.D.
TRANSCRIPT
OF PROCEEDINGS
AUSCRIPT
Western AustraliaLevel 216 St Georges TcePerth WA 6000Phone (09) 325 6029Fax (09) 325 7096
HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
TOOHEY J
No P 25 of 1996
IN THE MATTER of an application for a Writ
of Prohibition and a Writ of Certiorari against:ERROL RAYMOND HODDER
COMMISSIONER OF THE AUSTRALIAN
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSIONand
AUTOMOTIVE, FOOD, METALS, ENGINEERING,
PRINTING AND KINDRED INDUSTRIES UNIONEx parte
THE WESTERN AUSTRALIAN MINT
PERTH
10.02 AM, WEDNESDAY, 18 SEPTEMBER 1996
HIS HONOUR: Mr Cock?
MR R.E. COCK: I appear on behalf of the applicant.
HIS HONOUR: Yes, thank you. Mr Schapper?
MR D.H. SCHAPPER: I appear for the second respondent.
HIS HONOUR: Yes, thank you. I have been informed by the Australian Government solicitor for the first respondent that the first respondent does not wish to be represented at the hearing of this matter and will abide by any order save as to costs of this Court and if remitted, of the Industrial Relations Court of Australia. Yes, Mr Cock?
MR COCK: Thank you, your Honour. Your Honour, this is a motion dated 23 April this year for writs of prohibition and certiorari directed towards the Commissioner. It is supported by an affidavit of Mr King, sworn 11 April 1996, which is in two volumes, your Honour, essentially constituting a summary of the proceedings before the Commissioner, together with the transcript, some relevant exhibits, a copy of the decision of Commissioner Hodder and a copy of a decision of a Full Bench of the Commission, to which a statutory appeal was taken but unsuccessfully so.
There is also an affidavit dated 4 June of this year by Mr King, a supplementary affidavit, the purpose of which is to persuade your Honour in the event that we are successful in obtaining order nisi, to persuade your Honour not to remit the matter to the IR Court as is usual, but rather, in our submission, to send the matter directly to the Full Court of the High Court. Your Honour, we have prepared a brief outline of our submissions which I think should have been handed up recently. The applicant is a Western Australian statutory corporation. It carries on rather unique functions in Australia in that it mints, makes, buys, sells and otherwise deals in coins and other artefacts of precious metals.
There was some evidence led before the Commissioner which I think was not controverted that there are a couple of companies which also refine gold and some which do some minting, but the process undertaken by the applicant is rather unique itself. The conditions of the employment of employees at the Mint, in particular those covered by the second respondent, have always been dealt with by common law contract. They have neither been dealt with by awards of the Federal Commission or the State Commission.
The history disclosed by the evidence before Commissioner Hodder was that there had been some discussions between the union and the offices of the applicant…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Western Australian Mint, Ex parte- Re Hodder and Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1996] HCATrans 288
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Royal Commission had exceeded its jurisdiction by inquiring into matters that were not within the scope of its Letters Patent. The applicant argued that the terms of reference for the Commission were too broad and permitted an investigation into conduct that had already been the subject of other proceedings or was otherwise outside the Commission's mandate.
Toohey J considered the principles governing the scope of Royal Commissions and the grounds upon which a writ of prohibition might be granted. His Honour examined the Letters Patent to determine the precise ambit of the Commission's powers and concluded that the inquiry into the alleged misappropriation of gold was within the Commission's jurisdiction. The Court found that the Commission was entitled to investigate the matters complained of, as they fell within the broad terms of reference established by the Governor.
The application for a writ of prohibition was therefore dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Mint then sought prerogative relief from the High Court, arguing that the union's log of claims was not genuine and was merely a means to bring the dispute within the jurisdiction of the Commission. The Mint further argued that the case should not be remitted to the Industrial Relations Court but should be heard directly by the High Court to provide clarity on the principles involved. The union, on the other hand, argued that the application should be dismissed outright or remitted to the Industrial Relations Court, stating that the case turned purely on the evidence and did not warrant direct consideration by the High Court. The union contended that the log of claims was neither fanciful nor did it misstate the union's intentions, and that the evidence clearly demonstrated this.
