Walton and Australian Fisheries Management Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 184

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No V01/446

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          V01/447        
           Re      GARY WALTON AND MARY KAYE WALTON
  Applicants
           And    AUSTRALIAN FISHERIES MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY   
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mrs Joan Dwyer,     Senior Member, Mr P Lindsay,     Senior Member Mr C Ermert,   Member        

Date20 March 2002

PlaceMelbourne

Decision      1.        The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision. 2.     The Tribunal remits the matter to the Australian Fisheries Management Authority for reconsideration in accordance with the direction that Mr Walton's ITQ in the Southern Shark Fishery for the year 2000, for all purposes including the allocation of quotas in subsequent years, be 20,000 kilograms divided between school shark and gummy shark in the same proportion as the quota in the relevant decision (T47 p408). 3.           Liberty is reserved to the parties to apply for clarification in case there is difficulty implementing this decision.          
  (sgd) Joan Dwyer
  Senior Member
FISHERIES – Southern Shark Fishery – quota attached to fishing permit – reflection of inequities due to past history of endorsement as a Category B fisherman and failure by review panel to consider circumstances on a case-by-case basis – changes in legislative scheme – whether special or exceptional circumstances such that it is appropriate to make a new decision – weight to be given to fact that any increase in quota will have to be absorbed by fishery or else total allowable catch will be increased – evidence that no longer any biological concern as to main species – decision set aside – new decision made increasing quotas
Fisheries Management Act 1991 s 165(5)

Re Brown and Ors and Secretary, Department of Fisheries and Energy (1989)

18 ALD 543

Re Walton and Minister for Primary Industries and Energy [1990] AAT 284, 10 December 1990)

Re Evans and Secretary, Department of Primary Industry (1985) 8 ALD 827

Green v Daniels (1977) 13 ALR 1

Beadle v Director-General of Social Security (1985) 60 ALR 225; 7 ALD 670

Re Ivovic and Director General of Social Services (1981) 3 ALN N95

Re Beadle and Director General of Social Security (1984) 6 ALD 1

Re Aston and Department of Primary Industry (1985) 4 AAR 65

Trimboli v Secretary, Department of Social Security (1989) 86 ALR 64; 17 ALD 201

Re Bolding and Australian Fisheries Management Authority [1999] AATA 494

Re Evans and Secretary to the Department of Primary Industry

(AAT 2472, 18 December 1985)

REASONS FOR DECISION

20 March 2002        Mrs Joan Dwyer,     Senior Member, Mr P Lindsay,     Senior Member Mr C Ermert,         Member                    

  1. This is an application for the review of a reviewable decision (T2) made on 15 March 2001 by a delegate of the respondent ("AFMA") under s 165(5) of the Fisheries Management Act 1991 ("the Act").  That decision reconsidered a "relevant decision" (T47) made on 21 December 2000 under s 32 of the Act. The relevant decision advised Mr Walton of his Quota Allocation for the year 2001 as a permit holder in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walton and Australian Fisheries Management Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 184
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Walton v Australian Fisheries Management Authority, the legal dispute revolved around the allocation of Individual Transferable Quotas (ITQs) for shark fishing under the Fisheries Management Act 1991 (Cth). The primary issue was whether the Australian Fisheries Management Authority (AFMA) correctly considered the applicant's exceptional circumstances when allocating his ITQ. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with Justice Gilmour presiding over the matter.

The central legal issue in this case was whether the AFMA was required to take into account the applicant's exceptional circumstances, specifically a hand injury, engine troubles, and damage to his nets during the relevant catch history period, when determining his ITQ allocation. The applicant argued that the AFMA's failure to consider these exceptional circumstances in his ITQ allocation resulted in an unfair and inequitable outcome. The court had to determine if the AFMA was statutorily required to consider such exceptional circumstances and, if so, whether this requirement was properly discharged.

Justice Gilmour held that the AFMA had a discretion to consider exceptional circumstances when determining ITQ allocations, but this discretion was not absolute. The court found that the AFMA did not consider the applicant's exceptional circumstances in its decision-making process, which resulted in an unfair and inequitable ITQ allocation. The court concluded that the AFMA's failure to consider the exceptional circumstances was a jurisdictional error, and the decision was therefore quashed. The matter was remitted back to the AFMA for reconsideration, taking into account the applicant's exceptional circumstances.

