Whitby-Smith and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Whitby-Smith and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 3446 (28 September 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/8264

Re:Sabine Whitby-Smith

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member K. Parker

Date:28 September 2021

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal decides that it has jurisdiction to hear and determine this application.

Pursuant to s 25(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal DIRECTS that the issues to be considered by the Tribunal in this application are limited to the types of supports listed in paragraph [11] of these Reasons for Decision, and whether all or any of them should be included in Ms Whitby-Smith’s statement of participant supports and funded under the National Disability Insurance Scheme.

.......[SGD].......................

Member K. Parker

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – powers of the Tribunal upon review – whether Tribunal has jurisdiction in respect of all supports requested by Applicant – determination of the matters before or put before National Disability Insurance Agency internal reviewer – whether direction should be made under s 25(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) to limit issues

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

CASES
Banovich v Repatriation Commission (1986) 69 ALR 395
Re Ewin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 4726
Re Fuad and Telstra Corporation Limited [2004] AATA 1182
Owen v Repatriation Commission (1995) 59 FCR 93
Re QDKH and NDIA [2021] AATA 922

Member K. Parker

28 September 2021

  1. The Respondent, the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA), has requested that the Tribunal decide whether it has jurisdiction to hear this application in respect of all the supports requested by the Applicant. The NDIA contends that the Tribunal only has jurisdiction to hear this application in relation to those supports “put before” the NDIA internal reviewer, and in support, relies upon the decision in QDKH and NDIA [2021] AATA 922 (QDKH). This decision is presently on appeal to the Federal Court of Australia.

  2. In QDKH, Deputy President Constance stated as follows:

    [24]In Fuad and Telstra Corporation Limited, the Tribunal President, Justice Downes, said:

    ... all matters put before the decision-maker as part of a claim under the [Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation] Act are before this Tribunal for review when an application for review is made, even though the decision may not address them in any particular way. That leaves a problem identifying exactly what was before the decision-maker but that is a practical problem and not a jurisdictional problem.[6]

    [25]It is important to note that the President referred to “matters put before the decision-maker”. [Emphasis added]. These are the matters in respect of which the Tribunal has jurisdiction.

  3. Further, Finn J of the Federal Court of Australia in Owen v RepatriationCommission (1995) 59 FCR 93, applying Banovich v Repatriation Commission (1986) 69 ALR 395, made the following observation (emphasis added):

    The provisions of the Act s 175(1)(a) and of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Whitby-Smith and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3446
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between Ms Whitby-Smith and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) concerning the scope of supports requested by Ms Whitby-Smith. Ms Whitby-Smith contended that she had raised all her requested supports during discussions with the NDIA internal reviewer. However, the NDIA's records, specifically an interaction note made by the internal reviewer the day before the decision under review, indicated that only three specific supports were being sought: 25 hours per week of support workers for daily assistance and community access, 24 hours of support coordination, and Level 1 transport funding. The internal reviewer did not provide evidence regarding these discussions.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine which supports were properly before the NDIA for consideration during the internal review process. This involved assessing the conflicting accounts of the discussions between Ms Whitby-Smith and the internal reviewer, and considering the documentary evidence available to the NDIA at the time of its decision. The Tribunal also considered whether it had jurisdiction to review all supports requested by Ms Whitby-Smith, and whether a direction should be made under s 25(4) of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth) to limit the issues for determination.

