JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: WESTRAINT RESOURCES PTY LTD -v- BHP IRON ORE PTY LTD [No 4] [2009] WASC 17
CORAM: LE MIERE J
HEARD: 30 JULY 2008
DELIVERED : 5 FEBRUARY 2009
FILE NO/S: CIV 1372 of 1996
BETWEEN: WESTRAINT RESOURCES PTY LTD (ACN 009 083 783)
Plaintiff
AND
BHP IRON ORE PTY LTD (ACN 008 700 981)
Defendant
Catchwords:
Civil practice and procedure - Discovery - Application for discovery of particular documents - Whether documents sought to be discovered are relevant - Whether further discovery would be oppressive on the party ordered to give discovery - Discretion of court - Turns on own facts - Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) O 26 r 6
Legislation:
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 26 r 6
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr R E Birmingham QC & Mr P J Hannan
Defendant: Mr B D Luscombe
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Salter Power Pty Ltd
Defendant: Mallesons Stephen Jaques
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Westraint Resources Pty Ltd [2002] WASCA 18
British Association of Glass Bottle Manufacturers Ltd v Nettlefold [1912] AC 709
BT (Australasia) Pty Ltd v New South Wales [1997] FCA 1553
Cazaly Iron Pty Ltd v Bowler [2006] WASCA 282
Cazaly Iron Pty Ltd v Minister for Resources [2007] WASCA 60
Mulley v Manifold (1959) 103 CLR 341
PDM Australia Pty Ltd v Kellogg Overseas Corporation (Unreported, WASC, Library No 6646, 26 March 1987)
Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd (1996) 189 CLR 146
Re McGorm; Ex parte Co‑operative Building Society of South Australia (1989) 20 FCR 387; (1989) 86 ALR 275
Science Research Council v Nasse [1980] AC 1028
Tipperary Developments Pty Ltd v State of Western Australia [1999] WASC 62; (1999) 21 WAR 250
Westraint Resources Pty Ltd v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd [No 3] [2008] WASC 265
White & Co v Credit Reform Association and Credit Index Ltd (1905) 1 KB 653
Youlden Enterprises Pty Ltd v Health Solutions (WA) Pty Ltd [2005] WASC 60
LE MIERE J: The plaintiff applies for discovery of particular documents.
The application
This action commenced in 1996. It concerns alleged breaches by the defendant of an agreement made on 6 June 1988 between Hancock Mining Ltd (HML), Pennant Pty Ltd (PPL) and the defendant (6 June 1988 Agreement) and an agreement made on 17 May 1989 between HML and the defendant (the Ore Wagons Sale and Purchase Agreement). Those agreements in turn relate to an agreement made on 3 November 1986 between HML and Mineralimportexport (MIMEX) (a body established by the Socialist Republic of Romania) (Romanian Ore Sales Contract). The breaches of agreement are alleged to have occurred on and after 16 August 1990.
The current statement of claim was filed on 10 December 1998. In December 2000 the plaintiff sought to amend its statement of claim so as to introduce new causes of action. That attempt was…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Westraint Resources Pty Ltd v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd [No 4] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WASC 17
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the plaintiff's submissions and the defendant's extensive searches for discoverable documents. The plaintiff argued that documents referred to in already discovered documents are presumed to be relevant unless there is evidence to rebut this presumption. The defendant, however, maintained that the documents in question were not relevant and that further searches would be disproportionate and time-consuming. The court considered the affidavits of Ms Johnson and Ms Darnell, who provided detailed accounts of the search efforts and the challenges in locating specific documents due to the nature of the archiving systems. The court concluded that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that the documents sought were relevant, and the further searches proposed would be oppressive and disproportionate.
The court found that the plaintiff had not met the burden of proving the relevance of the documents sought and that the extensive searches already conducted by the defendant made further searches oppressive. The application for further discovery was dismissed. The court's decision underscored the importance of demonstrating relevance and the proportionality of the discovery process, in line with the applicable rules of court and judicial precedents.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application dismissed
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter involves an application for the discovery of particular documents, which has been heard by the court. The plaintiff, Westraint Resources, filed an application seeking the discovery of certain documents from the defendant, BHP Iron Ore. The defendant opposed the application, arguing that the documents were not relevant and that further discovery would be oppressive and impractical. The court considered the arguments presented by both parties and evaluated the relevance and practicality of conducting further searches for the documents.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Are the documents sought to be discovered relevant to the proceedings?
