Watts v Denis Kiternas, Ranko Kiternas and Nada Kiternas

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

WATTS v Denis KITERNAS, Ranko KITERNAS and Nada KITERNAS
[2006] ACTRTT 17 (15 June 2006)

CATCHWORDS

Anshun estoppel
Distress and inconvenience
Hungerford principle
Res judicata
Tort

LEGISLATION

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT)
Section: 12, 36, 71H, 73, 104(1)(d), 121
Prescribed term: 9,10, 63.

ISSUES

Whether res judicata and Anshun estoppel apply to previous proceedings in the Tribunal.
Whether the Tribunal has the power to order compensation to a landlord for distress and inconvenience pursuant to section 104(1)(d) arising from a tenants failure to pay rent.
Whether the Tribunal may award damages to a landlord for loss of use of money withheld by tenants
Whether damages can be awarded for distress and inconvenience to persons not parties to the lease
Whether a duty of good faith is implied in a residential tenancy agreement
Whether the Tribunal has any jurisdiction in actions in tort
Whether damages can be awarded to a landlord for economic loss arising from a tenants failure to vacate in response to a Notice of Termination.
Whether damages can be awarded to a landlord for a tenants failure to execute a written residential tenancy agreement and lodge a bond.

CASES CITED

The Progressive Mailing House P/L v Tabali P/L (1985) 157 CLR 17;
The Estate of Tanya Humphries v The Commissioner for Housing in the ACT [2003] ACTSC 40;
Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon 1993 176 CLR 344;
Northern Sandblasting P/L v Harrison 1997 188 CLR 313);
Hadley v Baxendale 1854 9 ex 341; 
Zavodnyik v Alex Constructions P/L [2005] NSWCA 438;
Glover Gibbs P/L t/as Balfours NSW P/L v Lybutt [2004] NSWCA 45;
Gygiel v Baine [2005] NSWCA 218;
Owners Corporation SP51652 v Consumer Trader and Tenancy Tribunal [2003] NSWSC 739
Hungerford v Walker (1989) 171 CLR 125;

Cheshire and Fifoot Law of Contracts 8th ed Seddon and Ellinghaus at [10.43-10.46] Residential Tenancies Law and Practice in NSW 2003 Anforth, Thawley & Christensen [1.5]

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:   RT 06/1857

RE: Premises at 10 Sulman Place, SWINGER HILL  ACT  2903

INTERIM ORDERS

  1. For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal determines that independently of the Anshun estoppel issue, it has no jurisdiction to hear the following parts of the landlord’s claims:

    a)The landlord’s losses stemming from the tenants failure to vacate in response to the Notice of Termination (paragraph 5(e))

    b)The claims relating to the distress caused to the landlord and his family (paragraphs 5(h) and 5(i))

  2. The Tribunal finds that it has already heard and determined claims 5(b) (except to the limited extent of the Hungerford claim) and 5(d) and will not further hear these claims.

  3. In terms of the Anshun estoppel issue the Tribunal declines to further hear the claim for water charges (claim 5(g)).

  4. The Registrar is to relisted the matter for directions only for disposition of the balance of the matter, namely claims 5(a), 5(b) (limited to the Hungerford claim), 5(c), 5(f), 5(g) and 5(j).

  5. The Registrar is to relist the matter for directions only…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Watts v Denis Kiternas, Ranko Kiternas and Nada Kiternas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] ACTRTT 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Watts v Denis Kiternas, Ranko Kiternas, and Nada Kiternas, the Residential Tenancies Tribunal (Tribunal) considered various claims brought by the landlord against the tenants for breaches of the residential tenancy agreement and sought damages for distress and inconvenience. The Tribunal had previously heard cases between the landlord and tenants, Kiternas v Watts [2005] ACTRTT 11 and Kiternas v Watts [2006] ACTRTT 4, in which the tenants were found to owe the landlord money for rent arrears, and the landlord was found to owe the tenants for failure to repair the premises. The Tribunal determined that it had no jurisdiction to hear certain claims made by the landlord in the present application, such as those for losses stemming from the tenants' failure to vacate in response to a Notice of Termination and claims relating to distress caused to the landlord and his family. The Tribunal found that the Anshun estoppel applied to preclude the landlord from raising certain claims that could have been raised in previous proceedings. The Tribunal concluded that it lacked the jurisdiction to award damages for injury or inconvenience to third parties and could not entertain claims for damages for distress and inconvenience on behalf of the landlord's family members, as such claims were outside the scope of the residential tenancy agreement and beyond the Tribunal's jurisdiction in tort. The Tribunal ordered the relisting of the matter for directions only for the disposition of the remaining claims against the tenants.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a landlord, Watts, who has lodged an application with the Residential Tenancies Tribunal (Tribunal) seeking damages against tenants for various alleged breaches of their residential tenancy agreement. The tenants, Denis Kiternas, Ranko Kiternas, and Nada Kiternas, have responded to the application with objections and submissions. The landlord alleges several breaches by the tenants, including failure to normalize their tenancy status, rent arrears, failure to return property, cleaning and damage to the premises, delay in vacating the premises, unauthorized residency, water consumption charges, emotional suffering caused by malicious emails, financial hardship due to rent default, and wasted time investigating a fraud allegation. The tenants dispute the landlord's claims, arguing that some claims were not raised in previous proceedings and are thus barred by the Anshun estoppel, and that the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction over certain claims.

