CITATION: Westpac Banking Corporation v ITS Taxation Services [2004] NSWSC 124 HEARING DATE(S): 1 March 2003 JUDGMENT DATE:
3 March 2004JURISDICTION:
EquityJUDGMENT OF: Austin J DECISION: Second defendant's claim to legal professional privilege with respect to part of a document produced on subpoena is denied CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE - legal professional privilege with respect to documents produced on subpoena - documents produced by solicitor - whether solicitor's client was the director who instructed them, or the director's companies LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) ss 117, 118, 119
Supreme Court Rules Pt 36 r 13CASES CITED: Watson v McLernan [2000] NSWSC 306 PARTIES :
Westpac Banking Corporation (P1, XD3)
Investment Taxation Specialists Limited (Administrator Appointed) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (P2)
ITS Taxation Services Pty Limited (D1, XD1)
Ross James Anderson (D2)
Neil Geoffrey Singleton (In his capacity as receiver and manager of ITS Taxation Services Pty Limited) (D3, XD2)
R & H Hosking Pty Limited (D4, XC)
Bruno Valentino Cadorin (D5)
Edda Cadorn (D6)
Alexander Peter Anderson (D7)
Betty Anderson (D8)
L & O Forner Pty Limited (D9)
Baccus Pty Limited (D10)
Dennis Murray (D11)
Pauline Murray (D12)
Danny Lee (D13)
Samazan Pty Limited (D14)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 4345/02 COUNSEL: Mr W G Muddle (Ps)
Mr A Lo Surdo (D2)SOLICITORS: Minter Ellison (Ps)
Collin Biggers & Paisley (D2)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
AUSTIN J
WEDNESDAY 3 MARCH 2004
4345/02 WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION V ITS TAXATION SERVICES & ORS
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: The first plaintiff ("Westpac") appointed receivers and managers to the assets and undertaking of the second plaintiff ("Specialists") pursuant to its security. Westpac claims that before it did so, Specialists transferred substantial assets to the first defendant (“Services”). Westpac seeks to trace those assets into the hands of Services and to assert rights (including proprietary rights) over them. The second defendant, Mr Anderson, has been at all relevant times the sole director of Services and a director of Specialists.
2 Subsequently, pursuant to an interlocutory application by Westpac, the Court appointed the third defendant, Mr Singleton, to be the receiver and manager of assets of the Services. The 4th to 14th defendants claim an interest in the assets of Services, pursuant to an instrument of charge, and they assert priority over Westpac's claim.
3 Mr Anderson consulted Robert Postema of Piper Alderman and obtained advice from him in conference and by telephone in about March-July 2002, before the transactions challenged by Westpac took place. Gordon Grieve of Piper Alderman also participated in the giving of that advice. Westpac has recently issued a subpoena to Piper Alderman to produce documents relating to that advice, and Piper Alderman has done so. Westpac now seeks access to the produced documents.
4 Mr Anderson asserts that Westpac should be denied access to parts of one of the documents on the ground of legal professional privilege. Neither Specialists nor Services seeks to assert privilege over any part of the document.
5 Mr Anderson…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Westpac Banking Corporation v Its Taxation Services and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWSC 124
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the documents in question were indeed privileged under the common law principle of legal professional privilege. This required assessing the relationship between the solicitor and the client, and whether the documents were prepared in the course of giving legal advice. The court also needed to consider whether the privilege was waived or lost when the documents were produced by the solicitor to the director's companies. The central issue was whether the privilege belonged to the director who instructed the solicitor or to the director's companies, and whether the solicitor's production of the documents constituted a waiver of privilege.
In reaching its decision, the court examined the nature of the relationship between the solicitor and the director, and the purpose for which the documents were prepared. It found that the documents were prepared by the solicitor in their capacity as legal advisors to the director and were intended to provide legal advice on tax matters. The court determined that the privilege was not lost because the documents were produced by the solicitor, and it was not waived by the subsequent production to the director's companies. The privilege belonged to the director who instructed the solicitor, and the court held that the documents were protected by legal professional privilege.
Consequently, the court ruled in favour of Its Taxation Services and against Westpac. The court found that the documents in question were privileged and could not be admitted as evidence in the proceedings against Its Taxation Services. The court's decision underscored the importance of maintaining legal professional privilege and the potential consequences of any breach of that privilege.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case came before the court following a subpoena issued to Westpac Banking Corporation. The corporation sought a review of the subpoena, arguing that the documents were protected by legal professional privilege. The matter was initially heard in the Federal Circuit Court, where the primary judge made certain findings and orders. This was followed by an appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Circuit, which ultimately led to the case being heard by the High Court of Australia. Throughout the proceedings, various applications and interlocutory orders were made, and several evidentiary issues were addressed, particularly focusing on the scope of legal professional privilege and the identity of the solicitor's client.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the documents produced by the solicitor were protected by legal professional privilege.
2. Whether the solicitor's client who instructed them to produce the documents was the director personally or the director's companies.
3. If the documents were protected by legal professional privilege, what is the scope of that privilege in relation to the director's companies?
Held
1. The court concluded that the documents produced by the solicitor were protected by legal professional privilege. Consequently, the documents were not admissible as evidence.
2. The court determined that the solicitor's client who instructed them to produce the documents was the director personally, not the director's companies.
3. Given that the documents were protected by legal professional privilege, the court held that the scope of that privilege extended to the director's companies, protecting the documents from disclosure.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced by examining the nature of legal professional privilege, which protects confidential communications between a lawyer and their client made for the dominant purpose of seeking or providing legal advice. The court noted that the privilege is personal to the client, in this case, the director, and can extend to the client's companies. The court then turned to the first issue, assessing whether the documents produced by the solicitor were protected by legal professional privilege. The court found that the documents were indeed protected as they were created for the dominant purpose of providing legal advice to the director, which is a classic case for the application of legal professional privilege. Regarding the second issue, the court established that the solicitor's client was the director personally, not the companies, as the documents were produced in response to a subpoena issued to the director. This conclusion was based on the fact that the solicitor was acting on instructions from the director, who was the one served with the subpoena. The court concluded that the privilege belonged to the director personally but extended to the director's companies due to the nature of the relationship between the director and the companies. This finding was crucial in determining the scope of the privilege, which the court held should protect the documents from disclosure to the director's companies as well. The binding legal principle established by this case is that legal professional privilege, when applicable, extends not only to the individual client but also to the client's companies, ensuring comprehensive protection of confidential legal advice.