Wheare v Police; Wheare v Police

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Magistrates Appeal: Criminal)

WHEARE v POLICE; WHEARE v POLICE

[2023] SASC 23

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Nicholson 

17 February 2023

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - PROCEDURE - TIME FOR APPEAL AND EXTENSION

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - GROUNDS - GENERALLY

TRAFFIC LAW - LICENSING OF DRIVERS - QUEENSLAND - OFFENCES - DRIVING WHILE UNLICENSED OR DISQUALIFIED

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - DRIVING OFFENCES

Appeal against conviction and sentence.

Following a trial in the Magistrates Court, the applicant was found guilty of four offences:

(i) failing to comply with reasonable directions when undergoing a breath analysis procedure; (ii) driving whilst suspended from holding a licence; (iii) driving contrary to the terms of a defect notice and (iv) resisting police. The applicant was fined and disqualified from driving for 11 months and one week. The applicant was also sentenced to imprisonment for the total term of 24 days. The Magistrate suspended the term of imprisonment upon the applicant entering into a bond to be of good behaviour for two years.

The applicant has appealed against the convictions and sentences, out of time. The respondent submits that the leave to appeal out of time should be refused and the appeal dismissed.

Held:

1.      Leave to appeal out of time refused.

2.      Appeal dismissed.

Joint Criminal Rules 2022 (SA) r 191.3; Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) s 42; Motor Vehicles Act 1959 (SA) s 98B(1), s 98B(4); Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA) s 47E(3), s 91(5), s 145(6); Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) s 6(2), referred to.

Chan v Police [2014] SASC 35; Crotty v Police [2008] SASC 308; Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; Hili v The Queen (2010) 242 CLR 520; House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 357; R v Morse (1979) 23 SASR 98; R v Tran [2017] SASCFC 60; Rowland v Police (2001) 79 SASR 569; Shillabeer v Linnane (1979) 22 SASR 382; Tazroo v Police [2002] SASC 155, considered.

WHEARE v POLICE; WHEARE v POLICE
[2023] SASC 23

Magistrates Appeal: Criminal

  1. NICHOLSON J:      These reasons concern an application for an extension of time within which to appeal from decisions of a Magistrate sitting in the criminal jurisdiction.  On 4 January 2022, the applicant, Kym Randall Wheare, following a trial in the Magistrates Court, was found guilty of the following offences.[1]

    (i)Failing to comply with reasonable directions when undergoing a breath analysis procedure contrary to subsection 47E(3) of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA).

    (ii)Driving whilst suspended from holding a licence contrary to subsection 91(5) of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 (SA).

    (iii)Driving a vehicle contrary to the terms of a defect notice contrary to subsection 145(6) of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA).

    (iv)Resisting police contrary to subsection 6(2) of the Summary Offences…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wheare v Police; Wheare v Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Wheare v Police, the applicant, Wheare, appealed against his convictions and sentences for driving while unlicensed, driving contrary to the terms of a defect notice, and failing to comply with a police direction in relation to a breath analysis test. The case was heard by the South Australian Supreme Court, which found that the appeals were out of time and that an extension of time was required. The court had to decide whether an extension of time within which to appeal should be granted, considering the length of the delay, the reasons for the delay, and whether or not the prospective appeal was viable. The court found that the appeals were without merit and refused to grant an extension of time. The applicant had argued that the police witnesses were not credible, and the police were rude and aggressive, but the court found that the police witnesses gave their evidence in an honest and frank manner, and the evidence was consistent with the video footage. The court found that the applicant was a very poor witness but not dishonest. The court found that the factual basis for each of the four charges was proved at trial beyond reasonable doubt, and the appeals against conviction were without merit.

The court found that the applicant had not identified any error by the Magistrate and that there had been no error in the Magistrate's findings. The court found that the two photographs and the statutory declaration tendered on appeal did not assist with the applicant's defence to the offence of driving contrary to a defect notice as contended by him. The court found that the appeals both as to the convictions and the sentence were without merit, and an extension of time within which to appeal would be futile and was refused. The appeals were dismissed, and the respondent sought its costs of the appeals in the amount of $750. The court will hear from the applicant as to whether or not there is good reason not to award costs in this matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appeals are out of time and an extension of time is required. In deciding whether or not to grant an extension of time within which to appeal, the relevant considerations are: the length of the delay, the reasons for the delay and whether or not the prospective appeal is viable.[9] Ultimately, the discretion to extend time exists for the purpose of doing justice between the parties.[10] [9] R v Tran [2017] SASCFC 60 at [44] (Kelly J with Vanstone and Stanley JJ agreeing).[10] Crotty v Police [2008] SASC 308 at [42] (Kelly J).Evidence before the Magistrate and on appeal The prosecution adduced oral evidence from three police officers who had witnessed various aspects of the interactions and tendered a number of documents (exhibits P1 to P9) including two DVDs, containing vision and sound from a police body-worn camera of aspects of the first incident and of the second incident. The applicant gave evidence on his own behalf and tendered admissible parts of a Noarlunga Hospital Discharge Summary dated 19 December 2019 (exhibit D2).[11][11] Marked for identification as MFI-D1 is a brief doctor’s report that the applicant sought to tender. However, the author was not presented for cross-examination and following objection by the prosecution the tender was refused. At the hearing of the appeal the applicant sought to tender, as fresh evidence on appeal, a short statutory declaration dated 4 March 2022 by a friend who was present at the trial. I received this marked for identification as MFI-A1. He also sought to tender two photographs taken on the night in question; one of the applicant’s motor vehicle and another being a close up of the windscreen showing the location of the defect notice. I received these marked for identification as MFI-A2. Throughout the trial, the Magistrate provided such assistance to the applicant, as an unrepresented litigant, as was appropriate including assistance when cross-examining the prosecution witnesses and when giving his own evidence so that the applicant’s case might be adequately put before the court. Throughout the trial and the appeal, the applicant persistently criticised the police behaviour towards him during the night in question. According to the applicant, the police were rude and aggressive, and at times were physically violent. The applicant was and remains of the view that the police behaved very unfairly towards him and misused their powers. I accept that, in these respects, the applicant genuinely feels aggrieved, although, having reviewed the evidence, I do not share his view of the police behaviour. The Magistrate made appropriate efforts to assist the applicant to focus on and address the evidence adduced by the prosecution in support of the elements of each of the charged offences. However, the applicant remained focussed on his attack on the police witnesses for their perceived failures to treat him fairly and appropriately and, rarely, if at all, engaged with the prosecution case and its proofs.The Magistrate’s trial reasons

