Wertheim v Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
69 CLR 601

THE COMMONWEALTH AND ANOTHER

DEFENDANTS. National Security-Power to Minister, in interests of defence, to control production

of "essential articles "-Operative provisions of order exceeding its stated objects -National Security (General) Regulations (S.R. 1939 No. 87-1944 No. 131) reg. 59-Fly and Insect Sprays Order.

The Fly and Insect Sprays Order, which purported to be made under reg. 59 of the National Security (General) Regulations, declared that the objects of the Order were by regulating the manufacture and putting up of fly and insect sprays, to ensure that essential materials, in particular kerosene and thanite, are not wasted through being used in the production of ineffective fly and insect sprays "; it provided that "a person shall not manufacture or put up any fly spray except under the authority of and in accordance with a licence granted pursuant to the Order, and it prohibited the disposal or acquisition of "any fly spray manufactured or put up in contravention of this Order."

Held that the Order was not authorized by reg. 59 of the National Security (General) Regulations and was invalid. Purporting to act in pursuance of reg. 59 of the National Security (General) Regulations, the Minister for War Organization of Industry on 6th September 1944 made the Fly and Insect Sprays Order, which provided -"3. The objects of this Order are, by regulating the manufacture and putting up of fly and insect sprays, to ensure that essential materials, in particular kerosene and thanite, are not wasted through being used in the production of ineffective fly and insect sprays. 4. In this Order, unless the contrary intention appears fly spray includes an insect spray, other than an insect spray manufactured for use in horticultural or animal husbandry; manufacture' means manufacture for the purpose of sale

69 CLR 602

OF A. 5. A person shall not manufacture or put up any fly spray except

under the authority of and in accordance with a licence granted by the Minister or an authorized officer

7. 1 A licence issued under this Order shall be in such form, and may be subject to such conditions, as the Minister or an authorized officer thinks fit.

9. A. person shall not, without the consent of the Minister or an authorized officer, sell or otherwise dispose of, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any fly spray manufactured or put up in contravention of this Order which he knows or has reasonable cause to suspect to have been SO manufactured or put up."

The plaintiff, who for many years had been engaged in the business of manufacturing fly and insect sprays, was refused a licence under the above Order. He brought an action in the High Court against the Commonwealth and the Minister, seeking a declaration that the Order was ultra vires and void as being beyond the powers conferred upon the Minister by reg. 59.

The defendants demurred to the statement of claim. Ashkanasy K.C. (with him Spicer), for the plaintiff. The Order goes beyond the authority conferred…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wertheim v Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1945] HCA 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, a manufacturer of fly and insect sprays, brought an action in the High Court against the Commonwealth and the Minister for War Organization of Industry. The dispute concerned the validity of the Fly and Insect Sprays Order, which purported to be made under regulation 59 of the National Security (General) Regulations. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the Order was ultra vires and void, as it exceeded the powers conferred upon the Minister by the regulation. The defendants demurred to the statement of claim.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the Fly and Insect Sprays Order was a valid exercise of the powers granted to a Minister under regulation 59 of the National Security (General) Regulations. Specifically, the court had to determine if the Order, which regulated the manufacture and sale of fly and insect sprays, was sufficiently connected to the defence of the Commonwealth, the efficient prosecution of the war, or the maintenance of essential supplies and services, as required by the regulation. The court also considered whether the stated objects of the Order limited its operative provisions and whether the Order was justified under either sub-regulation 59(1)(a) (concerning essential articles) or 59(1)(c) (concerning articles other than essential articles).

The High Court, in a unanimous decision, held that the Fly and Insect Sprays Order was invalid and that the demurrer should be overruled. The court reasoned that while regulation 59 permitted Ministers to make orders for defence purposes, the operative provisions of the Order went beyond the stated objects and the scope of the regulation. The declared object of the Order was to prevent the waste of essential materials, such as kerosene and thanite, in the production of ineffective sprays. However, the Order prohibited the manufacture of *any* fly spray without a licence, regardless of whether it contained essential materials or was effective. The court found that this broad prohibition was not justified by the stated objects or the defence power, as it did not appear to be necessary for the defence of the Commonwealth or the efficient prosecution of the war. The court also noted that the Order failed to adequately define or specify the "essential materials" it sought to protect, beyond mentioning kerosene and thanite as examples. Consequently, the Order was considered to be ultra vires and void.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established