Watt v Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Watt v Queensland Police Service [2023] QCAT 102

PARTIES:

CHRISTOPHER PAUL WATT

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE – WEAPONS LICENSING

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR068-21

MATTER TYPE:

General Administrative Review

DELIVERED ON:

2 March 2023

HEARING DATE:

23 November 2022

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Bertelsen

ORDERS:

1.     The Queensland Police Service suspension notice of 26 August 2020 is set aside.

2.     The Queensland Police Service revocation notice of 2 December 2020 is set aside.

3.     The Applicant Mr Watt’s firearms licence is reinstated to be renewed as necessary.

CATCHWORDS:

FIREARMS AND LICENSING – suspension notice – fit and proper person – misleading renewal application – revocation notice – public interest.

Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009 (Qld), s3, s20, s21, s24

Weapons Act 1990 (Qld), s3, s10B

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

Keen v Queensland Police Service -Weapons Licensing (2019) QCAT 235

Els v Queensland Police Service-Weapons Licensing (No2) (2022) QCAT 335

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Mr Barker Solicitor of McGinness & Associates for Christopher Paul Watt

Respondent:

Sgt A Bauer, Queensland Police Service

REASONS FOR DECISION

[1]By review application filed 20 January 2021 the Applicant Christopher Paul Watt seeks review of the Queensland Police Service (QPS) decision of 2 December 2020 to revoke his firearms licence. He seeks reinstatement and renewal of his weapons licence. Mr Watt’s weapons licence was revoked for the reason the QPS was satisfied he was no longer a fit and proper person to hold a licence, that it was not in the public interest.

[2]For the purposes of this application the Tribunal stands in the stead of the original decision maker and having regard to the material before it then makes a decision it considers to be the correct and preferable decision. There is no onus of proof nor is there any presumption that the QPS decision was correct. The Tribunal’s decision may confirm, vary or entirely replace the QPS decision. The standard of proof to be applied is the civil standard, that is, the balance of probabilities.

[3]Pursuant to section 20 Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009 (QCAT Act) the Tribunal must hear and decide the review by way of fresh hearing on the merits in order to produce the correct and preferable decision. The QPS as decision maker for the reviewable decision must use its best endeavours to help the Tribunal so that it can make its decision on the review. When considering who is a fit and proper person regard must be had to the public interest so that it can make its decision on review, (section 10B (1)(d) Weapons Act 1990 (Qld)).

[4]Mr Watt at the date of hearing was a sixty-year-old semi-retired man residing at 130 Gilliland Crescent Blackbutt North and working at the Tarong pipeline as a maintenance worker for some twenty-three years. He has been married since 1995 and is the father of two daughters. There is no history of domestic violence, of any offence relating…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Watt v Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Watt v Queensland Police Service involved Mr Watt, who was appealing against a decision by the Queensland Police Service to revoke his firearms licence. The dispute arose after a firearms prohibition order was discovered from 1989, following a psychiatric admission that was related to a motor vehicle accident Mr Watt had in 1984. The matter was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The central legal issues the court had to decide were whether Mr Watt had the mental capacity to hold a firearms licence and if he had made full and truthful disclosures in his firearms licence application. The Tribunal examined the medical evidence and history provided by Mr Watt, including the reports and testimonies of Dr Imam and Dr Crabbe, who both concluded that Mr Watt did not suffer from any current mental health issues and had the capacity to hold a firearms licence. The Tribunal also considered Mr Watt's history of job and relationship stability, and his ability to manage his life and business, which further supported his capacity. The Tribunal found that Mr Watt's past psychiatric admission was a one-off incident not indicative of ongoing mental health problems and that his reactions to the 2020 incident were not related to any mental health issue. The Tribunal concluded that Mr Watt was not suffering from any mental health issues and had the capacity to hold a firearms licence. The Tribunal also noted that while Mr Watt had not disclosed his 1984 accident and the 1989 firearms prohibition order in his 2017 application, there was no evidence of deceit or intent to mislead, and the oversight was due to the passage of time. The Tribunal accepted that Mr Watt was unaware of the firearms prohibition order at the time of his application.

The Tribunal found in favour of Mr Watt and quashed the decision to revoke his firearms licence. The Tribunal ordered that Mr Watt's firearms licence be reinstated, subject to any further conditions the Queensland Police Service may impose.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

After this incident Mr Watt and family relocated at considerable expense so as to avoid any further contact with the complainant and put the matter behind them. Dr Asher Imam Consultant Psychiatrist report 12 August 2021 and evidence. According to his report Mr Watt presented for assessment of capacity to continue to hold a firearms licence. Mr Watt attended Dr Imam in person for about forty-five to fifty minutes. Dr Imam spoke to Mrs Watt. Mr Watts past was traversed in some detail. Referring to the events of 1989 he considered Mr Watt may have suffered symptoms of adjustment disorder but there were never any issues with mental illness. Mr Watt had been able to manage his life since that time. There were no indicators of depression or anxiety. In evidence Dr Imam said for organic personality disorder to reoccur there must be symptoms throughout Mr Watts life. There had not been. Rather there was job stability and relationship stability. Regarding the 2020 incident Dr Imam said Mr Watts reactions could not be judged by one incident but must be judged in a holistic manner. In particular, he said this incident was not related to any mental health problem. In his report he recorded that since his discharge in 1989 Mr Watt had never seen any psychiatrist nor been on any medication. He had started a new life with his current wife 26 years ago and has two daughters. Mrs Watt described Mr Watt as a supportive and happy man. She has never witnessed any signs of aggression or agitation or violence or suicidal tendencies. He has been able to maintain his business. Mr Watt indicated he enjoyed sports (recreational) shooting but would also utilise a licence for pest/vermin control. Dr Imam confirmed his report conclusion that Mr Watt did not have any mental health issues and he believed Mr Watt had the capacity to hold a firearms licence again. Other issues The QPS material included drivers licence loss for two months based primarily around speeding fines at a time when Mr Watt was travelling long distances for work some sixty thousand kilometres a year a portion of which was on country roads. The issue went no further. It was asserted the firearms licence applied for in 2017 was approved without full disclosure of the firearms prohibition order. The Tribunal accepts that Mr Watt was not aware at the time of making his application that there was a firearms prohibition order dating back to 1989. There were no copies of any firearms applications by Mr Watt produced to the Tribunal. Apparently however Mr Watt did not disclose particulars of his 1984 accident which occurred over thirty years prior and from which he had made full recovery. In the intervening years he had held a firearms licence. It was asserted as an oversight on his part but not as deceit in terms of an application. On 9 June 2021 Mr Watt was examined by Dr Crabbe who indicated Mr Watt was not suffering from any lingering head or chest injuries.Summary On 17 May 1984 Mr Watt was involved in a serious motor vehicle accident. Full rehabilitation took a couple of years. In due course he was compensated.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established