WAYNE JAMES SMITH v KAYE LOUISE CHAMPION (NO 2)
[2009] ACTCA 15 (19 October 2009)
COSTS – costs of trial and costs of appeal – where proportional allocation of assets under Property (Relationship) Act 1984 (NSW) – where trial judge died before making order for costs – whether court has power to award costs of trial
Held: respondent pay appellant’s costs of trial on a party and party basis – appellant pay 80 percent of respondent’s costs of appeal – court has power to order costs of trial under s 37O(1)(b) of Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT) – appellant had substantial success at trial and had made offer to settle prior to trial – respondent had substantial success on appeal
PROPERTY – proportional allocation of assets under Property (Relationship) Act 1984 (NSW) – whether one party has preferential right to purchase property.
Held: neither party has preferential right to purchase property – assets allocated 59 percent to appellant and 41 percent to respondent taking into account appellant’s contributions.
Domestic Relationships Act 1994 (ACT) s 26
Property (Relationships) Act 1984 (NSW)
Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT) s 37O
Kardos v Sarbutt (No 2) [2006] NSWCA 206
Baker v Towle (2008) 39 Fam LR 323
Smith v Champion [2009] ACTCA 7
ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
No. ACTCA 25 - 2007
No. SC 270 of 2005
Judges: Higgins CJ, Refshauge and Besanko JJ
Court of Appeal of the Australian Capital Territory
Date: 19 October 2009
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE ) No. ACTCA 25 - 2007
) No. SC 270 of 2005
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
)
COURT OF APPEAL )
ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
BETWEEN: WAYNE JAMES SMITH
Appellant
AND: KAYE LOUISE CHAMPION
Respondent
ORDER
Judges: Higgins CJ, Refshauge and Besanko JJ
Date: 19 October 2009
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1 The appeal be allowed.
2 The orders made by Connolly J on 6 July 2007 be set aside.
3 In lieu of the orders made by Connolly J on 6 July 2007, there be the following orders.
3.1.1The property being Lot 1 in Deposited Plan 846623 at Hall, County of Murray in the State of New South Wales and known as “Dellwood” (Dellwood) be sold by auction in accordance with the following directions.
(a)The parties shall forthwith take all such steps, sign all such documents and give all such directions as may be necessary to cause Dellwood to be sold by auction with a reserve of $400,000.00 unless otherwise agreed between the parties;
(b)That the parties shall forthwith take all such steps, sign all such documents and give all such directions as may be necessary to appoint Richard Munings of Elders Real Estate Dickson as auctioneer including the signing of any agency agreement;
(c)Upon appointment the agent shall arrange for an inventory of all fixtures and fittings that are to be included in the sale;
(d)That…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wayne James Smith v Kaye Louise Champion (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] ACTCA 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether it possessed the power to award costs for the trial, given that the trial judge had died before making such orders. Additionally, the court had to determine if either party held a preferential right to purchase the property "Dellwood" and, consequently, the correct proportional allocation of assets between the parties.
The court held that it had the power to order costs of the trial under section 37O(1)(b) of the *Supreme Court Act 1933* (ACT). It found that neither party had a preferential right to purchase "Dellwood" and ultimately allocated the assets 59 percent to the appellant and 41 percent to the respondent, taking into account the appellant's contributions. The court ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the trial on a party and party basis, and that the appellant pay 80 percent of the respondent's costs of the appeal. The appeal was allowed, and the original orders were set aside and replaced with new orders detailing the sale of "Dellwood", the division of proceeds, and the payment of occupation fees and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be allowed.
2. The orders made by Connolly J on 6 July 2007 be set aside.
3. In lieu of the orders made by Connolly J on 6 July 2007, there be the following orders.
3.1.1 The property being Lot 1 in Deposited Plan 846623 at Hall, County of Murray in the State of New South Wales and known as “Dellwood” (Dellwood) be sold by auction in accordance with the following directions.
