Weiben v Great Southern Cattle Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Weiben & Ors v Great Southern Cattle Holdings Pty Ltd [2008] QLC 0141

PARTIES:Sydney Weiben (25%), Jeffrey Sydney Weiben (25%), Ken Leon Sutherland (25%) and Robert James Wiltshire (25%)

(Applicants)

v

Great Southern Holdings Pty Ltd
(Respondent)

FILE NO:MLC00256/2007

PROCEEDING:  Application to determine compensation

DELIVERED ON:                  16 July 2008

DELIVERED AT:                   Brisbane

MEMBER:Mr FW Windridge, Judicial Registrar

ORDERS:1.  Compensation determined at $100.00 for the term of the renewal.

2.Such compensation to be paid by the miner to the landowner in the sum of $100.00 within 2 months of notification of the renewal of the mining lease.

3.The miner pay the sum of $20.00 to the landowner for the second and subsequent years each and every year in arrears until such time as an alternate access is finalised.

4.No order for costs.

CATCHWORDS:                  Compensation – mining lease – grazing property – new access – injurious affection

Mineral Resources Act 1989, s. 281

Smith v Cameron [1986-1987] 11 QLCR 64

Shaw v Heritage Holdings Pty Ltd (1992-93) 14 QLCR 139

Mitchell v Oakhill and Mitchell (10 March 1998) unreported

APPEARANCES:                  Mr S Weiben (principal applicant) for miners

Mr J Minchinton of Clayton Utz for landowners

  1. This is an application under s. 281 of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (MRA) for the determination of compensation for the effect upon the respondent landowners (Great Southern Cattle Holdings Pty Ltd) of the proposed renewal of mining lease number 7525 in the Charters Towers District.

  1. The lease is located on Lot 3 on CP846344 for mining and access.  Compensation to be determined is that part of the mining lease and access that is on land held by the respondent landowners.  The actual area of the lease is 2.00 ha, and the renewal sought is for a period of five (5) years.  

  1. The parties have been unable to resolve the issue of compensation, and the matter has been referred by the principal applicant to the Land Court for determination. Whilst it is within the power of the parties to come to agreement on any issues, the power of the Court (as it now is), is limited to s. 281 of the MRA.

  1. The Land Court has given directions in relation to submissions, and this matter has been dealt with on the papers, with supplemental submissions from Mr Weiben by telephone and an appearance of Mr Minchinton solicitor of Clayton Utz for the respondent landowner, on 1 July 2008.  The landowners have lodged a written submission through their legal advisors.  The applicant miner has lodged a short written submission in which he refers to a number of matters.  The short and general submission of the miner made reference to some other leases in the area.  These leases are not under consideration here and I have restricted this determination to ML 7525 only.  No site visit has been conducted.

Compensation

  1. Relevantly, s. 281(3)(a) requires the Court to settle the amount of compensation an owner of land is entitled to as compensation for:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Weiben v Great Southern Cattle Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QLC 141
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Land Court of Queensland was asked to decide a compensation dispute between the applicants, who are the owners of a mining lease, and the respondent, who is the owner of a grazing property where the mining lease is located. The applicants sought a determination of compensation for the effect on the respondent's land due to the renewal of the mining lease. The dispute centred around the amount of compensation the applicants should pay to the respondent for the lease's impact on the land. The court was required to decide on the compensation amount, considering factors such as the deprivation of possession, diminution of value, and severance of land. The court also had to determine if any additional compensation should be awarded for the compulsory nature of the action taken under the Mineral Resources Act 1989.

The court considered the relevant provisions of the Mineral Resources Act 1989, as well as past cases such as Smith v Cameron, Shaw v Heritage Holdings Pty Ltd, and Mitchell v Oakhill and Mitchell. The court noted that the method of assessment remains a matter to be governed by the facts and circumstances of each case. In this instance, the parties had each arrived at a quantum by reference to what is in their opinion the value of the land. The court took into account the location of the lease, the proposed change of access, and the potential effect on the management of the pastoral holding. The court determined that an "en globo" award would sufficiently encompass any award under diminution of value, deprivation of use, and deprivation of value.

Based on the unimproved value of the land provided by the applicants and the location and size of the lease, the court determined compensation at the rate of $35.5129 per hectare for a term of 5 years on 2 hectares. The court also awarded compensation for access, as well as an additional 10% for the compulsory nature of the action. The total compensation determined was $100.00, which the court rounded off to $100. The court ordered that the compensation should be paid in full within 2 months of notification by the Registrar that the lease has been renewed, with an additional $20.00 per year in respect of the mining lease payable yearly in arrears until such time as the change of access is registered and the current nominated access is rendered null and void in respect of the lease.

