Wet Fix Holdings Pty Ltd v Gillion Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Wet Fix Holdings Pty Ltd v Gillion Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 67

File number: NSD 721 of 2017
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 5 February 2021
Catchwords: CONTRACTS – construction of agreements relating to the sale of a business – where one company was the operating entity and another company owned the assets of the business including the shares in the operating entity – claim for recovery of an alleged overpayment of the purchase price under a share sale agreement – where adjustments were made to the purchase price by reference to a balance sheet made available after settlement – whether applicant is precluded from raising objections to the purchase price and balance sheet – whether objections have been made out – claim dismissed – cross-claim for recovery of amount advanced under a vendor finance agreement – cross-claim allowed
Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hellicar (2012) 247 CLR 345

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104

Toohey v Gunther (1928) 41 CLR 181

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 327
Date of hearing: 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14 September 2020
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr E Hyde and Mr T Rogan
Solicitor for the Applicant: BT Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M Henry SC and Ms M Cowden
Solicitor for the Respondent: Brown Wright Stein Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 721 of 2017
BETWEEN:

WET FIX HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 606 009 116

Applicant

AND:

GILLION PTY LTD ACN 102 972 001

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 FEBRUARY 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 12 February 2021 the respondent is to file and serve an affidavit setting out the amount due to it on its cross-claim.

2.Subject to Order 3 below, on or before 19 February 2021 the parties are to provide to the Associate to Markovic J draft orders to be made giving effect to these reasons.

3.If no agreement is reached on the form of draft orders to be made giving effect to these reasons, on or before 19 February 2021 the parties are each to notify the Associate to Markovic J of the orders for which they contend and to provide submissions, not exceeding two pages in length, explaining why those orders should be made.

4.If agreement cannot be reached pursuant to Order 2 above, the proceeding will be listed for case management hearing before Markovic J on 26 February 2021 at 9.30 am.

5.In the absence of agreement between the parties, on or before 26 February 2021 each party is to file and serve submissions, not exceeding three pages in length, on the question of costs of the proceeding.  Unless either party requests an oral hearing, the question of costs will be determined on the papers.

Note:   Entry of orders is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wet Fix Holdings Pty Ltd v Gillion Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wet Fix Holdings Pty Ltd sought a review of the sale of the Wet Fix Business, alleging that Gillion Pty Ltd overcharged them for the purchase price. Gillion, in turn, filed a cross-claim seeking payment for the amount advanced under a vendor finance agreement plus interest and additional costs. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether Holdings was precluded from objecting to the purchase price and the balance sheet used for the post-settlement adjustment. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether Holdings’ objections to the purchase price and balance sheet were valid.

The court found that Holdings was not precluded from objecting to the purchase price or the balance sheet. The court noted that Holdings had participated in the process of determining the final purchase price and had not raised any objections until after the settlement. Regarding the objections themselves, the court found that Holdings had not substantiated their claims. The court found that the balance sheet used for the post-settlement adjustment was reasonable, and the adjustments made to the purchase price were justified. Consequently, Holdings' claim for recovery of the alleged overpayment was dismissed. In contrast, Gillion's cross-claim for the amount advanced under the vendor finance agreement plus interest was allowed.

The court ordered Gillion to provide an affidavit detailing the total amount claimed, including interest and additional costs. The court also set timelines for the parties to agree on draft orders and submit their proposed orders if they could not reach an agreement. If the parties could not agree on a form of orders, the case would be listed for a case management hearing. The court also reserved the question of costs and requested the parties to submit their proposed orders within the specified timeline. Unless either party requested an oral hearing, the question of costs would be determined on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 12 February 2021 the respondent is to file and serve an affidavit setting out the amount due to it on its cross-claim.

2. Subject to Order 3 below, on or before 19 February 2021 the parties are to provide to the Associate to Markovic J draft orders to be made giving effect to these reasons.

3. If no agreement is reached on the form of draft orders to be made giving effect to these reasons, on or before 19 February 2021 the parties are each to notify the Associate to Markovic J of the orders for which they contend and to provide submissions, not exceeding two pages in length, explaining why those orders should be made.

4. If agreement cannot be reached pursuant to Order 2 above, the proceeding will be listed for case management hearing before Markovic J on 26 February 2021 at 9.30 am.

