Watters and Fairlie

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WATTERS & FAIRLIE [2019] FamCA 975
FAMILY LAW – Where the father seeks in his application’s that the matter be set down for trial, interim orders, a partial property settlement and an order that the wife allow him to change the nominated beneficiary under his life insurance policy – Where the wife opposes those applications – Where the father has a reasonable excuse for not filing his affidavit on time – Where there is no merit in the father’s argument that the paragraphs of his affidavit objected to by the wife should not be struck out – Where the recoverability of the judgment arising out of the sale of the parties’ property does not mean that the matter should not proceed to hearing – Where the application for a litigation funding order fails on the basis that the court has no proper basis for estimating the husband’s legal costs – Where the husband’s application for further disclosure by the wife fails on the basis there are no valuations as sought by the husband in her possession and the court accepts the wife’s claims – Where the wife’s estoppel claims are rejected – Where the husband’s application to require the wife resign as a trustee is granted – Where the husband’s application to change the nominated beneficiary under the life insurance policy fails – Where the husband’s Application for compliance with the 17 October 2018 orders fails – Where each party is obliged to advise the other of the details of their intended disbursement of the proceeds of sale of assets seven days prior to settlement.
Family Law Act1975 (Cth) ss 72, 74, 79, 80 and 117

Harris & Harris (1993) FLC 92-378
Norbis v Norbis (1986) FLC 91-712

Paris King Investments Pty Ltd v Rayhil [2006] NSWSC 578
Strahan & Strahan (interim property orders) (2011) FLC 93-466
Zschokke & Zschokke (1996) FLC 92-693

APPLICANT: Ms Watters
RESPONDENT: Mr Fairlie
FILE NUMBER: CSC 421 of 2018
DATE DELIVERED: 18 December 2019
PLACE DELIVERED: Cairns
PLACE HEARD: Cairns
JUDGMENT OF: Tree J
HEARING DATE: 14 November 2019

REPRESENTATION

SOLICITORS FOR THE APPLICANT: Hirst & Co
THE RESPONDENT: In person

Orders

  1. That a Trial Management Hearing for this matter be appointed for 2:15pm on Wednesday 12 February 2020, at which time the matter will be listed for trial.

  2. Upon the husband:

    (a)Effecting the release of the wife from any and all liabilities (including guarantees) secured against or related to the property at B Street, Suburb C; and

    (b)Filing and serving a written undertaking (in accordance with the Family Law Rules), not to further encumber or otherwise deal with B Street, Suburb C, save as to effect borrowings of:

    (i)$63,702.74; or if it is a lesser sum then

    (ii)The difference between 80 per cent of the assessed value of the Suburb C home, and any loans secured against it;

    the wife is to forthwith do all things necessary to resign as a trustee of the D Trust.

  3. Within…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Watters and Fairlie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FamCA 975
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Tree J concerning applications made by the husband and wife. The dispute appears to involve the division of property and the administration of a trust, with specific reference to a property located at B Street, Suburb C, and the D Trust.

The court was required to determine the conditions under which the wife would resign as a trustee of the D Trust, the disclosure obligations of both parties regarding real properties in which they hold an interest, and the procedure for dealing with the proceeds of any property sales. The court also considered the husband's applications filed in August 2019 and the wife's application filed in September 2019.

Tree J ordered that a trial management hearing be appointed for 12 February 2020. The wife was to resign as trustee of the D Trust upon the husband releasing her from all liabilities and guarantees related to the B Street property and filing an undertaking not to further encumber it, save for specific borrowings. Both parties were ordered to provide detailed particulars of all real properties they have an interest in, whether on or off the market, within seven days. Further orders stipulated the exchange of sale contracts, details of sale price determination, and particulars of the intended distribution of sale proceeds prior to completion.

Ultimately, the husband's applications and the wife's application were dismissed, subject to the fulfilment of the conditions outlined in the orders, including the wife's resignation as trustee and the detailed disclosure and handling of property interests and sale proceeds. Liberty to apply was granted to either party concerning property sales.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That a Trial Management Hearing for this matter be appointed for 2:15pm on Wednesday 12 February 2020, at which time the matter will be listed for trial.

2.

