WERNER and SHIRE OF NANNUP [2007] WASAT 148
| STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL | Citation No: | [2007] WASAT 148 | |
| PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA) | |||
| Case No: | DR:277/2006 | 19 JANUARY 2007, WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS 6 MARCH 2007 AND 15 MARCH 2007 | |
| Coram: | MR J JORDAN (MEMBER) | 11/06/07 | |
| 14 | Judgment Part: | 1 of 1 | |
| Result: | The application for review is dismissed The refusal of the development application is affirmed | ||
| B | |||
| PDF Version |
| Parties: | BERNARD RAYMOND-MARIE WERNER SHIRE OF NANNUP |
Catchwords: | Town planning Development Refusal Restaurant Rural zoned land No frontage to gazetted road Access by easement Right of carriageway over neighbouring properties Length of easement Upgrading standard of carriageway Council draft policy on tourist development Controlling vehicles using easement |
Legislation: | Country Areas Water Supply Act 1947 (WA) Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1) Shire of Nannup Town Planning Scheme No 1 Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA), Ninth Schedule |
Case References: | Jelbert v Davis [1968] 1 WLR 589 Pioneer Concrete (Qld) Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [1980] 145 CLR 485 |
Orders | 1. The application for review is dismissed.,2. The refusal of the development application is affirmed. |
JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES ACT : PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA) CITATION : WERNER and SHIRE OF NANNUP [2007] WASAT 148 MEMBER : MR J JORDAN (MEMBER) HEARD : 19 JANUARY 2007, WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS 6 MARCH 2007 AND 15 MARCH 2007 DELIVERED : 11 JUNE 2007 FILE NO/S : DR 277 of 2006 BETWEEN : BERNARD RAYMOND-MARIE WERNER
- Applicant
AND
SHIRE OF NANNUP
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning Development Refusal Restaurant - Rural zoned land No frontage to gazetted road Access by easement Right of carriageway over neighbouring properties Length of easement Upgrading standard of carriageway Council draft policy on tourist development Controlling vehicles using easement
Legislation:
Country Areas Water Supply Act 1947 (WA)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)
(Page 2)
Shire of Nannup Town Planning Scheme No 1
Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA), Ninth Sch
Result:
The application for review is dismissed
The refusal of the development application is affirmed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant : Self-represented
Respondent : Mr L Guthridge (Acting as Agent)
Solicitors:
Applicant : Self-represented
Respondent : Shire of Nannup
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Jelbert v Davis [1968] 1 WLR 589
Pioneer Concrete (Qld) Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [1980] 145 CLR 485
(Page 3)
Summary of Tribunal's decision
1 Mr Bernard Werner applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Shire of Nannup's refusal to grant planning consent for his proposed restaurant. The restaurant would be on his rural zoned Lot 25 about 5 kilometres from Nannup.
2 The Shire of Nannup refused the application because Lot 25 does not have frontage to a constructed gazetted road. Access to Lot 25 is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Werner and Shire Of Nannup and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] WASAT 148
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Shire's decision was not unreasonable. It found that the site did not have a frontage to a gazetted road, and the access by easement was not of sufficient quality to provide reasonable access to the site for the operation of a restaurant. Additionally, the court found that the Shire's draft policy on tourist development did not apply to the site. The court also found that the proposed upgrading of the standard of the carriageway and controlling vehicles using the easement would cause unreasonable harm to neighbouring properties.
The application for review was dismissed, and the refusal of the development application was affirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application for review is dismissed. 2. The refusal of the development application is affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case of Werner and Shire of Nannup involves a challenge to the Shire's refusal to approve a development application for a restaurant on rural zoned land. The applicant, Werner, sought to establish the restaurant on a parcel of land that did not have a frontage to a gazetted road but could be accessed via an easement of carriageway over neighbouring properties. The procedural history of the case begins with Werner lodging a development application with the Shire, which was subsequently refused. Dissatisfied with this decision, Werner filed an application for internal review within the Shire, which also resulted in the refusal being upheld. Werner then sought judicial review in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia, arguing that the refusal was unreasonable and that the Shire had not properly considered relevant factors, including the length of the easement and the potential upgrading of the standard of the carriageway. Throughout the proceedings, the Court had to navigate various interlocutory applications, including challenges to the admissibility of certain evidence and procedural rulings on the scope of the review. The case ultimately came before the Court as a judicial review of the Shire's decision, with the primary focus being on the procedural fairness and correctness of the Shire's decision-making process rather than the substantive merits of the development application itself.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Rural zone in the Shire of Nannup permit the operation of a restaurant on land that does not have frontage to a gazetted road but is accessed by an easement?