5. In the absence of agreement between the parties, on or before 26 February 2021 each party is to file and serve submissions, not exceeding three pages in length, on the question of costs of the proceeding. Unless either party requests an oral hearing, the question of costs will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

1 The evidence

[6]

1.1 The witnesses

[7]

1.2 The Wet Fix Business and its growth

[18]

1.3 Sale of the Wet Fix Business

[28]

1.4 Discussions with Mr Starling

[31]

1.5 Negotiations for the sale of the Wet Fix Business

[40]

1.6 May to June 2015

[53]

1.7 Exchange of agreements for the sale of the Wet Fix Business

[57]

1.8 Share Sale Agreement and Business Sale Agreement

[68]

1.8.1 Share Sale Agreement

[69]

1.8.2 Business Sale Agreement

[75]

1.9 Blow moulder and bottle filling plant

[80]

1.10 Stocktakes

[94]

1.10.1 29 June 2015

[94]

1.10.2 30 September 2015

[96]

1.11 Settlement

[117]

1.12 Events following settlement

[122]

1.12.1 January 2016

[122]

1.12.2 February 2016

[146]

1.12.3 October 2016

[149]

2 The pleaded case

[158]

3 The issues

[163]

4 Holdings’ claim

[164]

4.1 The limitation issue

[164]

4.2 Purchase price – items in dispute

[186]

4.2.1 Inventory

[187]

4.2.1.1 Parties’ submissions

[190]

4.2.1.2 Consideration

[198]

4.2.2 Capital expenditure

[218]

4.2.2.1 Parties’ submissions

[219]

4.2.2.2 Consideration

[225]

4.2.3 Creditors

[232]

4.2.3.1 Parties’ submissions

[233]

4.2.3.2 Consideration

[238]

4.2.4 Other creditors

[243]

4.2.4.1 Parties’ submissions

[244]

4.2.4.2 Consideration

[246]

4.2.5 Blow moulder and bottle filling plant – ANZ leases

[251]

4.2.5.1 Parties’ submissions

[253]

4.2.5.2 Consideration

[274]

4.2.6 Plant and equipment – post 31 March 2015 assets

[295]

4.2.6.1 Parties’ submissions

[297]

4.2.6.2 Consideration

[306]

5 Gillion’s cross-claim

[313]

5.1 Vendor Finance Agreement

[314]

5.1.1 Consideration

[315]

6 Conclusion

[325]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Wet Fix Holdings Pty Ltd (Holdings) and Gillion Pty Ltd (Gillion) relating to the sale of a business. Gillion was the owner of the assets of the business, including the shares in the operating entity, while Holdings was the operating entity. The dispute arose from an alleged overpayment of the purchase price under a Share Sale Agreement. Adjustments to the purchase price were made by reference to a balance sheet made available after settlement. Holdings claimed for the recovery of the alleged overpayment, while Gillion filed a cross-claim for the recovery of an amount advanced under a Vendor Finance Agreement.

The Wet Fix Business, previously owned by Gillion, was sold to Holdings on 1 October 2015. The sale involved the transfer of shares in the operating entity and the assets of the business. The Share Sale Agreement and a Business Sale Agreement were executed between the parties. Stocktakes were conducted on 29 June 2015 and 30 September 2015, and the settlement of the sale took place on 1 October 2015.

Following the settlement, Gillion provided a balance sheet and made adjustments to the purchase price. Holdings raised objections to the purchase price and balance sheet, leading to the current dispute. Holdings claimed for the recovery of the alleged overpayment, while Gillion filed a cross-claim for the recovery of an amount advanced under a Vendor Finance Agreement.

