Wang v Kuzmanovic & Anor (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

WANG v KUZMANOVIC & ANOR (Residential Tenancies) [2023] ACAT 39

RT 745/2022; RT 860/2022

Catchwords:               RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – where applicant was proprietor of premises but not lessor – where ex-wife of applicant was the agent for and lessor of the premises – where applicant attempted to displace agent as lessor – whether agent or applicant was lessor at material times – whether tenancy agreement purportedly entered into by applicant and tenants was the result of duress – purported tenancy void – agent remained lessor until departure of tenants from premises – applicant’s claims for rent and cleaning bound to fail – tenants’ counterclaim dismissed – bond discharged to tenants

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2007 s 53

Evidence Act 2011 s 97
Residential TenanciesAct1997 ss 5, 6A, 8, 15, 29, 30, 30A, 31, 36, 64, 84, 133, Schedule 1, standard terms 52, 63, 64, 84, 96, 100
Residential Tenancies Legislation Amendment Act 2023
Statute Law Amendment Act 2022

Cases cited:Australian & New Zealand Banking Group v Karam [2005] NSWCA 344

Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio [1983] HCA 14
Crescendo Management Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corp (1986) NSWLR 40
Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8
Secola v McCann [2011] WASC 342
Thorne v Kennedy [2017] HCA 49
Tomanovic v Argyle HQ Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 152

Texts/papers cited:     Anforth et al, Residential Tenancies: Law and Practice in NSW (Federation Press, 7th edition, 2022)

Tribunal:Senior Member M Hyman

Date of Orders:  19 July 2023

Date of Reasons for Decision:      19 July 2023

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          RT 745/2022

BETWEEN:

YAOXIANG WANG
Applicant/Lessor

AND:

JACQUELINE KUZMANOVIC
First Respondent/Tenant

ALEKSANDAR KUZMANOVIC
Second Respondent/Tenant

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member M Hyman

DATE:19 July 2023

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The applicant is to pay the respondents the sum of $1,580, consisting of:

    (a)$2,040 paid as rent under the invalid tenancy agreement; and

    (b)$200 paid as advances on the bond for the premises under the invalid tenancy agreement;

    (c)less $660 owed by the respondent/tenants to the applicant/lessor for repair to or replacement of the damaged cavity sliding door.

  2. The counterclaim made by the respondents is dismissed.

  3. The purported tenancy between the applicant and the respondents dated 11 August 2022 is declared void for duress.

    ………………………………..

Senior Member M Hyman

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          RT 860/2022

BETWEEN:

YAOXIANG WANG
Applicant/Lessor

AND:

JACQUELINE KATRINA KUZMANOVIC
Respondent/Tenant

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member M Hyman

DATE:19 July 2023

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The applicant is to pay to the respondents the sum of $2,040 held by him as bond paid under the invalid tenancy agreement.

    ………………………………..

Senior Member M Hyman

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. This decision concerns residential tenancy arrangements in regard to a house in the suburb of Macquarie, ACT. It has come before the Tribunal through a confused and protracted path involving many different applications and decisions. The parties have on occasion attempted to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wang v Kuzmanovic & Anor (Residential Tenancies) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACAT 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Wang v Kuzmanovic & Anor, the applicant, Mr Wang, sought to reclaim a rental bond and unpaid rent from the tenants, Ms Kuzmanovic and Mr Kuzmanovic, who had been residing in a property managed by Ms Kuzmanovic, who was also Mr Wang’s ex-wife. The dispute centred on whether Mr Wang or Ms Kuzmanovic was the lessor of the premises at the relevant times, and whether the tenancy agreement entered into by Mr Wang and the tenants was the result of duress. The court was tasked with determining whether the tenancy agreement was valid and if the applicant’s claims for rent and cleaning were justified.

The court found that the evidence pointed to duress rather than undue influence, with Mr Wang’s persistent pressure and overbearing behaviour towards Ms Kuzmanovic culminating in the signing of various documents, including a power of attorney and a handwritten statement, which Ms Kuzmanovic did not fully understand. This was further evidenced by Mr Wang’s actions leading up to 11 August 2022, which were aimed at displacing Ms Kuzmanovic as the lessor of the property. The court concluded that Ms Kuzmanovic’s freedom in decision-making was seriously impaired, leading to the voiding of the tenancy agreement on the grounds of duress.

As a result, the court dismissed the applicant’s claims for rent and cleaning, ordered the applicant to pay the tenants $1,580, and dismissed the tenants’ counterclaim. Additionally, the bond was discharged to the tenants. The court declared the tenancy agreement dated 11 August 2022 void for duress, affirming that Ms Kuzmanovic remained the lessor until the tenants vacated the premises.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The applicant is to pay the respondents the sum of $1,580, consisting of:

(a) $2,040 paid as rent under the invalid tenancy agreement; and

(b) $200 paid as advances on the bond for the premises under the invalid tenancy agreement;

(c) less $660 owed by the respondent/tenants to the applicant/lessor for repair to or replacement of the damaged cavity sliding door.

2.

