FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| WELLS & ANOR & DELMONTE and VINCENT & WELLS & ANOR | [2020] FCCA 2084 |
| Catchwords: FAMILY LAW – Parenting – interim applications – mother of three dies suddenly – maternal grandparents who lived near and supported mother keep children – father of youngest child and with equal shared parental responsibility and alternate weekends seeks recovery of youngest child to him – father of middle child with autism and unknown court orders but limited actual contact with child takes child after funeral - maternal grandparents seek a recovery order for middle child – oldest child (16) self-places with maternal grandparents – allegations that now deceased mother previously told father of middle child and his mother that maternal grandfather had raped her as a child - allegations not pressed for consideration at hearing – children to live together with maternal grandparents – children to spend time with respective fathers pursuant to existing known orders as if maternal grandparents stand in place of deceased mother – appointment of ICL – likely transfer to Family Court of Australia. |
| Legislation: Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), ss.60CA, 60CC(2), 60CC(3), 64B, 65AA, 65D, 69ZL, Part VII |
| Cases cited: Vincent & Wells [2019] FamCA 578 Rice & Asplund (1979) FLC 90-725; [1978] FamCA 84 Mazorski & Albright (2007) 37 Fam LR 518; [2007] FamCA 520 Banks & Banks (2015) FLC 93-637; [2015] FamCAFC 36 Goode & Goode (2006) 206 FLR 212; [2006] FamCA 1346 Marvel & Marvel (2010) 240 FLR 367; [2010] FamCAFC 101 Deiter & Deiter [2011] FamCAFC 82 Eaby & Speelman (2015) FLC 93-654 |
| First Applicant: | MR WELLS |
| Second Applicant: | MR WELLS |
| Respondent: | MR DELMONTE |
| File Number: | SYC 4835 of 2020 |
| Applicant: | MR VINCENT |
| First Respondent: | MR WELLS |
| Second Respondent: | MS WELLS |
| File Number: | SYC 4298 of 2020 |
| Judgment of: | Judge B Smith |
| Hearing date: | 20 July 2020 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 20 July 2020 |
| Delivered at: | Sydney |
| Delivered on: | 20 July 2020 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicants in SYC4835/2020: | Mr Todd |
| Solicitors for the Applicants in SYC4835/2020: | Hinde Ginges Boyd Lawyers |
| The Respondent in SYC4835/2020 appeared for himself | Mr Delmonte |
| Counsel for the Applicant in SYC4298/2020 : | Mr Gardiner |
| Solicitors for the Applicant in SYC4298/2020: | Anderson Boemi Lawyers | |
| Counsel for the Respondents in SYC4298/2020: | Mr Todd | |
| Solicitors for the Respondents in SYC4298/2020: | Hinde Ginges Boyd Lawyers |
ORDERS
IN PROCEEDINGS SYC4835/2020
The matter be listed on 2 October 2020 at 9:30am for mention.
Any Application in a Case or Objection to Subpoena made returnable by the Registry from the date of these Orders until the next adjourned date will not be heard on that date without the express leave of Judge B Smith.
The parties are to arrange for the child, Z born in 2009, to be returned to the maternal grandparents in 2020 and are to negotiate a time and meeting point approximately halfway between the parties to make the change-over.
Pending further Order, the child Z live with the maternal grandparents.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read WELLS & ANOR & DELMONTE and VINCENT & WELLS & ANOR and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FCCA 2084
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were to determine the interim living arrangements for the three children, considering the recent death of their mother and the competing claims of the fathers and the maternal grandparents. The court was also required to consider the appointment of an Independent Children's Lawyer for each of the younger children and to make directions regarding the future conduct of the proceedings, including the potential transfer of the matter to the Family Court of Australia due to its complexity. Allegations that the deceased mother had previously accused the maternal grandfather of rape were noted but not pressed for consideration at this interim hearing.
The court's reasoning focused on ensuring the children's welfare and maintaining their sibling unit. It was ordered that all three children live with the maternal grandparents pending further order. The children were to spend time with their respective fathers in accordance with existing known orders, with the maternal grandparents effectively standing in place of the deceased mother for the purposes of these arrangements. An Independent Children's Lawyer was appointed for each of the younger children, and the Legal Aid Commission of New South Wales was requested to arrange representation. The court also directed that the two proceedings be case-managed together and anticipated a transfer to the Family Court of Australia.
