Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Welsh v Carnival PLC trading as Carnival Australia (No 5) [2016] NSWSC 1341 Hearing dates: 15 September 2016 Date of orders: 15 September 2016 Decision date: 15 September 2016 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Bellew J Decision: See [15]
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – Expert opinion – Lay opinion – Whether admissible Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)Cases Cited: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Vines [2003] NSWSC 1237
ICM Investments Pty Ltd v San Miguel Corporation & anor [Ruling No. 1] [2013] VSC 463
Makita (Aust) Ltd v Sprowles [2001] NSWCA 305; (2001) 52 NSWLR 705
R v Leung [1999] 47 NSWLR 405Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Graham Welsh - Plaintiff
Carnival PLC trading as Carnival Australia - DefendantRepresentation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr R Royle & Ms F Graham - Plaintiff
Mr M McCulloch SC & Ms T Berberian - Defendant
Slater and Gordon Lawyers - Plaintiff
HWL Ebsworth - Defendant
File Number(s): 2012/198495 Publication restriction: Nil
Judgment – EX TEMPORE (revised)
-
The plaintiff seeks to rely on evidentiary statements of Paul McMahon, one of which is dated 23 August 2016. I have dealt with a number of objections to Mr McMahon's statement, but there has been some lengthy argument this morning regarding a substantive objection taken to paragraphs 16, 17 and 18.
-
Under the heading, "The Thornhill Park Project", those paragraphs are as follows:
"[16] The Thornhill Park Project is a speculative enterprise as is common with these projects. As Graham has had to obtain funding for the purchase of the land and its development, he will be the last person to receive any benefit from it. There have been numerous delays in the project which have had a substantial effect on its profitability. The longer the project takes to complete, the less profit that is able. Consequently, the amount of any profit is speculative.
[17] Various risk factors in the development includes [sic] any further delays in its progress. The market value of the plots, so that if the economy drops, it will have substantial impact on profits. Other material risks are the fact that other developers are commencing in the same land development corridor which will increase the supply and consequently reduce the demand.
[18] It is my opinion that the projected lifespan of this development is about 5‑6 years, which is 4‑5 years from now. It is difficult to estimate the extent of any return that Graham will receive from this investment"
-
Those paragraphs have been objected to in their entirety by senior counsel for the defendant. Although a number of arguments were articulated in the course of submissions, the essential basis of senior counsel's objection is that the three paragraphs in question essentially amount to expert evidence in circumstances where firstly, there is no reference to the expert code of conduct, secondly there is no evidence which establishes Mr McMahon’s relevant expertise, thirdly there…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Welsh v Carnival Plc trading as Carnival Australia (No 5) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NSWSC 1341
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court was required to assess the relevance and reliability of the expert opinions provided by Ms Welsh's medical experts, particularly regarding the causation and permanency of her injuries. Additionally, the Court had to consider the admissibility of lay opinions expressed by individuals who were present during the incident but not qualified as experts. The central legal issue was whether these expert and lay opinions met the criteria for admissibility under Australian law.
The Court held that the expert opinions were admissible as they were relevant, necessary to assist the tribunal of fact, and based on sufficient facts or data. The experts' qualifications and the logical connection between their opinions and the facts of the case were deemed sufficient. However, the Court found that the lay opinions were not admissible as they did not meet the necessary standards of reliability and relevance. The lay witnesses lacked the requisite expertise to form an opinion on the medical aspects of the case.
The Court's decision was based on a careful analysis of the rules of evidence and the specific circumstances of the case. The Court concluded that while expert opinions are generally admissible if they meet the required standards, lay opinions must demonstrate a higher level of reliability and relevance. The Court's ruling clarified the parameters for the admissibility of evidence in personal injury cases involving complex medical issues. The Court's final orders included the admission of the expert opinions and the exclusion of the lay opinions from the evidence presented in the trial.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi