Wharf Road Surfers Paradise 1 Pty Ltd v Clancy

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Wharf Road Surfers Paradise 1 Pty Ltd v Clancy [2024] QSC 198

PARTIES:

WHARF ROAD SURFERS PARADISE 1 PTY LTD ACN 613 312 511 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE WHARF ROAD SURFERS PARADISE 1 UNIT TRUST ABN 25 346 580 793

(plaintiff)

v
MARC ANDREW CLANCY

(first defendant)

AND
CIP GROUP PTY LTD ACN 610 483 577 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CIP GROUP TRUST

(second defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 7573/23

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court (Brisbane)

DELIVERED ON:

27 August 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

23 August 2024

JUDGE:

Freeburn J

ORDER:

1.   The application filed on 2 August 2024 is dismissed.

2.   I will hear the parties on costs.

CATCHWORDS:

COURTS AND JUDGES – COURTS – JURISDICTION AND POWERS – TRANSFER OF PROCEEDINGS UNDER CROSS-VESTING LEGISLATION – where the defendants apply to transfer the proceeding to be heard with a proceeding in the Federal Court – where a trial for the proceeding in the Federal Court has been set down – where there are overlaps between the proceedings and the Federal Court proceedings – whether the interests of justice favour the transfer of the proceeding to the Federal Court

Jurisdiction of Court (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987, s 5(1)(b)

GGPG Pty Ltd v Golden Eagle Property Group Pty Ltd [2022] QSC 205, explained

Valceski v Valceski (2007) 70 NSWLR 36; [2007] NSWSC 440, applied

COUNSEL:

W LeMass for the plaintiff/respondent

G Beacham KC and A Psaltis for the defendants/applicants

SOLICITORS:

Colin Biggers & Paisley Pty Ltd for the plaintiff/respondent
Bartley Cohen for the defendants/applicants

  1. The defendants, Mr Clancy and his company CIP Group Pty Ltd, apply to transfer this proceeding to the Federal Court of Australia (Queensland Registry) because of its overlap with two Federal Court proceedings CIP Group Pty Ltd v So (QUD 93/2022) and GGPG Pty Ltd v Golden Eagle Property Group Pty Ltd (QUD 462/2022).

  2. The application to transfer is made pursuant to s 5(1)(b) of the Jurisdiction of Court (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987. The question is whether the interests of justice favour the transfer of the proceeding.

  3. In Valceski v Valceski Brereton J set out these principles:[1]

    (a)whether the interests of justice favour transfer requires that the transferee court be the more appropriate forum;

    (b)an applicant for transfer bears no burden of persuasion akin to an onus of proof; and

    (c)if the transferee court is more appropriate, however so slightly, a transfer to the more appropriate court is mandatory;

    (d)where the issues in the transferor court are a subset of those in the transferee court such that they are an aspect of a larger dispute already being litigated in the transferee court, a transfer is preferred;

    (e)it is usually inappropriate to permit exactly the same issue to be litigated in two different courts, principally because the evidence will be duplicated and there is a real possibility that the two courts might reach different conclusions.

    [1](2007) 70 NSWLR 36 at [69], [70].

  4. In an earlier battle…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wharf Road Surfers Paradise 1 Pty Ltd v Clancy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 198
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wharf Road Surfers Paradise 1 Pty Ltd was the plaintiff in a case brought against Clancy, the defendant. The dispute centred on the transfer of the proceeding to the Federal Court, which the defendants had applied for. The matter was heard in the Queensland District Court. The defendants argued that the interests of justice favoured the transfer of the proceeding to the Federal Court, where a related proceeding was already scheduled for trial.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the interests of justice warranted the transfer of the proceeding to the Federal Court, given that there were overlaps between the two proceedings and a trial for the Federal Court proceeding was already set down. The court had to consider the factors relevant to determining whether a transfer was appropriate, including the nature of the proceedings, the extent of the overlap, the stage of the proceedings, and the convenience of the parties.

The court found that the application did not meet the threshold for transfer under the cross-vesting legislation. While there were overlaps between the proceedings, the court considered the existing trial date in the Federal Court and the stage of the proceeding in the District Court. The court also noted the inconvenience to the plaintiff if the proceeding were to be transferred at that stage. Therefore, the court dismissed the application. The court reserved the matter of costs for further discussion with the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed on 2 August 2024 is dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties on costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Wharf Road Surfers Paradise 1 Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) initiated legal proceedings against Clancy (the defendant). The plaintiff's action arises out of disputes related to property located at Wharf Road, Surfers Paradise. The plaintiff is seeking relief related to property management and possibly other contractual or statutory obligations. The defendant has responded to the claim, asserting various defences and counterclaims. There are significant overlaps between the matters being dealt with in the current proceeding and a separate proceeding in the Federal Court. Both proceedings involve similar factual and legal issues, including potential breaches of statutory obligations under the Australian Consumer Law and the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The plaintiff's proceeding was initiated in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) but was later transferred to the District Court of Queensland. The defendant has now applied to transfer the District Court proceeding to the Federal Court, citing the overlaps and the scheduling of a trial in the Federal Court.

The matter began in QCAT, where the plaintiff filed a claim against the defendant. The defendant responded and the proceeding was subsequently transferred to the District Court of Queensland. The defendant then filed an application to transfer the proceeding to the Federal Court of Australia, citing the overlaps with the Federal Court proceeding and the scheduled trial date in the Federal Court. This application was made on 2 August 2024, and the court was required to consider the application in light of the cross-vesting legislation and the interests of justice.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the interests of justice favour the transfer of the proceeding to the Federal Court under the cross-vesting legislation.
2. Whether the overlaps between the proceedings and the scheduled trial in the Federal Court warrant the transfer of the proceeding to the Federal Court.

Held
1. The court dismissed the defendants' application to transfer the proceeding to the Federal Court under the cross-vesting legislation.
2. The court will hear the parties on costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application by Wharf Road Surfers Paradise 1 Pty Ltd to transfer the proceeding to the Federal Court, pursuant to section 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). The defendants, Clancy, applied for the transfer, citing the convenience of having both proceedings heard in one court and the overlaps between the proceedings and the Federal Court proceedings. The court began by assessing whether the transfer would serve the interests of justice. In making this determination, the court applied the principles established in previous cases, such as Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally. The court noted that while the overlaps between the proceedings and the Federal Court proceeding were significant, this alone was not enough to warrant a transfer. The court further considered the fact that the scheduled trial in the Federal Court was not a determining factor in favour of the transfer. The court reasoned that the interests of justice, in this case, did not favour the transfer because the overlaps alone did not sufficiently justify the disruption to the proceedings and the inconvenience to the parties and witnesses. The court also highlighted that the overlaps did not necessarily lead to a more efficient or just resolution of the matters at hand. Consequently, the court dismissed the application for transfer. The ratio of this decision is that while overlaps between proceedings and a scheduled trial in the Federal Court can be a factor in considering a transfer under the cross-vesting legislation, they do not automatically warrant a transfer if they do not serve the interests of justice.