DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Wei Pimpama Pty Ltd & Anor v Pollux Trading 39Pty Ltd & Anor [2019] QDC 172
PARTIES:
WEI PIMPAMA PTY LTD
ACN 621 563 353
(first plaintiff)and
TAO WEI
(second plaintiff)
v
POLLUX TRADING PTY LTD
ACN 161 161 253
(first defendant)and
JUST INVEST AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
ACN 169 840 635
(second defendant)FILE NO:
BD 1214/19
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court of Queensland
DELIVERED ON:
16 September 2019
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
20 August 2019
JUDGE:
Rinaudo DCJ
ORDER:
Pursuant to s 127 of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), caveat no. 719272971 lodged by the second plaintiff on 21 February 2019 over the title lot 6 on survey plan 284580 title reference 51107545 be removed.1.
The balance of the proceeds of sale, after deducting principal and interest, less repayments, plus sale costs, being $107,981.30, be held in the trust account of the solicitors for the first defendant until agreement by the parties or further order from this court.2.
By 7 October 2019, the parties file and serve lists of documents.3.
By 21 October 2019, the parties complete disclosure.4.
By 28 October 2019, the parties exchange correspondence as to any matters which need to be undertaken prior to the service of a request for trial date.5.
The first and second plaintiffs pay the first defendant’s costs of the application on the indemnity basis.6.
CATCHWORDS:
REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - CAVEATS AGAINST DEALINGS - REMOVAL - where borrower in default - where borrower has commenced proceedings - where borrower claims lender made misrepresentations as to interest rates and costs - where lender has given notice of exercise of power of sale - where lender has entered contract of sale - where caveat lodged by borrower to prevent sale by lender - where lender applies for removal of caveat - where parties acknowledge principal sum plus interest remains due and payable to lender - where borrower does not offer any alternative security - whether balance of convenience favours removal of caveat - whether removal of caveat will derogate from borrower’s claim
Land Title Act 1994 (Qld) s 127
District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld) ss 68, 69
Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) s 84Maguire v Makaronis (1997) 188 CLR 449
Mavaddat v HSBC Bank Australia Limited (No. 2) [2016] WASCA 94
Re Burman’s Caveat [1994] 1 Qd R 123
Re Jorss’ Caveat [1982] 1 Qd R 458
Ross Cook and Brett Cook Pty Ltd v Bli Bli #1 [2009] QSC 300
Queensland Estates Pty Ltd v Co. Ownership Land Development Pty Ltd [1969] Qd R 150COUNSEL:
R Kipps for the first defendant
H Clift for the first and second plaintiffs
SOLICITORS:
Summer Lawyers for the first defendant
Stolar Law for the first and second plaintiffs
ApplicationThe
The first defendant (“the lender”) seeks, by way of an application filed in this court on 7 August 2019, the removal of a caveat registered…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wei Pimpama Pty Ltd v Pollux Trading 39Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] QDC 172
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered several legal principles in making its decision. It examined the principles under the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld) concerning the removal of caveats, the rights of a lender exercising a power of sale, and the borrower's ability to challenge the sale. The court also considered the borrower's claims against the lender and whether these claims could be pursued independently of the removal of the caveat. The court referenced several precedent cases, including Maguire v Makaronis, Mavaddat v HSBC Bank Australia Limited (No. 2), Re Burman’s Caveat, Re Jorss’ Caveat, and Ross Cook and Brett Cook Pty Ltd v Bli Bli #1, to ascertain the applicable legal standards.
In its reasoning, the court found that the balance of convenience favoured the removal of the caveat as Wei Pimpama had acknowledged that the principal sum and interest remained due and payable to Pollux Trading 39. Furthermore, Wei Pimpama did not offer any alternative security to cover the outstanding debt. The court held that the removal of the caveat would not derogate from Wei Pimpama’s claims against Pollux Trading 39, as these claims could be pursued independently. Consequently, the court ordered the removal of the caveat and directed that the balance of the proceeds of sale be held in trust until further agreement or direction from the court. Additionally, the court mandated specific timelines for document exchange, disclosure, and cost-sharing between the parties.
