Wheeler and Smith v Body Corporate for Calypso Towers

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
CITATION: Wheeler and Smith v Body Corporate for Calypso Towers [2016] QCATA 66
PARTIES: Robert Wheeler and Michelle Smith
(Applicant/Appellant)
v
Body Corporate for Calypso Towers CTS 27849
MW Stone Pty Ltd
(Respondents)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL292-15
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: On the papers
DECISION OF: Senior Member Stilgoe OAM
Member Traves
DELIVERED ON: 3 May 2016
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE: 1.     The appeal is dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL –BODY CORPORATE - Appeal from decision of Adjudicator made under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 – exclusive use areas – where former owners of lots entered into reallocation agreement – where body corporate consented to the reallocation agreement but request to lodge new community management statement incorporating the agreement not recorded

Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), s 12, ss 46, 54, 66, 170, 171, 174, 176, 276, 289, 294, Schedule 5, Schedule 6
Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), ss 37, 49, 115L, 115K

Albrecht v Ainsworth [2015] QCA 220
Body Corporate for Palm Springs Residences CTS 29467 v J Patterson Holdings Pty Ltd [2008] QDC 300
Bossichix Pty Ltd v Martinek Holdings Pty Ltd  [2009] QCA 154
Cominos v Cominos (1972) 127 CLR 588
Crowbay Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for “Southbank Chambers” [2007] QCA 453.
Double Bay Properties v The Body Corporate for The Caribbean Kawana Island [2015] QCATA 30
Hannah v TW Hedley (Investments) Pty Ltd [2010] QCA 256
Talga Ltd v MBC International Ltd (1976) 133 CLR 622

APPEARANCES

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act).

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Robert Wheeler and Michelle Smith own Lot 73 in Calypso Towers CTS 27849.

  2. In 2006, the then owners of Lot 73 and Lot 105 agreed that Lot 73 should transfer its car park and storage space to Lot 105 and that Lot 105 would transfer its car park to Lot 73. The body corporate approved the agreement in 2006 but a new community management statement (CMS) was not registered.

  3. MW Stone Pty Ltd bought Lot 105 in 2010. Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith bought Lot 73 in November 2014.

  4. It was not until Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith purchased Lot 73, that the omission to record a new CMS, reflecting the 2006 agreement, was discovered. Both parties claim to be entitled to the car park and storage space transferred by agreement to Lot 105. The dispute before the adjudicator concerned whether the body corporate could be ordered now to record the new CMS reflecting the agreement made between lot owners in 2006.

  5. The determination by the adjudicator required the body corporate to prepare a new CMS reflecting the agreement entered into between the previous owners of lots 105 and 73, extended the time for lodging a request to record it and required the body corporate to lodge the request.[1]

    [1]        Calypso Towers [2015] QBCCMCmr 268.

  6. Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith have appealed the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wheeler and Smith v Body Corporate for Calypso Towers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCATA 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wheeler and Smith appealed the decision of an adjudicator who found that the body corporate was required to record a new Community Management Statement (CMS) showing the reallocation of car park C111 and storage area S30 to Lot 105. The appeal was based on two grounds: firstly, that the agreement to reallocate the exclusive use areas was conditional and therefore did not constitute a ‘further allocation’ within the meaning of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld); and secondly, that the adjudicator’s decision to require the body corporate to record a new CMS breached section 171 of the Act, which requires the written consent of the relevant lot owner to change an exclusive use by-law.

The court found that the agreement to reallocate the exclusive use areas was not conditional but unconditional, as the co-owner of Lot 73, Mr Evans, had clearly stated his intention for the reallocation agreement to take effect immediately and his consent was not conditional. The court also held that the reallocation agreement took effect once details of the allocation were given to the body corporate, which occurred in this case when the body corporate passed a resolution consenting to the agreement.

