Walker, in the matter of Plumbfirst Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Walker, in the matter of Plumbfirst Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2023] FCA 441  

File number: NSD 390 of 2023
Judgment of: CHEESEMAN J
Date of judgment: 8 May 2023
Date of publication of reasons: 9 May 2023
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – application under s 439A(6) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to extend the convening period for second creditors meeting and related orders – whether basis for extension and estimate of time required is reasonable – whether any material prejudice – whether in best interests of creditors and the companies – whether public interest is served in averting insolvency – Held: Application granted.
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 439A(5), 439A(6), 447A

Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016 (Cth) s 75-225   

Cases cited:

Crawford, in the matter of North Queensland Heavy Haulage Services Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2017] FCA 635

Farnsworth v About Life Pty Ltd (Administrator Appointed), in the matter of About Life Pty Limited (Administrator Appointed) [2019] FCA 11

In the matter of Harrisons Pharmacy Pty Limited (Administrators Appointed) (Receivers And Managers Appointed) [2013] FCA 458

Re Riviera Group Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 585

Silvia, in the matter of Austcorp Group Limited (Administrators Appointed) [2009] FCA 636

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 41
Date of hearing: 8 May 2023
Counsel for Plaintiff: Mr M Rose
Solicitor for Plaintiff: King & Wood Mallesons

 

ORDERS

NSD 390 of 2023
 IN THE MATTER OF PLUMBFIRST PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) ACN: 606 165 173

ALAN LEE WALKER AND GLENN IAN LIVINGSTONE IN THEIR CAPACITIES AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF PLUMBFIRST PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) ACN 606 165 173

Plaintiff

ORDER MADE BY:

CHEESEMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 MAY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Originating Process be made returnable instanter.

Extension of Convening Period

2.Pursuant to s 439A(6) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the convening period within which the plaintiffs must convene the second meeting of creditors of Plumbfirst Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) and each of the companies listed in the Schedule (together, including Plumbfirst Pty Ltd, the Companies) under s 439A of the Act (Second Meeting) be extended from 11 May 2023 to 10 August 2023.

3.Pursuant to s 447A(1) of the Act, Part 5.3A of the Act is to operate such that the Second Meeting may be held at any time during, or within five business days after the end of, the convening period as extended by paragraph 2 above, notwithstanding the provisions of s 439A(2) of the Act.

Service and Notices

4.The plaintiffs, within seven business days of making these orders, are to take all reasonable steps to give notice of the orders to the Companies’ creditors (including the persons claiming to be creditors), by means of a circular:

(a)to be sent by email transmission to creditors for whom the plaintiffs have a current email address; or

(b)to be sent by ordinary post to creditors for whom…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walker, in the matter of Plumbfirst Pty Ltd (Administrators... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 441
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrators of Plumbfirst Pty Ltd and its related entities sought an extension of the convening period for a second creditors meeting and related orders under section 439A(6) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The Companies had been placed into administration due to financial difficulties attributed to increased operational costs, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the expenses associated with establishing a business in New South Wales. The Administrators argued that the additional time would enable them to complete a thorough expression of interest campaign for the potential sale of the business as a going concern, thereby maximizing the return for creditors.

The court had to determine whether the basis for the extension and the estimated time required were reasonable, whether there would be any material prejudice to creditors, whether the extension was in the best interests of the creditors and the companies, and whether the public interest would be served in averting insolvency. The court found that the Administrators' rationale for the extension was sound and in line with established jurisprudence. Given the Companies' financial status, with approximately $32.8 million in liabilities and $3.26 million in current assets, the extension was deemed necessary to complete the EOI process and potentially achieve a better outcome for creditors.

The court granted the application for an extension of the convening period, allowing the Administrators more time to complete their investigations and facilitate a potential sale of the business. The court also ordered that the Administrators' costs of the application be treated as costs of the administration and be paid from the Companies' assets. This decision ensures that the Administrators can pursue the most beneficial path for the creditors, while also considering the broader implications for the Companies and the public interest.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Originating Process be made returnable instanter.

Extension of Convening Period

2. Pursuant to s 439A(6) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the convening period within which the plaintiffs must convene the second meeting of creditors of Plumbfirst Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) and each of the companies listed in the Schedule (together, including Plumbfirst Pty Ltd, the Companies) under s 439A of the Act (Second Meeting) be extended from 11 May 2023 to 10 August 2023.

3. Pursuant to s 447A(1) of the Act, Part 5.3A of the Act is to operate such that the Second Meeting may be held at any time during, or within five business days after the end of, the convening period as extended by paragraph 2 above, notwithstanding the provisions of s 439A(2) of the Act.

Service and Notices

4. The plaintiffs, within seven business days of making these orders, are to take all reasonable steps to give notice of the orders to the Companies’ creditors (including the persons claiming to be creditors), by means of a circular:

(a) to be sent by email transmission to creditors for whom the plaintiffs have a current email address; or

(b) to be sent by ordinary post to creditors for whom the plaintiffs have only a postal address.

5. Pursuant to s 447A(1) of the Act, Part 5.3A of the Act is to operate such that the requirement on the plaintiffs to issue notices under ss 75-225(1) and 75-15 of the Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016 (Cth) be modified such that notice of the Second Meeting will be validly given to any creditors by, not less than five business days prior to the date of the proposed meeting:

(a) giving such notice electronically by email sent to the email address of any creditor (including persons claiming to be creditors) of the Companies for whom or which the plaintiffs hold an email address;

(b) sending such notice to the postal address or facsimile number, or otherwise as provided for by the Act or the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth), to any creditors not being a creditor referred to in sub-paragraph (a); and

(c) causing such notice to be published in The Insolvency Notices website located at: https://insolvencynotices.asic.gov.au/.

6. The following parties have liberty to apply on giving all other interested parties not less than 3 business days’ notice:

(a) any person who can demonstrate sufficient interest (including any creditor of the Companies) for the purpose of modifying or discharging any orders made pursuant to paragraphs 2 and 3 above; and

(b) the plaintiff, for the purpose of seeking any further extension of the convening period.

Costs

7. The plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to this application be costs and expenses in the administration of each of the Companies, and be paid out of the assets of the Companies.

SCHEDULE

A. Firstaction Group Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 139 666 247

B. Plumbfirst Elecfirst Comfyfirst NSW Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 639 243 360

C. