Warke v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Warke v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPICMP 666        
CLAIMANT: Mark Raymond Warke
INSURER: Allianz Insurance Australia Limited
REVIEW PANEL
MEMBER: Ray Plibersek
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Geoff Stubbs
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Margaret Gibson
DATE OF DECISION: 8 December 2023
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Claimant was injured when his motorcycle collided with a car turning in front of him; He received injuries to his shoulders, chest, face and throat; sometime after the accident he also claimed for treatment and care for a bilateral open carpal tunnel release surgery; on review, the Panel found a total whole person impairment of 13% for both shoulders; as a result of the accident the claimant suffered a full thickness rotator cuff tear in the left shoulder; MRI scans of the left shoulder showed the presence of an acute and chronic rotator cuff tear with a pre-existing retracted tear; regarding the right shoulder the right rotator cuff tear was asymptomatic prior to the motor vehicle accident but then became symptomatic a few weeks after the accident partly due to being aggravated by single arm use during the period of incapacity of the left shoulder; the Panel also found that the bilateral open carpal tunnel release surgery did not relate to the injury caused by the motor accident and was not reasonable and necessary; the soft tissue injury to his brachial plexus had resolved; Held – original medical certificate set aside regarding permanent impairment; original medical certificate affirmed regarding carpal tunnel surgery.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

The Review Panel revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Clive Kenna dated 21 February 2023 regarding permanent impairment.
The Panel issues a new certificate determining that:

1.     The following injuries were caused by the motor accident and give rise to a permanent impairment which is not greater than 10%:

·        cervical spine- soft tissue injury now resolved, and

·        brachial plexus injury – not found.

2.     The following injuries were caused by the motor accident and give rise to a permanent impairment which is greater than 10%:

·        left shoulder – acute rotator cuff tear, and

·        right shoulder – pre-existing rotator cuff tear aggravated by single arm use during the period of incapacity of the left shoulder.

The Review Panel affirms the certificate of Medical Assessor Clive Kenna dated 21 February 2023 regarding treatment and care.

3.     The following treatment and care of a:

·        bilateral open carpal tunnel release surgery as proposed by Dr Chris Scott on 17 February 2021;

does not relate to the injury caused by the motor accident.

4.     The following treatment and care of a:

·        bilateral open carpal tunnel release surgery as proposed by Dr Chris Scott on 17 February 2021;

is not reasonable and necessary in the circumstances.

REVIEW PANEL REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 22 February 2019 Mark Raymond Warke (the claimant) was riding his motorbike on St Johns Road Bradbury when a car pulled out in front of him resulting him hitting the front and back…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Warke v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMP 666
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Warke v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was a dispute between the claimant, Mr Warke, and the insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited. The dispute arose after Mr Warke was injured in a motorcycle accident involving a car. He suffered injuries to his shoulders, chest, face, and throat, and later sought treatment for bilateral open carpal tunnel release surgery. The insurer contested the extent and causation of these injuries, leading to a review by a medical panel. The panel found a 13% whole person impairment for both shoulders, with a full thickness rotator cuff tear in the left shoulder and a pre-existing retracted tear. They also determined that the bilateral open carpal tunnel release surgery was unrelated to the motor accident and was not reasonable and necessary.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the injuries sustained by Mr Warke were directly caused by the motorcycle accident, and if so, to what extent they warranted compensation. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the bilateral carpal tunnel release surgery was related to the accident and if the injuries to the shoulders were permanent impairments that resulted from the accident. The claimant argued that his injuries were a direct consequence of the accident, while the insurer argued that some of the injuries and treatments were not related to the accident.

The court carefully examined the medical evidence presented, including the reports from various doctors and the findings of the medical panel. It noted that the left shoulder injury was a direct result of the accident, evidenced by the arthroscopic double row repair performed soon after the accident. The court also found that the right shoulder injury, while pre-existing, became symptomatic and aggravated due to the accident. Regarding the bilateral open carpal tunnel release surgery, the court agreed with the medical panel that this surgery was not related to the motor accident. The court concluded that the soft tissue injury to the brachial plexus had resolved, and thus, the claimant's claim for treatment and care for this injury was not substantiated.

The court set aside the original medical certificate regarding permanent impairment and affirmed it concerning the carpal tunnel surgery. This means that while the injuries to the shoulders were recognized as a result of the accident, the surgery for the carpal tunnel was not considered related to the accident and thus not compensable.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Post-accident treating medical evidence The claimant was taken by ambulance to Liverpool Hospital shortly after the accident. The hospital notes show that he stayed in hospital for three days. The main findings were reduced range of movement in the left shoulder. A CT scan and an X-ray of the left shoulder both showed no acute fractures of the left shoulder.[8] The left shoulder was enlocated. Mild loss of acromioclavicular joint space with adjacent osteoarthritic changes suggestive of chronic rotator cuff arthropathy was found.[8] Claimant’s Bundle pp 177-179. A number of an allied health request dated from at least April 2019 from Mr Daniel Chiovitti summarised the claimant’s current signs and symptoms including noting that right shoulder pain increasing over the last few weeks and then noting a right rotator cuff tear.[9][9] Claimant’s Bundle pp 190-256. In in an allied health request dated 19 September 2019 Mr Daniel Chiovitti summarised the claimant’s current signs and symptoms as follows: “An Left shoulder now post op rotator cuff repair (large repair - double row)Left thumb pain intermittent P 0-2/10 with thumb ext, abd and add manual muscle testing.Shoulder ROM: F: (L) ROM 110 deg P 0-5/10, (R) 170 deg P1-2/10 less clunking in shoulder.Abd: (L) 90 deg, (R) 160 deg P 0-2/10 in shoulder.HBB (L) LI P 0-2/10, (R) T10 no pain.The left thumb pain is 0-2/10. The right thumb is now pain free.MRI of right shoulder: full thickness and full width tear of the supraspinatus with tendon retraction.Partial tear to the infraspinatusPartial tear to the subscapularisInjury to the long head of biceps biceps pulley.Subacromial bursitis.” [10][10] Claimant’s Bundle pp 140 - 143. In a report dated 17 February 2021 Dr Chris Scott wrote to the insurer that he reviewed Mark in his rooms today. Dr Scott wrote that the claimant was referred by his general practitioner (GP) with bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome which has only come on after his motor vehicle accident in 2019. Dr Scott discussed further treatment with him today and have recommended proceeding with a bilateral open carpal tunnel release. The claimant is keen to go ahead with surgery and Dr Scott sought approval to proceed at Sydney Southwest Private Hospital.[11][11] Claimant’s Bundle pp 284 On 17 February 2021 Dr Scott wrote to the insurer that he did not attribute the carpal tunnel syndrome to the motor accident.[12][12] Insurer’s Bundle p31 and 42 On 26 June 2019 Dr Chandra Dave performed on the claimant's left shoulder an arthroscopic double row repair. The operation report showed that the claimant had a large tear involving supra and infraspinatus and biceps rupture.[13][13] Claimant’s Bundle pp 320-347 In a report dated 12 September 2019 Dr Chandra Dave reported on the claimant's left shoulder arthroscopic double row repair. On examination the claimant showed he has virtually full range in forward flexion but does have some pain in external rotation and in extension some restriction.