The final orders of the court were:
1. Compensation determined at $100.00 for the term of the renewal.
2. Such compensation to be paid by the miner to the landowner in the sum of $100.00 within 2 months of notification of the renewal of the mining lease.
3. The miner pay the sum of $20.00 to the landowner for the second and subsequent years each and every year in arrears until such time as an alternate access is finalised.
4. No order for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves an application under s. 281 of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 for the determination of compensation for the effect upon the respondent landowners (Great Southern Cattle Holdings Pty Ltd) of the proposed renewal of mining lease number 7525 in the Charters Towers District. The lease is located on Lot 3 on CP846344 for mining and access. The area of the lease is 2.00 ha, and the renewal sought is for a period of five years. The lease is situated in a remote part of the property, near the Stalwell River which is the boundary between Chudleigh Park and other properties to the south. The parties have been unable to resolve the issue of compensation, leading to the matter being referred to the Land Court for determination.

This matter was referred to the Land Court by the principal applicant for the determination of compensation under s. 281 of the Mineral Resources Act 1989. The Court has given directions in relation to submissions, and the matter has been dealt with on the papers, with supplemental submissions from Mr Weiben by telephone and an appearance of Mr Minchinton, solicitor of Clayton Utz for the respondent landowner, on 1 July 2008. The landowners have lodged a written submission through their legal advisors, and the applicant miner has lodged a short written submission referring to a number of matters. No site visit has been conducted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate compensation for the deprivation of possession of the surface of the land?
2. What is the appropriate compensation for the diminution of the value of the land or any improvements thereon?
3. What is the appropriate compensation for the diminution of the use made or which may be made of the land or any improvements thereon?
4. Should compensation be awarded for severance of any part of the land from other parts thereof or from other land of the owner?
5. What is the appropriate compensation for any surface rights of access?
6. What is the appropriate compensation for all loss or expense that arises as a consequence of the grant or renewal of the mining lease?
7. Should an additional amount be determined to reflect the compulsory nature of action taken under this part, and if so, what is the appropriate amount?

Held
1. The appropriate compensation for the deprivation of possession of the surface of the land was determined to be nominal, given the remote location of the lease.
2. The appropriate compensation for the diminution of the value of the land or any improvements thereon was not quantified but considered negligible.
3. The appropriate compensation for the diminution of the use made or which may be made of the land or any improvements thereon was not quantified but considered negligible.
4. The court did not award compensation for severance of any part of the land from other parts thereof or from other land of the owner, as there was no evidence of severance.
5. The appropriate compensation for any surface rights of access was determined to be $100.00 for the first year and $20.00 per year in arrears thereafter until a new access is registered.
6. The appropriate compensation for all loss or expense that arises as a consequence of the grant or renewal of the mining lease was determined to be $100.00 for the term of the renewal.
7. An additional amount of 10% was determined to reflect the compulsory nature of action taken under this part, amounting to $9.10.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the compensation payable under section 281(3) of the Mineral Resources Act 1989, which requires the court to account for the deprivation of possession of the surface of the land, diminution of the value of the land or any improvements thereon, diminution of the use made or which may be made of the land or any improvements thereon, severance of any part of the land from other parts thereof or from other land of the owner, surface rights of access, and all loss or expense that arises as a consequence of the grant or renewal of the mining lease. The court also considered the additional amount to be determined under section 281(4)(e) to reflect the compulsory nature of action taken under this part, which is not less than 10% of the aggregate amount determined under subsection (3). The court acknowledged that the legislation does not prescribe a method of assessment and that each case will depend on its own facts and circumstances. The court determined that an "en globo" award will sufficiently encompass any award under diminution of value, deprivation of use, and deprivation of value. The court accepted the unimproved valuation of the land per hectare put forward by the miner and determined compensation at the rate of $35.5129 per hectare for a term of 5 years on 2 hectares. The court also determined compensation for access and an additional 10% to reflect the compulsory nature of action taken under this part. The court did not award compensation for injurious affection as it considered that a prudent purchaser at arm's length, and fully appraised of the facts and circumstances, would not seek any reduction in the purchase price because of the existence of this lease.

The binding legal principle established or applied by the decision is that the court has the power to determine compensation for the effect upon the landowner of the proposed renewal of a mining lease under section 281 of the Mineral Resources Act 1989, and that the court should consider all relevant factors in determining the amount of compensation payable. The court distinguished the present case from previous cases by considering the specific facts and circumstances of the case, including the remote location of the lease, the lack of evidence of severance or diminution of value or use, and the proposed change of access. The court followed previous cases in considering that the amount of compensation finally determined sufficiently accounts for each of the matters referred to in subsection (3) of section 281 of the Act, and that it is not necessary to quantify an amount in respect of each of the matters referred to.