Walton and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

Walton and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2018] AATA 4585 (12 December 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/2167 & 2017/2981

Re:Mr Campbell Walton

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms Anna Burke, Member

Date:12 December 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and finds that Australia Post is liable to pay compensation in accordance with the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 for Mr Walton’s injuries resulting in his incapacity for work. The Tribunal remits the matters to Australia Post for reconsideration in accordance with this decision.

.....[sgd]........................................

Ms Anna Burke, Member

Catchwords

WORKER’S COMPENSATION – postal worker – denial of liability – whether primary injury exists or is work related – whether second psychology injury exists or is work related - whether there is incapacity leading to entitlement to medical expenses and incapacity payment – conflicting medical evidence - decision set aside

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535, [2006] HCA 47

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms Anna Burke, Member

12 December 2018

  1. Mr Campbell Walton (the Applicant) is seeking review of a decision made by the Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post) (the Respondent) pursuant to section 62 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act). The reviewable decision affirmed an earlier determination denying liability for the injury of common extensor tendon tear/arm which developed over a period of weeks (application number 2016/2167). The Applicant also seeks review of a decision by Australia Post, which affirmed an earlier determination denying liability for the condition of adjustment disorder (application number 2017/2981).

  2. Mr Walton commenced work with Australia Post as a Postal Delivery Officer on


    10 October 2007 at Moorabbin; later working at Seaford, Mornington and Cranbourne. His job required him to sort, bundle and deliver mail. He completed his round on a motorcycle.

  3. Mr Walton remains an employee of Australia Post but he stopped working on


    22 February 2016 as he claims he is unable to travel to his current work location as he can no longer drive a car, ride a motorcycle or  use public transport as a result of his injuries. Mr Walton has been a Country Fire Authority (CFA) volunteer for over 30 years, reaching the position of Crew Leader.

  4. Mr Walton has had a series of WorkCover, Comcare and Transport Accident Commission (TAC) claims in respect of injuries:

    ·a  September 1987 WorkCover claim for a shoulder injury whilst employed at Seppelt’s as a storeman;

    ·an April 2004 WorkCover claim for right knee strain sustained whilst carrying heavy objects down seven floors whilst employed at Lebour Pty Ltd;

    ·a May 2006 WorkCover claim for an allergic reaction from inhalation of particles spilt from delivered goods whilst working at Lebour Pty Ltd;

    ·a 2009 accepted Comcare claim for bilateral knee injury for which he had a left knee arthroscopic procedure (Mr Walton reported this in his history to various specialists seen as part…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walton and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4585
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr. Campbell Walton against a decision by the Australian Postal Corporation denying liability for his claimed work-related injuries. Mr. Walton alleged he suffered from right lateral epicondylitis, commonly known as tennis elbow, and a subsequent psychological injury, leading to incapacity and entitlement to medical expenses and incapacity payments. The Australian Postal Corporation contended that Mr. Walton's employment had not contributed to a significant degree to his alleged injuries.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether a primary injury, specifically right lateral epicondylitis, existed and if it was work-related. Furthermore, it needed to ascertain if a secondary psychological injury had arisen and if that, too, was connected to his employment. The ultimate question was whether these injuries resulted in an incapacity for work that entitled Mr. Walton to compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth).