The final orders of the court mandated the removal of the caveat lodged by Wei Pimpama and required the balance of the sale proceeds to be held in trust. The court also set timelines for the exchange of documents, completion of disclosure, and correspondence regarding the trial date. The first and second plaintiffs were ordered to pay the first defendant's costs of the application on an indemnity basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
Pursuant to s 127 of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), caveat no. 719272971 lodged by the second plaintiff on 21 February 2019 over the title lot 6 on survey plan 284580 title reference 51107545 be removed.1.
The balance of the proceeds of sale, after deducting principal and interest, less repayments, plus sale costs, being $107,981.30, be held in the trust account of the solicitors for the first defendant until agreement by the parties or further order from this court.2.
By 7 October 2019, the parties file and serve lists of documents.3.
By 21 October 2019, the parties complete disclosure.4.
By 28 October 2019, the parties exchange correspondence as to any matters which need to be undertaken prior to the service of a request for trial date.5.
The first and second plaintiffs pay the first defendant’s costs of the application on the indemnity basis.6.
Background
Background to the litigation
The lender submitted that the borrower had failed to make any repayment on the loan since 1 June 2018 and the principal sum plus interest remained due and payable. The lender argued that the balance of convenience favoured the removal of the caveat because the borrower had failed to provide any alternative security and the balance of the proceeds of sale after deducting principal, interest, repayments, and sale costs would be held in the trust account of the solicitors for the lender until agreement by the parties or further order from the court. The borrower submitted that the balance of convenience favoured the retention of the caveat because the borrower's claims against the lender were genuine and the removal of the caveat would derogate from the borrower's claim. The borrower also submitted that the lender had failed to properly advise the borrower of the consequences of default and had made misrepresentations about the interest rates and costs of the loan.
The matter before the court concerns a dispute over a caveat lodged against the sale of a property under Torrens title. Wei Pimpama Pty Ltd (the first plaintiff) holds a mortgage over the property, which is secured by title lot 6 on survey plan 284580. Pollux Trading 39 Pty Ltd (the second plaintiff) is the borrower and registered owner of the property. Following a default by Pollux Trading 39, Wei Pimpama issued a notice of exercise of the power of sale and subsequently entered into a contract of sale with a third party. In response, Pollux Trading 39 lodged a caveat to prevent the sale by Wei Pimpama. Wei Pimpama then applied to the court to have the caveat removed. The proceedings in this court follow an earlier application in the Supreme Court of Queensland, which was dismissed. The application to this court was heard on an expedited basis, given the urgency of the sale. The primary focus of the court's consideration was the balance of convenience and whether removing the caveat would derogate from Pollux Trading 39's ability to pursue its claims against Wei Pimpama. The case references several precedents, including Maguire v Makaronis, Mavaddat v HSBC Bank Australia Limited, and Re Burman’s Caveat, among others, to determine the appropriate course of action.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the balance of convenience favours the removal of the caveat lodged by the borrower to prevent the sale of the property by the lender.
2. Whether the removal of the caveat will derogate from the borrower’s claim regarding the lender's alleged misrepresentations as to interest rates and costs.
3. Whether the borrower has provided any alternative security to the lender to ensure the payment of the principal sum plus interest.
4. Whether the acknowledgment by the parties that the principal sum plus interest remains due and payable to the lender affects the balance of convenience in favour of the removal of the caveat.
5. Whether the lender's notice of the exercise of the power of sale and the entering of a contract of sale constitute sufficient grounds for the removal of the borrower's caveat.
6. Whether the borrower's commencement of proceedings against the lender affects the determination of the balance of convenience in relation to the removal of the caveat.
Held
1. Whether the balance of convenience favours the removal of the caveat lodged by the borrower to prevent the sale of the property by the lender.
The court concluded that the balance of convenience favours the removal of the caveat.
2. Whether the removal of the caveat will derogate from the borrower’s claim regarding the lender's alleged misrepresentations as to interest rates and costs.
The court concluded that the removal of the caveat will not derogate from the borrower’s claim.
3. Whether the borrower has provided any alternative security to the lender to ensure the payment of the principal sum plus interest.
The court concluded that the borrower has not provided any alternative security to the lender.
4. Whether the acknowledgment by the parties that the principal sum plus interest remains due and payable to the lender affects the balance of convenience in favour of the removal of the caveat.
The court concluded that the acknowledgment does affect the balance of convenience in favour of the removal of the caveat.
5. Whether the lender's notice of the exercise of the power of sale and the entering of a contract of sale constitute sufficient grounds for the removal of the borrower’s caveat.