The court further found that there was no error of law in the adjudicator’s decision as section 171 was not relevant to the current owners of Lot 73, and the reallocation agreement did not require a change to the exclusive use by-law, only to the details recorded in Schedule E to the CMS. The requirement to obtain the consent of the affected lot owner applied to the lot owners immediately prior to the resolution consenting to the recording of the new CMS, which in this case were the owners of Lot 73 and Lot 105 in 2006.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the appeal and upheld the adjudicator’s decision that the body corporate was required to record a new CMS showing the reallocation of car park C111 and storage area S30 to Lot 105.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 16 September 2006, the Evans entered into a contract of sale of Lot 73 with Mr McKnoulty. That contract contained a special condition that the exclusive use of car park C111 and storage area S30 would be transferred to Lot 105 and that the contract was conditional on the Evans obtaining the approval of the body corporate and a new CMS being registered. It also provided that if the Evans were unable to obtain the approval and subsequent registration of the new CMS prior to settlement they could terminate the contract without penalty.[15] On 27 September 2006, the then owners of Lot 73 and Lot 105 executed an authority for the transposition of carpark C111 and storage space S30 (which used to attach to Lot 73) with carpark C31 (which used to attach to Lot 105).[16] The reallocation agreement provided:The Owners of Lot 105 and Lot 73 Calypso Towers have agreed to the transposition of the exclusive use of Carpark C31, currently attached to Lot 105 to Lot 73 upon the basis that Carpark C111 and Storage Space S30, currently attached to Lot 73 are to be transferred to Lot 105 and a new Community Management Statement to be prepared by Solicitors for the Owners of Lot 73. [17] On 10 October 2006, the body corporate approved the transposition between the original owners of Lots 73 and 105 by resolution without dissent.[18] The body corporate prepared and endorsed a new CMS reflecting the reallocation agreement but a request to record it was not lodged.[19] On 6 March 2010, MW Stone purchased Lot 105 from the Evans. MW Stone believed Lot 105 came with carpark C111 and storage space S30. This was because it was on the Body Corporate Disclosure Statement dated 3 March 2010, it was on the PAMDA Form 22a dated 6 July 2010 and the real estate agent had represented that the Lot included a carpark and storage space. MW Stone has enjoyed exclusive use of C111 and S30 since its purchase of Lot 105 in 2010.[20] On 14 October 2014, Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith signed a contract to buy Lot 73. On 25 October 2014, Mr Wheeler inspected Lot 73. He noticed most units had a storage space. He made enquiries of the real estate agent but was told that Lot 73 did not have a storage space. The contract did not provide that the car park or storage space was included and the Owner’s Information sheet attached to the contract dated 14 October 2014 had a column headed Car Space and Storage Space, which was left blank.[21] On 29 October 2014, Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith received the results of their solicitor’s searches including a CMS recorded with the Land Registry on 19 September 2013 which indicated Lot 73 was entitled to S30 storage space and the C111 car park. [22] The contract became unconditional on 3 November 2014.[23] On 5 November 2014 Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith contacted Mr Dickinson, a representative of Mantra, the service contractor and letting agent, requesting a photo of the storage space for their records. Mr Dickinson advised that Lot 105 was entitled to use the space but that the body corporate records had not been updated to reflect this. [24] Settlement of Lot 73 took place on 19 November 2014.[25] The next day Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith contacted MW Stone and, a few days later, the original owners of Lot 73, the Evans. On 24 November 2006, Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith received a copy of the reallocation agreement and new CMS.What constitutes a ‘further allocation?’[26] Section 176(1) provides:Within 3 months, or a longer time stated in an order of an adjudicator under the dispute resolution provisions, after the taking effect of a further allocation, the body corporate must lodge a request to record a new community management statement showing all allocations currently in place when the body corporate consented to the recording of the new statement.[27] ‘Further allocation’ means ‘agreed allocation’.[4] ‘Agreed allocation’ is defined in Schedule 6 by reference to s 171(1)(b)(ii).[4] Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), s 176(4).