DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Whiley v The Commissioner of Police [2021] QDC 241
PARTIES:
GEORGE WILLIAM WHILEY
(Appellant)
v
THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(Respondent)
FILE NO:
D25/2021
DIVISION:
Criminal
PROCEEDING:
Appeal – s 222 Justices Act 1886 (Qld)
ORIGINATING COURT:
Rockhampton Magistrates Court
DELIVERED ON:
29 September 2021
DELIVERED AT:
Rockhampton District Court
HEARING DATE:
23 September 2021
JUDGE:
Clarke DCJ
ORDER:
The appeal is allowed
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION – s 222 Justices Act 1886 (Qld) – failure to make out grounds of appeal – misdirection – rehearing required
LEGISLATION:
Justices Act 1886 (Qld) ss 222, 223, 225
CASES:
Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172
Teelow v Commissioner of Police [2009] QCA 84
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
Robinson Helicopter Company Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679
McDonald v Queensland Police Service [2018] 2 Qd R 612
Mbuzi v Torcetti [2008] QCA 231
APPEARANCES: The appellant appeared on his own behalf
Mr M Sutton, instructed by the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent
The appellant was convicted following a summary hearing, which proceeded over two days on 4 and 5 May 2021, of offences of public nuisance[1] and driving without due care and attention.[2] A global fine of $750.00 was imposed with no conviction recorded for the public nuisance offence.
[1]Section 6(1) Summary Offences Act 2005 (Qld).
[2]Section 83 Transport Operations (Road Use Management) Act 1995 (Qld).
The grounds of appeal are:
1.The magistrate made a crucial factual error when delivering his verdict; and
2.The magistrate failed to give proper attention to the hearing of evidence.
By leave, and by consent, the appellant added a third ground which had been identified in his outline of argument:
3.That (the magistrate) erred by failing to direct the prosecution in relation to my complaint witness collusion was occurring.
Appeal generally a rehearing on the evidence
Section 223 Justices Act 1886 (Qld) confirms an appeal under s 222 is by way of rehearing on the original evidence given in the proceeding the order is appealed against.
Courts have regularly determined the basic following principles apply: it is for the appellant to demonstrate some legal, factual or discretionary error;[3] the court is obliged to conduct a “real review”, and to make its own findings of fact, or draw its or draw its own inferences and conclusions.[4]
[4]Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; Robinson Helicopter Company Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679; McDonald v Queensland Police Service [2018] 2 Qd R 612.
In Mbuzi v Torcetti[5] Fraser JA said this:
The appeal proceeded under s 223(1) on the evidence given in the Magistrates Court. On such an appeal the judge should afford respect for the decision of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Whiley v The Commissioner of Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] QDC 241
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court first considered whether the grounds of appeal raised by the appellant were valid. The appellant contended that the magistrate had misdirected himself by considering inadmissible body-worn camera footage and that the witnesses had colluded to give consistent evidence. The court found that these grounds lacked substance and did not establish any error warranting a rehearing. However, the court also highlighted that the magistrate had taken into account irrelevant and inadmissible evidence, which was a significant error. Furthermore, the magistrate applied an incorrect legal test when evaluating the appellant's evidence, leading to a flawed conclusion.
The court determined that despite the appellant failing to substantiate the grounds of appeal, the magistrate's misdirection concerning the inadmissible evidence and the incorrect application of the legal test required a rehearing. The evidence of the appellant was not accepted by the magistrate, a conclusion the court found the magistrate was entitled to reach. However, the procedural errors and misapplication of the law necessitated a rehearing of the case to ensure a fair trial.
The court allowed the appeal and ordered a rehearing of the case to rectify the errors identified. The decision underscored the importance of adhering to legal principles and ensuring that all evidence presented is admissible and appropriately evaluated to maintain the integrity of the judicial process.
Orders
Orders of the court
The appeal is allowed
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The evidence of the appellant was ultimately not accepted by the magistrate. He was entitled, with respect, to reach that conclusion. Consideration of the grounds of appeal Turning to the grounds of appeal, ground 1 has no substance. The “crucial factual error” about the defendant riding in the middle of the road was simply part of the magistrate’s recitation of Ms Ganfield’s evidence. As to ground 2, I am not satisfied the magistrate was inattentive to the playing of the body-worn camera footage. It would perhaps be unsurprising if he was seen to rub his eyes and temples while watching an hour and a half of irrelevant footage.[15] The transcript shows the magistrate re-watched part of it and agreed with the appellant to skip other parts. The magistrate provided quite detailed ex- tempore reasons at the end of the hearing, based upon some of the contents of the footage.[15]Indeed, at the hearing of the appeal, the appellant contrarily asserted the Magistrate was “having a nap” while the footage was played. As to the third ground belatedly added, it also lacks foundation. The appellant’s complaint at the hearing and again on the appeal, is that witnesses were “colluding” prior to giving their evidence. Putting aside the fact the appellant was in the court room when he alleged this was occurring, one wonders what they could collude about, prior to giving evidence. They were each taken to their statements in cross-examination and to things they had apparently said on the body-worn camera footage. No recently invented evidence could be pointed to by the appellant to confirm the alleged conspiracy. The fact the evidence overall was consistent appeared to be the product of the witnesses simply recounting what had happened. Their individual accounts appeared largely consistent with other versions they were each taken to. Although the appellant has failed to demonstrate any of the grounds of appeal are made out, I am nonetheless of the view the magistrate misdirected himself in reaching his verdict. Firstly, he took into account irrelevant and inadmissible evidence in the form of the body-worn camera footage. No basis was advanced for the admissibility of the out of court hearsay statements. In my view, it is incumbent upon the prosecution to present only relevant and admissible evidence. On the appeal, the respondent was unable to point to any reason for admissibility. Although the appellant had contended at the hearing there was some discrepancy between what witnesses said on the day of the incident and on another occasion, the appropriate manner of attempting to prove a prior inconsistent statement was not followed. Of greater concern is the incorrect test applied by the magistrate in his consideration of what use to make of the appellant’s evidence and how he used that incorrect test as the basis to find the appellant guilty. His Honour said this, after summarising the defendant’s evidence:“That evidence itself was far from convincing as it related to the elements of the charges. Where his evidence conflicted with the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, I prefer the evidence of the prosecution witnesses. Having preferred that evidence, I find beyond reasonable doubt that on the offence date that the defendant…”[16]before going on to make findings of fact and finding the defendant guilty.[16]D5/25 – 30.