Wan and Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 217

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2001/780

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE   DIVISION     )          
           Re      Lei Wan       
  Applicant
           And    Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs   
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr R P Handley, Deputy President         

Date4 April 2002

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Respondent with a direction that the discretion not to refuse the grant of a visa under section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 should be exercised in the case of Lei Wan.
  ..............................................
  R P Handley
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – Spouse Visa – whether of good character – past criminal record – best interests of the children – discretion to be applied if applicant found not to be of good character - best interests of the children considered as primary to the interests of the Australian community.
Migration Act 1958 ss 499(1) (2) (2A), 501, 501(1)
Migration Legislation Amendment (Strengthening of Provisions Relating to Character and Conduct) Act 1998
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 90 FCR 583
Lei Wan v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [2000] AATA 685
Wan v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [2000] FCA 1822
Lei Wan v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [2001] FCA 568
Vaitaiki v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1998) 150 ALR 608

REASONS FOR DECISION

4 April 2002 Mr R P Handley                  

  1. This is an application by Lei Wan ("the Applicant") for a review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs ("the Respondent") made on 6 May 1999 to refuse the grant of a subclass 820/801 general (residence class) visa to Mr Wan. At the hearing, the Applicant was represented by Paul Brereton and Mark Robinson, of Counsel, and the Respondent was represented by Andras Markus, Solicitor, of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the documents produced pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the T Documents"), together with the documents tendered by the parties. Oral evidence was given in person by the Applicant's wife, Min Hua Yang and by telephone by Dr David Lamb.
    BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant, Mr Wan was born in the People's Republic of China on 26 April 1966 and is aged 35.  He first arrived in Australia on 3 January 1990 on a student visa permitting him to stay until 22 July 1990.  On 8 November 1990, Mr Wan applied for a protection visa which was refused on 9 February 1993.  On 12 March 1993, Mr Wan applied for a review of that decision which was affirmed by a delegate of the Respondent on 30 June 1993. 

  3. Ms Yang was born in the People's Republic of China on 5 December 1962 and is aged 39.  She first met Mr Wan in July 1990 at the International Language School in Melbourne.  They began a relationship towards the end of 1990 and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wan and Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenou... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 217
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Lei Wan, sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs to refuse the grant of a subclass 820 visa. The legal issue before the court was whether Mr Wan was of good character, given his past criminal record, and if not, whether the Minister's discretion should be exercised in his favour considering the best interests of his children. The court had to consider the criteria under sections 499(1), (2), (2A), 501, and 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958, as well as relevant case law.