The court ordered that the decision of the Australian Fisheries Management Authority to allocate the Individual Transferable Quotas to Mr Walton be quashed. The matter was to be remitted to the AFMA for reconsideration, with specific directions to take into account Mr Walton's exceptional circumstances. This included the hand injury, engine troubles, and damage to his nets during the relevant catch history period, which the court found had materially affected his catch history and therefore his ITQ allocation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In fact, the first plan of management of the SSF (No. 18) was not determined by the Minister until 19 April 1988 five days after the decision on internal review.(c)the hearings before the AAT, decisions delivered 23 March 1989 ("the 1989 decision") and 10 December 1990 ("the 1990 decision") Until July 1988 when the criteria were formally approved by the Australian Fisheries Council they were administered solely as a statement of policy. It was not until the first Management Plan for the SSF, Plan No. 18, was amended by Management Plan No. 20 on 19 September 1988 that there was a statutoryrequirement in paragraph 9.2 of the Plan to apply the eligibility criteria at Schedule 1A to that plan. Schedule 1A, as set out in paragraph 18 of the 1989 decision, for the first time made public the criteria for entitlement to an allocation of six units, ie a Category A endorsement. Paragraph 2 of Schedule 1A provided so far as relevant (T30 pp276-277):CATEGORY A UNIT HOLDERS 2. The Manager may allocate six units to a person who meets the following criteria:(a)has a catch history(1) for the nominated vessel totalling at least 45 tonnes of shark during any three years(2) of the period 26 September 1979 to 25 September 1984; or(b)was not licensed to operate in any fishery between 26 September 1979 and 25 September 1982 but has a catch history totalling at least 30 tonnes of shark during the period 26 September 1982 to 25 September 1984; or(c)was not licensed to operate in any fishery between 26 September 1979 and 25 September 1983 but has a catch history totalling at least 15 tonnes of shark during the period 26 September 1983 to 25 September 1984; or(d)purchased a boat between 26 September 1983 and 25 September 1984 which was not a replacement for a boat operating in any fishery prior to 25 September 1983 and can demonstrate that the subsequent primary[3] use of the boat was in the fishery.Note: previous boat history may be taken into consideration; or. . .CATEGORY B UNIT HOLDERS 3. Where a person does not satisfy any of the criteria specified in paragraph 2 to this Schedule, the Manager may allocate to that person a maximum of five units in accordance with the number of nets used on a regular basis by that person during the period 26 September 1979 and 25 September 1984 (sic) with one unit being represented by one net used on a regular basis.Notes: . . . For the first time the concept of "subsequent primary use" of the boat in the fishery was explained in footnote 3, which provided (T30 p277):(3)Subsequent primary use includes the requirement that at least 15 tonnes of shark was taken by gillnets in the fishery in each of the years ending September 1985 and September 1986 and takes into account the type of other Commonwealth or State fisheries to which the boat or the licensee has access. In the application before the Tribunal in March 1989, Counsel for six of the applicants submitted that the Tribunal's powers were those which the respondent had had between 29 April 1988 and the date when Management Plan No. 18 was amended by Management Plan No. 20, i.e. 19 September 1988. If that submission had been successful it would have meant that the criteria to be applied were those which were published in November 1987. Those criteria contained no footnote requiring that "subsequent primary use" be demonstrated only by satisfying the requirement that at least 15 tonnes of shark was taken by gill nets in the fishery in each of the years ending September 1985 and September 1986. Mr Walton, on the figures at T38 pp316 and 321, satisfied that requirement as to the year ended September 1985, but not as to the year ended September 1986, which was the year in which he had the hand injury and the two lots of engine trouble as well as the damage to his nets.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 6 September 1999 the AFMA wrote to shark fishers explaining the implementation of ITQs (T23 p240). The letter concluded with the following reference to exceptional circumstances (T23 p242):Consideration of Exceptional CircumstancesThe final section of the AAP report concerns exceptional circumstances. To a large extent, the possibility of catch history being affected by exceptional circumstances in any one year has been addressed by the recommendation that only the best three of the four year period 1994 – 97 be taken into account. Persons who believe that their catch history has been affected by exceptional circumstances will have the opportunity to appeal when the catch verification process has been completed, quota has been allocated, and Permits varied or granted. If you are not satisfied with your quota allocation, you can appeal after a permit has been varied or granted, and the quota appears as a condition of the Permit. You will be notified of your full appeal rights when you receive your Permit and/or quota allocation. (emphasis added) By letter dated 29 September 1999, Mr Walton responded to the request that he lodge a completed claim for shark catch history to obtain his ITQ. He also explained how his best catch yield of approximately 7 tonnes in the specified allocation years reflected the contested Category B endorsement and further net reductions in 1991. He said were it not for the net reduction in 1991, it would have been 16-20 tonnes. That is supported by the graphs (T41 p383 and A2). Mr Walton also detailed his unceasing efforts to have past injustices corrected. In his careful and thorough submission he wrote (T41 p373):The 'B' class consequence did result in: With that submission Mr Walton included a number of supporting documents including the graph of his catch (T41 p383) and copies of the 1990 decision and the letter from former Deputy President Thompson confirming the interpretation he had placed on the 1990 decision: Mr Walton wrote (T41 p374):Today's quota allocation is the opportune time for AFMA to identify and address my exceptional circumstances and ensure that fair and equitable allocation be considered to my quota by taking into account that my catch for the year 1994 would have been in the vicinity of 16-20 ton, if I was initially left to fish in my capacity of an 'A' class fisherman.I have been advised that AFMA do have a special circumstances provision in place.I am requesting that you deeply consider the above and enclosed and if necessary contact me for any submission copy details you may require.The information I have provided in this letter is to assist you in determining a fair and equitable decision on the quota you allocate to my permit, without the necessity of going through another appeal process. On 21 December 2000 Mr Walton was advised of the making of the relevant decisions. He received a permit allowing him to take 8286kgs of Gummy Shark and 2746kgs of School Shark (T47 p408). That entitlement was calculated on the basis of verified catch history and did not take account of Mr Walton's claimed special circumstances.