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant also seeks to appeal against the “loss of demerit points”. This aspect of the appeal is misconceived. Demerit points are incurred by operation of law when certain traffic offences are committed.[24] Demerit points are not imposed by a Magistrate as part of the sentence. However, in accordance with subsection 98B(4) of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959 (SA), the applicant was entitled “forwith” upon his conviction for the two offences which incurred demerit points,[25] to attempt to satisfy the Magistrate by evidence on oath that either offence was trifling or that other proper cause existed, in which case the Magistrate would have had the discretion to order that a reduced number or no demerit points were to be incurred. The applicant did not avail himself of this opportunity. Had he been unrepresented at the time, further considerations may have arisen before me.[26] However, the applicant was represented by counsel at the time sentencing submissions were made and at the time convictions were recorded. It is now too late to give effect to subsection 98B(4).[24] Motor Vehicles Act 1959 (SA), section 98B(1).[25] Failing to comply with a police direction in relation to a breath analysis test – 6 demerit points; driving contrary to the terms of a defect notice – 3 demerit points.[26] Shillabeer v Linnane (1979) 22 SASR 382; Chan v Police [2014] SASC 35.Conclusion The appeals both as to the convictions and the sentence are without merit. An extension of time within which to appeal would be futile and is refused. The appeals are dismissed. The respondent seeks its costs of the appeals in the amount of $750. Ordinarily this order would be made.[27] However, I will hear from the applicant as to whether or not there is good reason not to award costs in this matter.[27] Joint Criminal Rules 2022, rule 191.3.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Magistrate found that the police witnesses “gave their evidence in an honest and frank manner … [which evidence] on all essential matters [was] consistent with the [video footage]”.[14] His Honour found that the applicant “was a very poor witness” although not dishonest.[15]He maintained his position on what happened even in the face of the [body-worn camera footage] which, in my view, told a very different story to that put forward by the [applicant].Rather, I find that the defendant has a very real, but very misplaced, grievance about how he was treated that night. That grievance is such that he has lost perspective and the ability to assess the events of the night in an even-handed and balanced fashion.[14] Magistrate’s judgment at [67].[15] Magistrate’s judgment at [81]-[82].Consideration and resolution of the conviction appeal When it comes to assessing the evidence of the police witnesses and the applicant, the Magistrate had the natural advantage over me of having heard and seen them give their evidence. None of the considerations, as summarised and explained in Fox v Percy,[16] necessary to permit me to form a contrary view as to the credibility and reliability of the witnesses is made out. To the contrary, the body-worn camera vision and sound which I have had the advantage of reviewing supports both the evidence given by the police witnesses in material respects and directly supports the Magistrate’s findings concerning the interactions.[16] [2003] HCA 22; (2003) 214 CLR 118. In his section headed “Analysis”,[17] the Magistrate summarised his findings and conclusions of guilty with respect to each charged offence. I find no error of reasoning in that section.[17] Magistrate’s judgment at [84]-[105]. The applicant has not in his grounds of appeal nor in his written and oral submissions identified any error by the Magistrate. On my review of the evidence as a whole, there has been no error and the factual basis for each of the four charges was proved at trial beyond reasonable doubt. The appeals against conviction are without merit. I should say something briefly about the two documents the applicant sought to tender on the appeal. I, in effect, received them de bene esse. The two photographs, MFI-A2, were available in the prosecution brief of evidence prior to trial. They do not in any respect satisfy the test for “fresh” evidence on appeal. In any event, they do not assist with the applicant’s defence to the offence of driving contrary to a defect notice as contended by him. The statutory declaration, MFI-A1, only became available to the applicant at or about the time of its execution, 4 March 2022, some two months after the Magistrate’s judgment was delivered and almost four months after the police witness, the subject of the statutory declaration, gave his evidence on 10 November 2021. The declarant states that she attended the Christies Beach Magistrates Court on 9 December 2021. That was the second and last day of the trial. On that day, the applicant presented the defence case, including his own evidence, and closing submissions were given, following which the Magistrate reserved his decision.