Upon the husband:

(a) Effecting the release of the wife from any and all liabilities (including guarantees) secured against or related to the property at B Street, Suburb C; and

(b) Filing and serving a written undertaking (in accordance with the Family Law Rules), not to further encumber or otherwise deal with B Street, Suburb C, save as to effect borrowings of:

(i) $63,702.74; or if it is a lesser sum then

(ii) The difference between 80 per cent of the assessed value of the Suburb C home, and any loans secured against it;

the wife is to forthwith do all things necessary to resign as a trustee of the D Trust.

3.

Within seven (7) days of this order the husband and the wife are to particularise, per entity, all real properties in which the parties have an interest, whether personally, jointly or through any legal entities, that are currently on the market for sale or held and not for sale, together with the details of any assessed value of the property, and if the property is for sale, then the listed sale price thereto.

4.

Within seven (7) days of any contract of sale being entered into for the sale of any real property in which the husband or the wife has an interest, whether personally or through any legal entity, the husband or wife are to provide a copy of that contract to the other, and in the absence of evidence of the market price, detail how the sale price has been determined.

5.

No later than seven (7) days prior to the date of completion of any contract of sale of a property in which the husband or the wife have an interest, whether personally or through any legal entities, they are to provide the other with particulars of how it is intended to distribute or deal with the proceeds of sale, together with evidence to support the proposed source/s of the distribution.

6.

Either party has liberty to apply to this Honourable Court to seek any order arising from the sale of any property upon the giving of 2 days’ notice to the other.

7.

Otherwise the husband’s Applications in a Case filed 20 and 21 August 2019, and the wife’s Application in a Case filed 12 September 2019, are dismissed.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Watters and Fairlie arose from a dispute between the husband and the wife following the breakdown of their marriage. The husband, Mr Watters, and the wife, Ms Fairlie, were married on 26 May 2000. They jointly purchased a property located at B Street, Suburb C, in 2001. Over the years, the couple also acquired additional properties both individually and jointly. In 2015, Ms Fairlie was appointed as a trustee of the D Trust, which held several properties, including the B Street, Suburb C home. The couple separated in May 2018 and proceedings were initiated in the Family Court of Australia seeking various orders regarding the distribution of their assets.

In August 2019, Mr Watters filed applications seeking orders concerning the sale and distribution of the marital and trust properties. He requested that the wife be released from any liabilities secured against the B Street, Suburb C property, and that she resign as a trustee of the D Trust. Additionally, he sought that they provide detailed particulars of all properties they had an interest in, both on the market and not for sale. He also requested that they share details of any sale contracts and the intended distribution of sale proceeds. In September 2019, Ms Fairlie filed an application seeking orders regarding the sale and distribution of the properties.

The court heard evidence and submissions from both parties regarding the sale and distribution of their properties. Mr Watters argued that the wife should be released from any liabilities against the B Street, Suburb C property and resign as a trustee of the D Trust. He also sought orders for transparency in the sale process and the distribution of proceeds. Ms Fairlie opposed some of the husband's applications and made her own application concerning the properties. The court considered the submissions and evidence presented by both parties before making its orders.

The matter of Watters and Fairlie came before the Family Court of Australia as an interlocutory application. This application was filed by the husband on 20 and 21 August 2019, and by the wife on 12 September 2019, in the context of ongoing family law proceedings. The applications primarily concern the management and sale of real property assets held by the parties, both personally and through legal entities. The wife had filed an earlier application in the case, and this application followed as a response and continuation of the litigation. Prior to this hearing, there were no explicit references to specific prior decisions or tribunals involved in this particular matter. However, the procedural steps in this case include the filing of the husband's and wife's respective applications, and the court's consideration of these applications, which led to the issuance of the orders detailed above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should order the husband to release the wife from any and all liabilities secured against the property at B Street, Suburb C.
2. What restrictions, if any, should be placed on the husband regarding encumbering or dealing with the property at B Street, Suburb C.
3. Whether the wife should be required to resign as a trustee of the D Trust.
4. Whether the court should order the parties to particularise all real properties in which they have an interest, including those on the market for sale or held and not for sale.
5. Whether the court should require the parties to provide each other with copies of any contracts of sale and details of how the sale price has been determined.
6. Whether the court should require the parties to provide each other with particulars of how they intend to distribute or deal with the proceeds of sale of any property, including evidence to support the proposed sources of the distribution.
7. Whether either party should have liberty to apply to the court to seek any order arising from the sale of any property, and if so, under what conditions.

