Warwick and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

Warwick and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 3093 (28 September 2023)

ReviewNumber:     2021/8101, 2023/1209

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/8101

2023/1209

Re:Carle John Warwick

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION                 

Tribunal:The Hon Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

Date:  28 September 2023

Place:Sydney

In respect to matter 2021/8101, the application for review made on 28 October 2021 is dismissed by the Tribunal due to lack of jurisdiction, pursuant to section 42A (4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

Secondly, in respect to matter 2023/1209, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review made by the delegate dated 20 February 2023, pursuant to section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

...........................[SGD].........................................

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME (NDIS) – jurisdiction – reasonable and necessary supports – relocation costs – value for money – effective and beneficial – home modification – retrospective – prospective-reimbursement – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

CASES

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Makasa (2021) 270 CLR 420
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79 FCR 415
Palin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 94
Pearce and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 3608
Rogers and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 2809
Totten and Secretary, Department of Social Services (2016) [2016] AATA 240

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Operational Guidelines: Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guideline- Overview; the Guidelines

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

28 September 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant is a 69-year-old man with a diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease. He became a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘the Scheme’) on 26 March 2018, and his first plan was approved on 9 April 2020 (Plan A).

  2. Over the course of 2020 and early 2021, the Applicant’s condition deteriorated. The family decided to sell the Applicant’s current home and ultimately relocated to a house closer to   their daughter, which they considered would be more suitable for him. His daughter, the Applicant’s representative, then commenced negotiations with the Respondent for additional supports (in the form of relocation costs) to be included in the participant’s Statement of Supports (SOPS), before Plan A’s expiry date of 9 April 2021.

  3. Following the expiry date for Plan A (9 April 2021), the Applicant’s supports continued, as did negotiations with the Respondent regarding the relocation costs sought by the Applicant.

  4. On 23 July 2021, a new plan (Plan B), was approved for the Applicant. This Plan did not include the relocation supports requested by the Applicant.

  5. On 5 October 2021, the Applicant sought review of Plan B; specifically, to include reimbursement of his property transaction and removal costs to a new property.

  6. On 8 October 2021, the Respondent confirmed the earlier decision to approve the SOPS in Plan B and rejected the Applicant’s request for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Warwick and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3093
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between an applicant, diagnosed with Parkinson's Disease, and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) concerning the reimbursement of relocation costs. The applicant had sold his former home and purchased a new one due to his declining mobility. The core of the dispute involved whether these relocation costs, incurred between the expiry of his first NDIS plan (Plan A) and the commencement of his second plan (Plan B), could be considered reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the Act) and thus reimbursed.

The Tribunal was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, it needed to ascertain its jurisdiction to hear the applications, particularly concerning whether relocation costs incurred before the approval of Plan B could be included within that plan. Secondly, the Tribunal had to consider whether the relocation costs met the criteria of being "reasonable and necessary supports" as defined by section 34 of the Act, specifically focusing on the "value for money" (s 34(1)(c)) and "effective and beneficial" (s 34(1)(d)) requirements, as well as relevant Support Rules.

