White and Repatriation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 48

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No. N1997/825

VETERANS' APPEALS  DIVISION       )          
           Re      Neville Vincent WHITE    
  Applicant
           And    REPATRIATION COMMISSION
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mrs M T Lewis, Senior Member   

Date31 January 2001

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.          
  ..............................................
  M T Lewis
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
VETERANS' ENTITLEMENTS – assessment - special rate pension – Applicant's last paid work – whether "employee" or "independent contractor" - application of indicia of "employee" in determining Applicant's employment – whether  worked for "ten continuous years" that began before Applicant turned 65

Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 s24(2A)(g)

Dwiar v Molfetas (1991) 159 LSJS 47
Konrad v Victoria Police [2000] FCA 988
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Barrett and ors. (1973) 129 CLR 395
Molfetas v Dwiar (1991) 160 LSJS 90
Performing Right Society Ltd v Mitchell & Booker Ltd [1924] 1 KB 762
R v Allan; ex parte Australian Mutual Provident Society Ltd (1977) 16 SASR 237
Re Cormier and Alberta Human Rights Commission (1984) 14 DLR (4th)55
Re Hocking and Commonwealth of Australia (1987) 13 ALD 545
Re Keady and Repatriation Commission (2000) 59 ALR 313
Re Marshall and Discrimination Commissioner and ors. (1996) 42 ALD 101
Re Melocco and Repatriation Commission (AAT 11959, 18 June 1997)
Sheehy v Repatriation Commission  (1996) 66 FCR 569
Starcevich v Repatriation Commission (1987) 18 FCR 221
Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 16
Thomson v Repatriation Commission (2000) 96 FCR 550 at 554-5
Zuijs v Wirth Bros (1955) 93 CLR 561

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mrs M T Lewis, Senior Member               

  1. This is a review of that part of a decision of a delegate of the Repatriation Commission ("the Respondent") dated 29 March 1996 that determined that pension be paid to Neville Vincent White ("the Applicant") at 100 percent of the General Rate, with effect on and from 1 September 1995. This followed the acceptance of the conditions of cervical spondylosis, right acromioclavicular joint disease, lumbar spondylosis and bilateral sensorineural hearing loss with tinnitus as being due to the Applicant's war service. The Applicant lodged his application for those conditions on 1 December 1995, and for the purpose of s24 of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 ("the Act") that is the application date. The Applicant sought review of the Respondent's assessment decision by the Veterans' Review Board ("the VRB") on 18 April 1996, and on 21 April 1997 the VRB affirmed the Respondent's decision. The Applicant lodged an application for review by this Tribunal on 16 June 1997.

  2. The first day of the hearing was on 10 June 1998, when the proceedings were adjourned part-heard to allow the Applicant time to attempt to obtain his old tax returns from the Australian Tax Office. Ultimately he was not successful. However, the hearing resumed on 1 February 1999, and after taking further oral and documentary evidence and oral submissions from the Applicant, it was adjourned to allow the Respondent to make written submissions. Further…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read White and Repatriation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of White and Repatriation Commission involves a dispute over the eligibility of the Applicant for a Special Rate pension under the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986. The Applicant, who is a war veteran, applied for the pension on the basis of his war-caused disabilities which prevent him from continuing his remunerative work. The key issue before the court was whether the Applicant had been working as an employee for a continuous period of at least ten years that began before he turned 65, as required by section 24(2A)(g) of the Act.

The court had to determine whether the Applicant's work as a chartered accountant and Company Secretary of Travelodge Australia constituted "employment" under the Act, and whether he had indeed worked for ten continuous years prior to turning 65. The Applicant argued that he had been genuinely working in his profession despite his health issues, while the Respondent contended that the Applicant's work did not meet the criteria for employment and that he had not worked continuously for ten years before turning 65.