[28] Section 171(1)(b)(ii) provides, relevantly, that the common property to which an exclusive use by-law for a community titles scheme applies must be:(a)specifically identified in the by-law; or(b)allocated – (i) by a person (who may be the original owner or the original owner’s agent) authorised under the by-law to make the allocation (an authorised allocation); or(ii) by 2 or more lot owners under a reallocation agreement (an agreed allocation).[29] The issue is whether there was an ‘agreed allocation’ between the relevant owners of lots 73 and 105 within the meaning of s 171(1)(b)(ii). [30] A ‘reallocation agreement’ is defined in Schedule 6 to mean:An agreement in writing under which 2 or more owners of lots for which allocations are in place under an exclusive use by-law agree to redistribute the allocations between the lots.[31] In the circumstances, each of two lot owners redistributed to the other their respective allocations. [32] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith submit that ‘agreement’ in this context must mean an unconditional one. We disagree. An agreement can include a conditional agreement. In any event, the agreement was not conditional.[33] The co-owner at the time of Lot 73, Mr Evans states, in his affidavit dated 17 November 2015 at [7]: I intended for this reallocation agreement to take effect immediately. My consent to the reallocation agreement was not conditional in any respects, including on the successful settlement of the property under the First Purchase Contract or the First Contract of Sale.[34] The adjudicator found that this was a binding agreement. We agree. It is a binding agreement between two lot owners based on mutual promises, namely to transfer allocations to each other. It is irrelevant that the purchase of Lot 105 was made conditional on the sale of Lot 73 and that the sale of Lot 73 was made conditional on the seller obtaining the consent of the body corporate to the transfer of exclusive use allocations and the registering of the new community management statement. Not only were these conditions in different independent agreements, the Evans could waive those conditions. When does a reallocation agreement ‘take effect?’[35] Under s 174(1), an agreed allocation has no effect unless details of the allocation are given to the body corporate. [36] There are no other provisions which deal with the time from when an agreed allocation is to take effect. It is reasonable to infer from this that once details are provided, the allocation takes effect. The issue of consent is not relevant at this stage. Consent affects only whether a new CMS can be recorded.[5][5] Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), s 54(2).[37] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith submit that the transfer was to place at a future time and that the agreement could not therefore have “taken effect” until then. There is no requirement in the legislation that the redistribution of allocations under the agreement has to occur immediately or have occurred prior to notification to the body corporate of the agreement. Indeed, it is logical that the notification and approval by the body corporate to the transfer take place first. [38] In conclusion, we agree with the adjudicator’s conclusion that that the body corporate was required to lodge a request to record a new CMS once a binding agreement had been entered into and once details of that agreement had been notified to the body corporate. Both elements were satisfied in this case.No error of law in relation to the pre-conditions to the application of s 176[39] We find no error of law inherent in the adjudicator’s determination that the agreement of 27 September 2006 was a reallocation agreement within the meaning of the Act. [40] As discussed above, all that needs to be satisfied in order for a “reallocation agreement” to exist is that there be an agreement between two lot owners for which allocations were in place under an exclusive use by-law and under which they agreed to redistribute the allocations between the lots.[41] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith submitted that the exchange of exclusive use rights was conditional on the sale of Lot 105 to the owners of Lot 73. We do not agree. In our view it was not the transfer agreement that was conditional but the contract of sale of Lot 73 that was conditional on the transfer of the exclusive use entitlement to Lot 105. [42] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith also submitted that there was no reallocation agreement because the transposition could not happen until some time in the future, that is, once the settlement of Lot 105 took place.[43] In our view, there is no legal force in this argument. The further allocation ‘takes effect’ once the details of it are given to the body corporate. This is implicit in s 174(1) which provides:An authorised or agreed allocation has no effect unless details of the allocation are given to the body corporate.