The matter came before the Tribunal following an application by the landlord seeking damages against the tenants. This application follows previous decisions of the Tribunal between the landlord and the tenants, specifically Kiternas v Watts [2005] ACTRTT 11 and Kiternas v Watts [2006] ACTRTT 4. The tenants filed submissions raising jurisdictional objections and the Anshun estoppel. The Tribunal ordered further submissions from both parties and held a directions hearing. The landlord filed additional submissions, and the tenants filed a reply. The Tribunal then issued an interim decision determining which claims would proceed to hearing and which would not, based on jurisdictional limits, the Anshun estoppel, and the applicability of the Hungerford principle.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether res judicata and Anshun estoppel apply to previous proceedings in the Tribunal.
2. Whether the Tribunal has the power to order compensation to a landlord for distress and inconvenience pursuant to section 104(1)(d) arising from a tenant's failure to pay rent.
3. Whether the Tribunal may award damages to a landlord for loss of use of money withheld by tenants.
4. Whether damages can be awarded for distress and inconvenience to persons not parties to the lease.
5. Whether a duty of good faith is implied in a residential tenancy agreement.
6. Whether the Tribunal has any jurisdiction in actions in tort.
7. Whether damages can be awarded to a landlord for economic loss arising from a tenant's failure to vacate in response to a Notice of Termination.
8. Whether damages can be awarded to a landlord for a tenant's failure to execute a written residential tenancy agreement and lodge a bond.

Held
1. The Tribunal has determined that it does not have jurisdiction to hear claims for losses stemming from the tenants' failure to vacate in response to the Notice of Termination and claims relating to distress caused to the landlord and his family.
2. The Tribunal has already heard and determined claims 5(b) (except to the limited extent of the Hungerford claim) and 5(d) and will not further hear these claims.
3. In terms of the Anshun estoppel issue, the Tribunal declines to further hear the claim for water charges (claim 5(g)).
4. The Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to award damages for economic loss arising from the tenants' failure to vacate in response to a Notice of Termination.
5. The Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to award damages for distress and inconvenience to persons not parties to the lease.
6. The Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to entertain actions in tort.
7. The Tribunal will allow the landlord to further pursue claims against the First Respondent for water consumption, failure to execute a written residential tenancy agreement, and malicious allegations made by the tenants.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal addressed several jurisdictional and estoppel issues in its decision. Firstly, the Tribunal found that it does not have jurisdiction to hear claims for losses stemming from the tenants' failure to vacate and claims relating to distress caused to the landlord and his family. The Tribunal considered the jurisdictional limit under section 115 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997, which precludes making an order for payment of an amount exceeding $10,000. However, this limit applies to the financial extent of the order, not the financial extent of applications which may be entertained by the Tribunal.

Secondly, the Tribunal addressed the application of Anshun estoppel and res judicata. Anshun estoppel applies when a party could have raised a claim in previous proceedings but failed to do so, making it unreasonable for them to raise it in subsequent litigation. The Tribunal found that some claims could have been raised in previous proceedings but were not, and thus Anshun estoppel applies to those claims. However, the Tribunal determined that other claims were not raised in the previous proceedings and thus no Anshun estoppel applies.

Thirdly, the Tribunal found that it lacks jurisdiction to award damages for economic loss arising from the tenants' failure to vacate in response to a Notice of Termination. The Residential Tenancies Act 1997 prescribes a process for terminating a tenancy and obtaining vacant possession, and there is no scope for obtaining vacant possession in a manner other than that set out in the Act.

Fourthly, the Tribunal found that it lacks jurisdiction to award damages for distress and inconvenience to persons not parties to the lease. The doctrine of privity of contract restricts damages that may be awarded to losses sustained by parties to the tenancy, i.e., the landlord himself and not to his wife and daughter.

Fifthly, the Tribunal found that it lacks jurisdiction to entertain actions in tort on behalf of the landlord's wife and daughter, arising out of the tenancy agreement. The Act defines a "tenancy dispute" as a dispute between the parties to a residential tenancy agreement, and actions in tort are not considered disputes between the parties within the meaning of the Act.

Finally, the Tribunal found that the landlord is entitled to further pursue claims against the First Respondent for water consumption, failure to execute a written residential tenancy agreement, and malicious allegations made by the tenants. The Tribunal found that the First Respondent was not a party to the previous proceedings and thus no Anshun estoppel applies. However, the claim against the First Respondent must be confined to rent arrears, damage to the property, and other alleged breaches which occurred during the tenancy of the First Respondent and not after its termination.

The binding legal principle established or applied by this decision is that the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to hear certain claims and award certain damages in residential tenancy disputes. The Tribunal's jurisdiction is limited by the monetary limit under the Act and the scope of claims that can be raised in previous proceedings. Additionally, the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to award damages for distress and inconvenience to persons not parties to the lease and to entertain actions in tort.