Water Administration Ministerial Corporation v Jones

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Reported Decision:

139 LGERA 198

Court of Appeal


CITATION:

Water Administration Ministerial Corporation v Jones [2005] NSWCA 181

HEARING DATE(S):

19 May 2005

 
JUDGMENT DATE: 


9 June 2005

JUDGMENT OF:

Giles JA at 1; Hodgson JA at 48; McClellan AJA at 51

DECISION:

(1) Appeal allowed in part; (2) Set aside the declaration in para 2 and the order in para 4 of the minute of order; (3) Respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise qualified.

CATCHWORDS:

Applications for licences to sink bores - statutory procedure for dealing with applications - opinion whether or not to advertise - whether opinion not to advertise could be changed - whether opinion not to advertise meant obliged to issue licences - construction of Water Act 1912 - forming opinion not the exercise of a power which, once exercised, was spent - could later form opinion to advertise - not obliged to issue licences. D

CASES CITED:

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Kurtovic (1990) 21 FCR 193;
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj (2002) 209 CLR 597.

PARTIES:

Water Administration Ministerial Corporation - Appellant
Donald Jones - Respondent

FILE NUMBER(S):

CA 41066/04

COUNSEL:

B Green - Appellant
N Perram - Respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legal Service Branch, Department of Infrastructure, Planning and Natural Resources - Appellant
Jackson Smith - Respondent

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

Supreme Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):

30041/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:

Levine J



                          CA 41066/04
                          SC 30041/02

                          GILES JA
                          HODGSON JA
                          McCLELLAN AJA

                          Thursday 9 June 2005
THE WATER ADMINISTRATION MINISTERIAL CORPORATION v JONES
Judgment

1 GILES JA: The substantive question in this appeal is whether the appellant is required to issue to the respondent licences for sinking bores on his family’s properties “Roeta and “Iota”, near Hillston in mid-western New South Wales. If issued, the licences will be very valuable to the respondent.

2 The applications for the licences were made in 1998 under the Water Act 1912 (“the Act”). The Act was repealed by the Water Management Act 2000, by which the issue of such licences, within the category of aquifer access licences, is now governed. It was common ground that, through transitional provisions, the respondent’s applications continued to be governed by the Act as if it had not been repealed.

3 For the reasons which follow, in my opinion the appellant is not required to issue the licences.


      The Act

4 The Act was a consolidation of seven statutes dealing with water rights, water and drainage, drainage promotion and artesian wells, and was frequently amended in the years after 1912. The result fell short of current standards in statutory expression. Licences for sinking bores were addressed in Division 3 of Part 5.

5 By s 112 of the Act, a bore could not be sunk, enlarged, deepened or altered, other than by the Crown, without a licence issued under Part 5 of the Act. It was an offence to contravene…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Water Administration Ministerial Corporation v Jones and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Water Administration Ministerial Corporation (the appellant) appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision concerning applications for licences to sink bores. The respondent, Mr Jones, had applied for such licences, and the core of the dispute revolved around the appellant's statutory obligations and the interpretation of the *Water Act 1912* (NSW) in relation to the process of considering these applications.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the appellant's initial opinion not to advertise the bore applications was final and binding, thereby obliging the appellant to issue the licences, or whether the appellant retained the power to form a subsequent opinion to advertise. The Court also considered whether the formation of an opinion not to advertise constituted the exercise of a power that, once exercised, was spent.

The Court held that the appellant's opinion not to advertise the bore applications was not the exercise of a power that was spent upon formation. Instead, it was an ongoing process where the appellant could form a new opinion to advertise the applications at a later stage. Consequently, the appellant was not obliged to issue the licences simply because it had initially formed an opinion not to advertise them. The Court reasoned that the statutory procedure allowed for flexibility in the decision-making process regarding advertising.

The appeal was allowed in part. The declaration in paragraph 2 and the order in paragraph 4 of the minute of order were set aside. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and was granted a certificate under the *Suitors Fund Act* if otherwise qualified.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Appeal allowed in part; (2) Set aside the declaration in para 2 and the order in para 4 of the minute of order; (3) Respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise qualified.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Water Administration Ministerial Corporation (WAMC) applied for licences to sink bores in two separate applications by Jones, a landowner, in accordance with the statutory procedure outlined in the Water Act 1912. WAMC, as the relevant authority, was required to form an opinion on whether to advertise each application. In its initial assessment, WAMC formed the opinion not to advertise either application, thereby deeming the applications to be exempt from public notification. Jones subsequently sought judicial review of WAMC's decision not to advertise the applications.

