Watts v Brophy

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   WATTS -v- BROPHY [2016] WADC 131

CORAM:   PETRUSA DCJ

HEARD:   23 MAY 2016

DELIVERED          :   26 AUGUST 2016

FILE NO/S:   APP 89 of 2015

BETWEEN:   STEPHEN DALE WATTS

SABRINA MARIA WATTS
Appellants

AND

GERARD JOHN BROPHY
CARRIE MARIE BROPHY
Respondents

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  MAGISTRATES COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :MAGISTRATE O'SULLIVAN

Citation  :KAL GCLM 689 OF 2013

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Appeal from magistrate's decision to award nominal damages - Evidence of loss - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Magistrates Court (Civil Proceedings) Act 2004

Result:

Appeal upheld
Appellants' application dated 19 April 2016 to adduce additional evidence in the appeal dismissed
Respondents' application dated 18 April 2016 to adduce additional evidence in the appeal dismissed

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellants:     Ms C A McKenzie

Respondents                 :     In person

Solicitors:

Appellants:     McKenzie and McKenzie

Respondents                 :     Not applicable

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2000] HCA 47; (2000) 203 CLR 194

Morrison v Town of Victoria Park [2007] WASCA 164

Re Warden P Roth; Ex parte Cazaly Iron Pty ltd [No 2] [2011] WASC 343

PETRUSA DCJ: 

Introduction

  1. The appellants and the respondents entered into a contract for the sale of a property at 7 Addis Street, Kalgoorlie on 20 August 2012.  The contract was terminated for default on the part of the respondents (as purchaser).  The appellants subsequently sold the property for $9,000 less than the contract price.  A general procedural claim was filed on 23 December 2013 claiming liquidated damages in the sum of $24,842.30 plus interest.

  2. The matter proceeded to trial in the Kalgoorlie Magistrates Court on 23 and 24 September 2015.  On 28 October 2015 the magistrate found that the respondents had breached the contract of sale and were liable for damages.  However, only nominal damages in the sum of $101 were awarded for the reasons that:

    1.The evidence of the quantum of the loss suffered by the appellants was imprecise and uncertain; and

    2.The appellants had failed to lead evidence as to the reasonableness of the amounts claimed by them in circumstances where they were obliged to mitigate their loss (ts 215).

Grounds of appeal

  1. The appellants now seek to appeal the magistrate's decision to award nominal damages.  The grounds of appeal are as follows:

    1.The learned Magistrate erred in finding that the Appellants proved the fact of a loss but failed to adduce any evidence as to the amount of the loss.  More particularly:

    (a)The General Procedure Claim filed by the Appellants set out the amount and description of the loss claimed.

    (b)The First Appellant adduced oral evidence as to the amount of the loss.

    (c)The Respondents did not dispute the First Appellant's adduced evidence as to the amount of the loss during Cross Examination despite:

    (i)Clear direction from the learned Magistrate to the Respondents that if the First Appellant's evidence was in dispute and it wasn't…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Watts v Brophy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] WADC 131
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Watts v Brophy involved an appeal from a decision of the Magistrates Court of Western Australia, concerning a dispute over the award of damages. The respondents, Watts and others, sought damages for breach of contract against the appellants, Brophy and others. The respondents claimed loss due to the appellants' failure to deliver certain property and alleged that they had not mitigated their loss by re-selling the property at an undervalued price. The magistrate awarded nominal damages to the respondents, finding that there was insufficient evidence to determine the reasonableness of the amount claimed by the respondents.

The legal issues before the court were twofold. Firstly, whether the magistrate erred in placing the onus of proving the reasonableness of the amount claimed on the respondents instead of the appellants. Secondly, whether the respondents had failed to adduce proper evidence of their loss, and if so, whether this justified the magistrate's decision to award only nominal damages. The respondents argued that the magistrate's decision was based on an incorrect legal standard and that they had provided sufficient evidence to support their claim. The appellants, on the other hand, contended that the respondents had failed to properly adduce evidence of their loss and that the magistrate's decision was justified.

In determining the appeal, the court found that the magistrate had indeed erred in placing the onus of proving the reasonableness of the amount claimed on the respondents. The court cited the principle that the onus rests on the defendant to prove that the plaintiff has not taken reasonable steps to mitigate their loss. The court also found that the magistrate's decision to award nominal damages was influenced by a misunderstanding of the evidence presented by the respondents. The court held that the respondents had provided sufficient evidence of their loss, and that the magistrate's failure to properly consider this evidence constituted a denial of procedural fairness. The court concluded that the magistrate's error in placing the onus of proof and the denial of procedural fairness warranted a re-hearing of the case.

The court ordered that the case be remitted to the Magistrates Court for a re-hearing, with the understanding that the onus of proving the reasonableness of the amount claimed would be placed on the appellants. The court also directed that the respondents' evidence of loss be properly considered in the re-hearing, and that procedural fairness be observed in the proceedings. The court did not specify the amount of damages to be awarded but left it to the Magistrates Court to determine the appropriate measure of damages based on the evidence presented in the re-hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

An appeal from a decision of a magistrate to this court is by way of a re‑hearing. An appellate court hearing an appeal by way of a re-hearing, can exercise its appellate powers only if satisfied there was some legal, factual, or discretionary error on the part of the primary decision maker: Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2000] HCA 47; (2000) 203 CLR 194. I find that the magistrate erred in law in finding that the onus was on the appellants to prove that they had acted reasonably in mitigating their loss. Her Honour Wheeler J in Morrison v Town of Victoria Park [2007] WASCA 164 [37] (Pullin & Buss JJA) succinctly states the legal position [37]:It is the case that a plaintiff who has suffered loss through a breach of contract by a defendant must act reasonably to endeavour to mitigate that loss. However, the standard is not a high one because the defendant is the wrongdoer. The onus rests on the defendant to prove that the plaintiff has not taken reasonable steps to mitigate its loss. (citations omitted) The contract provided the measure of liquidated damages. There was no suggestion by the respondents that the appellants had acted unreasonably in re‑selling the property. If there was any dispute about the measure of the loss occasioned by the re-sale, the onus was on the respondents to prove that the appellants had failed to mitigate. At no time did the respondents raise such an issue. The learned magistrate's error is plain from his reasons where he said:The second difficulty and perhaps an even more fundamental one is that no evidence was led as to the reasonableness of the amount claimed. Even had the accounts been tendered through Mr Watts or handed up, had that course been permitted, it would not have enabled the court to determine if the amounts claimed were reasonable. As a consequence, for example, bearing in mind the obligation of the claimants to mitigate their loss, I have no way of knowing whether the price the property ultimately sold for was reasonable having regard to the prevailing market conditions at the time. (ts 215) In addition, I find that there was a denial of procedural fairness. Procedural fairness is a practical concept. The purpose of the law of procedural fairness is to avoid practical injustice and a court in considering whether there has been a denial of procedural fairness must determine whether the decision-maker has departed from the requirements of procedural fairness by analysing all of the facts and circumstances relevant to this consideration viewed in the context of the statutory framework conferring the relevant power for the purposes of ascertaining whether there has been practical injustice in the particular circumstances: see Re Warden P Roth; Ex parte Cazaly Iron Pty ltd [No 2] [2011] WASC 343 [15]. It was, of course, incumbent on the appellants' counsel at trial to adduce in proper form the evidence relied upon to prove loss. Counsel had clearly failed to do so as the learned magistrate pointed out during her closing address. Counsel should have formally applied to re‑open when the deficiency in her case, which was clearly remediable at that stage, was made clear. Even so, her failure to do so, in my opinion, did not justify the course taken by the court below.