SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION v GIBBONS (No 2)
[2011] SASC 186
Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
25 October 2011
PROCEDURE
Application for payment out of Court of monies paid into Court from the surplus on a mortgagee's sale of land - two opposing claimants sought a summary determination in their favour on affidavit evidence - when a summary determination is permissible - claim of one intervener raised a disputed factual issue which best determined by a formal trial - summary determinations declined and directions for a trial to be given.
WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION v GIBBONS (No 2)
[2011] SASC 186JUDGE LUNN:
Reasons on application of Suzan Gibbons for payment of monies out of Court
Abbreviations
In these reasons:
“KG” is the defendant, Kirk Gibbons, who is now bankrupt;
“SG” is Suzan Gibbons, an intervener, who is the wife of KG;
“Westpac” is the plaintiff, Westpac Banking Corporation;
“AS” is Anthony Angel-Smith;
“the Wirrina property” is the property at 38 Seaview Road, Wirrina Cove, being the land in Certificate of Title Volume 6069 Folio 948;
“the Cape Jervis property” is the property at Cape Jervis which is the land in Certificate of Title Volume 5358 Folio 691.[1][1] There have been several changes in the title reference to this property, but this reference is sufficient to identify it.
The Cape Jervis property
KG and SG were originally the joint owners of this property. SG alleges that she made substantial contributions to its acquisition and improvement. It was mortgaged to the Commonwealth Bank.
In September 1975 the Commonwealth Bank exercised its power of sale as mortgagee and sold the Cape Jervis property to AS, who in turn mortgaged it to Citibank Ltd and later to others.
On 24 April 1998 AS transferred the Cape Jervis property to KG, but not to SG.[2] SG now claims that there was a resulting trust impressed on KG’s interest in this property after he became its sole proprietor, representing her interest in it emanating from her contributions to its original acquisition and its improvement.
[2] It appears the money paid by KG to AS for this transfer came from the proceeds of a personal injury claim which had been received by KG.
On 30 September 1999 KG mortgaged the Cape Jervis property to Westpac. On 14 August 2003 that mortgage was discharged, but KG gave a new mortgage over it to Westpac to secure monies which he owed to it.
In September 2007 SG lodged a caveat over the title to the Cape Jervis property claiming an indefinable interest in the land from her contributions to its acquisition and improvement. That caveat remained on the title.
Westpac exercising its powers as mortgagee sold the Cape Jervis property and on 27 October 2010 applied the whole of the sale price of $500,000 in reduction of KG’s indebtedness to it. After this, KG still owed a balance of $87,886 to Westpac.
The Wirrina property
On 14 July…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Westpac Banking Corporation v Gibbons (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] SASC 186
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether a summary determination was appropriate for the claims made by SG and the first intervener, given the complexity and disputed factual issues involved. SG argued that her claim for a resulting trust in the Cape Jervis property should take priority over the first intervener's claim to the proceeds from the sale of the Wirrina property. The first intervener contested SG's claim, arguing that her factual assertions were inconsistent and required a formal trial to be properly resolved.
The court found that SG's claim for a resulting trust in the Cape Jervis property was based on insufficient evidence and raised disputed factual issues that could not be properly resolved through a summary determination. The court noted that SG's affidavit contained legal conclusions rather than detailed evidence, and there were inconsistencies and anomalies that needed to be addressed through cross-examination and the presentation of additional evidence from all relevant parties. The court also noted that other issues, such as the contention that the Westpac debts were separate liabilities, were best left to a formal trial.
The court declined to make a summary determination in favour of either claimant, stating that the factual issues and disputes required a conventional trial. The court directed that further steps be taken to resolve the claims, including potentially issuing pleadings, making interlocutory orders, and conducting a formal trial of the issues raised by the pleadings.
In conclusion, the court ordered that the applications for payment out be declined, and directions for a trial to be given to resolve the claims of SG and the first intervener. The court emphasized the need for a formal trial to properly address the complex and disputed factual issues involved in the case.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.