The counterclaim made by the respondents is dismissed.

3.

The purported tenancy between the applicant and the respondents dated 11 August 2022 is declared void for duress.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It might be possible to set out a case that Ms Kuzmanovic’s will was subservient to that of Mr Wang on 11 August 2022, so as to support a finding of undue influence. But most of the evidence leading up to that date suggests that Ms Kuzmanovic was resistant to Mr Wang’s pressure. The evidence is much more aligned with the indicia of duress. Relevant evidence includes:(a)Mr Wang’s marked and persistent determination to become the lessor for the Macquarie premises, leading to almost constant pressure on Ms Kuzmanovic. In succession, there are the visit to the premises on 9 May 2022, the termination notice of the same date under section 64 of the RTA, the application under that section to the ACAT of 10 July 2022, the termination and possession order of 27 July, the visit to the premises on 28 July, the warrant of eviction applied for on 4 August 2022 and the events of 11 August 2022, after the termination and possession order was set aside. All of these were plainly aimed at the same end – displacing Ms Bian as lessor of the Macquarie premises; and all of them put pressure on Ms Kuzmanovic.(b)That determination was accompanied by an apparently equal determination that Ms Kuzmanovic should not take up the tenancy at the Palmerston property. This is evident in Mr Wang’s email response to Ms Kuzmanovic on the afternoon of 11 August 2022[101] and in his text messages to her of 9 to 11 September 2022.[102] Once again, this determination was manifested in pressure on Ms Kuzmanovic.(c)Mr Wang showed himself as capable of being physically overbearing. The police report of 9 May 2022 reports him as “yelling and standing over the tenants, stating that he was legally allowed to kick them out of the location”. Mr Wang played this down, but I have no reason to treat the police report as anything but neutral and reliable evidence. The evidence about events on 28 July 2022 is very limited, as Ms Kuzmanovic arrived home as Mr Wang, or perhaps some other visitor, was leaving. Her account of her father’s story is hearsay and of little value as evidence. But in his own evidence at the hearing, Mr Wang acknowledged that he had visited the premises in July without warning or consent and had spoken to Mr Kuzmanovic. Ms Kuzmanovic said that Mr Wang yelled at her and her father on 11 September 2022 at the Palmerston property, but there is no evidence in support in the police report (Mr Wang was the complainant on that occasion). Section 97 of the Evidence Act 2011 (the Evidence Act) limits the use of evidence going to the tendency of a person to behave in particular ways. I am not bound by the rules of evidence, but the weight given to this point needs to take into account the potential for tendency evidence to be prejudicial. Section 97 of the Evidence Act provides that evidence of a person’s tendency to behave in a particular way may only be admitted if the court thinks that the evidence, alone or with other evidence, has significant probative value. In this instance, the evidence of Mr Wang’s behaviour on 9 May 2022, and the limited evidence of his visit to the Macquarie premises on 28 July 2022, align with other evidence to support Ms Kuzmanovic’s account of what occurred on 11 August. Accordingly, I am assigning reasonable weight to the evidence that shows Mr Wang as having a tendency to yell at and be overbearing with his tenants.(d)The email and text message exchanges between Mr Wang and Ms Kuzmanovic, especially those on 11 August 2022, illustrate the strength of Mr Wang’s determination to resolve his differences with Ms Bian in ways that would be to his advantage; and they once again show how it was Ms Kuzmanovic who was on the receiving end of his attentions (in oral evidence she spoke of the endless stream of emails on that day).[103] The line adopted by Mr Wang on that day was a substantial shift from that he had followed up to that point: previously he had attempted to terminate the existing tenancy and evict the respondents, but on 11 August 2022 he offered Ms Kuzmanovic and her father the option of staying in the property under a new tenancy agreement. It is perhaps not surprising that Ms Kuzmanovic seized the opportunity with both hands – but it also points to the possibility that she was not taking the decision in a free and considered way.(e)The other documents signed on or about 11 August 2022, namely the power of attorney and the handwritten statement by Ms Kuzmanovic suggest very forcibly that Ms Kuzmanovic, and equally her father, were not able to withstand the pressure that Mr Wang brought to bear on them. These are not documents that gave any advantage to the respondents, unlike the tenancy agreement, which arguably had the advantage of keeping them in accommodation until the Palmerston property became available to them. That Ms Kuzmanovic and her father signed the power of attorney, and that Ms Kuzmanovic wrote and signed her handwritten statement, both of them documents that she showed little understanding of at any stage, suggest very strongly that Ms Kuzmanovic’s freedom in decision-making was seriously impaired.(f)The evidence of Ms Kuzmanovic at the hearing was that on 11 August 2022 Mr Wang arrived at night; stood throughout the visit despite invitations to sit; insisted that she and her father sign the documents he put before them; said that if she did not she would no longer have a roof over her head; and dictated her handwritten statement to her; and that she had little understanding of the documents that she signed.[101] Respondent’s documents, page 40[102] Respondent’s documents, pages 78-83[103] Transcript of proceedings, 8 March 2023, page 70

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.