The Tribunal reasoned that the NDIA's "auto-extension" of Plan A constituted a new plan, Plan A2, which conferred jurisdiction on the Tribunal to review the matter. In relation to the relocation costs, the Tribunal examined the evidence and submissions concerning whether the move represented value for money and was effective and beneficial. The NDIA contended that the costs did not represent value for money as there was insufficient evidence that the move would reduce future support costs, and that the new home required significant modifications, thus not being effective and beneficial. The applicant argued that the relocation offered better value for money and met the accessibility needs. The Tribunal ultimately concluded that it had jurisdiction to hear the matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues concerning whether the requested supports are reasonable and necessary rest on the requirements of s 34 of the Act. However, before they can be addressed, it is necessary to decide whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear either of these applications. BACKGROUND The Applicant was diagnosed with Parkinson’s Disease and became a participant in the Scheme in 2018. His first plan, Plan A, was approved on 9 April 2020 for one year until 9 April 2021. The Applicant and his wife lived in a house they had jointly owned in Thornleigh, NSW, for many years. The split-level house was built into the side of a hill and traversing the property entailed moving over uneven terrain and several steps of stairs of varying accessibility. In January 2021, considering the Applicant’s declining mobility, his house was assessed over several site visits by an occupational therapist (OT), Ms Anita Green, for complex home modifications. Her OT Report was submitted on 3 March 2021 (that is, during the period of Plan A). A supplementary OT report (Supplementary Report) was submitted on 29 July 2021, during the period of Plan B. Meanwhile, on 26 February 2021, the Applicant, purportedly (resulting from discussions with his family and the OT during the assessment period), sold his house in Thornleigh. He then moved to his daughter’s house while he and his family searched for a more suitable home. A new home at Westleigh, close to his daughter’s residence, was purchased on 31 May 2021. It is not disputed that the transaction costs associated with the sale of the Thornleigh house and purchase of the Westleigh house occurred after the expiry date of Plan A on 9 April 2021, and before the commencement of the Applicant’s subsequent plan, Plan B, on 23 July 2021. It is not disputed that the transaction costs were not first approved by the Respondent and are being sought as reimbursement. The Respondent submitted that a review under Division 4, s 48 of Plan A was conducted on 23 July 2021 (the date that Plan B was approved). The Respondent submitted that it failed to conduct a review of Plan A as required under Division 4, s 48 (5) of the Act, before the expiry of Plan A on 9 April 2021. The Applicant submitted that the question of relocation costs was raised on several occasions by the Applicant’s Representative, who sought assurances that those costs would be met by the Respondent as a form of support for the Applicant. The first instance of the Applicant seeking to have relocation costs considered by the Respondent was, according to the Applicant’s representative, 16 March 2021, before the expiry of Plan A. The Tribunal notes that the opportunity to vary a participant’s plan was not available at the time of these events, that is, prior to the proclamation of relevant amendments to the Act in July 2022. Rather, plans could (at the time) only be replaced by new plans under Division 4, either resulting from a change in the Participant’s Statement of Goals and Aspirations (which did not occur), or a s 48 review of the Act by the CEO. In other words, if the Applicant wanted relocation costs included in the Participant’s plan, Plan A needed to be replaced by a new plan resulting from such a review. Then, if the new plan did not provide the requested costs, it would be open to the Applicant to seek internal review and ultimately review by the Tribunal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal has had regard to various material before it, including:·Section 37 T-Documents filed 16 November 2021·Supplementary T-Documents filed 19 April 2023·Applicant’s updated bundle of evidence filed 15 February 2023·Report of Helen Wood dated 8 April 2022·Updated Statement of Melannie Hogan dated 30 May 2023·Respondent’s Schedule of Costs filed 7 June 2023·Respondent’s Chronology filed 7 June 2023·Applicant’s Schedule of Costs filed 9 June 2023·Document containing Applicant’s amendments to Chronology 9 June 2023·Respondent’s post hearing submissions dated 21 August 2023·Applicant’s amended post hearing submissions dated 22 August 2023Oral evidence The Tribunal also heard oral evidence from Melannie Hogan and Anita Green. CONTENTIONS The Respondent contended that the relocation costs do not represent value for money and therefore do not meet the requirements of s 34 (1) (c), value for money. This involves “more than determining the cheapest option, it involves assessing the quality and cost of the alternative supports”. The Respondent also contended in relation to s 34 (1) (c), value for money, Rule 3.1 of the Support Rules must be applied and, in this case, had not been met. Rule 3.1 requires the CEO (the decision maker) to consider several matters which would assist in determining value for money, set out in R 3.1 (a) –(f). The Respondent contended there was little or no evidence that by moving to his new and more expensive home, the applicant was likely to reduce the cost of the funding of future (emphasis added) supports for the participant in the long term, as Rule 3.1 (c) requires. Further, that there was no evidence of the cost or extent of any [future] modifications that were needed to the original home at Thornleigh (Page 43 of Respondent’s SOFIC) which would be the appropriate comparator in applying R 3.1 (c). The Applicant contended that the costs and benefits from relocation make this option better value for money, satisfying the requirements of s 34 (1) (c). The Respondent contended that it was not appropriate to compare, as part of a cost/benefit analysis, the costs of modification to the transaction and removal costs in this case, where the new home also needed significant modification. Accordingly, the Respondent included the significant modification costs the Applicant incurred at the new home (the installation of the stair climber and the bathroom renovations) as part of the relocation costs. The Respondent further contended that the relocation to the Applicant’s new property did not meet the Applicant’s accessibility needs and, because more than minor modification to that property was required before the Applicant could occupy the house (the installation of the stair climber), with potentially more modifications required in future, therefore the requirements of s 34 (1) (d), effective and beneficial, were also not met. The Applicant rejected this contention. The Respondent contended again that the requirement of Supports for Participants Rule 3.1 (c), which requires an assessment as to “whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term” had not been met and therefore the requirements of s 34 (1) (d) were again, not met. The Applicant rejected this contention.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Respondent has not disputed this chronology and accordingly, the Tribunal accepts the chronology provided by the Applicant.CONCLUSION The Tribunal concludes, having considered the evidence provided and having found that the “auto-extension” of Plan A, so described by the Respondent, was a new plan, Plan A2, that the Applicant properly sought internal review of this decision and, also properly, applied to the Tribunal for review of the reviewable decision under s 103 of the Act. Accordingly, the Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear this matter.REIMBURSEMENT OF THE APPLICANT’S RELOCATION COSTS AS A REASONABLE AND NECESSARY SUPPORTLEGAL FRAMEWORK This review relies upon s 34 (1) of the Act, which sets out the requirements of a reasonable and necessary support. Particularly, the Respondent relies upon paragraphs 34 (1) (c), value for money; and s 34 (1) (d), effective and beneficial, which are outlined below. It may also rely on the residual discretion available in s 33(2) of the Act. Additionally, the Support Rules 3.1, 5.1 and 5.2 require satisfaction and the decision must at least be consistent with the Support for Participant Guidelines. Relevant Sections of the ActCriterion under s 34(1)(c) - Value for money In deciding whether the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support, the CEO (and the Tribunal) is to consider the following matters:(a) whether there are comparable supports which would achieve the same outcome at a substantially lower cost;(b) whether there is evidence that the support will substantially improve the life stage outcomes for, and be of long term benefit to, the participant;(c) whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term (for example, some early intervention supports may be value for money given their potential to avoid or delay reliance on more costly supports);(d) for supports that involve the provision of equipment or modifications:(i) the comparative cost of purchasing or leasing the equipment or modifications; and(ii) whether there are any expected changes in technology or the participant’s circumstances in the short term that would make it inappropriate to fund the equipment or modifications.(e) whether the cost of the support is comparable to the cost of supports of the same kind that are provided in the area in which the participant resides;(f) whether the support will increase the participant’s independence and reduce the participant’s need for other kinds of supports (for example, some home modifications may reduce a participant’s need for home care).Criterion under s 34(1)(d) - Effective and beneficial In deciding whether the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for a participant, having regard to current good practice, the CEO is to consider the available evidence of the effectiveness of the support for others in like circumstances. That evidence may include:(a) published and refereed literature and any consensus of expert opinion;(b) the lived experience of the participant or their carers; or(c) anything the Agency has learnt through delivery of the NDIS.In deciding whether the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for a participant, having regard to current good practice, the CEO is to take into account, and if necessary, seek expert opinion.Residual Discretion

