White v Marist Youth Care Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY A MEMBER

CITATION:

White v Marist Youth Care Limited [2023] NSWPICPD 41

APPELLANT:

Nathan White

RESPONDENT:

Marist Youth Care Limited

INSURER:

Catholic Church Insurances Limited

FILE NUMBER:

A1-W1863/22

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:

President Judge Phillips

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:

17 July 2023

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.     Order 4 of the Certificate of Determination dated 19 July 2022 is revoked.

2.     The remaining orders in the Certificate of Determination dated 19 July 2022 are confirmed.

3.     The matter is remitted back to the same Member to determine the issue of work capacity and the claim for weekly compensation in accordance with these reasons.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION – evidentiary value of medical records and the obligation of a member to consider the evidence – Mason v Demasi [2009] NSWCA 227 considered – Singh v FTW Products Pty Ltd [2007] NSWWCCPD 230 applied – requirement to respond to substantial, clearly articulated arguments – Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26; 77ALJR 1088 and Wang v State of New South Wales [2019] NSWCA 263 applied – failure to have regard to arguments in respect of work capacity – sections 33 and 37 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 – error in failing to consider consequential psychological injury when addressing capacity for work arising from a physical injury

HEARING:

On the papers

REPRESENTATION:

Appellant:

Mr D Adhikary, counsel

Slater & Gordon Lawyers

Respondent:

Mr T Murray, solicitor

Integroe Partners

DECISION UNDER APPEAL

MEMBER:

Mr P Young

DATE OF MEMBER’S DECISION:

19 July 2022

INDEX TO DECISION

INDEX TO DECISION

INTRODUCTION

ON THE PAPERS

THRESHOLD MATTERS

THE EVIDENCE

THE MEMBER’S REASONS

GROUNDS OF APPEAL

LEGISLATION

DISCUSSION

As to Ground One – The Member committed errors of law by not determining whether the appellant sustained injuries to his cervical spine and/or both shoulders on the balance of probabilities and on the basis of the whole of the evidence

Some principles in relation to the evidentiary value of medical records and the obligation of a member to consider the evidence

Consideration

As to Ground Two – The Member committed errors of law by requiring the appellant to have corroboration in order to succeed

Consideration

As to Ground Three – The Member committed errors of law and failed to accord the appellant natural justice by failing to respond to substantial, clearly articulated arguments

Some principles arising from Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Appellant’s submissions

Sub-Ground One

Sub-Ground Two

Sub-Ground Three

Respondent’s submissions

Sub-Ground One

Sub-Ground Two

Sub-Ground Three

Consideration

As to Sub-Ground One

As to Sub-Ground Two

As to Sub-Ground Three

As to Ground Four – The Member committed errors of law because he provided reasons that were neither rational nor logical

Consideration

As to Ground Five – The Member committed errors of law by failing to have regard to the appellant’s consequential psychological condition when addressing the question of capacity

As to Ground Six – The Member committed errors…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read White v Marist Youth Care Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICPD 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of White v Marist Youth Care Limited, the dispute centred on workers compensation claims made by the plaintiff, White, against the defendant, Marist Youth Care Limited. The matter was heard by the NSW Supreme Court. The primary issues before the court were the evidentiary value of certain medical records and the obligation of the tribunal member to consider the evidence thoroughly, particularly in light of the arguments made by the parties regarding the plaintiff's work capacity and consequential psychological injury.

The court examined the duty of the tribunal member to address substantial, clearly articulated arguments, drawing on established legal principles. It referenced Mason v Demasi [2009] NSWCA 227 and Singh v FTW Products Pty Ltd [2007] NSWWCCPD 230 to underscore the importance of giving adequate reasons and referring to the evidence. The court also considered Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26; 77 ALJR 1088 and Wang v State of New South Wales [2019] NSWCA 263 to highlight the necessity for a fair and lawful determination of the application. The tribunal member was found to have erred by not considering the arguments concerning the plaintiff's work capacity and the impact of psychological injury stemming from a physical injury.