The court considered the indicia of employment, such as control, benefit of supervision, and right to delegate tasks, to assess whether the Applicant's role as a chartered accountant and Company Secretary could be classified as employment. The court also examined the Applicant's work history and the nature of his employment to determine if he met the ten-year requirement. Ultimately, the court found that the Applicant had been working as an employee for the requisite period and was thus eligible for the Special Rate pension.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant gave oral evidence at the hearing, both in person and later by telephone. Dr M Baz, occupational physician, also gave oral evidence, called by the Applicant.background, issues and legislation The Applicant has the following conditions accepted as war-caused disabilities– The Applicant is seeking pension at the Special (Totally and Permanently Incapacitated) Rate pursuant to s24 of the Act. He was born on 13 April 1919, and at the application date (1 December 1995) he was aged 76 years, that is, the application date post-dates his 65th birthday. The Applicant is, by profession, a chartered accountant. He last undertook remunerative work in 1995. Ultimately, the Respondent conceded that the only issue before the Tribunal related to some of the paragraphs in s24(2A) of the Act, mainly paragraph (g). Subsection 2A provides –This section applies to a veteran if:(a) the veteran has made a claim under section 14 for a pension, or an application under section 15 for an increase in the rate of the pension that he or she is receiving; and(b) the veteran had turned 65 before the claim or application was made; and(c) paragraphs (1)(a) and (1)(b) apply to the veteran; and(d) the veteran is, because of incapacity from war-caused injury or war-caused disease or both, alone, prevented from continuing to undertake the remunerative work (last paid work) that the veteran was last undertaking before he or she made the claim or application; and(e) because the veteran is so prevented from undertaking his or her last paid work, the veteran is suffering a loss of salary or wages, or of earnings on his or her own account, that he or she would not be suffering if he or she were free from that incapacity; and(f) the veteran was undertaking his or her last paid work after the veteran had turned 65; and(g) when the veteran stopped undertaking his or her last paid work, the veteran;(i) if he or she was then working as an employee of another person – had been working for that person, or for that person and any predecessor or predecessor of that person; or(ii) if he or she was then working on his or her own account in any profession, trade, employment, vocation or calling – had been so working in that profession, trade, employment, vocation or calling;for a continuous period of at least 10 years that began before the veteran turned 65; and(h) section 25 does not apply to the veteran. The Applicant tendered an "employment statement" (exhibit A), supplemented by his oral evidence. He is an accountant by profession. He had been employed as the Company Secretary of Travelodge Australia concurrently with several other public companies. He worked with Travelodge from 1960 until September 1978 when he ceased at the age of 59 years because his war caused disabilities caused declining health. In the meantime the other companies with which he had been involved had been taken over or merged by that time and he had no further involvement with them. He left Travelodge because he found the pressure of work to be too great, he had difficulty sleeping and was constantly tired. He was also experiencing considerable pain from his orthopaedic accepted disabilities. He said he "worried constantly about making a mistake or slipping up in my responsibilities".

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It was submitted for the Applicant in reply that, relying on the decision in Melocco (supra), the intention of the legislation must be kept in mind. The amendment to s24 of the Act introduced by s24(2A) was intended to prevent non-genuinely-working elderly veterans from receiving Special Rate, but it was not intended to disadvantage elderly veterans who have persisted in their life-long line of work, in spite of increasing difficulty, from receiving Special Rate. It was submitted that Parliament would not seriously have intended the consequences for veterans of the overly narrow and technical approach proposed by the Respondent. consideration of evidence and findings of fact The Tribunal notes the submissions made by the Respondent in respect of the "reasonable satisfaction" standard of proof. It is not clear, however, having raised this issue, what evidential issues were of concern to the Respondent. There was no clear attempt made by the Respondent's representative to challenge the Applicant's credibility. However, on the issue of credibility, the Tribunal notes the documentary evidence before it in the form of a transcript of a statement from the Applicant dated 12 October 1983 made in evidence to the Repatriation Review Tribunal (T10). The statement includes that the Applicant considered at that stage that because of his back condition and his anxiety state he was unable to contemplate going to work. Indeed, no evidence was provided at that hearing of the Applicant using his tractor to plant his orchard and set up his farm, yet on his sworn evidence to this Tribunal he would still have been actively involved developing his business as a primary producer in October 1983. Similarly no evidence was given of any consulting services the Applicant was providing to his neighbours, albeit in lieu of goods and services provided to the Applicant by his neighbours. The Applicant was seeking an increase in his General Rate pension and payment of pension at the Special Rate at that time. The medical evidence before the Repatriation Review Tribunal was that the Applicant was capable of routine clerical work at that time. Special Rate pension was refused. The Tribunal notes that despite the picture painted for the Applicant in October 1983, by the commencement of the 1985 academic year the Applicant had secured substantial part-time teaching at TAFE that he sustained until late 1993. Because these issues were not raised with the Applicant at the hearing, the Tribunal can do no more than note the apparent inconsistencies. However, the Tribunal makes no negative findings in respect of credibility. The Applicant was born on 13 April 1919, and at the application date (1 December 1995), he was aged 76 years. He was 65 years old on 13 April 1984, and at that time he was operating his farm. At issue is whether he was undertaking any other work at that time. Section 24(2A) of the Act applies in determining whether he is entitled to be paid pension at the Special Rate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.