Walker v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Walker v State of Queensland [2004] FCA 640

EILEEN WALKER AND ORS v STATE OF QUEENSLAND AND ORS
QG 6008 of 1998

ALLSOP J
17 MAY 2004
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QG 6008 of 1998

BETWEEN:

IN THE MATTER OF EILEEN WALKER, AGNES WALKER, JOHN WALKER JNR, HAZEL DOUGLAS AND PETER FISCHER ON THEIR OWN BEHALF AND ON BEHALF OF THE EASTERN KU – KU YALANJI PEOPLE

APPLICANT

AND:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND
FIRST RESPONDENT

COOK SHIRE COUNCIL
SECOND RESPONDENT

DOUGLAS SHIRE COUNCIL
THIRD RESPONDENT

WUJAL WUJAL COMMUNITY
FOURTH RESPONDENT

ERGON ENERGY CORPORATION LIMITED
FIFTH RESPONDENT

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED
SIXTH RESPONDENT

RUSSELL DAVID O’DOHERTY
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

ODETTE CATHERIN PHILLPOT
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

ARNFRIED BRENDECKE
NINTH RESPONDENT

VERNON JOHN GOODYEAR
TENTH RESPONDENT

TERRY ANN ROGERS
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

KEVIN JOHN BRANDT
TWELFTH RESPONDENT

ROBERT ALFRED HARLOW
THIRTEENTH RESPONDENT

ANDREW ALAN MARSHALL
FOURTEENTH RESPONDENT

RODERICK WILLIAM MCLEAN
FIFTEENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

ALLSOP J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 MAY 2004

WHERE MADE:

CAIRNS

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

(1)Leave be granted to the applicant to amend the Native Title Determination Application in the form exhibited to the affidavit of Marita Louise Stinton, sworn and filed 24 March 2004.

(2)Leave be granted to the applicant to file a settled clear version of the Amended Application with the Federal Court Registry. 

(3)Such an amended application and such a clear version of the amended application not be filed before 1 June 2004.

(4)The disposition of order 2 in the notice of motion filed on 24 March 2004 be stood over and order:

(a)     that Messrs Brandt, Harlow, Marshall and McLean file and serve within 28 days any further affidavits and submissions directed to the remaining parties and the interests they say support that position.

(b)     That within 14 days thereafter the applicant file and serve any affidavits and submissions on that issue;

The Court notes the undertakings of the persons identified as the Applicant given through their counsel that should a future Native Title Determination Application be filed on behalf of the Yalanji people over the areas presently subject to the interests of Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow, where any of those persons remain as holders of an interest in those areas, then the costs of the present proceedings incurred by any of Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow who remain may be recoverable from the Native Title applicant; and

(5)The question of costs be reserved; and

(6)Liberty be granted to Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow and the Commonwealth of Australia, through the Attorney-General or otherwise, to re-list this matter and argue that the costs of Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow to date or some of them should be paid by the applicant or others should any further claim be made for Native Title over the leasehold areas held by Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow.

(7)The Burungu Aboriginal Corporation be joined as a party to the determination application.

(8)Leave be granted to the Cook and Douglas Shire…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walker v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 640
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Walker v State of Queensland involves several applicants, including Eileen Walker, Agnes Walker, John Walker Jnr, Hazel Douglas, and Peter Fischer, who are acting on behalf of the Eastern Ku-Ku Yalanji People. They are seeking to amend their Native Title Determination Application and file a clear version of the amended application. The respondents in the case include various individuals and entities, such as Messrs Brandt, Harlow, Marshall, and McLean, who hold interests in the areas subject to the native title claim. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where the applicants sought several orders to facilitate the amendment and filing of their application, as well as to address the costs implications of the proceedings.

The legal issues before the court included whether the applicants should be granted leave to amend their Native Title Determination Application and file a clear version of the amended application, the appropriate timeline for these actions, and the implications for the parties involved regarding the costs of the proceedings. Additionally, the court considered the need to join the Burungu Aboriginal Corporation as a party to the determination application and to allow the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils to withdraw their notice of motion. The applicants also sought to reserve the question of costs and to obtain liberty for the respondents to argue for the recovery of costs in the event of a future claim for native title over the leasehold areas.

The court granted the applicants' requests for leave to amend their application and to file a clear version of the amended application, with specific timelines and conditions. The court also made orders regarding the filing of further affidavits and submissions, the joining of the Burungu Aboriginal Corporation, and the withdrawal of the notice of motion by the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils. The court stood over the disposition of certain orders and reserved the question of costs, while also allowing the respondents to seek recovery of costs if a future claim for native title was made over the leasehold areas. The matter was then stood over for directions by video-link.

The final orders of the court included granting leave to the applicants to amend their Native Title Determination Application and to file a clear version of the amended application by 1 June 2004. The court also made orders regarding the filing of further affidavits and submissions, the joining of the Burungu Aboriginal Corporation, and the withdrawal of the notice of motion by the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils. The court reserved the question of costs and granted liberty to the respondents to argue for the recovery of costs in the event of a future claim for native title over the leasehold areas. The matter was stood over for further directions.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Leave be granted to the applicant to amend the Native Title Determination Application in the form exhibited to the affidavit of Marita Louise Stinton, sworn and filed 24 March 2004.

(2) Leave be granted to the applicant to file a settled clear version of the Amended Application with the Federal Court Registry.

(3) Such an amended application and such a clear version of the amended application not be filed before 1 June 2004.

