Weismann & Anor v Noel Victor Weismann and Heritage Ironwork Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2009] QDC 153

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No 498 of 2008

DESLEY WEISMANN AND
DARREN ARCH
Plaintiffs

and

NOEL VICTOR WEISMANN AND
HERITAGE IRONWORK PTY LTD (ACN 052 482 603)
Defendants

BRISBANE

..DATE 30/01/2009

ORDER

CATCHWORDS: Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 s 9(7), s 43, s 59 - Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 69 - plaintiffs' application to substitute as defendant (after expiration of the limitation period) the two individuals who were the
directors and shareholders of the defendant company - the proceedings were instituted pursuant to leave under s 43 of the Act - whether the statutory stay under the section precluded the substitution

HIS HONOUR:  On the 15th of March 2005, a tragic accident occurred at the premises of the first defendant.  A nine-year-old boy, the son of the plaintiffs and grandson of the first defendant, was found crushed under a large metal gate weighing some 300 kilograms which was intended to slide on a track across the entrance to the first defendant's place.  It had come off the track and nobody knows how.  The female plaintiff was in the house.  The male plaintiff was out of town.  Both claim damages for nervous shock attributable to their learning of the accident, which, if I haven't made it clear already, culminated in the nine-year-old boy's death when his life support was turned off. 

The second defendant was sued as the supplier of the gate.  There is material before the Court suggesting that the first defendant undertook some of the installation himself.  He certainly appears to have undertaken the maintenance of the gate and may well have made some changes to it since its installation which it seems occurred in 1991 although it may have been later. 

The Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 applies to the claim. The filing of the proceeding occurred pursuant to an order of his Honour Judge Brabazon QC pursuant to section 43 which acknowledged the stay required by the Act to apply until the pre-litigation steps mandated by it were attended to. The claim and statement of claim were duly filed before the expiration of the three-year limitation period. By that time a Part 1 notice of claim under the Act had gone to the second defendant, Heritage Ironwork Pty Ltd, as well as one going to the first defendant.

It has subsequently emerged that the second defendant may be the wrong party, that at the relevant time the business known as Weldcraft, which the first defendant indicated, presumably correctly, was the supplier of the gate, was conducted by the respondents to this application, Mr and Mrs Simpson, who have been ably represented by Mr Evans of counsel to resist it.  They present to the Court, according to Mr Littler's affidavit, as uncertain whether they had any, if so what, insurance.  That consideration ought not to affect the outcome but it may explain why the application before the Court which was filed on the 28th of November last year as one seeking…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Weismann & Anor v Noel Victor Weismann and Heritage Ironwork... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QDC 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Desley Weismann and Darren Arch, brought a claim against Noel Victor Weismann and Heritage Ironwork Pty Ltd (Heritage) after a tragic accident in which the plaintiffs' son was crushed to death by a metal gate at Noel's premises. The plaintiffs sought damages for nervous shock due to witnessing the accident. The Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 applied to the case. The proceedings were instituted with leave under section 43 of the Act, which mandated a pre-litigation stay that was in effect until the plaintiffs completed the required steps. The plaintiffs filed their claim and statement of claim within the three-year limitation period. However, it was later discovered that Heritage might not be the correct defendant, and the actual supplier of the gate could have been Paul and Wendy Simpson, who conducted the business under the name Weldcraft.

The court had to decide whether the plaintiffs could substitute the Simpsons as defendants after the limitation period had expired and whether the statutory stay under section 43 precluded such substitution. The plaintiffs argued that the substitution related to the constitution of the proceeding by getting the correct parties involved rather than advancing the proceeding in a material way. They relied on section 9(7) of the Act, which allows for the identification of parties intended to be brought into litigation based on their roles. The Simpsons, on the other hand, objected to being brought into the proceeding, citing unfairness and the potential loss of the protection of the limitation period.

The court held that the statutory stay under section 43 effectively prevented any step from being taken in the relevant proceeding that would advance it. However, the substitution sought by the plaintiffs related to the constitution of the proceeding by getting the correct parties involved, rather than advancing the proceeding. The court found the plaintiffs' argument persuasive and allowed the substitution of the Simpsons as defendants, holding that the statutory stay did not preclude such substitution. The court made orders in terms of the original application, allowing the plaintiffs to file an amended claim and statement of claim naming Paul and Wendy Simpson trading as Weldcraft as the second defendant. The court also awarded costs in the cause.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established