WALKER v POLICE
Magistrates Appeal
Mullighan J
The appellant was charged on information that on 16th February 1997 at Elizabeth North he indecently assaulted a young girl, aged 8 years, whom I shall refer to as “the girl”. He pleaded not guilty and the matter came to trial at the Magistrates Court at Elizabeth on 14th August 1997. The trial continued from time to time thereafter and was completed on 12th February 1988. The learned Magistrate found the appellant guilty as charged. He was convicted and sentenced to imprisonment for nine months. He appeals against the conviction but not the sentence.
At the time of the trial the girl was aged eight years. She was born on 31st March 1989. In February 1997 she lived with her mother, the defacto husband of the mother, two brothers and a sister and an uncle who is the brother of the mother in a house at Elizabeth North. The appellant also lived with that family. He is the stepfather of the mother but the father of the man I have referred to as the uncle. In order to preserve the anonymity of the child, I shall refer to the relevant family members as the mother, the husband, the uncle and the brothers and the sister. The sister was aged 6 years and the brothers were aged 4 years and 1 year respectively in February 1997. The appellant and the brother moved into the house in November 1996 and they occupied a caravan at the rear of the premises. The mother and the husband occupied a bedroom. The brothers also slept in that room and the two girls occupied another bedroom.
On the day in question all of the family went to the Myer Centre in the City. The mother worked there as a cleaner. The family went to Dazzleland and when the mother commenced work at about 4.45 pm, the others went home. The appellant and the uncle went to a hotel about 500 metres from the home leaving the husband with the children. The mother arrived home at about 9.30 pm. The children were in bed. The appellant returned from the hotel at about 10.15 pm. The mother and the husband went to the hotel room leaving the appellant to mind the children. She claimed that she spent some time with the appellant beforehand to satisfy herself that he was not so intoxicated as not to be able to care for the children. Having done so, she and the husband left the house at 11.15 pm. At that time the appellant was in the lounge room watching television.
At the hotel the mother and the husband met up with the uncle and they played poker machines until closing time at about midnight. The mother did not consume alcohol. Upon returning home about twenty minutes later, they found the light and television on in the lounge room but the appellant was not there. They saw him on the girl’s bed. He was lying…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Walker v Police No. Scgrg-98-368 Judgment No. S6717 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6717
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Magistrate's decision to accept the child's testimony and other witness accounts was supported by the evidence. The child's explanation of being asleep yet aware of the assault was clarified during re-examination and did not undermine her credibility. The court also noted that the appellant's level of intoxication, as evidenced by his interaction with the police, did not meet the threshold for involuntariness. The admission of the police interview was upheld as there was no objection to its admissibility. Finally, the court concluded that the Magistrate appropriately considered the need for corroboration, finding it in the observations of the mother and uncle, and thus affirmed the conviction. The appeal was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi