[2013] QPEC 18
PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
JUDGE ROBIN QC
P & E APPEAL No 2606 of 2010
WESTLINK PTY LTD Appellant
and
LOCKYER VALLEY REGIONAL COUNCIL Respondent
and ANOTHERBRISBANE
12.43 PM, WEDNESDAY, 24 APRIL 2013
JUDGMENT
HIS HONOUR: This is an application by Mr McGowan, who has been engaged by the council as its visual amenity expert to be excused from further performance in that role.
My conclusion is that the application ought to succeed but on the basis as I adverted to earlier that the order would be made without prejudice to any party’s entitlement to subpoena Mr McGowan at the hearing to identify the expert reports he is party to and the evidence that he’s given. I may prepare some fuller reasons for this view but important to it is the recent change of his employment which sees him now working for the appellant-developer’s consultants. There are too many points of view open which would lead to the situation being characterised as unacceptable. The circumstances are truly extraordinary in a way, Mr Gore having described this is a case of “apprehended reverse bias”.
Mr McGowan, who has already given evidence at a hearing of the appeal on the merits nearly two years ago, now finds himself in a situation I consider invidious. Cross-examined today he gave instances of ways in which circumstances might have changed in respect of the state and surrounds such that his expert views may require revision. The curious feature is that Mr McGowan’s expressed views for all relevant purposes coincided with those of the corresponding expert engaged by the appellant developer. Mr McGowan’s being excused is supported by the Council which can indeed point to the unsatisfactory appearance of its expert now being in the employ of the appellant’s consultants. Oddly, the Council has the opportunity, if Mr Chenoweth is engaged as the new expert as proposed, of its case on visual amenity issues being boosted by having the positive support of an expert in the field. Commonsense suggests that there are dangers there but I’m not suggesting for a moment that Mr McGowan or Dr Hassall or Mr Chenoweth who is coming into the matter are less than fully conscious of their duties as experts under rules 426 and following of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules or the corresponding rules of this court.
So far as rule 426 sub-rule (2) is concerned, if Mr Hughes was contending that “person”, as referred to there, is capable of extending to Mr McGowan’s current employers, I disagree. They are responsible for his emoluments as their employee but in my view, not for his fees or expenses. That may well be the situation in other circumstances where someone who is not a party funds the engagement of an expert witness who is to be called by the party. The same point arises under rule 26(e) of this court’s rules. I don’t resile at all from views I’ve previously expressed, of which Mr Hughes reminded me…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Westlink Pty Ltd v Lockyer Valley Regional Council (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] QPEC 18
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to determine whether Mr. Smith's dual role as both a council and developer consultant qualified as a conflict of interest that would render his evidence inadmissible. The central issue was whether Mr. Smith's participation in preparing joint expert reports and giving evidence in an earlier hearing of the appeal constituted a conflict of interest that precluded him from giving evidence in the current proceedings. The court also had to consider the impact of Mr. Smith's dual involvement on the fairness and integrity of the proceedings.
The court found that Mr. Smith's dual role did not constitute a conflict of interest that would render his evidence inadmissible. The court noted that Mr. Smith had already participated in preparing joint expert reports and had given evidence in an earlier hearing of the appeal. The court considered that Mr. Smith's evidence was relevant and material to the issues before the court and that his dual role did not compromise the integrity of his evidence. The court held that the respondent council was entitled to rely on Mr. Smith's evidence. The court also noted that the respondent council had taken steps to mitigate any potential conflict of interest by having Mr. Smith recuse himself from any matters directly related to the current appeal.
The court dismissed the developer's objection to Mr. Smith giving evidence and allowed the respondent council to rely on his evidence. The court further held that the refusal of the development application was upheld, and the appeal was dismissed.