The court found that Mr Wan was not of good character, based on his criminal history and the running of brothels in which illegal workers were found. Despite this, the court considered the best interests of Mr Wan's children as a primary factor, in line with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. The court balanced this against the expectations of the Australian community regarding standards of behaviour. Ultimately, the court determined that the best interests of Mr Wan's children, along with other primary considerations, outweighed the negative aspects of Mr Wan's past conduct. The court exercised its discretion in favour of Mr Wan, leading to the refusal of the Minister's decision to be set aside and the grant of the visa to be ordered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by Lei Wan ("the Applicant") for a review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs ("the Respondent") made on 6 May 1999 to refuse the grant of a subclass 820/801 general (residence class) visa to Mr Wan. At the hearing, the Applicant was represented by Paul Brereton and Mark Robinson, of Counsel, and the Respondent was represented by Andras Markus, Solicitor, of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the documents produced pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the T Documents"), together with the documents tendered by the parties. Oral evidence was given in person by the Applicant's wife, Min Hua Yang and by telephone by Dr David Lamb. BACKGROUND The Applicant, Mr Wan was born in the People's Republic of China on 26 April 1966 and is aged 35. He first arrived in Australia on 3 January 1990 on a student visa permitting him to stay until 22 July 1990. On 8 November 1990, Mr Wan applied for a protection visa which was refused on 9 February 1993. On 12 March 1993, Mr Wan applied for a review of that decision which was affirmed by a delegate of the Respondent on 30 June 1993. Ms Yang was born in the People's Republic of China on 5 December 1962 and is aged 39. She first met Mr Wan in July 1990 at the International Language School in Melbourne. They began a relationship towards the end of 1990 and began to live together in early 1991. In about May 1992, their relationship broke down and, on 28 September 1992, Ms Yang, who was then pregnant, married Raymond Gordon, an Australian citizen. Mr Gordon and Ms Yang travelled to China together where Ms Yang gave birth to her first child, Annie Yang Wan, on 17 February 1993. Following the birth, it became apparent that the father of the child was Mr Wan, and Mr Gordon returned to Australia. Ms Yang remained in China with her parents for a while before returning to Australia on 25 March 1993, leaving Annie in the care of her grandparents. Initially, on her return to Australia, Ms Yang lived with Mr Gordon but, by about May 1993, that relationship had deteriorated and she resumed living with Mr Wan. She was divorced from Mr Gordon on 18 April 1995 and married Mr Wan on 28 May 1995. On 6 June 1995, Ms Yang became an Australian citizen. . On 23 October 1992, Mr Wan was charged with a number of offences relating to an assault that took place on 12 October 1992. Mr Wan was subsequently released on bail, subject to reporting conditions. On 9 March 1994, he was sentenced by Judge Ross in the Melbourne Country Court to 8 months imprisonment for intentionally causing serious injury, 4 months for intentionally and recklessly causing injury, and 1 month for wilful damage to property, the sentences to be served concurrently, together with an order to pay compensation of $893.00. Mr Wan served 8 months and was released from prison on 21 September 1994.. On 27 July 1994, Mr Wan lodged an application for a special (permanent) entry permit - class 816 to enable him to remain permanently in Australia. On 7 July 1995, after his marriage to Ms Yang, Mr Wan notified the Department that he wished to withdraw his application for a class 816 entry permit. Then, on 13 July 1995, he lodged an application for a subclass 801 (spouse) visa based on his marriage to Ms Yang. 6. In 1996, Mr Wan and Ms Yang moved to Canberra. A company owned by Ms Yang, Rachelle Richie Pty Ltd, purchased a legal brothel called "Club 77", located at 77 Gladstone Street, Fyshwick. In August 1997, the company purchased a second brothel located at Mitchell called "Pretty Woman", which was leased out. Neither Mr Wan nor Ms Yang worked at this second brothel. Club 77 employed prostitutes on a casual basis, many of them from various countries in Asia, including Indonesia, Thailand and China. Compliance officers from the ACT Regional Office of the Department undertook field operations targeting Club 77 on 31 May 1996, 16 January 1997 and on several occasions during the period between March 1997 and July 1998. On each occasion, illegal workers were detected and detained.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue for the Tribunal to determine in this case is, therefore, whether Mr Wan is not of good character having regard to his past criminal conduct and his general conduct, so as to be precluded from the grant of a subclass 820 visa. If the Tribunal decides he is not of good character, it must exercise the residual discretion under s 501(1) to decide whether, nevertheless, not to refuse the grant of a visa. EVIDENCEMin Hua Yang Ms Yang said she lives at Wahroonga with her family and her present occupation is that of a "housewife". Her daughter, Annie, aged 9, is in Year 4 at Abbotsleigh School at Wahroonga and Ms Yang says she plans for Annie to continue her schooling there. Ms Yang plans for Andrew, aged 2 ½, to attend Knox Grammar School which is straight across the Pacific Highway from where they live. Ms Yang said her husband sold the Barbecue Kitchen Restaurant at Turramurra in March 2001 because they were concerned at the outcome of the current proceedings and, in particular, that if her husband had to return to China, she would not be able to run the business as well as caring for her children. Ms Yang was asked about a statement setting out her and her husband's assets (A11). She said her company, Rachelle Riche Pty Ltd, owns a property at 1/108 Gladstone Street, Fyshwick, ACT which was purchased in 1998/1999 for between $50,000 - $60,000. She and her husband gradually developed the premises, which are used for the Club 77 brothel which they own, and the premises are now worth $300,000. At the time she and her husband purchased the property, they were both living in Canberra and working at Club 77 for up to 16 hours a day. Ms Yang said her role in Club 77 was that of managing phone enquiries and talking with the clients. When she and her husband moved to Sydney in 1999, they leased the Club 77 brothel and now receive an income from that business by way of a licence fee of $600 per week. They also receive rent of $1,000 per week in respect of the premises at Gladstone Street. With regard to the property at 1 Gilda Avenue, Wahroonga where she and her family live, Ms Yang said some of the money for the deposit was loaned to them by her younger brother in China. Ms Yang said this property was purchased in late 1998 for $600,000 in her name. Otherwise, the purchase was financed by a mortgage of $450,000 and from their savings after many years of hard work. The repayments on the mortgage are $3,000 per month. Ms Yang confirmed that in the past 12 months, 1 Gilda Avenue has been re-zoned for multi-unit development. Ms Yang said the flat at 9/21 Guilfoyle Avenue, Double Bay which was purchased for $380,000 in the year 2000, was purchased in her husband's name. Ms Yang said they owe $280,000 in respect of the flat, for which they pay mortgage payments of $2,000 per month and, receive $1,300 per month in rent. They paid a deposit of between $20,000 – $30,000 on the purchase price of $340,000. Ms Yang said when her husband sold the Barbecue Kitchen Restaurant in March 2001, for between $70,000 - $80,000, part of this money was used to repay a friend who had loaned them some money for the purpose of buying the Double Bay flat. Part also went to purchasing the property at 275/398 Pitt Street, Sydney, purchased some 2 to 3 months ago, as premises for the business from which her husband and his partner, Zhu Jing Can, run their introduction agency known as Golden Bird Australia Group. The Pitt Street premises are worth approximately $200,000 and the mortgage on those premises is $125,000, on which the mortgage repayments are $1,200 per month. Her husband's income from the introduction agency is approximately $1,000 per week. Her husband has only been involved in this partnership for two to three months.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

