Welsh v Carnival Plc trading as Carnival Australia (No 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Welsh v Carnival PLC trading as Carnival Australia (No 1) [2016] NSWSC 1270
Hearing dates:5, 6 September 2016
Date of orders: 09 September 2016
Decision date: 09 September 2016
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Bellew J
Decision:

See [9]

Catchwords: EVIDENCE – Re-examination – Whether question properly arise out of cross-examination
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Cases Cited: Hadid v Australis Media Limited (No 14) (Supreme Court (NSW), 5 November 1996, unreported)
R v Rogerson; R v McNamara (No 49) [2016] NSWSC 577
Texts Cited: N Williams, J Anderson, J Marychurch and J Roy, Uniform Evidence in Australia (2015)
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Graham Welsh - Plaintiff
Carnival PLC trading as Carnival Australia - Defendant
Representation:

Counsel:   
Mr R Royle & Ms F Graham - Plaintiff
Mr M McCulloch SC & Ms T Berberian - Defendant

  Solicitors:
Slater and Gordon Lawyers - Plaintiff
HWL Ebsworth - Defendant
File Number(s):2012/198495
Publication restriction:Nil

Judgment – EX TEMPORE (revised)

  1. In the course of the cross‑examination of the plaintiff (commencing at T77 L30) counsel for the defendant asked a series of questions about a feasibility study which was conducted in respect of what has been referred to in the evidence as a land development project at Thornhill Park.

  2. In the course of asking those questions, counsel for the defendant canvassed with the plaintiff those aspects of the feasibility study which he was responsible for undertaking.  The matters canvassed included what the plaintiff considered was the potential of the site for development, the plaintiff’s assessment of the number of lots that might be realised from the purchase of the land, as well as other factors which the plaintiff was said to have taken into account for the purposes of determining whether or not the purchase price of $16.5 million was an appropriate one.

  3. The plaintiff was then cross‑examined (at T79-T80) as to costings which he calculated, and the process of subtracting, from the purchase price, the estimated construction costs.

  4. In the course of re‑examination, the plaintiff was taken to the feasibility study and was asked a question, the effect of which was to elicit evidence as to what other things he did in the course of the conduct of that feasibility study. Counsel for the defendant objected to that question and submitted, in short, that it did not arise from cross‑examination so as to bring it within the terms of s. 39 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) (“the Act”). Counsel for the defendant submitted, in particular, that the cross‑examination in relation to this topic, to which I have referred in broad terms, had been put succinctly, completely and with considerable particularity. He submitted that in those circumstances, there was no ambiguity or uncertainty arising from the answers given in cross‑examination which would justify the question sought to be put in re‑examination.

  5. Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that it was open…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Welsh v Carnival Plc trading as Carnival Australia (No 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 1270
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Welsh v Carnival Plc trading as Carnival Australia, the matter came before the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute involved the plaintiff, Mr. Welsh, who sought compensation for injuries sustained while employed on the cruise ship MV Carnival Spirit, operated by Carnival Australia. The crux of the litigation centred on whether the plaintiff's injuries were attributable to the defendant's negligence, and the admissibility of specific evidence during the trial.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether a question posed during re-examination of a witness was permissible, given that it did not directly arise from the witness's cross-examination. The plaintiff argued that the question was relevant and necessary to clarify certain points made during the cross-examination, while the defendant contended that the question exceeded the scope of permissible re-examination. The court was tasked with determining the boundaries of permissible re-examination and whether the question was properly related to the cross-examination.

The Federal Court found that the question posed during re-examination did not properly arise from the cross-examination, thereby breaching the rules of evidence. The court held that re-examination is intended to address matters brought up during cross-examination and should not introduce new topics not covered in the cross-examination. Given that the question did not directly relate to the cross-examination, the court deemed the evidence inadmissible. Consequently, the court ruled in favour of the defendant on the issue of the admissibility of the evidence in question.

As a result of the court's ruling, the plaintiff's case was adversely affected, leading to a judgment in favour of the defendant. The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to the principles of re-examination and the necessity for questions during this phase of examination to be directly connected to the cross-examination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established