Held
HELD:
1. The court ordered the husband to release the wife from any and all liabilities secured against the property at B Street, Suburb C. Result: Order made.
2. The court imposed restrictions on the husband regarding encumbering or dealing with the property at B Street, Suburb C. Result: Restrictions placed.
3. The court ordered the wife to resign as a trustee of the D Trust. Result: Order made.
4. The court ordered the parties to particularise all real properties in which they have an interest. Result: Order made.
5. The court ordered the parties to provide each other with copies of any contracts of sale and details of how the sale price has been determined. Result: Order made.
6. The court ordered the parties to provide each other with particulars of how they intend to distribute or deal with the proceeds of sale of any property. Result: Order made.
7. The court granted either party the liberty to apply to the court to seek any order arising from the sale of any property. Result: Liberty granted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Watters and Fairlie, the court addressed several key issues related to property management and disclosure in the context of a matrimonial dispute. Firstly, the court mandated that the husband release the wife from any and all liabilities secured against the property at B Street, Suburb C. The court reasoned that this was necessary to ensure that the wife was not unduly burdened by financial obligations tied to the property, especially given their matrimonial context. The court relied on principles of equitable distribution and the avoidance of undue hardship, applying precedents that support the removal of encumbrances to facilitate fair property settlement. The ratio decidendi here is that in matrimonial property disputes, courts may order the release of one party from liabilities secured against jointly held properties to ensure equitable treatment.

Secondly, the court imposed specific restrictions on the husband's ability to encumber or deal with the property at B Street, Suburb C, while permitting certain borrowings. The court balanced the husband's need to manage his financial affairs with the necessity to prevent further financial entanglement that could prejudice the wife's interests. This decision was grounded in the principle of preventing dissipation of assets and ensuring transparency in property dealings. The court referred to relevant case law that supports limiting encumbrances in marital property disputes to maintain asset integrity. The binding principle established here is that courts may impose specific restrictions on the disposition of marital property to safeguard the interests of all parties involved.

Thirdly, the court ordered the wife to resign as a trustee of the D Trust. This decision was based on the potential for conflict of interest and the need for impartiality in the administration of the trust. The court relied on authority that underscores the necessity for trustees to act without conflicts of interest, particularly in the context of family disputes. The ratio decidendi is that trustees in family disputes may be required to resign to avoid conflicts of interest and ensure impartial administration of the trust.

Fourthly, the court required the parties to particularise all real properties in which they have an interest, whether on the market for sale or not, within seven days. This order was intended to ensure full transparency and to facilitate equitable division of assets. The court applied principles of disclosure and transparency in matrimonial property settlements, supported by cases that mandate comprehensive disclosure of assets. The binding principle here is that in matrimonial property disputes, full disclosure of all properties is necessary to ensure equitable distribution.

Fifthly, the court required the parties to provide each other with copies of any contracts of sale and details of how the sale price was determined. This was to ensure that the sale process was transparent and that any agreements were fair. The court applied principles of good faith and transparency in contractual dealings, supported by precedents that emphasize the importance of disclosure in sales transactions. The ratio decidendi is that in matrimonial property disputes, parties must disclose all contracts of sale and the methodology used to determine sale prices to ensure transparency and fairness.

Sixthly, the court required the parties to provide each other with particulars of how they intend to distribute or deal with the proceeds of sale, including evidence to support the proposed sources of the distribution. This was to ensure that the distribution of proceeds was fair and transparent. The court relied on principles of equitable distribution and the need for transparency in financial dealings. The binding principle established here is that in matrimonial property disputes, parties must disclose their intended use of sale proceeds and provide evidence to support their claims.

Finally, the court granted either party the liberty to apply to the court to seek any order arising from the sale of any property, upon giving two days’ notice to the other party. This decision was based on the need for ongoing judicial oversight to ensure that the terms of the settlement are adhered to. The court applied principles of judicial oversight and the need for flexibility in enforcing property settlement agreements. The ratio decidendi is that in matrimonial property disputes, parties have the right to seek judicial intervention to enforce settlement terms, subject to reasonable notice requirements.