Upon review, the court was asked to determine whether WAMC's initial opinion not to advertise precluded it from later forming an opinion to advertise and whether the opinion not to advertise necessarily obliged WAMC to issue the licences. Jones argued that once WAMC formed the opinion not to advertise, it was legally bound to proceed with issuing the licences without further consideration. WAMC contended that forming an opinion not to advertise was not the exercise of a power which, once exercised, was spent, and that it retained the discretion to change its opinion and decide to advertise the applications at a later stage. Furthermore, WAMC asserted that forming the opinion not to advertise did not obligate it to issue the licences, as the Act did not automatically mandate the issuance of licences upon such an opinion.

The case of Water Administration Ministerial Corporation v Jones originated as an application for licences to sink bores, which were contested under the statutory procedure outlined in the Water Act 1912. The respondent, Jones, sought clarification on the procedure for dealing with such applications, specifically challenging the opinion of the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation not to advertise the applications. The appellant argued that once an opinion not to advertise was formed, it was binding and did not permit a subsequent change of opinion. This issue was brought before the court following an initial determination by the tribunal, which held that the opinion not to advertise did not obligate the Corporation to issue the licences. The tribunal's decision was subsequently appealed by the Corporation, leading to the current proceedings. Key procedural steps included the filing of the appeal and the making of interlocutory orders, which were later contested. The matter was heard at first instance in the tribunal, and the appeal was brought before this court to review the tribunal's interpretation of the statutory procedure and its implications on the administrative process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications under the Water Act 1912 is a final decision or can be changed later.

2. Whether the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications obligates the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation to issue licences.

3. Whether forming an opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications is an exercise of a power that, once exercised, is spent.

4. Whether the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation can form a subsequent opinion to advertise bore sinking applications after initially deciding not to advertise.

5. Whether the construction of the Water Act 1912 supports the notion that forming an opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications does not compel the issuing of licences.

Held
1. The court held that the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications under the Water Act 1912 is not a final decision and can be changed later.

2. The court concluded that the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications does not obligate the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation to issue licences.

3. The court found that forming an opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications is not an exercise of a power that, once exercised, is spent.

4. The court determined that the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation can form a subsequent opinion to advertise bore sinking applications after initially deciding not to advertise.

5. The court held that the construction of the Water Act 1912 supports the notion that forming an opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications does not compel the issuing of licences.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Water Administration Ministerial Corporation v Jones, the Court meticulously navigated through several critical issues pertaining to the statutory procedures for dealing with bore sinking applications under the Water Act 1912. The Court's analysis focused on the scope and implications of forming an opinion on whether or not to advertise such applications. Firstly, the Court examined whether the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications constitutes a final decision or if it can be altered subsequently. The Court determined that the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications does not represent a conclusive decision that cannot be changed. This interpretation was grounded in the understanding that administrative decisions often require flexibility to adapt to new information or changing circumstances.

The Court further delved into whether the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications imposes an obligation on the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation to issue licences. Here, the Court decisively ruled that forming an opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications does not obligate the Corporation to issue licences. The Court underscored that the decision to advertise or not is a preliminary step in the application process, and it does not automatically lead to the issuance of licences. The Court relied on the statutory language and the purpose of the Water Act 1912 to support this interpretation, emphasizing that the decision to advertise is not synonymous with granting a licence.

Another pivotal issue addressed by the Court was whether forming an opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications constitutes the exercise of a power that, once exercised, is spent. The Court rejected this notion, asserting that the formation of such an opinion is not a power that becomes exhausted upon its exercise. Instead, the Court viewed it as a dynamic process that can be revisited and changed based on new information or altered circumstances. This interpretation was consistent with the principles of administrative law, which often permit reconsideration and flexibility in decision-making processes.

The Court also considered whether the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation could form a subsequent opinion to advertise bore sinking applications after initially deciding not to advertise. The Court affirmed that the Corporation retains the authority to change its opinion and decide to advertise bore sinking applications later. This conclusion was based on the understanding that administrative bodies must have the capacity to adapt their decisions in response to new developments or information. The Court emphasized that the statutory framework does not restrict the Corporation from altering its initial opinion.

Finally, the Court examined whether the construction of the Water Act 1912 supports the notion that forming an opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications does not compel the issuing of licences. The Court found that the Act's construction aligns with this interpretation. By scrutinizing the language and intent of the Act, the Court concluded that the decision not to advertise bore sinking applications is a preliminary step and does not inherently lead to the issuance of licences. This interpretation was deemed necessary to maintain the flexibility and practicality of the administrative process.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the opinion not to advertise bore sinking applications under the Water Act 1912 is not a final decision that cannot be altered and does not obligate the Water Administration Ministerial Corporation to issue licences. The Court's decision provides clarity on the nature of the opinion-forming process and reinforces the administrative flexibility inherent in the statutory framework. The Court's interpretation ensures that the administrative process remains adaptable to new information and circumstances, while also maintaining a clear distinction between the decision to advertise and the decision to issue licences.