the Marina the greater the pool of potential customers for HeliTaxi. For this reason Mr Burfitt wanted to sponsor an event at the Marina as a way to jointly promote and also associate himself (HeliTaxi) with the Marina. Although Mr McCaul and Mr Burfitt agree they reached agreement that Project 64 would participate with APM in sponsoring the welcome party, both gave different accounts of their dealings in late 2015 and early 2016. Mr Burfitt claimed that he and Mr McCaul reached 2 agreements – an agreement for Project 64’s co-sponsorship of the welcome party, and a separate agreement further to a request by Mr McCaul that Mr Burfitt take some “footage for us to use in a promotional video about the event”, and that Mr McCaul asked for some helicopter shots of the arrival and departure of the race fleet. Mr Burfitt claims that he offered a 50% discount for the helicopter use, but would take the footage for free. He says that both the footage and the reduced helicopter rates were entirely separate to the sponsorship of the welcome party. He provides no explanation why this was so, nor did the evidence, taken as a whole support this claim. Mr Burfitt says further that on or about 12 January 2016, he and Mr McCaul had a conversation about the footage APM wanted, and that Mr McCaul then said he wanted “low angled shots” of the Marina and “the Clipper Boats”. In his witness statement Mr Burfitt says the conversation was as follows:[18]On or about 12 January 2018, Mr McCaul and I had a conversation about the footage that the Respondent wanted. To the best of my recollection, the part of the conversation about the low angled shots was to the following effect: Mr MCCAUL: We want low angled shots of marina and the Clipper Boats. ME: It will not be safe to take these shots, particularly at sunset, with one of my helicopters. We need to comply with our CASA licence. I have a good working relationship with a drone company called WASP, I should be able to get them to do those shots. They might give me a good price and should be able to do it at short notice. I will pay for the footage. MRMCCAUL: Yes, that sounds like a good solution. ME: I will contact them and ask them to do the shoot. In cross‑examination, contrary to the above, Mr Burfitt says that he had already offered to provide the helicopters at reduced rates before the email exchange dated 17 December 2015 (see below at [160]). In his witness statement Mr Burfitt then says that to the best of his recollection in the above conversation on 12 January 2016 he said to Mr McCaul to the effect that “the footage taken by WASP will only be able to be used for the purpose of producing the video promoting the 2016 Clipper Race” and that Mr McCaul said to the effect “we only need the footage for the one video”. Mr McCaul says no such conversation occurred, nor was any such statement made.