[44] There is no requirement in the Act that the transfer or redistribution be immediate. [45] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith submit that the body corporate did not have notice that the Evans’ sales had been effected and, therefore, the assignment agreement was unconditional. [46] The body corporate did have notice that the sales had been effected; it is a normal part of conveyancing practice that the body corporate is notified of a new owner on settlement, if for no other reason than to update the records for billing purposes. The body corporate was given a copy of the agreement and passed a resolution consenting to it. Any argument that the body corporate needed further notification once the settlement of Lot 105 had occurred is a technical one and without merit. The body corporate was entitled to assume that the transfer would occur in accordance with the details of the unconditional agreement already notified to it.[47] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith point out that there is a provision in the Act which states that, where there is inconsistency between an agreement reached at conciliation and the Act, the agreement is ineffective to the extent of the inconsistency.[6] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith cannot rely on this provision to argue that the reallocation agreement was invalid. Firstly, the provision is limited in its terms to an agreement reached at conciliation. This agreement was not reached at conciliation. Secondly, the agreement is not inconsistent with the Act. As we have pointed out, the Act sets out a clear process for agreements about the reallocation of common property. The question for the adjudicator, and for us, is whether that process was followed. We have found that it was followed and that the adjudicator was correct in the conclusions drawn.[6] Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), s 252I(3).[48] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith also submit that, if the body corporate had acted against the Evans’ instruction and lodged the CMS even though the sale of the lots did not progress, there would have been legal action against the body corporate that would have been ‘undefendable’.[49] As we have already noted, the Evans wanted the reallocation regardless of the transfer of the lots, so the argument is an arid one. Further, the appeal tribunal is not inclined to deal with hypothetical situations. We have dealt with what, in fact, occurred and that is a sufficient answer to this ground of appeal.[50] We conclude that there has been no error of law demonstrated by this ground.Ground Two: That the adjudicator’s decision breaches s 171 of the Act. [51] Mr Wheeler and Ms Smith argue that the adjudicator’s exercise of the power in s 276 was in breach of s 171. They argue that s 171 provides that an exclusive use by-law can only be changed with the written consent of the relevant lot owner, which, they say, was themselves. It follows, they say, that as they provided no consent, the order is invalid.[52] Section 171 is not relevant to the current owners of Lot 73 and, for that reason, there has been no error of law by the adjudicator in failing to refer to it in the decision under appeal. [53] Under s 171, an exclusive use by-law may attach to a lot or stop applying to a lot only if the lot owner agrees in writing before the passing of the resolution without dissent consenting to the recording of the new CMS to either incorporate or not incorporate the by-law or the lot owner votes personally in the resolution. [54] The relevant exclusive use by-law was by-law 49. The exclusive use by-law provides, relevantly:Each owner for the time being of a Lot in the Community Titles Scheme ….shall be entitled to the exclusive use for himself and his licensee of the car space or spaces, identified in Schedule E of the Community Management Statement and delineated on plans 6894-104, 6894-105 and 6894-106 attached to the Community Statement, the identifying number or numbers of which shall be notified in writing ….to the body corporate within 12 months after the date of recording of the Community Management Statement. In respect of those spaces allocated pursuant to this By-law, the Committee hereby authorises to vary the allocations so made and to transpose spaces or any part of those spaces from one Lot to another Lot at any time and from time to time on the written request of the owners of the Lots involved. [55] There is an equivalent by-law in relation to storage spaces.[56] The reallocation agreement did not require a change to the exclusive use by-law, only to the details that were recorded in Schedule E to the CMS. There was, therefore, no need to comply with s 171.[57] In any event, the requirement to obtain the consent of the affected Lot owner applies to the lot owner immediately prior to the resolution without dissent consenting to the recording of the new CMS. That is, the relevant lot owners in 2006, not the current lot owner of Lot 73. [58] There was no further resolution without dissent required here. The relevant consent was the consent given by the body corporate on 10 October 2006 and the lot owners immediately prior to that resolution were the owners, at the time, of Lot 73 and Lot 105.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established