The case of Western Australian Mint, Ex parte- Re Hodder and Anor, involves an application for a writ of prohibition and a writ of certiorari against Errol Raymond Hodder, the Commissioner of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, and the Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union. The application was brought by the Western Australian Mint, a statutory corporation that deals in coins and precious metals. The matter came before the High Court following a decision by Commissioner Hodder to determine an industrial dispute between the Mint and the union, which was later appealed unsuccessfully to a Full Bench of the Commission. The Mint sought to challenge the Commissioner's decision directly in the High Court, arguing that the application of principles enunciated in previous cases required the matter to be heard by the High Court rather than being remitted to the Industrial Relations Court of Australia (IR Court). The Mint's application was opposed by the union and the Commissioner, who argued that the matter should be remitted to the IR Court in accordance with the usual process. The High Court considered the arguments and decided to remit the application to the IR Court, emphasizing the importance of adhering to the established judicial process and the distinct roles of the Industrial Relations Commission, the IR Court, and the High Court in industrial relations matters.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is there a basis for the High Court to grant an order nisi in this case?
2. Should the application for prerogative relief be remitted to the Industrial Relations Court, or should it remain in the High Court?
3. Are there exceptional circumstances that would warrant bypassing the ordinary process of the Industrial Relations Commission and Court?
4. Does the present application involve the same principles as the pending appeals and should it be considered alongside them to save time and cost?
5. What is the appropriate role of remitters and the respective functions of the Industrial Relations Court and the High Court in this context?
Held
1. The court concluded that there was no basis for the High Court to grant an order nisi in this case. As such, the application for prerogative relief was to be remitted.
2. The court decided that the application should be remitted to the Industrial Relations Court rather than remaining in the High Court.
3. The court determined that there were no exceptional circumstances that would warrant bypassing the ordinary process of the Industrial Relations Commission and Court.
4. The court held that the present application did not involve the same principles as the pending appeals, and thus should not be considered alongside them to save time and cost.
5. The court concluded that remitters play an important role in maintaining the respective functions of the Industrial Relations Court and the High Court. The court emphasized that adding to the matters before the Court in relation to Re State Public Services Federation would undermine these roles.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court considered whether it should grant an order nisi for the applicant, the Western Australian Mint, in its application for prerogative relief against the Commissioner of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission. The applicant sought writs of prohibition and certiorari against the Commissioner and the Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union. The applicant's case was that the Commissioner should not have determined that an industrial dispute existed concerning the Mint, as the log of claims served by the union was fanciful and not genuinely seeking improvements in terms and conditions of employment. The union argued that the matter should be remitted to the Industrial Relations Court, as the application turned on factual considerations best resolved by that Court.
The Court noted that it was not necessary to grant an order nisi in order to remit the matter, as the ordinary process would be for the High Court to remit the application to the Industrial Relations Court. The applicant argued that the matter should remain in the High Court as it involved the same principles as two pending appeals before the Court, and considering the application alongside those appeals would save time and cost. However, the Court observed that while the present application involved similar principles, the facts and evidence would inevitably differ to some extent, and adding to the matters presently before the Court could undermine the role of remitters and the respective functions of the Industrial Relations Court and the High Court.
The Court decided to remit the application to the Industrial Relations Court, as the situations in which bypassing that Court is appropriate would be exceptional. The Court considered that the remitter process should not be circumvented, as it would undermine the ordinary process and the roles of the various courts in dealing with industrial relations matters. The Court's decision highlights the importance of following the established process for industrial relations disputes and the limited circumstances in which the High Court should intervene directly.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the High Court should remit applications for prerogative relief to the Industrial Relations Court, except in exceptional circumstances where bypassing that Court is warranted. The Court emphasised the importance of the remitter process and the respective roles of the Industrial Relations Court and the High Court in dealing with industrial relations matters. The Court distinguished this case from previous decisions where the High Court had either remitted or retained matters for determination, based on the particular facts and circumstances of each case.