(4) The disposition of order 2 in the notice of motion filed on 24 March 2004 be stood over and order:

(a) that Messrs Brandt, Harlow, Marshall and McLean file and serve within 28 days any further affidavits and submissions directed to the remaining parties and the interests they say support that position.

(b) That within 14 days thereafter the applicant file and serve any affidavits and submissions on that issue;

The Court notes the undertakings of the persons identified as the Applicant given through their counsel that should a future Native Title Determination Application be filed on behalf of the Yalanji people over the areas presently subject to the interests of Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow, where any of those persons remain as holders of an interest in those areas, then the costs of the present proceedings incurred by any of Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow who remain may be recoverable from the Native Title applicant; and

(5) The question of costs be reserved; and

(6) Liberty be granted to Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow and the Commonwealth of Australia, through the Attorney-General or otherwise, to re-list this matter and argue that the costs of Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow to date or some of them should be paid by the applicant or others should any further claim be made for Native Title over the leasehold areas held by Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow.

(7) The Burungu Aboriginal Corporation be joined as a party to the determination application.

(8) Leave be granted to the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils to withdraw the notice of motion filed by them on 4 May 2004.

(9) Save for those orders made, the notice of motion of the applicant dated and filed 24 March 2004 be dismissed.

(10) The matter be stood over for directions by video-link to Friday, 9 July 2004 at 10.15am.

(11) Liberty to apply on two days’ notice.

Background

Background to the litigation

Eileen Walker, Agnes Walker, John Walker Jnr, Hazel Douglas, and Peter Fischer, on their own behalf and on behalf of the Eastern Ku-Ku Yalanji People, filed a Native Title Determination Application against the State of Queensland. The applicants sought amendments to the application to include additional parties and to clarify certain legal and factual issues. The application was contested by several parties, including Messrs Brandt, Harlow, Marshall, and McLean, who held interests in the areas subject to the native title claim. The Cook and Douglas Shire Councils also filed a notice of motion to intervene in the proceedings. The case involved complex issues of native title, land interests, and procedural requirements under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth).

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia in the form of a notice of motion filed by the applicants on 24 March 2004. The applicants sought various orders, including leave to amend their application, to file a clear version of the amended application, and to join additional parties to the determination application. The respondents, including Messrs Brandt, Harlow, Marshall, McLean, and the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils, filed responses to the notice of motion. The court heard the matter on the papers filed and made several orders, including granting leave for the applicants to amend and refile their application, reserving the question of costs, and dismissing the notice of motion filed by the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils. The matter was stood over for further directions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ALLSOP J
Issues
1. Whether leave should be granted to the applicant to amend the Native Title Determination Application.
2. Whether leave should be granted to the applicant to file a settled clear version of the Amended Application with the Federal Court Registry.
3. Whether the amended application and clear version should be filed before 1 June 2004.
4. Whether the disposition of order 2 in the notice of motion filed on 24 March 2004 should be stood over.
5. Whether the question of costs should be reserved.
6. Whether liberty should be granted to Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow, and the Commonwealth of Australia to re-list the matter to argue for costs reimbursement.
7. Whether the Burungu Aboriginal Corporation should be joined as a party to the determination application.
8. Whether leave should be granted to the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils to withdraw the notice of motion filed on 4 May 2004.
9. Whether, save for those orders made, the notice of motion of the applicant dated and filed 24 March 2004 should be dismissed.
10. Whether the matter should be stood over for directions by video-link to Friday, 9 July 2004 at 10.15am.

Held
1. Leave should be granted to the applicant to amend the Native Title Determination Application in the form exhibited to the affidavit of Marita Louise Stinton, sworn and filed 24 March 2004.
2. Leave should be granted to the applicant to file a settled clear version of the Amended Application with the Federal Court Registry.
3. Such an amended application and such a clear version of the amended application should not be filed before 1 June 2004.
4. The disposition of order 2 in the notice of motion filed on 24 March 2004 should be stood over.
5. The question of costs should be reserved.
6. Liberty should be granted to Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow, and the Commonwealth of Australia to re-list the matter to argue for costs reimbursement.
7. The Burungu Aboriginal Corporation should be joined as a party to the determination application.
8. Leave should be granted to the Cook and Douglas Shire Councils to withdraw the notice of motion filed on 4 May 2004.
9. Save for those orders made, the notice of motion of the applicant dated and filed 24 March 2004 should be dismissed.
10. The matter should be stood over for directions by video-link to Friday, 9 July 2004 at 10.15am.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ALLSOP J

The Federal Court granted leave for the applicant to amend the Native Title Determination Application in accordance with the affidavit of Marita Louise Stinton. The Court also allowed the filing of a settled clear version of the amended application but deferred its filing to a date after 1 June 2004 to allow further proceedings and submissions. Regarding the disposition of order 2, the Court stood it over, allowing time for Messrs Brandt, Harlow, Marshall and McLean to file and serve any further affidavits and submissions, followed by similar submissions from the applicant. The Court noted the undertakings of the applicants regarding cost recovery should a future Native Title Determination Application be filed over the leasehold areas. The Court reserved the question of costs, allowing Messrs Brandt, Marshall, McLean and Harlow, and the Commonwealth of Australia the liberty to re-list the matter to argue for costs reimbursement. The Burungu Aboriginal Corporation was joined as a party to the determination application. The Cook and Douglas Shire Councils were granted leave to withdraw their notice of motion filed on 4 May 2004. The Court dismissed the notice of motion filed on 24 March 2004, except for the orders explicitly made. The matter was stood over for further directions by video-link. The Court emphasised the importance of allowing all parties an opportunity to present their positions and the flexibility required in complex Native Title cases.