On 10 October 2018, Gillion filed a cross-claim against Holdings. The matter was heard in the court, and the parties presented their evidence and arguments. The court considered the claims and cross-claim, and the procedural history included the filing of the cross-claim and the subsequent hearings and submissions by the parties. The court was required to determine the legal issues raised by the parties' claims and cross-claim.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 10 October 2018 Gillion filed a cross-claim in which it seeks judgment against Holdings for the amount it contends it advanced to Holdings by way of vendor finance plus interest or, in the alternative, declarations as to the amount it alleges it advanced to Holdings by way of vendor finance and that the amount advanced remains unpaid.1. The evidence The parties relied on a significant amount of evidence, some of which, given the narrowing of Holdings’ claim and the issues in dispute assumed little, if any, significance in the determination of the remaining issues. That observation should not be taken as a criticism. The steps taken by the parties to narrow the areas of dispute between them were appropriate and of assistance to the Court. It is apparent that much of the evidence was prepared at a time when the dispute was broader in scope, hence covering matters no longer in contention. I point this out to explain why, in these reasons and, in particular, in setting out the facts, I have focused only on the evidence that assists in explaining the background and is relevant to the resolution of the remaining issues in dispute between the parties. 1.1 The witnesses The following witnesses gave evidence for Holdings:(1)Darren Starling who was involved in the negotiations for the purchase of the Wet Fix Business and ultimately acquired the Wet Fix Business through interests associated with him. Mr Starling has been a director of Elem Investments Pty Ltd (Elem Investments) since 21 October 2013, is a director of Wet Fix and, in the period between 1 October 2015 (when the sale of the Wet Fix Business settled) and 28 November 2017, was its sole director. He has been the sole director of Holdings and Wet Fix Equipment Pty Ltd (Wet Fix Equipment) since their respective registrations on 23 and 24 May 2015. Mr Starling was cross-examined;(2)Valerie Richardson who from 29 June 2015 was the stock control and production manager for Wet Fix and was involved in stocktakes undertaken for the purposes of the sale of the Wet Fix Business. Ms Richardson was cross-examined; and(3)Dylan Byrne, a certified practising accountant with BDO Australia (BDO), who was instructed to undertake certain analyses and calculations in relation to the purchase price of the Wet Fix Business for the purposes of the proceeding. Mr Byrne was cross-examined. The following witnesses gave evidence for Gillion:(1)Pamela Gill who has been a director of Gillion, the previous owner of the Wet Fix Business, since its registration in 2002. Mrs Gill was a director of Wet Fix from its registration on 23 June 2004 until 21 December 2015. She managed production and the overall operation of the Wet Fix Business, including the day to day operation of its factory situated at 25-29 Christensen Road, Stapylton (Christensen Road Factory). Mrs Gill was cross-examined;(2)Maurice Gill, Mrs Gill’s husband, who has also been a director of Gillion since its registration and was a director of Wet Fix from its registration until 1 October 2015. Mr Gill was the general manager of the Christensen Road Factory and oversaw the day to day operation of equipment and machinery. Mr Gill was not cross-examined;(3)Candice Power who is Mr and Mrs Gill’s daughter and who, without intending any disrespect, I will refer to as Candy in these reasons. Candy worked in the Wet Fix Business until early January 2016 managing accounts receivable and clients as well as assisting on the factory floor as required. She was not cross-examined; and (4)Christopher Chapman, a chartered accountant, who has practised on his own account since about 2014. Prior to that time Mr Chapman was employed in various accounting practices. He first undertook accounting work for Gillion and Mr and Mrs Gill while he was employed by Liu Madden Partners from 1997 to 2005. In June 2013 Mr Chapman again became the accountant for Gillion and Mr and Mrs Gill and, save for the period from December 2015 to May 2016, has continued to act in that capacity. At the time of the acquisition of the Wet Fix Business, Mr Chapman was also the accountant for Wet Fix and Mr Starling. Mr Chapman was cross-examined.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Gillion has not provided a calculation of the interest payable on the amount outstanding under the Vendor Finance Agreement, being $948,190.34, or of any additional costs claimed pursuant to cl 5.1. I will make an order for Gillion to file and serve an affidavit setting out the amount it claims is due. 6. Conclusion It follows from the above that:(1)Holdings has failed to establish its claim and the SFASOC should be dismissed; and(2)Gillion has succeeded on its cross-claim and is entitled to judgment for the amount outstanding under the Vendor Finance Agreement plus interest accrued and unpaid on that amount and any costs pursuant to cl 5.1 of the Vendor Finance Agreement. As there is no evidence of the total amount claimed, Gillion will be required to file and serve an affidavit setting out that amount within seven days of the date of publication of these reasons. Within 14 days of the date of publication of these reasons, the parties should provide to my associate draft orders reflecting these reasons. If the parties cannot agree on the form of orders then, within that timeframe, each party is to provide its proposed draft orders to give effect to these reasons together with submissions, not exceeding two pages in length, explaining why those orders should be made. In the event that the parties cannot agree on a form of orders, the proceeding will be listed before me on 26 February 2021 at 9.30 am. The parties asked that I reserve on the question of costs of the proceeding. Accordingly, in the absence of agreement on this issue between the parties, I will also make orders requiring the parties to provide submissions in relation to the costs of the proceeding, not exceeding three pages in length, within 21 days of the date of publication of these reasons. Unless either party requests an oral hearing, the question of costs will be dealt with on the papers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the terms of the Share Sale Agreement and the Business Sale Agreement between Holdings and Gillion, along with the balance sheet provided post-settlement. The court found that the agreements were clear in allowing adjustments to the purchase price based on the balance sheet, and the obligations were not precluded from being raised by Holdings. The court then assessed Holdings' objections, which were based on alleged inaccuracies in the balance sheet and subsequent adjustments to the purchase price. The court determined that Holdings failed to substantiate its claims of overpayment and inaccuracies, and therefore, its objections were not made out. Consequently, Holdings' claim for recovery of the alleged overpayment was dismissed. Regarding Gillion's cross-claim, the court found that Gillion was entitled to recover the amount advanced under the Vendor Finance Agreement, as per the terms of that agreement. The court ordered Gillion to provide a detailed affidavit regarding the amount due, including interest and costs, to finalize the judgment.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party is not precluded from objecting to a purchase price and balance sheet adjustments as per the terms of the contracts, but such objections must be substantiated with sufficient evidence. If the objections are not substantiated, the claim for recovery of overpayment will be dismissed. Conversely, if a cross-claim for recovery of amounts due under a vendor finance agreement is substantiated, it will be allowed.