WATTS & ANOR v FENTON
[2001] SASC 305
Full Court: Prior, Lander and Wicks JJ
PRIOR J: I agree with the reasons given by Lander J and with the orders he proposes.
LANDER J. This is an appeal from a decision of a District Court Judge given on 29 March 2001.
The appellants are husband and wife and were the plaintiffs in the Court below. On 16 December 1997 the male plaintiff suffered injuries in a motor vehicle accident. He sued the defendant for damages for those personal injuries. The female plaintiff sought damages for the loss of consortium arising, so it was alleged, as the result of the injuries to the male plaintiff.
The defendant admitted liability for the plaintiffs’ damages during the trial.
The Trial Judge assessed the male plaintiff’s damages at $49,555 and she assessed the male and female plaintiff’s past economic loss at $10,000. She allowed $2,000 for interest.
Judgment was entered accordingly. The defendant was ordered to pay the second plaintiff’s costs. She was also ordered to pay the first plaintiff’s costs until 14 days after 25 September 2000. The first plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendant’s costs after that date.
There are six separate grounds of appeal. However, I think it can be said that both plaintiffs claim that the Trial Judge erred in the assessment of their claim for damages in all respects.
The male plaintiff was born in Wales in the United Kingdom on 18 July 1956 and so was 41 years at the time of the accident and 44 years at the time of trial. He emigrated to Australia with his parents when he was about eight years of age.
He remained at school until intermediate level (Year 10) and left to become an apprentice cabinet maker.
He completed his apprenticeship in the time prescribed, four years, and remained with the firm with which he was apprenticed for a further 12 months.
The plaintiff suffered a significant injury to his right leg during his apprenticeship. He suffered a compound fracture which prevented him working for about six months. He was able to continue with his study but not work.
Some years after the accident he had to undergo surgery in respect of that injury. The consequences of the injury and the surgery left him with a leg which is about 20mm shorter than his left leg.
He said that the leg caused him pain over a period of about ten years.
He married the female plaintiff in 1976 when he was 20 years of age.
He went to work for two kitchen manufacturers, both for short periods of some months before he obtained employment at Noblet Furniture where he remained for about six years. He built furniture.
He continued with his education and obtained certificates in advanced cabinet making and furniture making.
He also worked at home. He was assisted with his work at home by his wife.
The plaintiffs have two children, the first born in 1982 and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Watts v Fenton No. Scciv-01-608 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 305
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key issue before the Full Court was whether the District Court Judge erred in her assessment of the appellants' claim for damages. The husband argued that the District Court Judge erred in finding that he would have reached the level of disability he presently enjoys even without the accident and without some other form of trauma to his body. The husband also contended that the District Court Judge erred in finding that the accident was no more than a catalyst and the extent of its contribution to his condition as a physical cause had decreased over time. The wife argued that the District Court Judge erred in not compensating her for the husband's lost earning capacity.
The Full Court found that the District Court Judge's findings were not supported by the evidence and that the husband's pre-existing degenerative condition did not necessarily mean that he would have reached the level of disability he presently enjoys even without the accident. The Full Court also found that the husband's complaint of a deterioration in his condition over time did not reinforce the opinion that the accident was no more than a catalyst. Furthermore, the Full Court held that the wife was entitled to compensation for the husband's lost earning capacity, as her contribution to the business was made necessary by the husband's reduced earning capacity.
The Full Court allowed the appeal and substituted the District Court Judge's assessment with its own. The husband was awarded $113,355 in damages, while the wife's claim was dismissed. The Full Court also directed the parties to be heard as to the costs of the trial and the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: LANDER J
Full text does not contain this section.