With regard to other considerations, Mr Markus said the Respondent notes that Ms Yang and her parents are all Australian citizens and accepts that Ms Yang would experience hardship if Mr Wan had to return to China and she chose not to accompany him. However, Mr Markus said that when considering any hardship to Ms Yang, the Tribunal should take into account her knowledge of her husband's activities. The Respondent does not accept that if Ms Yang moved back to China, there would need to be a fire sale of her and Mr Wan's properties in Australia. In conclusion, Mr Markus said the Respondent submits that the other primary considerations outweigh the best interests of Mr Wan's and Ms Yang's children, and, therefore, the Minister's discretion should not be exercised in Mr Wan's favour, so as not to refuse the grant of a visa.CONSIDERATION OF LAW AND FINDINGS The first issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether, in accordance with s 501(2)(a) of the Act, it is satisfied that Mr Wan is not of good character. The Applicant accepts the conclusion reached by Deputy President McMahon in the original Tribunal hearing that Mr Wan is not of good character and the findings in Deputy President McMahon's decision upon which he based that conclusion. The Tribunal also relies on those findings. The Tribunal had particular regard to the comments by Judge Ross in the Melbourne County Court when sentencing Mr Wan on 9 March 1994. The Tribunal also noted Deputy President McMahon's comments concerning the running of the brothels with which Mr Wan and Ms Yang were associated and, the raids made by officers of the Department acting in conjunction with the Australian Federal Police, during which illegal workers were detected, detained and taken away. Deputy President McMahon commented that Mr Wan's evidence was self-contradictory and was inconsistent with that of his wife. Deputy President McMahon said he formed the "distinct impression that he [Mr Wan] would say anything to assist what he perceived to be his interests". Nevertheless, the Tribunal notes that it is nine and half years since the offences which took place in October 1992 and that Mr Wan and Ms Yang are no longer involved in running brothels. Having determined that Mr Wan is not of "good character", the Tribunal must consider the exercise of the residual discretion under s 501(1) of the Act to decide whether, notwithstanding, not to refuse the grant of a visa to Mr Wan. In doing so, the Tribunal will have regard to General Direction No 5 as a guide to the exercise of its discretion. In particular, the Tribunal must have regard to the view of the Government expressed in paragraph 2:that non-citizens must comply with expected standards of behaviour that reflect community attitudes to such matters as criminality, provocation conduct, and complicity with others who are involved in, or connected with organised criminal behaviour. The Tribunal will also have regard to the best interests of Mr Wan's and Ms Yang's children, Annie and Andrew, as a primary consideration, in accordance with the legitimate expectation that administrative decision-makers will act in conformity with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child of 17 December 1990, as recognised in Teoh (supra) at 291-292 by Mason CJ and Deane J. Such an approach was adopted in Vaitaiki (supra) and in Wan (supra). As the Full Federal Court stated in Wan at paragraph 32, the approach which the Tribunal should adopt is first "to identify what the best interests of Mr Wan's children required with respect to the exercise of its discretion" and, second, "to assess whether the strength of any other consideration, or the cumulative effect of other considerations, outweighed the consideration of the best interests of the children understood as a primary consideration". As the Full Court recognised, the Tribunal is also entitled to regard the expectations of the Australian community as a primary consideration.