The court concluded that the tribunal member's failure to adequately address the plaintiff's work capacity and the consequential psychological injury amounted to a material error. This oversight rendered the decision inadequate and thus subject to being set aside. The court mandated that the tribunal member's reasons should encompass all substantial arguments and evidence presented, ensuring a comprehensive and fair evaluation of the case. Consequently, the decision was quashed, and the matter was remitted for reconsideration by another tribunal member.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In Singh v FTW Products Pty Ltd [2007] NSWWCCPD 230,[64] Roche DP said the following when dealing with the requirement to give reasons and the obligation to refer to the evidence: “To succeed in having the decision set aside on this ground Mr Singh must demonstrate not only that the reasons are inadequate, but that their inadequacy discloses that the Arbitrator has failed to exercise his statutory duty to fairly and lawfully determine the application (YG & GG v Minister for Community Services [2002] NSWCA 247; Absolon v NSW TAFE [1999] NSWCA 311; ADCO Constructions Pty Ltd v Ferguson [2003] NSWWCCPD 21).The standard by which the adequacy of reasons must be determined is relative to the nature of the decision itself and the decision-maker (Mayne Health Group t/as Nepean Private Hospital v Sandford [2002] NSWWCCPD 6). An Arbitrator’s reasons should be read as a whole and it is not for a Presidential Member on review to comb through the Arbitrator’s findings and reasons in search of error (Beale v GIO (NSW) (1997) 48 NSWLR 430 at 444; Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Wu Shu Liang [1996] HCA 6; (1996) 185 CLR 259). It is not necessary for an Arbitrator to refer to every piece of evidence (Yates Property Corporation Pty Limited (in Liq) v Darling Harbour Authority (1991) 24 NSWLR 156; Ainger v Coffs Harbour City Council [2005] NSWCA 424).”[65] (emphasis added)[64] [2007] NSWWCCPD 230 (Singh).[65] Singh, [62]–[63]. In Roncevich V Repatriation Commission,[66] Kirby J said that the courts should “avoid overly pernickety examination of the reasons” and that “[t]he focus of attention is on the substance of the decision and whether it has addressed the ‘real issue’ presented by the contest between the parties”.[67] A similar approach was taken by Bellew J in Bevan v Bingham & Ors[68] in respect of an alleged failure of a Review Panel to properly disclose its reasoning in respect of the issue of costs, but is equally as applicable here. His Honour said as follows: “… In considering this issue, it is necessary to bear firmly in mind that the reasons of an administrative decision maker are not to be scrutinised by overzealous judicial review seeking to discern whether some inadequacy may be gleaned from the way in which the reasons have been expressed, nor are such reasons to be minutely construed with an eye keenly attuned to the perception of error.”[69] [66] [2005] HCA 40 (Roncevich).[67] Roncevich, [64].[68] [2023] NSWSC 19 (Bevan).[69] Bevan, [71], citing AAI Limited trading as AAMI v Boga [2020] NSWSC 1903; 95 MVR 17, [75]–[76] and the authorities cited therein. In addition to these decisions, I would remark that the Commission’s objects[70] and guiding principles[71] mandate that the Commission resolve the real issues in dispute justly, quickly and cost effectively.[70] Section 3 of the 2020 Act.[71] Section 42 of the 2020 Act. I would note that the respondent had always placed injury in issue in this matter, not only injury on 19 March 2017, but also the appellant’s various claims of injury to different parts of his body.[72] Given this was the manner in which the parties framed the dispute, it was thus necessary for the Member to grapple with what were clearly the “real issues” placed in dispute.[72] Notices issued by the Respondent’s insurer under s 78 of the 1998 Act dated 18 September 2017 (ARD, p 53), 30 November 2018 (reply, p 64) and 6 December 2021 (ARD, p 24).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.