Orders
Orders of the court
IN PROCEEDINGS SYC4835/2020
1.
The matter be listed on 2 October 2020 at 9:30am for mention.
2.
Any Application in a Case or Objection to Subpoena made returnable by the Registry from the date of these Orders until the next adjourned date will not be heard on that date without the express leave of Judge B Smith.
3.
The parties are to arrange for the child, Z born in 2009, to be returned to the maternal grandparents in 2020 and are to negotiate a time and meeting point approximately halfway between the parties to make the change-over.
4.
Pending further Order, the child Z live with the maternal grandparents.
5.
Pursuant to Section 68L of the Family Law Act an Independent Children’s Lawyer be appointed for the child Z born in 2009.
6.
The Legal Aid Commission of New South Wales is requested to make arrangements as soon as possible for appropriate representation for the child.
7.
The Court advise the Senior Solicitor, Family Law Litigation Section of the Legal Aid Commission of NSW of this Order forthwith.
8.
Each party make available to the Legal Aid Commission of NSW (Sydney Office) forthwith copies of all applications and affidavits upon which that party relies together with any existing Orders and copies of any relevant reports.
9.
The parties facilitate the attendance upon his/her representative of the child at times and dates requested by that representative.
10.
Leave be granted to the Independent Children’s Lawyer to issue more than five subpoena.
11.
Liberty is granted to the parties, and any Independent Children's Lawyer, to approach the Court in Chambers to have the matter relisted on short notice.
12.
Leave be granted to the parties to issue up to 10 subpoena.
13.
The matters SYC4298/2020 and SYC4835/2020 be case managed together, and subject to further Orders to be heard together.
AND THE COURT NOTES THAT:
14.
The parties are to liaise as to an appropriate arrangement for the child to spend time with the father between his return on 28 October 2020 and 2 October 2020.
15.
Unless there are any issues requiring further determination on an interim basis the Court anticipates that the matter being both long and potentially complex will be transferred to the Family Court of Australia.
16.
Pursuant to ss.65DA(2) and 62B of the Family Law Act 1975, the particulars of the obligations these Orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these Orders are set out in Annexure A and those particulars are included in these Orders.
IN PROCEEDINGS SYC4298/2020
1.
The matter be listed on 2 October 2020 at 9:30am for mention.
2.
Any Application in a Case or Objection to Subpoena made returnable by the Registry from the date of these orders until the next adjourned date will not be heard on that date without the express leave of Judge B Smith.
3.
Pending further Order, the child, X born in 2011, live with the Respondent maternal grandparents.
4.
The child spend time with the Applicant father:
(a) until the commencement of term 1 in 2021:
(i) from 9:00 am on Saturday until 2:00 pm on Sunday each alternate weekend, with changeover to occur in Suburb E at a place agreed between the parties and in the event that there is no agreement then at McDonalds Suburb E, NSW;
(ii) in the third mid-term school holiday in the first weekend the child spends with the father the time will commence from 7pm Friday to 2pm Tuesday, and
(iii) in the 2020/2021 end of year holiday period the weekends;
A. the child shall spend time with the father from 11.00am 24 December 2020 until11.00am 26 December 2020,
B. if that Christmas time is not otherwise the weekend the child spends with the father then it will be in replacement of the previous weekend, and
C. in January 2021 the alternate time will commence from 7pm Friday to 2pm Tuesday and shall conclude at the latest 4 days before school term in 2021 commences.
(b) from the commencement of school term I in 2021 the child shall spend time with the father:-
(i) during school terms from 7pm Friday to 2pm Sunday each alternate weekend with changeover to occur in Suburb E at a place agreed between the parties and in the event that there is no agreement then at McDonalds Suburb E, NSW; and
(ii) for the first half of school holidays in odd numbered years and for the second half of the holidays in even numbered years with changeover to occur in Suburb E at a place agreed between the parties and in the event that there is no agreement McDonalds Suburb E, NSW subject to the child being returned to the maternal grandparents at the end of December/January holiday 4 days before school term commence.