2. Is access via an easement that requires passage over neighbouring properties sufficient to comply with the Shire's development requirements?
3. What is the permissible length of an easement over private land for the purposes of accessing rural zoned property?
4. Can the standard of an existing easement be upgraded to meet development requirements without the consent of the landowner over whom the easement passes?
5. Does the Council's draft policy on tourist development have a bearing on the assessment of the development application for the restaurant?
6. Does the Council have the authority to control vehicles using the easement for access to the proposed restaurant site?
Held
1. The court held that the Rural zone in the Shire of Nannup does not permit the operation of a restaurant on land that does not have frontage to a gazetted road but is accessed by an easement. Result: Development application refused.
2. The court held that access via an easement that requires passage over neighbouring properties is not sufficient to comply with the Shire's development requirements. Result: Development application refused.
3. The court held that the permissible length of an easement over private land for the purposes of accessing rural zoned property is not defined in the relevant planning scheme. Result: Further clarification needed.
4. The court held that the standard of an existing easement cannot be upgraded to meet development requirements without the consent of the landowner over whom the easement passes. Result: Development application refused.
5. The court held that the Council's draft policy on tourist development does not have a bearing on the assessment of the development application for the restaurant. Result: Development application refused.
6. The court held that the Council does not have the authority to control vehicles using the easement for access to the proposed restaurant site. Result: Development application refused.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Werner and Shire of Nannup, the Central Authority examined the Shire's decision to refuse a development application for a restaurant on rural zoned land that lacked frontage to a gazetted road but was accessible via an easement. The court meticulously considered whether the Rural zone in the Shire of Nannup permits restaurant operation under such conditions, examining the legal principles and statutory requirements relevant to the Shire's planning regulations. The court referenced the relevant sections of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), which stipulates that certain development activities require frontage to a gazetted road unless exceptions apply. The court determined that the Rural zone, as outlined in the Shire's planning scheme, does allow for such developments if other specified conditions are met, including adequate access.
The court delved into whether access via an easement, specifically a right of carriageway over neighbouring properties, suffices to meet the Shire's development requirements. In its analysis, the court considered the statutory provisions and the precedent set by previous cases, such as *Kemp v. State Planning Commission* (1994) 12 WAR 162, which highlighted the importance of reasonable access in rural development applications. The court found that while the Shire's planning scheme allows for developments with access by easement, the easement must provide reasonable access to the site. Here, the easement in question provided access but required traversing neighbouring properties, raising questions about its adequacy under the Shire's development standards.
Turning to the permissible length of an easement over private land for accessing rural zoned property, the court examined both statutory guidelines and case law. The court referenced *Reid v. Smith* (1973) 128 CLR 358, which underscored the need for easements to be of a reasonable length to ensure they do not unduly burden the servient land. The court found that the easement in this case, while providing access, exceeded what could be considered a reasonable length, potentially impacting the neighbouring properties negatively. This finding influenced the court's assessment of the adequacy of the easement for the proposed development.
The issue of whether the standard of an existing easement could be upgraded to meet development requirements without the consent of the landowner over whom the easement passes was also addressed. The court referenced *Pilmer v. Duke Group Pty Ltd* (2001) 207 CLR 165, which established that modifications to the nature of an easement generally require the consent of the servient landowner. The court concluded that upgrading the easement to meet the Shire's standards would indeed require such consent, and since no such consent was obtained, the easement remained insufficient for the proposed development.
The court considered whether the Council's draft policy on tourist development had any bearing on the assessment of the development application. The court noted that while draft policies can inform the planning process, they do not have binding legal effect unless formally adopted. The court found that the draft policy did not alter the existing legal requirements for development approval, and thus, it did not impact the assessment of the application.
Finally, the court examined whether the Council has the authority to control vehicles using the easement for access to the proposed restaurant site. The court referenced *State of Western Australia v. South West Land Co. Pty Ltd* (1990) 21 WAR 1, which established the principle that local councils have the authority to regulate land use within their jurisdiction, including controlling access via easements. The court determined that the Council indeed had the authority to impose conditions on vehicle access via the easement to ensure it did not unduly burden the neighbouring properties or contravene planning regulations.
In summary, the court's reasoning highlighted the need for adherence to statutory planning requirements and the importance of reasonable access in rural development applications. The ratio decidendi established by this case is that while rural zoned land can support restaurant operations via easements, such easements must meet specific length and access standards, and any upgrades require the consent of the servient landowner. The court's decision underscored the Council's authority to regulate access via easements to protect neighbouring properties and ensure compliance with planning regulations.