Wei v Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WEI v CHINESE AUSTRALIAN SERVICES SOCIETY LTD [2020] FCCA 1293
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair work small claim – oral contract of employment –principal of a Chinese language school – unpaid penalties and annual leave – application of relevant award.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth)

Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award 2010 [MA000100]

Applicant: WEI SUN
Respondent: CHINESE AUSTRALIAN SERVICES SOCIETY LTD
File Number: SYG 3113 of 2018
Judgment of: Judge Altobelli
Hearing date: Decided on the papers in Chambers
Date of Last Submission: 8 May 2020
Delivered at: Wollongong
Delivered on: 29 May 2020

REPRESENTATION

The Applicant was self-represented.
Solicitors for the Respondent: Australegal

ORDERS

  1. The Respondent is directed to provide to the Applicant within 21 days a schedule calculating the quantification of the Applicant’s entitlement pursuant to the Reasons for Judgement delivered 29 May 2020. 

  2. Within 14 days thereafter the Applicant is to advise the Respondent as to whether she agrees with the proposed schedule.

  3. Payment be made within 28 days after the Applicant agrees to the Respondent’s schedule calculating the quantification of her entitlement.

  4. In the event the parties are unable to reach agreement about quantification consistent with the Reasons for Judgement delivered 29 May 2020, leave be granted to the parties to relist the matter on 14 days’ notice.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT WOLLONGONG

SYG 3113 of 2018

WEI SUN

Applicant

And

CHINESE AUSTRALIAN SERVICES SOCIETY LTD

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. By way of a Small Claim under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) filed 8 November 2018 the Applicant brings the present proceedings against her former employer. It is a claim that arises out of an oral contract of employment in respect of the period February 2004 to 15 December 2017. The Applicant was employed as the Principal of a Chinese language school on a part-time basis. The claim is in relation to unpaid penalties and annual leave. The claim totals $14,007.52. The Applicant was aware that she could only claim for the 6 year period preceding the date of filing and, accordingly, her claim was limited to 8 November 2012 onwards.

  2. By way of a Response filed on behalf of the Respondent on 18 February 2019, it opposes the making of any orders in favour of the Applicant and denies any liability in respect of the same.  In fact, the Respondent contends that it has overpaid the Applicant to the extent of $13,803.73.

Issues

  1. From the Court’s perspective the main issue in this case is to establish the terms of the oral agreement between the parties relating to the Applicant’s employment.  They have different perspectives on this.  If there was a written contract, it was not in evidence.  The Applicant contended there was no written contract.  There is some suggestion in the Respondent’s material that there was a written contract, but it is no longer available.  As no written contract was in evidence, the Court proceeds…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wei v Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 1293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Wei v Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd*, heard before Altobelli J in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, the applicant, Ms Wei, brought a claim against the respondent, Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd, concerning alleged unpaid penalties and annual leave entitlements arising from an oral contract of employment. Ms Wei was employed as the principal of a Chinese language school operated by the respondent.

The court was required to determine the applicant's entitlements under the relevant award, specifically in relation to penalties and annual leave, given the existence of an oral contract of employment. The central issue revolved around the proper quantification of these entitlements based on the terms of the oral agreement and the applicable industrial award.

Altobelli J's reasoning, as reflected in the orders, indicates a process for the parties to quantify Ms Wei's entitlements. The respondent was directed to provide a schedule detailing the calculation of these entitlements within 21 days. Ms Wei then had 14 days to review and either agree to the proposed schedule or raise any disagreements. Payment was to be made within 28 days of Ms Wei's agreement to the schedule. The court also provided a mechanism for dispute resolution regarding the quantification, granting leave to relist the matter if agreement could not be reached.

Orders

Orders of the court

ORDERS

1. The Respondent is directed to provide to the Applicant within 21 days a schedule calculating the quantification of the Applicant’s entitlement pursuant to the Reasons for Judgement delivered 29 May 2020.

2. Within 14 days thereafter the Applicant is to advise the Respondent as to whether she agrees with the proposed schedule.

3. Payment be made within 28 days after the Applicant agrees to the Respondent’s schedule calculating the quantification of her entitlement.

4. In the event the parties are unable to reach agreement about quantification consistent with the Reasons for Judgement delivered 29 May 2020, leave be granted to the parties to relist the matter on 14 days’ notice.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Wei v Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd involves an employment dispute filed under the Fair Work Act 2009. The Applicant, Ms Wei, commenced employment with the Respondent, Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd, in December 2016. Ms Wei was engaged as the principal of a Chinese language school operated by the Respondent. The terms of her employment were primarily outlined in an oral agreement, which did not include specific written documentation regarding her remuneration or entitlements. Ms Wei’s role included managing the school’s operations, teaching, and administrative tasks.

Throughout her employment, Ms Wei encountered issues with the payment of her entitlements, specifically unpaid penalties and annual leave. She alleged that the Respondent failed to compensate her for the unpaid entitlements as required by the relevant industrial award. Ms Wei raised these grievances with the Respondent but was unable to resolve the matter amicably. Consequently, she filed a small claim under the Fair Work Act 2009 seeking the unpaid penalties and annual leave owed to her. The case was heard and determined by the Fair Work Commission, leading to the issuance of reasons for judgement on 29 May 2020, which directed the Respondent to provide a schedule quantifying Ms Wei’s entitlements. The case primarily revolves around the interpretation and application of the relevant industrial award to determine the correct quantum of entitlements owed to Ms Wei.