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issues in the two applications differ. In the first Application it is whether Plan B was able to include relocation costs which were incurred before that plan commenced. The jurisdictional question in the second Application relates to the status of the funding arrangements in place between the expiry date of Plan A and the commencement of Plan B. Legislative and Operational Guidance regarding Jurisdiction The relevant legislative provisions in the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the Act) are those applying before the commencement of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Amendment (Participant Service Guarantee and Other Measures) Act 2022. For completion, these are: ss 33 (2); ss 37 (1) (b); s 37 (3) 9 (a); s 48 and s 100(6) (a). Furthermore, I note that the Applicant has also relied upon s 43 (6) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). The first Application is concerned with whether the translocation costs incurred before the approval of Plan B can be considered as part of Plan B and therefore reviewable by the Agency and by the Tribunal. The second Application is concerned with whether the supports provided during the so-called extension period (between the expiry of Plan A and the approval of Plan B) resulted from an implicit (or actual) plan review under s 48 of the Act, requiring, as the Respondent has put it, “a decision to approve a new SOPS under s 33(2) of the Act” and [therefore] a right of internal review under s 100(2) of the Act, or did not result from an implicit (or actual) review under s 48 of the Act.REASONABLE AND NECESSARY SUPPORT ISSUES The issues concerning whether the requested supports are reasonable and necessary rest on the requirements of s 34 of the Act. However, before they can be addressed, it is necessary to decide whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear either of these applications. BACKGROUND The Applicant was diagnosed with Parkinson’s Disease and became a participant in the Scheme in 2018. His first plan, Plan A, was approved on 9 April 2020 for one year until 9 April 2021. The Applicant and his wife lived in a house they had jointly owned in Thornleigh, NSW, for many years. The split-level house was built into the side of a hill and traversing the property entailed moving over uneven terrain and several steps of stairs of varying accessibility. In January 2021, considering the Applicant’s declining mobility, his house was assessed over several site visits by an occupational therapist (OT), Ms Anita Green, for complex home modifications. Her OT Report was submitted on 3 March 2021 (that is, during the period of Plan A). A supplementary OT report (Supplementary Report) was submitted on 29 July 2021, during the period of Plan B. Meanwhile, on 26 February 2021, the Applicant, purportedly (resulting from discussions with his family and the OT during the assessment period), sold his house in Thornleigh. He then moved to his daughter’s house while he and his family searched for a more suitable home. A new home at Westleigh, close to his daughter’s residence, was purchased on 31 May 2021.