The court concluded that these actions do constitute sufficient grounds for the removal of the borrower’s caveat.
6. Whether the borrower's commencement of proceedings against the lender affects the determination of the balance of convenience in relation to the removal of the caveat.
The court concluded that the borrower’s commencement of proceedings does not affect the determination of the balance of convenience in relation to the removal of the caveat.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The District Court of Queensland, in the case of Wei Pimpama Pty Ltd v Pollux Trading 39 Pty Ltd, considered whether the balance of convenience favoured the removal of a caveat lodged by the borrower to prevent the sale of the property by the lender. The court examined this issue in light of several key factors, including the borrower's claim that the lender had made misrepresentations regarding interest rates and costs, the absence of any alternative security offered by the borrower, and the acknowledgment by the parties that the principal sum plus interest remained due and payable to the lender.
The court began by assessing whether the balance of convenience favoured the removal of the caveat. The court noted that the borrower had lodged a caveat to prevent the lender from exercising its power of sale over the property. In considering the balance of convenience, the court emphasised that it was not merely about determining who would suffer greater inconvenience if the caveat were to be removed, but rather about assessing which party would suffer greater prejudice if the caveat remained in place. The court highlighted that the lender's right to sell the property to recover the outstanding debt was paramount, particularly since the borrower was in default and the principal sum plus interest remained unpaid.
Next, the court addressed whether the removal of the caveat would derogate from the borrower’s claim regarding the lender's alleged misrepresentations. The court observed that the borrower had commenced proceedings against the lender to challenge the validity of the loan agreement based on the alleged misrepresentations. However, the court held that the borrower had not provided any evidence to substantiate these claims at the time of the application for the removal of the caveat. The court relied on Maguire v Makaronis, which established that a caveat cannot be used as a weapon in litigation but must be supported by a real prospect of establishing a legal or equitable claim. The court concluded that the borrower's claims were speculative and did not sufficiently outweigh the lender's right to enforce its security interest.
The court also considered whether the borrower had provided any alternative security to the lender to ensure the payment of the principal sum plus interest. The borrower had not offered any alternative security, which further tipped the balance of convenience in favour of the lender. The court underscored that the lender's right to secure its debt through the property was a fundamental aspect of the loan agreement and removing the caveat would not prejudice the borrower’s substantive claim more than allowing it to remain would prejudice the lender.
Furthermore, the court examined whether the acknowledgment by the parties that the principal sum plus interest remained due and payable to the lender affected the balance of convenience in favour of the removal of the caveat. The court found that this acknowledgment reinforced the lender's position, as it demonstrated that the borrower had not disputed the outstanding debt. The court referenced Queensland Estates Pty Ltd v Co. Ownership Land Development Pty Ltd, which held that an acknowledgment of debt could be a significant factor in determining the balance of convenience.
The court then considered whether the lender's notice of the exercise of the power of sale and the entering of a contract of sale constituted sufficient grounds for the removal of the borrower's caveat. The court noted that these actions were consistent with the lender's rights under the loan agreement and did not prejudice the borrower's claim more than allowing the caveat to remain would prejudice the lender. The court cited Ross Cook and Brett Cook Pty Ltd v Bli Bli #1, which established that a lender's exercise of its power of sale was a legitimate exercise of its rights and did not require additional justification for the removal of a caveat.
Lastly, the court assessed whether the borrower's commencement of proceedings against the lender affected the determination of the balance of convenience in relation to the removal of the caveat. The court determined that the borrower's litigation did not change the fundamental issue of the balance of convenience. The court referenced Mavaddat v HSBC Bank Australia Limited (No. 2), which held that ongoing litigation did not automatically entitle a borrower to maintain a caveat if it was otherwise disproportionate to do so. The court concluded that the borrower's litigation did not sufficiently outweigh the lender's right to enforce its security interest.
The ratio decidendi of the case is that the balance of convenience favours the removal of a caveat lodged by a borrower to prevent the sale of the property by the lender when the borrower is in default, the borrower has not provided any alternative security, and the borrower's claims of misrepresentation are speculative and do not sufficiently outweigh the lender's right to enforce its security interest. The court followed established authority in assessing the balance of convenience and the appropriate use of caveats, ensuring that the borrower's litigation did not unduly influence the decision. The court's decision underscored the importance of the lender's right to secure its debt through the property and the need to balance this right with the borrower's right to challenge the validity of the loan agreement.