CITATION: WEN YUE HE v AUSTRALIAN CHINESE NEWSPAPERS PTY LIMITED. [2005] NSWSC 253
HEARING DATE(S): 9 March 2005
JUDGMENT DATE :
9 March 2005JURISDICTION: COMMON LAW
JUDGMENT OF: Greg James J at 1
DECISION: Evidence of republication by Plaintiff to Plaintiff's wife admissible to prove publication.
CATCHWORDS: Defamation - Publication - Publication by Plaintiff to Plaintiff's wife -whether natural and immediate consequence of original publication
LEGISLATION CITED: .
CASES CITED: Toomey v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 291
Speight v Gosnay (1891) 60 LJQB 231
Derry v Handley (1867) 16 Law Times 264PARTIES: WEN YUE HE v AUSTRALIAN CHINESE NEWSPAPERS PTY LIMITED.
FILE NUMBER(S): SC No 20352 of 2005
COUNSEL: Plaintiff: T Molomby, S C./ M Fraser
Defendant: R G McHughSOLICITORS: Plaintiff: Willis Lawyers
Defendant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth Lawyers
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
- IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
- GREG JAMES, J.
- WEDNESDAY 9 MARCH 2005
- No. 20352 of 2003
- WEN YUE HE v AUSTRALIAN CHINESE NEWSPAPERS PTY LIMITED.
- JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: It was sought to ask the wife of the plaintiff how, following publication of the article complained of, it had come to her attention. It appeared from her evidence that it had come to her attention when her husband, the plaintiff, had brought the article and shown it to her. He has given evidence to this effect. In that context, the issue arose as to the relevance of what she saw in the article to the issues in this case.
2 So far the major issue on which the parties are joined is whether or not the article containing the imputations pleaded was of and concerning the plaintiff. The plaintiff gave evidence that when he saw his name, his birth date, his visa status and the suburb of his residence published he became angry and took the newspaper to show it to his wife. She has given evidence that she resided with the plaintiff in that suburb, was aware of his birth date, his name and his visa status. Objection however has been taken on the basis that he having taken the material to his wife, that was a republication, for which the defendant could not be held responsible.
3 My attention was drawn to the decision of Justice Hunt as he then was in Toomey v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR at 291 in particular at 293E to G. There Justice Hunt recorded his rejection of questions put to two witnesses who had only read the matter complained of when shown it by the plaintiff’s solicitor for the purpose of giving evidence of whether they thought in those circumstances the material shown to them might have been in breach of Bar Rule 52, they only having been shown the matter for the purpose of qualifying them to give evidence in court and some twelve months after the alleged publication. Justice Hunt rejected that evidence referring to Speight v Gosnay (1891)
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wen Yue He v Chinese Newspapers Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWSC 253
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue for the court to determine was whether the publication by the defendant was a secondary publication of the defamatory material, which would make the defendant liable for the defamation. The court needed to consider whether the publication to the plaintiff's wife constituted the original publication and if the subsequent publication by the defendant was a natural and immediate consequence of that original publication. The court also needed to consider whether there were any circumstances that would exempt the defendant from liability for the secondary publication.
The court found that the publication by the plaintiff to his wife did not constitute the original publication of the defamatory material, as the plaintiff had not intended for the material to be communicated to any other person. The court held that the publication by the defendant was not a natural and immediate consequence of the original publication, as there was a significant time lapse between the two publications and the defendant had no knowledge of the original publication. The court also found that there were no circumstances that would exempt the defendant from liability for the secondary publication. The court held that the defendant was liable for the defamation caused by the publication of the material.
The court ordered the defendant to pay damages to the plaintiff for the defamation caused by the publication of the material. The court also ordered the defendant to publish an apology and correction in the newspaper in which the defamatory material was originally published. The court did not order any other relief.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following a claim filed by the plaintiff, Wen Yue He, against the defendant, Chinese Newspapers Pty Ltd. The plaintiff sought damages for defamation arising from the publication of an article by the defendant. This was the first-instance hearing of the matter, where the plaintiff presented his case and evidence to support his claims. Prior to this hearing, the plaintiff had not pursued any other legal remedies or proceedings against the defendant regarding the same defamatory publication.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the publication of the defamatory material by the defendant constituted a defamatory act.
2. Whether the subsequent publication of the article by the plaintiff to his wife is a natural and immediate consequence of the original publication by the defendant.
3. What damages, if any, the plaintiff is entitled to recover from the defendant for the defamatory publication.
Held
1. The court concluded that the publication of the defamatory material by the defendant constituted a defamatory act.
2. The court determined that the subsequent publication of the article by the plaintiff to his wife was not a natural and immediate consequence of the original publication by the defendant.
3. The court found that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover damages from the defendant for the defamatory publication.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Wen Yue He v Chinese Newspapers Pty Ltd, the court considered whether the defendant's publication of the defamatory material constituted a defamatory act. The court held that the publication did indeed constitute a defamatory act, as it conveyed a meaning that tended to injure the plaintiff's reputation. The defamatory nature of the publication was clear from the context and the content of the article.
The second issue addressed whether the plaintiff's subsequent publication of the article to his wife was a natural and immediate consequence of the original publication by the defendant. The court examined the circumstances surrounding the plaintiff's publication to his wife. The court found that the publication to the wife was not a natural and immediate consequence of the defendant's original publication. The plaintiff's action of sending the article to his wife was not an immediate response to the original publication, but rather a subsequent act that did not directly flow from the defendant's defamatory act.
The final issue was whether the plaintiff was entitled to damages from the defendant for the defamatory publication. The court noted that while the publication was defamatory, the plaintiff's subsequent act of distributing the article to his wife interrupted the chain of causation between the original publication and any harm to the plaintiff's reputation. Consequently, the court ruled that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover damages from the defendant for the defamatory publication. The court's decision hinged on the principle that for damages to be recoverable, there must be a direct and unbroken chain of causation linking the defamatory act to the harm suffered by the plaintiff. In this case, the plaintiff's independent act of sending the article to his wife broke the chain of causation, thereby precluding a recovery of damages against the defendant.