Waymark Hotels Properties No 20 Pty Limited v Prentice Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Waymark Hotels Properties No 20 Pty Limited & Anor v Prentice Properties Pty Ltd & Ors [2023] QSC 117
PARTIES:

WAYMARK HOTELS PROPERTIES NO 20 PTY LIMITED ACN 662 746 929 ATF WARWICK PROPERTY TRUST

(first applicant)
CRITERION WARWICK OP CO PTY LIMITED ACN 662 749 582
(second applicant)
v
PRENTICE PROPERTIES PTY LTD ACN 009 997 513 ATF THE PRENTICE PROPERTIES TRUST

(first respondent)

CRITERION HOTEL MOTEL PTY LTD ACN 087 306 036
(second respondent)
ANTHONY ERNEST PRENTICE ATF THE SEI STAFF SUPERANNUATION FUND
(third respondent)
JENNY MAURICETTE PRENTICE ATF THE SEI STAFF SUPERANNUATION FUND
(fourth respondent)

ANTHONY ERNEST PRENTICE

(fifth respondent)

FILENO/S: BS No 4224 of 2023
DIVISION: Trial Division
PROCEEDING: Hearing
ORIGINATING COURT: Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVEREDON: 29 May 2023
DELIVEREDAT: Brisbane
HEARINGDATE: 24 April 2023; Further written submissions received on 28 April 2023 and 2 May 2023
JUDGE: Kelly J
ORDER:

1.     It is declared that the following contracts are valid and enforceable:

(a)     The Business Sale Contract dated 27 October 2022 for the sale of the business known as the Criterion Hotel Warwick, conducted at 84-86 Palmerin Street, Warwick and at Detached Bottle Shops at 108 Wood Street, Warwick and

Shop 1 Rose City Shopping World, Warwick, between the first respondent as seller and the second applicant as buyer (“the Business Contract”);

(b)     The Contract for Commercial Lots in a Community Titles Scheme dated 27 October 2022 for the sale of Lot 2 on BUP 102967 between the second respondent as seller and the first applicant as buyer (“the Hotel Land Contract”);

(c)      The Contract for Commercial Lots in a Community Titles Scheme dated 27 October 2022 for the sale of Lot 1 on BUP 102967 between the third and fourth respondents as sellers and the first applicant as buyer (“the Commercial Property Contract”);

(d)     The Contract for Commercial Land and Buildings dated 27 October 2022 for the sale of

14 Wallace Street Warwick between the first respondent as seller and the first applicant as buyer (“the Vacant Land Contract”);

(e)      The Contract for Commercial Land and Buildings dated 27 October 2022 for the sale of

108 Wood Street Warwick between the first respondent as seller and the first applicant as buyer (“the Wood Street Contract”).

(f)      The Umbrella Agreement dated 27 October 2022 between the first and second applicants, collectively being referred to as the Buyers, and the first to third respondents, collectively being referred to as the Sellers and the fifth respondent as guarantor, as amended by the Deed of Variation dated 20 December 2022 (“the Umbrella Agreement”).

2.    It is ordered that the Umbrella Agreement, the Business Contract, the Hotel Land Contract, the Commercial Property Contract, the Vacant Land Contract, and the Wood Street Contract be specifically performed.

3.    I will hear the parties as to any necessary orders and directions required for the implementation of the specific performance order.

4.    I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS: CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES –…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waymark Hotels Properties No 20 Pty Limited v Prentice Prope... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Waymark Hotels Properties No 20 Pty Limited v Prentice Properties Pty Ltd was heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland. The dispute between the parties revolved around the enforceability of certain contracts and agreements, including the Umbrella Agreement, Business Contract, Hotel Land Contract, Commercial Property Contract, Vacant Land Contract, and Wood Street Contract. The primary issue before the court was whether the contracts and agreements were binding and enforceable, or if they were too vague to be considered a binding contract.

The court had to determine whether the contracts were clear and specific enough to be enforceable, or if they contained vague or ambiguous terms that would render them unenforceable. The court examined the language and definitions used in the contracts, as well as the intentions of the parties involved. The court also considered whether the contracts contained all the necessary elements for a binding agreement, such as offer, acceptance, consideration, and intention to create legal relations.