The Tribunal considered extensive medical evidence, including diagnostic studies and reports from general practitioners. It found that the majority of medical experts, along with Mr. Walton's general practitioners, diagnosed him with right lateral epicondylitis. While one expert suggested the condition may have resolved, the Tribunal concluded, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr. Walton sustained this injury in the course of his employment with Australia Post due to the repetitive nature of his work. The Tribunal noted that the *SRC Act* does not require a specific incident for an injury to be compensable, but rather that the injury arises out of employment. The Tribunal set aside the decision under review, finding Australia Post liable for compensation for Mr. Walton's injuries resulting in incapacity for work, and remitted the matter for reconsideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A 15-minute video of Mr Walton was tendered and viewed during the hearing. The video showed him mowing the lawn at the front of his family home on the 29 September 2018, and then walking towards his home at 8:36am on 2 October 2018. Medical EvidenceDiagnostic Studies The following diagnostic studies were referred to by the parties during the course of the tribunal hearing:·A right elbow x-ray dated 7 June 2016 reporting: no acute bony lesion or fracture noted. Alignment is normal and the articulated margins are smooth with maintained joint space. There is no degenerative change. No joint effusion or intra-articular loose body noted.·A right elbow ultrasound dated 7 June 2016 reporting: moderate thickening of the common extensor origin. The area is heterogeneously hypoechoic with increased internal vascularity and focal tenderness. The appearance is in keeping with common extensor origin tendinopathy. No associated tear identified. There is no associated abnormality with a common flexor origin.·Right elbow ultrasound dated 21 July 2016 reporting: no joint effusion. Common flexor and extensor origin appear normal. Medial and lateral collateral ligaments normal. Distal biceps insertion normal. Triceps tendon normal.·Right elbow ultrasound-guided injection dated 28 July 2016, reporting: informed consent was obtained. Under aseptic technique and ultrasound-guided 10 ml of 0.5% Marcaine was introduced around the left common extensor origin. This was followed by 2cc of Celestone injected into the common extensor origin at the site of maximal abnormality. No immediate complications were reported.·Right elbow x-ray dated 12 May 2017 reporting: bone mineral density appears normal. No acute, displaced fracture or bony malignant. No elbow effusion. Minor enthesopathy is seen at the lateral epicondylar region of the distal humerus.Dr Peter Rudiger, General Practitioner Dr Rudiger was not called as a witness but numerous medical certificates, clinical notes and reports from him were tendered as part of the evidence before the Tribunal. Both parties referred to Dr Rudiger’s extensive clinical records during the hearing. In a medical certificate dated 2 December 2015, he diagnosed Mr Walton with: pain in his R arm/elbow that developed 2 weeks ago and aggravated by pulling mail out of bag, pressing bike brakes, throwing mail. He advised that Mr Walton should avoid forceful action of griping and wrist extension can use his arm for support role. He also stated that Mr Walton was in need of physio help. Dr Rudiger provided a further medical certificate dated 14 January 2016 where he diagnosed Mr Walton as suffering from right lateral epicondylitis. On 1 February 2016 Dr Rudiger provided a letter which certified:I have today examined Mr Walton.In my opinion, Mr Campbell Walton is suffering from right-sided lateral epicondylitis.This is to confirm that Mr Walton has presented with typical history of right forearm pain and has developed gradually on lifting mail out of bag and steering his motorbike.He was given WorkCover certificate.Surprisingly his claim has been rejected mainly because it was not a.. incident.This is happened without even requesting treating doctor/physio report.Could union look at assisting Mr Walton in getting his injury treated through work. Dr Craig Smith, General Practitioner

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal observes that Australia Post and Mr Walton had not engaged in a constructive process to resolve this protracted dispute. Further, the Tribunal observes that Australia Post dealt with Mr Walton’s intransigence in respect of his views about workplace health and safety by not addressing his issues but moved him around numerous facilities. Mr Walton also appeared to be uninterested in working with his employer or colleagues to achieve a resolution to his conflict, viewing their approach as not up to his standard and maintaining a perception that he was being victimised for drawing attention to areas of genuine concern.CONCLUSION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review, finding Australia Post is liable to pay compensation in accordance with the SRC Act for Mr Walton’s injuries resulting in his incapacity for work. It remits the matter to Australia Post for reconsideration in accordance with this decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Seymour strenuously argued that the Tribunal should affirm both decisions as Mr Walton’s employment with Australia Post had not contributed, to a significant degree, to his injury.CONSIDERATION AND FINDINGS The Tribunal, having considered the considerable medical evidence in this matter, found that Mr Walton’s general practitioners and the majority of medical experts called in this matter had all determined that he had suffered from right lateral epicondylitis. The only dissenting opinion was that of Dr Kostos, who observed that if Mr Walton did have right lateral epicondylitis in the past, it has since resolved. Dr Kostos noted that his findings were similar to Dr Boys, opining that Mr Walton’s history was consistent with resolved right lateral humoral epicondylitis. The Tribunal was also informed by the x-ray and ultrasound of 7 June 2016, which reported moderate thickening of the common extensor origin; and by the successful outcome of the right elbow ultrasound-guided injection of 28 July 2016, which had resulted in Mr Walton experiencing relief from the condition for six months. The Tribunal concludes that, on the weight of the medical evidence, Mr Walton had suffered from right lateral epicondylitis commencing in November 2015. However, it had resolved on 28 July 2016 when he received relief from an ultrasound guided injection. Whilst the Tribunal accepts that Mr Walton continues to report ongoing mild pain, there is no corroborating diagnostic evidence to substantiate that he continues to suffer from right lateral epicondylitis. Mr Kossmann’s report indicated that Mr Walton had an aggravation of his condition in February/March 2017 and he is awaiting an MRI of his right elbow. As this was after 22 February 2016 when Mr Walton discontinued attending the workplace, the aggravation could not be work-related. The Tribunal also relied upon Dr Smith’s medical certificate of 27 February 2018, in which he indicated Mr Walton’s intermittent right elbow pain had resolved. The Tribunal, referring to the weight of evidence, finds that on the balance of probabilities Mr Walton sustained the injury to his right elbow in the course of his employment with Australia Post. Mr Walton’s employment as a postal delivery officer involved grasping, throwing, reaching with his right hand, and placing force on his right hand, on a repetitive basis, would have contributed to the development of the tendinitis of the right elbow over time. The Tribunal concurs with Mr Carey that the SRC Act does not specify that an incident must be recorded as a precursor for an injury to be compensable. The SRC Act states an injury suffered by an employee arising out of their employment. The Tribunal finds that Mr Walton’s primary injury of tennis elbow was sustained over a period of time in the course of his employment with Australia Post, based on the repetitive nature of his work and the described aetiology of such an injury by the various medical experts testifying before the Tribunal.