(a) The parties shall forthwith take all such steps, sign all such documents and give all such directions as may be necessary to cause Dellwood to be sold by auction with a reserve of $400,000.00 unless otherwise agreed between the parties;
(b) That the parties shall forthwith take all such steps, sign all such documents and give all such directions as may be necessary to appoint Richard Munings of Elders Real Estate Dickson as auctioneer including the signing of any agency agreement;
(c) Upon appointment the agent shall arrange for an inventory of all fixtures and fittings that are to be included in the sale;
(d) That the parties shall to the extent necessary accept the advice of the said Richard Munings as to the most opportune marketing campaign including the timing of the said auction; and further they shall each contribute, within seven days of being called upon, one half of moneys required by the said Richard Munings to enable an appropriate advertising campaign to be put in place;
(e) That Rod Barnett of Rod J Barnett & Associates of Fyshwick, ACT, be appointed solicitors for the sale; and further the parties shall each contribute, within seven days of being called upon, one half of moneys required by the said Rod Barnett to enable the preparation of necessary contractual documentation; and further the parties shall within seven days sign a fees agreement and/or letter of engagement or such other document which may be required by the said Rod Barnett to enable him to carry out the said instructions;
(f) The parties shall, when called upon, whether by the said Richard Munings or the said Rod Barnett attend upon the said person for the purpose of signing any necessary documentation including the contract for sale and/or the Transfer;
(g) The parties or their agents, duly authorised in writing, will attend the auction sale and, in the event Dellwood is passed in at auction, negotiate with the highest bidder at the said auction and shall in the event of a dispute between the parties accept the advice of the said Richard Munings whose decision shall be final;
(h) In the event Dellwood fails to sell at auction, or to sell immediately following upon the auction, and failing a determination in that event of the said Richard Munings that Dellwood should be offered by sale by private treaty, the said Richard Munings shall relist Dellwood for a further auction at a reserve price as agreed or otherwise as determined by the said Richard Munings.
3.1.2 The respondent shall have sole occupation of Dellwood until settlement of the sale provided that the respondent shall pay an occupation fee from the date of entry of these orders until settlement, such fee to be determined by a single judge of the Supreme Court having regard to the cost of improvements effected by the respondent to the property during her occupation of it and in the absence of agreement either party may apply for such determination upon three days’ notice to the other.
3.1.3 The respondent shall keep Dellwood in good order and condition in preparation for the sale.
3.1.4 Upon the sale of Dellwood the proceeds of sale shall be applied in the following manner and priority:
a. Payment of all funds necessary to discharge the mortgage to the National Australia Bank bearing registered number 2792770;
b. Payment of agent’s commission and disbursements including if necessary any outstanding expenses not paid by the parties;
c. Payment of any moneys necessary to enable an adjustment of rates to the date of settlement;
d. Payment of all legal costs and disbursements of Rod Barnett; AND the balance of the proceeds then remaining shall be divided between the parties in the following proportions: (i) 59 per cent to the appellant (ii) 41 per cent to the respondent
3.1.5 In the event that either party within seven days of being called upon neglects or fails to sign any documents, or to execute any deed, instrument or writing necessary to give effect to these Orders, the Registrar of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory is hereby appointed pursuant to section 26 of the Domestic Relationships Act 1994 (ACT) to sign the relevant document in the name of the defaulting party, and the defaulting party shall be solely liable for all costs arising from the operation of this Order.
3.1.6 Pending completion of the sale of Dellwood, the parties hold their respective interests in the property upon trust pursuant to these orders and neither party shall:
(a) encumber the property without the consent in writing of the other party;
(b) remove, or cause to be removed from the property, any furniture, effects, appliances and chattels listed in the inventory.
3.2 The proceeds of the sale of the Camden property be divided between the parties in the proportion of 41 per cent to the plaintiff and 59 per cent to the defendant.
3.3 The interim distribution to the parties of $50,000.00 each from the proceeds of the sale of the Camden property is to be taken into account in part satisfaction of the foregoing orders.
3.4 The plaintiff pay the defendant’s costs of the trial to be assessed on a party and party basis.
4. The appellant pay the respondent 80 per cent of her costs of the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.