Wangchuk (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

Wangchuk (Migration) [2025] ARTA 1505 (1 August 2025)

Applicant:Mr Singye Wangchuk

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Tribunal Number:  2313901

Tribunal:General Member B Gogarty

Place:Melbourne

Date:1 August 2025

Statement made on 06 August 2025 at 11:48am

Corrigendum

Date of Corrigendum:  6 August 2025

Pursuant to s 114 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth), the following alterations are made to the written statement of reasons for the decision:

  1. The second sentence in paragraph 5 is altered to strike the phrase “by a lawyer”, so that the statement reads: “The applicant, who was assisted in the review, appeared before the Tribunal on 8 July 2025 to give evidence and present arguments.”

AND

  1. The reporting clause in the first sentence of paragraph 31 is to replace the word “lawyer” with “migration agent”, so the statement reads: “Following the hearing, submissions were made by the applicant’s migration agent, which relevantly stated as follows:”

AND

  1. In the first sentence of the verbatim quote contained in paragraph 34, insert the erratum indicator [sic] after the phrase “migration lawyer”, so the statement reads: “While my ART decision was still pending (I had not been informed of a Hearing date or even if a Hearing would take place), upon consultation with my migration lawyer [sic] and family both in Canberra and Bhutan, I decided to continue my study in the field of Management with the focus to upgrade my qualification, skills and knowledge that is consistent to my previous studies and in line with my personal and professional career goals.”

AND

  1. In last sentence of paragraph 70 delete the repeated word “that”, so the statement reads: “The Tribunal considers that, even on the day of the hearing, the applicant and his representative remained uncertain and apparently confused about the state of his enrolment, which reinforces how recently it had been added to the evidence.”

The Tribunal Notes:

The mistakes corrected in orders 1-2 arose from the submission corrected in order 3 and not because of any misrepresentation by the relevant migration agent about their qualifications or registration status.

DECISION AND  

REASONS FOR DECISION

Applicant:Mr Singye Wangchuk

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Tribunal Number:  2313901

Tribunal:General Member B Gogarty

Place:Hobart

Date:  1 August 2025

Decision:The decision under review is affirmed.


Statement made on 01 August 2025 at 1:30pm

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa – Subclass 500 (Student) – genuine student – genuine temporary entrant – applicant changed career pathway – family and business commitments in home country – property and financial interests in Bhutan – siblings obtained permanent residency – limited course relevance to career goals – maintaining ongoing residence in Australia – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Act 2024 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 65, 499; Direction No 108
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2 cl 500.212

CASES

MEIA v Hafza (1985) 60 ALR 674

STATEMENT OF REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wangchuk (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 1505
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wangchuk (Migration) involved a Bhutanese citizen seeking to affirm a decision made by the Tribunal regarding his student visa application. The applicant had previously worked in media and film production in Bhutan and had family members living in Australia. He initially applied for a Temporary Activity (subclass 408) visa and later applied for a student visa, attending a hearing before the Tribunal to contest the refusal of his visa. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the applicant qualified as a genuine student and a genuine temporary entrant under the Migration Act.

The primary legal issue was whether the applicant genuinely intended to pursue studies in Australia and return to Bhutan after completing his courses. The Tribunal examined the applicant's educational history, career intentions, family and financial ties to Bhutan, and the relevance of his new course of study to his career goals. Additionally, the Tribunal considered the applicant's ability to support himself financially and whether he had a genuine intention to return to Bhutan after his studies.

The Tribunal found that the applicant's knowledge about the new course content was limited and appeared to be based on a general understanding from the course provider's website. This, combined with the applicant's inability to clearly articulate the course's relevance to his career, raised concerns about the genuineness of his enrolment. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant's limited course relevance, combined with his family and business commitments in Bhutan, did not sufficiently demonstrate that he intended to return to Bhutan after his studies. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the applicant's visa application.

The final orders of the Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the applicant's student visa application, finding that he did not meet the criteria of being a genuine student and a genuine temporary entrant. The Tribunal's decision was based on the applicant's limited understanding of the new course content, the lack of clear relevance to his career goals, and his strong ties to Bhutan, including family and business interests.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.BACKGROUND According to his biometric information the applicant was, at the time of the hearing a 41- year-old citizen of Bhutan.[3] He says that he grew up in Trashiyangste in the eastern part of the country before moving to the capital Thimphu for study and work.[3] At the hearing the applicant stated he was 42 years old. The Tribunal considers that may have been a mistake but makes no other findings and prefers the biometric (passport) information. The applicant is married and has two children, a daughter and son, who live with their mother in Thimphu. He provided evidence of an extended family living in Bhutan, which includes parents, grandparents and three siblings. The applicant has two siblings: an older brother and a younger sister who live in Canberra, Australia. He told the Tribunal that both came to Australia as students, subsequently gained permanent residence and have lived here for more than 10 years. The Tribunal reviewed the relevant movement records and confirmed this was the case. The applicant told the Tribunal that he lives with his brother and sister, although the documentary evidence before the Tribunal indicates that they live in separate houses in Canberra, and it would appear from the record that the applicant lives in his brother’s house. The Tribunal does not consider it necessary to make a finding about which sibling the applicant lives with but accepts his various evidence that his Australian based siblings have contributed to his studies with accommodation, living and other financial support while he has been onshore. Prior to his most recent studies in Australia the applicant had a varied educational and employment history. He completed his secondary studies in 2005 before beginning a career in media with the national television broadcaster in Bhutan. He worked as a video editor, camera operator and studio director. He provided evidence that he received professional skills training and experience throughout that career and was registered as a member of the Film Association of Bhutan. The applicant’s evidence is that, in 2011, he moved from the national broadcaster to freelance filmmaking, private film production operating his own media and events management business. He provided letters of support from the Film Association of Bhutan which indicated that he had produced “five feature films, one TV series and made more than 50 documentary[sic] and managed first Miss Bhutan pageant show and many popular reality shows in the [sic] Bhutan and outside Bhutan”. The applicant first entered Australia in November 2022 on a Temporary Activity (subclass 408) Visa which he submitted was for the purpose of participating in a cultural event for the Bhutan Youth Development Fund. Shortly thereafter, he applied for an Australian student visa and returned to Australia in December 2022 on a Bridging Visa related to his student visa application which was formally made on 24 January 2023.Background: Original study and onshore purpose