2. Would further discovery be oppressive on the party ordered to give discovery?
3. What is the discretion of the court in determining whether to order the discovery of the documents in question?
Held
1. The court concluded that the documents sought to be discovered were not relevant to the proceedings. The plaintiff's reliance on documents already discovered to establish relevance was insufficient.
2. The court found that further discovery would not be oppressive on the party ordered to give discovery. Although the search process was time-consuming, the court did not consider it to be oppressive.
3. The court exercised its discretion and determined not to order the discovery of the documents in question, considering the findings on relevance and the impracticality of further discovery.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In essence, the plaintiff says that the documents listed are discoverable because they are referred to in other documents discovered by the defendant. The defendant denies that the documents are relevant. The plaintiff submits that where an application is made in respect of a document referred to in a document already discovered it is to be presumed, in the absence of evidence rebutting the presumption, that the document referred to is relevant. That issue was considered by Olney J in PDM Australia Pty Ltd v Kellogg Overseas Corporation (Unreported, WASC, Library No 6646, 26 March 1987). Olney J said:It is not sufficient to show that a particular document of which discovery is sought is referred to in another document of which discovery has been given. It is necessary for the party seeking discovery to demonstrate from admissions on the pleadings or otherwise or from the documents previously discovered that a particular document which might be material to the issues raised in the action is in the hands of the party against whom the order is sought and has not been disclosed (13).I respectfully agree with the statement of Olney J of the applicable principles. Ms Johnson swears that the defendant has conducted extensive searches for all discoverable documents. She does not believe that any further search would locate the documents requested but that the further search that could be undertaken would take months to complete. In her affidavit sworn 23 May 2008 Ms Johnson swore:On the basis of further work undertaken and referred to in paragraph 6 above and from information provided to me by Ms Darnell, I believe that the archiving systems used by the defendant is not indexed to the level of specific documents. In order to locate specific documents, it is necessary to undertake an electronic search of keywords to first locate files or boxes of documents which may contain documents with references to these words and to then manually review each of the documents in these files or boxes. Departments within the BHP Billiton group generally provide a description of the files within the boxes sent to archives. These descriptions are then inputted into the database and are used for the keyword searches. If a file contains documents about many subjects, it is possible that the description provided may not cover all of those subjects and therefore these documents may not be highlighted by an electronic keyword search.Following my request, Ms Darnell caused to be undertaken specific electronic keyword searches in respect of the following items listed in Annexure D - items, 1, 3, 5(2), 6(1), 6(2), 6(4), 7(1), 9, 10, 11(2), 12, 16(2), 17, 18(1) and (2), 22, and 23. In order to undertake these keyword searches, I provided to Ms Darnell the 2008 Application and a list of the documents requested in Annexure D with expanded descriptions based on our review of the relevant discovered documents. Attached hereto and marked 'JLJ6' is a summary of the documents requested by the plaintiff in Annexures C ‑ E (with Mallesons expanded descriptions of the Annexure D documents appearing in the left hand column) and the results of the electronic keyword searches that were undertaken by Ms Darnell, Ms Francis, Senior Technical Advisor, BHP Billiton Archives and Mrs Wharton, Senior Technical Advisor, BHP Billiton Archives. I am informed by Ms Darnell that where there is no information in the two right hand columns, this indicates that this keyword search has not been undertaken because these items are covered by broader search terms. As a consequence of the searches undertaken by Ms Darnell, I believe it will not be possible to use the BHP Billiton group's electronic database to locate the specific documents sought by the plaintiff.I am informed by Ms Darnell that searches were conducted across two modules of the BHP Billiton Archives database - SSAMS and ARC. SSAMS contains temporary records comprising 188,000 boxes. ARC contains permanent records comprising 159,011 items/files/reports. These records originate from departments and businesses across the BHP Billiton group. Approximately 3,000 boxes registered in the SSAMS module of the database are attributable to the Perth Iron Ore office. Further, approximately 9,000 boxes are stored in commercial storage in Perth and are not registered in either SSAMS or ARC. I, and lawyers under my supervision, have generally reviewed hard copy lists of some of these 9,000 boxes and on the basis of that general review and [Mr] Myers' Affidavit, I do not believe that further documents relevant to the issues in these proceedings are likely to be among the 9,000 boxes stored in Perth. However in order to be certain, it would be necessary to review all 9,000 boxes and this task would likely take months to complete [40] ‑ [42].