In its decision, the court found that the contracts were sufficiently clear and specific to be considered binding and enforceable. The court noted that while some of the terms used in the contracts were broad or general, they were not so vague as to render the contracts unenforceable. The court also found that the contracts contained all the necessary elements for a binding agreement, and that the parties had clearly intended to create legal relations. As a result, the court declared that the contracts were valid and enforceable. The court also found that the Deed of Variation, which amended certain terms of the contracts, was valid and enforceable. The court made orders declaring the contracts and agreements to be valid and enforceable, and dismissed the claims of the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It is declared that the following contracts are valid and enforceable:

(a) The Business Sale Contract dated 27 October 2022 for the sale of the business known as the Criterion Hotel Warwick, conducted at 84-86 Palmerin Street, Warwick and at Detached Bottle Shops at 108 Wood Street, Warwick and

Background

Background to the litigation

The recitals to the Umbrella Agreement provide as follows: “Background Respondents’ Outline [24]. Ibid [37]. Ibid [42]. Exhibit 1 page 7. Clause 1 of the Umbrella Agreement contains the following definitions and provisions relating to interpretation:(a)“The Effective Date” for the purposes of the Umbrella Agreement was the date of its execution, 27 October 2022;(b)“Business” had the meaning given to it in the Business Contract, that is, the Business;(c)“Property” had the meaning given to it in the Business Contract, that is, the Hotel Land;(d)“Conditions” meant the Business Conditions and the Property Conditions;(e)“Business Conditions” had the meaning given to it in the Business Contract;(f)“Property Conditions” meant the conditions precedent set out in the Hotel Land Contract;(g)“The Deposit” meant “$825,000.00 on account of the total of all the deposits to be paid by [the second applicant] and [the first applicant] under the Sale Agreements”;(h)“Completion” meant “the completion of the sale and purchase of [the Hotel Land] and the Business in accordance with clause 5;(i)“Purchase Price” meant “the aggregate of the Initial Purchase Price and the Stock Purchase Price subject to any adjustments set out in the Sale Agreements being the price for [the Business] and [the Hotel Land]”;(j)“Initial Purchase Price” meant “$8,250,000.00, for the purchase of … the Business and [the Hotel Land]”;(k)“Stock Purchase Price” meant the Stock Amount as defined in the Business Contract;(l)“Satisfaction Date” had the meaning given to it in the Business Contract;(m)“Transaction Documents” relevantly meant the Umbrella Agreement, the Business Contract, the Hotel Land Contract, the Commercial Property Contract, the Vacant Land Contract and the Wood Street Contract; and The Umbrella Agreement then included the following substantive clauses: “2. Sale Agreements(a)On the Effective Date:(i) the Sellers must each duly execute and deliver to the Buyers counterparts of the relevant Sale Agreements and other Transaction Documents to which they are a party;(ii) the Buyers must each duly execute and deliver to the relevant Seller counterparts of the Sale Agreements and other Transaction Documents.(b)Within 5 Business Days after the Satisfaction Date, the Buyers must pay the Deposit to the Deposit Holder, to be held by the Deposit Holder as independent stakeholder.3. Conditions Precedent Clause 1.4(a) of the Umbrella Agreement. Defined to mean A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth). As to clause 6, schedule 1 relevantly included a warranty by the Sellers that the Transaction Documents were valid and binding agreements on the Sellers, enforceable in accordance with their terms.9 By the Deed of Variation:(a)The definition of the Deposit was amended so that the term meant $715,000; and(b)The definition of Initial Purchase Price was amended so that the term meant$7,150,000. The Business Contract defined “the Business” as “the business conducted by [the first respondent] known as the Criterion Hotel (Warwick) at [the Hotel Land] and the DBS Business conducted by the [first respondent] at the DBS Properties [being Wood Street and Rose City]”. “DBS Business” meant the business of a bottle shop carried on by the first respondent at Wood Street and Rose City.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established