West v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  

West v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 077

PARTIES:  

West, Toby
(Appellant)

v

Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2012/496

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against a decision of Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)

DELIVERED ON:

29 April 2015

HEARING DATES:

12 and 13 August 2013

MEMBER:

Deputy President Bloomfield

ORDERS:

1.      The Appeal is dismissed.

2.      The Appellant is to pay the Respondent's costs of, and incidental to, the Appeal with recourse available to the Commission.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - whether injury arose out of or in the course of employment - whether employment was a significant contributing factor - Appellant worked as a waterproofer - Appellant also has diabetes and peripheral neuropathy - likely cause of carpal tunnel syndrome - medical evidence - different opinions as to likely cause of condition - obligation on Appellant to establish claim on the balance of probabilities - obligation not satisfied - Appeal dismissed. 

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, s 32

APPEARANCES: Mr M. J. Smith, Counsel instructed by
Ms N. Howie of Parker Simmonds Solicitors & Lawyers for the Appellant.
Mr G. Rhead, Counsel directly instructed by Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator), the Respondent, with Ms L. Hedges. 

Decision

Introduction

  1. This decision relates to an Appeal by Mr Toby West against a decision of Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) (the Regulator) to confirm an earlier decision of WorkCover to reject Mr West's Notice of Claim for Damages in accordance with section 32 of the Worker's Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (the Act).

  1. The Notice of Claim for Damages sought compensation for right carpal tunnel syndrome said to have been incurred between 27 January 2009 and 4 January 2010* with Commercial Waterproofing Services (CWS) during which time Mr West was employed in the capacity of Site Supervisor/Waterproofer and (allegedly) required to undertake work involving the extensive use of a hammer drill and injection pump, amongst other tools and equipment.  (*While the claim specifies this date, the period most often mentioned was January 2009 to March 2010 - the date Mr West went on stress leave (see below)).    

Issue requiring determination

  1. The issue requiring determination in this case is whether Mr West's carpal tunnel syndrome arose out of, or in the course of, his employment during the designated period and whether his employment was a significant contributing factor. 

Evidence

Mr West

  1. Mr West said he had worked in the waterproofing industry for 23 years and started working with CWS in early 2001 in New South Wales.  About 18 months after he commenced he moved to Queensland and became the Construction Foreman, managing construction projects in Sydney, Newcastle, the Gold Coast, Caloundra, Cairns and Port Douglas.  In the course of performing this job he was required to drive between Sydney and Caloundra on a regular basis, and his car effectively became his office.  In early - mid 2009 he was required to spend more time working on the tools because CWS was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read West v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QIRC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of West v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) involved an appeal by the appellant, Mr West, against a decision regarding his workers' compensation claim. The central issue was whether the injury, specifically carpal tunnel syndrome in Mr West's right wrist, arose out of or in the course of his employment as a waterproofer. The dispute also examined whether his employment was a significant contributing factor to the injury. Mr West claimed that his job-related activities caused the condition, while the Workers' Compensation Regulator argued that other factors, such as his diabetes and obesity, were more significant.

The legal issues before the court were the determination of the primary cause of Mr West's carpal tunnel syndrome and whether his employment contributed significantly to the injury. The court had to evaluate the medical evidence presented by both parties, focusing on the opinions of Dr Stabler and Dr Coleman. The appellant argued that Dr Coleman's evidence should be preferred due to his specialisation in hand surgery, whereas the Regulator maintained that Dr Stabler's opinion, which considered constitutional factors like diabetes and obesity, was more credible. The court had to decide which medical opinion was more reliable and relevant to the specific time period of Mr West's employment when the injury was alleged to have occurred.

In rendering its decision, the court noted that both Dr Coleman and Dr Stabler had significant expertise in hand surgery, but the court found that Dr Stabler's evidence was more comprehensive and relevant to the case. Dr Stabler's report considered Mr West's diabetes and other constitutional factors, which the court deemed crucial to understanding the likely cause of the carpal tunnel syndrome. In contrast, Dr Coleman's report did not adequately address these factors, and his opinion seemed based more on Mr West's general occupation rather than the specific work activities during the relevant period. Therefore, the court found that Mr West had not met the burden of proving on the balance of probabilities that his employment was a significant contributing factor to his injury. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and Mr West was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal with recourse available to the Commission.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Appeal is dismissed.

2. The Appellant is to pay the Respondent's costs of, and incidental to, the Appeal with recourse available to the Commission.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In response to a further question as to what he regarded as the significant cause of Mr West's carpal tunnel syndrome Dr Stabler responded by saying "well, I have no doubt, in my opinion, the most significant contributing factors are the diabetes and the alcohol intake … and, of course, with the obesity, which is part of those constitutional factors."Findings and conclusion In the course of his submissions Mr M Smith of Counsel, who represented Mr West, urged me to prefer the evidence of Dr Coleman over that of Dr Stabler. This was on the basis that Dr Coleman is a Specialist engaged in surgery of the hand and upper limb. The submission is an interesting one and resulted in me comparing the curriculum vitae of each of the doctors. This revealed the following: Dr Coleman: With great respect to Mr Smith, I cannot accept his submission that Dr Coleman's evidence should be preferred over that of Dr Stabler because of his area of speciality. The curriculum vitae of the respective doctors shows a similar level of interest in the field of hand surgery over many years and a similar standing in that area in terms of peer recognition. In addition, no hard, assessable, evidence was led to support the submission that Dr Coleman possessed a higher level of expertise or knowledge in the field of the likely origin of an individual employee's carpal tunnel syndrome than Dr Stabler. Quite apart from that, the evidence presented would not support a decision to prefer Dr Coleman's opinion over that proffered by Dr Stabler. Dr Coleman's Report (Exhibit 10), prepared on 21 June 2011, is notable in several respects - more so for what it does not mention than what it says. Firstly, it was prepared prior to lodgement of the Notice of Claim with WorkCover for Mr West's right wrist carpal tunnel syndrome which is said to have arisen from his work during the period January 2009 - January (or March) 2010. On my reading of his Report, Dr Coleman's opinion about the cause, or likely cause, of Mr West's carpal tunnel syndrome appears to be entirely based on his knowledge that Mr West worked as a waterproofer for 23 years. Although he indicated in cross-examination that he understood Mr West's workers' compensation claim related to the period January 2009 to January 2010, it is not clear, from his oral evidence, whether he had particularly considered the nature of the work undertaken by Mr West during this limited period in formulating his opinion about the likely cause of Mr West's carpal tunnel syndrome. Secondly, Dr Coleman's Report does not make any mention of the fact that Mr West had diabetes since 2001/2002, nor does he appear to have given any consideration as to what impact this condition - particularly the uncontrolled nature of it - might have had on the development of Mr West's carpal tunnel syndrome. In this respect, it is worth noting that while Dr Stabler's Report of 7 October 2010 (which was provided to Dr Coleman before he saw Mr West in June 2011) contained extensive reference to Mr West's diabetes, its uncontrolled nature as well as the fact that Dr Stabler considered constitutional factors to be the cause of Mr West's injury rather than his work as a waterproofer, Dr Coleman did not touch on any of these matters in his own Report.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.