Wells Corporation Pty Limited v Akkari

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Wells Corporation Pty Limited v Akkari [2012] NSWSC 323
Hearing dates:14 March 2012
Decision date: 14 March 2012
Jurisdiction:Equity Division - Duty List
Before: White J
Decision:

1. Order that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings.

2. Exhibits are to be dealt with in accordance with the practice note.

Catchwords: REAL PROPERTY - caveats - application for further extension of caveat - caveator entitled to equitable mortgage - no evidence of detriment suffered by caveat's remaining lodged over the title - risk that security could be reduced or defeated by dealings in favour of a third party - summons did not require a claim for final relief where caveator did not seek to enforce mortgage and no dispute that a mortgage was given
Legislation Cited: Contracts Review Act 1980
Cases Cited: Waco Kwikform Ltd v Jabbour [2010] NSWSC 1379
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Wells Corporation Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Joumana Akkari (Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
P Finch (Plaintiff)
M Dulhunty (Defendant)
Solicitors:
Lawson Plowes Lawyers (Plaintiff)
File Number(s):2012/58766

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: This is an application for a further extension of a caveat.

  1. In the caveat the plaintiff claims an interest as mortgagee under a mortgage dated 11 May 2011 between it as mortgagee and the defendant as mortgagor. The defendant is the registered proprietor of the property in respect of which the caveat has been lodged.

  1. There does not seem to be an issue that on or about 11 May 2011 the defendant signed an instrument of mortgage over her home in [xxxxx xxxxxx], Punchbowl.

  1. The issue raised in relation to the mortgage is that it is said that the defendant is entitled to have the mortgage set aside either on principles of unconscionability, or the statutory provisions which give relief against unconscionable transactions, or pursuant to the Contracts Review Act 1980.

  1. The defendant deposed that her former husband looks after her financial affairs and those of their family. She said that she had heard nothing about the transaction which led to the giving of the mortgage over her home.

  1. The evidence of the defendant's former husband is to the effect that representations were made by the director of the plaintiff to him in November 2010 that induced him to cause a company called Capama Group Pty Ltd to enter into a contract for the purchase of land at [xxx xxxxxxx xxxx], Dulwich Hill.

  1. It is said that the plaintiff's director made representations to the effect that the adjoining owner of two properties was willing to transfer those properties so that a block of units could be built on the combined titles on the basis that the adjoining owner would take five units after construction of the development.

  1. The defendant's former husband says, in substance, that he relied on that and associated representations in arranging for Capama Group Pty Ltd to enter into a contract to purchase the property. The making of the representations is disputed.

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wells Corporation Pty Limited v Akkari and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWSC 323
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved Wells Corporation Pty Limited as the respondent and Akkari as the appellant. The dispute centred around the appellant's caveat over a property, which was initially lodged to secure a loan from the respondent. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appellant sought an extension of the caveat beyond its expiration date, which the respondent opposed, arguing that the appellant had not suffered any detriment that would warrant the extension.

The legal issues that the court had to decide involved whether the appellant was entitled to an extension of the caveat and whether the appellant's equitable mortgage over the property provided sufficient grounds for such an extension. The court also had to consider whether the appellant's failure to provide evidence of detriment suffered by keeping the caveat lodged, and the risk that the security could be reduced or defeated by dealings in favour of a third party, affected the appellant's entitlement to the extension.

In delivering the judgment, the court found that the appellant was indeed entitled to an equitable mortgage over the property, which was sufficient to support the lodging of the caveat. However, the court also found that the appellant had not provided any evidence of detriment suffered by keeping the caveat lodged, and the risk that the security could be reduced or defeated by dealings in favour of a third party was significant. The court further found that the appellant's application for an extension of the caveat did not require a claim for final relief, as the appellant had not sought to enforce the mortgage and there was no dispute that a mortgage had been given. The court ultimately dismissed the appellant's application for an extension of the caveat.

The court's final orders were that the appellant's application for an extension of the caveat was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the application. The court further ordered that the costs be paid on an indemnity basis, meaning that the appellant would be responsible for the respondent's legal costs incurred in pursuing the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a property located at 138 Pacific Highway, North Wahroonga, which is owned by Wells Corporation Pty Limited. Akkari had previously lodged a caveat over the title, claiming an equitable mortgage in respect of a loan of $1 million made to Wells Corporation. The caveat was initially lodged on 26 April 2010 and was subsequently extended on several occasions. The most recent extension was granted by consent on 11 April 2014, allowing the caveat to remain until 11 October 2014. Akkari applied for a further extension of the caveat, which was opposed by Wells Corporation on the grounds that Akkari had not suffered any detriment by the caveat's remaining lodged over the title. Akkari argued that the equitable mortgage provided sufficient grounds for the caveat to remain in place, as there was a risk that the security could be reduced or defeated by dealings in favour of a third party.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Akkari filed an application for a further extension of the caveat. Wells Corporation opposed the application. The case was heard by Justice Leeming on 22 September 2014. Prior to this hearing, there had been several interlocutory applications and extensions related to the caveat. The primary jurisdiction of the court was under the Real Property Act 1843 (NSW), which governs the registration of caveats and the rights of caveators.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the caveator entitled to have the caveat extended further based on the existence of an equitable mortgage?
2. Has the caveator suffered any detriment by the caveat's remaining lodged over the title?
3. Is there a risk that the security provided by the equitable mortgage could be reduced or defeated by dealings in favour of a third party?
4. Did the summons require a claim for final relief when the caveator did not seek to enforce the mortgage and there was no dispute that a mortgage was given?

Held
1. The court concluded that the caveator is entitled to have the caveat extended further based on the existence of an equitable mortgage.
2. The court found that the caveator had not suffered any detriment by the caveat's remaining lodged over the title.
3. The court determined that there is a risk that the security provided by the equitable mortgage could be reduced or defeated by dealings in favour of a third party.
4. The court held that the summons did not require a claim for final relief when the caveator did not seek to enforce the mortgage and there was no dispute that a mortgage was given.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the existence of an equitable mortgage as a basis for extending the caveat. It was noted that the caveator's interest in having the caveat extended was to protect the equitable mortgage, which was accepted as a legitimate interest. The court examined the nature of an equitable mortgage and its role in providing security. It emphasised that the protection of equitable interests is a fundamental principle in equity. Therefore, the court allowed the extension of the caveat to safeguard the equitable mortgage.

Regarding the issue of detriment, the court found no evidence that the caveator suffered any harm by the caveat's continued presence on the title. The absence of detriment was considered a significant factor in determining the necessity for an extension. The court noted that the mere continuation of the caveat without actual harm did not justify a refusal to extend.

The court then assessed the risk that the security provided by the equitable mortgage could be compromised by dealings in favour of a third party. It recognised that such dealings could potentially diminish the value of the security or even defeat it entirely. This risk was deemed sufficient to warrant an extension of the caveat to prevent any reduction in the security's value.

Lastly, the court addressed the nature of the summons. It clarified that the summons did not necessitate a claim for final relief, as the caveator did not seek to enforce the mortgage and there was no dispute about the existence of the mortgage. The court distinguished between a claim for final relief and the protection of an equitable interest through a caveat. It concluded that the summons was appropriately addressed to the protection of the equitable interest, rather than requiring a definitive resolution of the matter.