Walsh v K.C. & W.L. Brain Pty Limited (No. 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

District Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Walsh v K.C. & W.L. Brain Pty Limited (No. 5) [2024] NSWDC 335
Hearing dates: 27-28 May 2024
Date of orders: 28 May 2024
Decision date: 28 May 2024
Jurisdiction:Civil
Before: Neilson DCJ
Decision:

I allow $1.20 per head for 1,100 ewes for 24 weeks, which, is a sum of $44,880.

Catchwords:

Quantification of claim made by Defendant for agisting sheep on Defendant’s property after it was sold to Defendant by Plaintiff – Plaintiff estopped from arguing his case on an alternative basis.

Legislation Cited:

Nil.

Cases Cited:

Nil.

Texts Cited:

Nil.

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Plaintiff – Alan David Walsh
Defendant – KC & WL Brain Pty Ltd
Representation:

Counsel:
Plaintiff – Mr Gunning, M.
Defendant – Mr O’Connor, J.

Solicitors:
Plaintiff – Rural Law
Defendant – Walsh & Blair Solicitors
File Number(s): 2020/00107856
Publication restriction: Nil.

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: The final claim made by the defendant is made formally in the pleadings. In the First Amended Cross-claim filed by the defendant on 14 May 2021 there is this claim:

"Ewe Agistment Costs Claim

39. In Breach of Clause 17 of the Dalree Sale Contract, following the settlement of the sale of Dalree to the cross-claimant on 22 March 2017, the cross-defendant failed to remove 1,000 ewes and their progeny from the property from 22 March 2017 to 29 December 2017.

40. From 22 March 2017 to about 26 - 29 December 2017, the cross-claimant incurred the agistment costs of maintaining the 1,100 ewes and their progeny because the cross-defendant failed to remove from Dalree in breach of the Dalree Sale Contract.

41. From 22 March 2017, 17 to 29 December 2017, the cross-claimant requested the cross-defendant remove the 1,100 ewes and their progeny from Dalree.

42. From 22 March 2017 to 29 December 2017, the cross‑defendant refused and failed to remove the cross-defendant's ewes and their progeny from Dalree.

43. As a result of the cross-defendant's failure to remove the 1,100 ewes and progeny from Dalree from 22 March 2017 to 29 December 2017, the cross-claimant suffered loss and damages.

PARTICULARS

(a) From 22 March 2017 to 29 December 2017 the cross-claimant incurred costs of $1.50 plus GST per week for each of the 1,100 ewes and their progeny which the cross-defendant failed to remove from Dalree, being a total cost to the cross-claimant of approximately $66,000 plus GST.

44. The cross-defendant is liable to the cross-claimant in the sum of approximately $66,000 plus GST for the loss suffered by the cross‑claimant as a result of the cross-defendant's failure to remove the 1,100 ewes and their progeny from Dalree from 22 March 2017 to about 29 December 2017."

  1. In the defence to the Amended First Cross-claim filed on 20 August 2021 the defendant pleaded this:

"18. The Cross-Defendant denies the allegations set out in paragraphs 39, 40, 41, 42, 43 and 44 of the amended cross-claim and states that:

'(a) The first request made by the cross-claimant for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walsh v K.C. & W.L. Brain Pty Limited (No. 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWDC 335
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Walsh, the plaintiff, and K.C. & W.L. Brain Pty Limited, the defendant. The plaintiff sold his property, including a flock of sheep, to the defendant. However, after the sale, the defendant continued to agist the sheep on the property for a period of time. The dispute centered around the quantification of the claim made by the defendant for the agistment of the sheep.

The court had to determine the appropriate compensation for the defendant's use of the property and the sheep. The legal issues involved the calculation of the agistment fee and whether the plaintiff was estopped from arguing his case on an alternative basis. The court needed to consider the terms of the sale, the duration of the agistment, and the fair value of the services provided.

The court found that the defendant was entitled to claim compensation for the agistment of the sheep. It calculated the compensation at $1.20 per head for 1,100 ewes for a period of 24 weeks, resulting in a total sum of $44,880. The court also held that the plaintiff was estopped from arguing his case on an alternative basis, as he had previously represented that the sheep were not part of the sale. The court allowed the defendant's claim for compensation and dismissed the plaintiff's counterclaim.

Orders

Orders of the court

I allow $1.20 per head for 1,100 ewes for 24 weeks, which, is a sum of $44,880.