WAV and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 463

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No W2001/388

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      WAV
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon C R Wright QC., (Deputy President)  

Date14 June 2002

PlacePerth

Decision      1.     The decision under review is set aside. 2.     In lieu thereof it is decided that the applicant is not precluded from the provisions of the Refugees Convention by virtue of the provisions of Article IF of the Convention. 3.   The applicant's application for a protection visa is remitted to the respondent for reconsideration in accordance with this decision.   

[Sgd The Hon C R Wright QC]
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
Refugees - Protection visa - applicant prison officer during Communist regime in Afghanistan - alleged to have committed crimes against humanity - whether there was "serious reason" for so considering.

W97/164 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs - AATA 618

Refugees Convention 1951, Article IF.

REASONS FOR DECISION

14 June 2002          The Hon C R Wright QC., (Deputy President)              

Introduction

  1. The applicant is aged 39 years.    He is an Afghan national of Tajik ethnicity.  He commenced work at the Pul-e-Charkhi Prison in Kabul at the age of 18 years as a prison officer.   Before this he had spent 2 years studying at a police academy in the Soviet Union.   He worked at Pul-e-Charkhi Prison from 1981 until 1988 when, for disciplinary reasons he was demoted and sent to a war zone to assist in the conflict between the Communist administration and the Mujahideen rebels.   He was injured and retired from the police service.   Thereafter he was employed in a civilian job issuing identity cards.   When the Taliban took over control in Afghanistan in 1992 he became fearful for his life and moved about within Afghanistan to avoid detection.   It has been claimed that about 200 former police officers were killed by the Taliban in revenge and retribution for the perceived excesses of security forces during the Communist era.

  2. With the assistance of people smugglers the applicant came to Australia via Pakistan, Malaysia and Indonesia arriving here on 8 March 2001.   He was accompanied by his wife and children who were granted protection visas in June 2001.  

  3. The applicant's application for a protection visa was refused on 18 October 2001 on the ground that he was not a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations as he came within the exclusionary provisions of Article IF(a) of the Refugees Convention.   He now seeks a review of that decision.
    Legislative Framework

  4. Under s29 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ("the Act") the Minister may grant a visa to a non-citizen to travel to and enter or remain in Australia. Under s65(1) a visa may be granted only if the Minister is satisfied that the prescribed criteria for the visa have been satisfied.

  5. The criteria for the grant of a protection (Class XA) visa subclasses 785 and 866 are set out in Parts 785 and 866…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WAV and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 463
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of WAV and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, who was a former police officer during the Communist regime in Afghanistan, applied for a protection visa on the basis of fear of persecution if returned to his home country. The central issue was whether there was "serious reason" to consider that the applicant had committed crimes against humanity. The applicant's role as a police officer and his family's involvement with the People's Democratic Party of Afghanistan (PDPA) raised concerns, but there was no direct evidence of his involvement in illegal activities or crimes against humanity.

The court had to determine if the evidence provided a secure basis for inferring the applicant's involvement in crimes against humanity. The court considered that while there were suspicions and some country information suggested that the ordinary police force was involved in brutal conduct, this did not sufficiently implicate the applicant. The lack of detail and specificity in the evidence meant it was insufficient to draw an inference of guilt. The court emphasised that mere suspicion was not enough; established facts were needed to infer guilt, and in this case, the evidence fell short of establishing "serious reasons for considering" the applicant's guilt of crimes against humanity.

The outcome of the case was that the court did not find "serious reason" to consider that the applicant had committed crimes against humanity. The court acknowledged the Minister's delegate's detailed and scholarly assessment but reached a different conclusion after careful consideration. The final orders were not explicitly detailed in the text but implied that the applicant's application for a protection visa would likely proceed based on the court's determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Nonetheless, he was employed as a police office for some 8 years. He had a formal training in the Soviet Union which I am sure would not have been provided to the average applicant for police status. He is obviously intelligent and I would be surprised if a man of his obvious talents did not achieve a fairly rapid rise in power and influence in the police hierarchy. His family involvement with the PDPA would have been an obvious advantage. On the other hand he was only 23 or 24 years old when he ceased working at Pul-e-Charkhi. Conclusion There is no direct evidence of the applicant's involvement in illegal activity of any kind, let alone crimes against humanity. I do not think his statements during interview provide a secure basis for inferring that he was so involved. Nor do I think that they provide "serious reason for considering" that he was. Some of the country information suggests that the ordinary police force was involved with brutal and oppressive conduct against enemies of the state similar to that perpetrated by KHAD, but without more this kind of material does little to enhance the case against the applicant. The point was well made, I think, that the appalling conditions at the prison were not so much part of a systematic process of degradation of prisoners involving the applicant and others, but were more probably the product of the generally primitive conditions one might expect in an impoverished country after years of war and internecine bloodshed. In Exhibit "K" information from the Afghanistan Information Centre says (inter alia):"The civilian police force (Saradoi) in Kabul did indeed engage in the surveillance and apprehension of suspect mijideen [sic] activists (and other supporters) on behalf of KHAD. They arrested them, tortured them, and delivered them to KHAD and sometimes took them to Pul-e-Charkhi (and other) prisons. They were all part of the same regime". This is as close as the evidence gets to involving the applicant in crimes against humanity, but in my opinion it lacks the quality of detail and specificity to enable an inference to be drawn that the applicant was involved with an organisation with a "limited brutal purpose" of the kind described by Mathews J in W97/164 (above) or was himself engaged in activities within the police force which of necessity not only afforded him knowledge of torture and unlawful killings and the like, but also implicated him in an accessorial role. This does not mean that I do not have strong suspicions of the applicant. His exculpatory evidence does not convince me of his innocence; in fact it tends to deepen the suspicion, but mere suspicion is not enough. There must be established facts from which an inference of guilt may be drawn – "may" be drawn will suffice. However in my opinion the evidence falls short of establishing "serious reasons for considering" his guilt of crimes against humanity. Although I have reached a different conclusion from the Minister's delegate, this should not be seen as a criticism of his very detailed and scholarly assessment of the relevant issues in his written decision, which caused me to give very careful thought and consideration to the case before arriving at the conclusion which I have stated.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established