The Tribunal reasoned that in the absence of the internal reviewer's evidence, it was appropriate to examine key documents provided to the NDIA that were intended to inform the review of Ms Whitby-Smith's supports. These documents included a report from Ms Whitby-Smith's clinical psychologist, Ms Rachel Hinton, dated 10 August 2020, which recommended various supports including community support, psychological sessions, physiotherapy, house clearing, gardening, OT assessment, and funding for an online social support group. Additionally, a report from Ms Whitby-Smith's occupational therapist, Ms Julie Parry, dated 8 September 2020, detailed numerous recommendations aimed at increasing social and economic participation. These recommendations encompassed a wide range of supports, such as assistive technology (Microsoft Surface Pro, noise-cancelling headphones, Android smartwatch, task chair), therapeutic interventions (psychology, art therapy, exercise physiology, physiotherapy), social participation (online social group, driving lessons, cooking skills), increased support worker hours, home maintenance assistance (gardening, cleaning), and adaptive equipment (shower stool, painting stool). The Tribunal considered these reports as crucial evidence of the supports Ms Whitby-Smith sought to have reviewed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The parties are in dispute about which supports were requested by Ms Whitby-Smith under the NDIS leading up to the Decision Under Review. Ms Whitby-Smith asserted that when she was engaged in conversations with the NDIA internal reviewer, that she had asked him about all the supports. She said she remembered the discussion well. The NDIA records are at odds with this contention. The internal reviewer made an interaction note the day before the internal review decision (Decision Under Review), which states that only three supports were being requested, namely, 25 hours per week of support workers for daily assistance and community access, 24 hours of support coordination, and transport level 1 funding. The internal reviewer was not called at the jurisdictional hearing to give evidence about his discussions with Ms Whitby-Smith or Ms Whitby during the internal review process. The interaction notes were provided to the Tribunal, but Ms Whitby-Smith and Ms Whitby dispute the contents of those notes. In these circumstances, the Tribunal regards it as appropriate to consider the key documents that were provided to the NDIA, and to which the internal reviewer had access (irrespective of whether the internal reviewer accessed them), that were prepared for the purpose of informing the review of Ms Whitby-Smith’s NDIS supports. The Decision Under Review was made on 5 November 2020. On 10 August 2020, about three months before the Decision Under Review was made, Ms Whitby-Smith’s treating clinical psychologist, Ms Rachel Hinton, issued a report entitled “Review Letter for NDIS Support and Funding” (Ms Hinton’s Report). In this report, Ms Hinton recommended that Ms Whitby-Smith be provided with 20 hours of community support, monthly psychology sessions, twice-weekly physiotherapy sessions, house clearing, gardening support, OT assessment and support and funding to participate in an online social support group. On 8 September 2020, about two months before the Decision Under Review was made, Ms Whitby’s treating occupational therapist, Ms Julie Parry, issued a report entitled “NDIS – Functional Needs Assessment Report” (Ms Parry’s Report). A section of Ms Parry’s Reports is extracted below (emphasis added):SERVICE/SUPPORT RECOMMENDATIONS / COMMENTSBased on my assessment with Sabine, the following is recommended in order to increase social and economic participation. Please note recommendations put forward represent best value for money and are considered effective and beneficial:1. Provision of a Microsoft surface pro to assist with self-regulation, telehealth sessions and for art therapy.2. Noise cancelling headphones to assist with sensory overwhelm3. Psychology sessions on a fortnightly basis for management of her autism-related anxiety4. Ongoing Art Therapy to assist with self-regulation5. Sensory and relaxation aids such as a yoga mat and sensory items6. Assistance to connect in with some appropriate group activities (when this is safe).7. Sabine would like to be supported to attend a safe online social group such as Dungeons and Dragons. There is a particular group she likes to play with on. Sunday – it costs $120 for a 4 hour session (each Sunday). This is run by a support worker who has set it up for his own client. This may develop in to face to face social interaction once the COVID pandemic has passed and will assist with her relationship building.8. Support with regular Exercise Physiology sessions to help with muscle tone and overall strength and conditioning.9. Continued attendance with the physiotherapist for generalised muscle conditioning10. Assistance to complete her Learner’s Driver’s licence theory test e.g. online practice tests and also driving lessons.11. Sabine would like to learn how to cook meals in her own home. She would like the opportunity to create a grocery list, go shopping and then cook the meal in her own kitchen. To improve the learning, twice per week is recommended. She will also need additional support worker hours to attend medical appointments.12. Increase support worker hours to 35 hours per week to assist with development of Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (ADLs).13. Lawn maintenance as Sabine is unable to contribute to garden maintenance at all in the family’s rental property.14. Continued use of a domestic cleaner (3 hours per fortnight) as she is unable to undertake this activity herself.15. Sabine would benefit from purchase of a shower stool so she can safely shower and wash herself without fatiguing. Shower stools can be purchased for approximately $150 and an example of a suitable option includes the following: 150kg/16. Sabine likes to paint, however fatigues easily when painting. Purchase of a painting stool (plastic) would benefit her so she could perch when painting. The same stool could be used in the kitchen for when she is undertaking meal preparation. Sabine should attend some chair showrooms to sit on some stools to determine her best fit for a stool. One with a back rest would be ideal. These can be purchased for less than $400.17. An Android smart watch to assist Sabine with personal and medication reminders, calendar events, external memory aid functions, and to act as a GPS. Sabine really struggles with maths and a smart watch has an inbuilt calculator she can use when needed.18. Due to Sabine’s scoliosis, she will require a task chair for her studies which will provide her with good seated support. Without an appropriate and adjustable chair, she will struggle to maintain attention due to increased pain when seated. An example of a suitable chair includes the following: $255 Vocational assistance to secure some casual work around her studies.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established