5.
Notwithstanding the above orders, in the event that the child will otherwise spend the weekend with the maternal grandparents on Father's Day, such alternate weekend shall switch to that weekend so the child will spend the weekend with the father on Father's Day.
6.
In relation to Christmas periods, the following shall apply, notwithstanding the above.
(a) the child will spend Christmas with the father from 11.00am 24 December 2022 until 11.00am 26 December 2022 and each alternate year thereafter, with changeover to take place at Suburb E, as set out above; and
(b) the child will spend Christmas with the maternal grandparents from 11.00am 24 December 2021 until 11.00am 26 December 2021 and each alternate year thereafter, with changeover to take place at Suburb E, as set out above;
7.
The father will ensure that the child is able to contact her maternal grandparents by telephone during any time she is in his care, and will ensure she has access to a telephone to do this. For this purpose, the maternal grandparents may nominate a telephone number that the child can call and provide it to the father.
8.
The party with who the child is not living or spending time shall have telephone or other electronic communication with the child each Wednesday between 5.00pm and 6.00pm and the other party will ensure that the other has appropriate telephone numbers and will make the child available.
9.
Each party shall ensure the child's timely and appropriate attendance at school.
10.
The father is restrained from using or being affected any illicit drugs while the child is in his care.
11.
The father continue to engage with an appropriate therapist for the purpose of drug and alcohol counselling for as long as the therapist deems such engagement necessary.
Each party is restrained from speaking about the other parent or member of their family or household in a negative, derogatory or offensive manner in the presence or hearing of the child, and will remove the child from the presence or hearing of any third party that does so.
12.
Each party will forthwith and contemporaneously with the event advise the other of any significant illness or injury requiring hospitalisation or specialist medical appointment relating to the child, and will provide all consents, authorities and instructions to allow each parent to be advised with respect to any treatment and to visit her if hospitalised.
13.
The parties will continue any counselling for the child engaged in pursuant to order 17 of the Orders of 14 March 2019 and still in place as at the 1 July 2020.
14.
For the purpose of any communication required relating to the child and pursuant to these orders, each party will within seven (7) days provide the other with a current email address ( and will notify the other party of any changes to their email address within seven (7) days).
15.
Pursuant to Section 68L of the Family Law Act an Independent Children’s Lawyer be appointed for the child X born in 2011.
16.
The Legal Aid Commission of New South Wales is requested to make arrangements as soon as possible for appropriate representation for the child. The Legal Aid Commission of New South Wales is requested to consider appointing the same Independent Children’s Lawyer who appeared in Vincent & Wells (P)PAC5705/2011.
17.
The Court advise the Senior Solicitor, Family Law Litigation Section of the Legal Aid Commission of NSW of this order forthwith.
18.
Each party make available to the Legal Aid Commission of NSW (Sydney Office) forthwith copies of all applications and affidavits upon which that party relies together with any existing orders and copies of any relevant reports.
19.
The parties facilitate the attendance upon his/her representative of the child at times and dates requested by that representative.
20.
Leave be granted to the Independent Children’s Lawyer to issue more than five subpoena.
21.
Liberty is granted to the parties, and any Independent Children's Lawyer, to approach the Court in Chambers to have the matter relisted on short notice.
22.
Leave be granted to the parties to issue up to 10 subpoena.
23.
The matters SYC4298/2020 and SYC4835/2020 be case managed together, and subject to further orders to be heard together.
AND THE COURT NOTES THAT:
24.
The time with and consequential orders relating to the child’s time with the father are intended to reflect the orders of 14 March 2019 in Vincent & Wells PAC5705/2011, where the maternal grandparents are for the time being to stand in the place of the deceased mother Ms Wells.
25.
Unless there are any issues requiring further determination on an interim basis the Court anticipates that the matter being both long and potentially complex will be transferred to the Family Court of Australia.
26.
Pursuant to ss.65DA(2) and 62B of the Family Law Act 1975, the particulars of the obligations these orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these orders are set out in Annexure A and those particulars are included in these orders .
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.