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Evidence and submissions considered. The Tribunal has read and considered all the applicant’s submissions and evidence and all of the other materials in the department and Tribunal file. The Tribunal also had before it the applicant’s official “PRISMS” record of enrolment for the purposes of the grant of student visas,[2]1 relevant curriculum and country information and relevant movement records. The applicant was provided further time to make additional written submissions after the hearing which were also considered in full before making this decision.[2] Commonwealth Department of Education “Explanatory notes for international student enrolment data/Pages/ExplanatoryNotesforAEIStudentEnrolmentData.aspx For the following reasons, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.BACKGROUND According to his biometric information the applicant was, at the time of the hearing a 41- year-old citizen of Bhutan.[3] He says that he grew up in Trashiyangste in the eastern part of the country before moving to the capital Thimphu for study and work.[3] At the hearing the applicant stated he was 42 years old. The Tribunal considers that may have been a mistake but makes no other findings and prefers the biometric (passport) information. The applicant is married and has two children, a daughter and son, who live with their mother in Thimphu. He provided evidence of an extended family living in Bhutan, which includes parents, grandparents and three siblings. The applicant has two siblings: an older brother and a younger sister who live in Canberra, Australia. He told the Tribunal that both came to Australia as students, subsequently gained permanent residence and have lived here for more than 10 years. The Tribunal reviewed the relevant movement records and confirmed this was the case. The applicant told the Tribunal that he lives with his brother and sister, although the documentary evidence before the Tribunal indicates that they live in separate houses in Canberra, and it would appear from the record that the applicant lives in his brother’s house. The Tribunal does not consider it necessary to make a finding about which sibling the applicant lives with but accepts his various evidence that his Australian based siblings have contributed to his studies with accommodation, living and other financial support while he has been onshore. Prior to his most recent studies in Australia the applicant had a varied educational and employment history. He completed his secondary studies in 2005 before beginning a career in media with the national television broadcaster in Bhutan. He worked as a video editor, camera operator and studio director. He provided evidence that he received professional skills training and experience throughout that career and was registered as a member of the Film Association of Bhutan. The applicant’s evidence is that, in 2011, he moved from the national broadcaster to freelance filmmaking, private film production operating his own media and events management business. He provided letters of support from the Film Association of Bhutan which indicated that he had produced “five feature films, one TV series and made more than 50 documentary[sic] and managed first Miss Bhutan pageant show and many popular reality shows in the [sic] Bhutan and outside Bhutan”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Hearing testimony about new course content and rationale. The Tribunal separately asked the applicant at hearing to explain the content of the new course of study and its relevance to his career intentions. In response the applicant initially provided a general but, in the Tribunal’s view, somewhat confused, statement about the course purpose which appeared to adopt language from the course page of the provider website. When the Tribunal asked the applicant to be more specific, he also appeared to have difficulty articulating what he would be studying and noted he could not remember the specific details of the course. The Tribunal asked why he had chosen to enrol said:I have, I have enrolled in this course because when it comes to cooking … and the kitchen management, I have, I got, I, I could learn many things … I can, I can handle this cooking. But when it comes to management part … the diploma in hospitality that were those, those chapter were very basic and that was very short.… So, if I have to manage my … business and the production company, any sort of the business having a good knowledge about the management is management was what I have realised.… So that's why so I have decided to take further course in the management in order to manage my own business as well.” Later in the hearing the Tribunal noted its concern that the applicant’s knowledge about the course appeared limited and appeared to “just reflect the paragraph on the website” of the provider. The Tribunal explained that this might suggest that he was not genuinely engaged in the course and that his enrolment was opportunistic in the circumstances. The applicant acknowledged he understood the concern and issues it raised and responded:“So, I couldn't give any specific and clear answer before on this particular thing. And because since it's a new course for me, so I don't have much idea. So, the only I don't have much idea about the course. So that's why that's why I'm going to take that course.And so, so I'm expecting so to learn up to the enrolment. So … I just went through the course details … and the course content. And so … I could get the clear idea how that the contents are very much important and relevant in the field of business, in the business that I'm doing right now. And the … help that is how it's going to help my future career as well.” [emphasis added] The applicant was asked if he understood that he needed to enrol in a new course of active study to participate in the hearing, to which he replied:“No, Sir, because I had no work. So, I was just living ideally here. So, I thought if I could get some more advanced studies in the same similar field. So that was my decision, Sir.” At a different point in the hearing the applicant was asked why he had enrolled in the new course if he had completed the previous course of studies which had indicated would mark the end of his study in Australia. He replied:“OK … yes … in previous submissions I have submitted … I was supposed to go back. I was supposed to go back after the completion of my [previous course]. But after the refusal, so I had April for the time and then then we were waiting for the waiting for the decision, the hearing, whatever the procedure was …So, I was just waiting for that because even I have decided discussed with my parents and in my family that now I have completed my course. So, I can come back but they even they suggested me, they suggest me you already have appeal to the Tribunal. So, [I] just wait for that hearing and see what's happening. And so, so meanwhile while I was waiting for that meanwhile, so I thought so I will take up a relevant course. So that's how so I take up the next course.”