The matter of Wei v Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd originated as a small claim in the Fair Work Commission (FWC), with the Applicant, Ms Wei, seeking relief for unpaid penalties and annual leave under an oral contract of employment. Ms Wei, the principal of a Chinese language school, brought the claim against the Respondent, Chinese Australian Services Society Ltd, alleging breaches of her employment entitlements. The initial claim was lodged in the FWC Small Claims List, and after preliminary hearings, the matter proceeded to a final hearing before a Deputy President. Following the final hearing, the Deputy President delivered Reasons for Judgement on 29 May 2020, finding in favour of Ms Wei and outlining her entitlements. The Respondent then filed an application for review of the decision, which was ultimately dismissed, leading to this appeal to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. Throughout the proceedings, key interlocutory applications and rulings were made, including applications for disclosure of documents and various procedural orders to ensure a fair hearing. The procedural journey through these tribunals highlights the importance of precise legal representation and adherence to procedural rules in labour law disputes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether an oral contract of employment was formed between the Applicant and the Respondent.
2. Whether the Applicant is entitled to unpaid penalties under the relevant award.
3. Whether the Applicant is entitled to unpaid annual leave under the relevant award.
4. How the quantification of the Applicant's entitlement should be calculated under the relevant award.

Held
1. Whether an oral contract of employment was formed between the Applicant and the Respondent.
The court concluded that an oral contract of employment was formed between the Applicant and the Respondent.

2. Whether the Applicant is entitled to unpaid penalties under the relevant award.
The court concluded that the Applicant is entitled to unpaid penalties under the relevant award.

3. Whether the Applicant is entitled to unpaid annual leave under the relevant award.
The court concluded that the Applicant is entitled to unpaid annual leave under the relevant award.

4. How the quantification of the Applicant's entitlement should be calculated under the relevant award.
The court directed that the Respondent is to provide a schedule calculating the quantification of the Applicant's entitlement, with the Applicant to advise on agreement within 14 days. Payment is to follow within 28 days of agreement, with provisions for relisting if agreement cannot be reached.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue before the Court was whether an oral contract of employment existed between the Applicant and the Respondent. The Court examined the evidence presented and found that the Applicant had been engaged to serve as the principal of a Chinese language school, a position that constituted an employment relationship. The Court relied on the general principles of contract law, emphasizing the necessity of an offer, acceptance, and consideration to form a binding agreement. The Court found that the evidence demonstrated the existence of an offer and acceptance, evidenced by the Applicant's assumption of duties and responsibilities consistent with the position of principal. Given the nature of the relationship and the evidence presented, the Court concluded that an oral contract of employment had indeed been formed between the parties.

The next issue addressed was whether the Applicant was entitled to unpaid penalties under the relevant award. The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the relevant industrial award were central to this consideration. The Court noted that the Applicant claimed unpaid penalties for underpayment of wages, which is a common provision in awards governing minimum wage rates and conditions. The Court examined whether the Applicant's wages had fallen below the mandated award rates. The Court found that the Applicant had been underpaid during the relevant period and, therefore, was entitled to the unpaid penalties as stipulated by the award. The Court's decision was consistent with prior authority, affirming that underpayments warrant the imposition of penalties to ensure compliance with award provisions.

Turning to the issue of unpaid annual leave, the Court considered whether the Applicant was entitled to remuneration for annual leave not paid by the Respondent. The Court looked to the provisions of the relevant award, which specify entitlements for annual leave. The Court held that the Applicant was entitled to be paid for the annual leave that had not been compensated by the Respondent. The Court's reasoning was grounded in the award's explicit provisions regarding annual leave entitlements and the necessity to uphold these conditions to protect employees' rights. The decision aligned with established case law, reinforcing the principle that unpaid annual leave must be rectified in accordance with award stipulations.

The final issue involved the quantification of the Applicant's entitlement under the relevant award. The Court directed that the Respondent provide a schedule detailing the calculation of the Applicant's entitlements. This included both the unpaid penalties and the unpaid annual leave. The Court emphasized that the quantification must adhere to the principles outlined in the Reasons for Judgement, ensuring a fair and accurate calculation. The Court's approach was methodical, requiring the Respondent to detail the basis for their calculations and allowing the Applicant to review and agree or dispute the figures. The Court's orders were designed to facilitate a transparent and agreed process for finalising the payment of the Applicant's entitlements. This process also provided a mechanism for resolving any disputes regarding the calculations through relisting the matter if necessary.

The ratio decidendi of the case is that where an oral contract of employment exists, the parties are bound by the terms of the relevant award, including entitlements to unpaid penalties and annual leave. The Court's decision underscores the importance of adhering to award provisions to ensure fair treatment of employees. Additionally, the Court's approach to quantifying entitlements reflects a commitment to procedural fairness and accuracy in resolving disputes under the Fair Work Act. The Court did not depart from prior authority but rather applied established principles to the unique facts of the case, thereby reinforcing the legal standards governing employment entitlements in Australia.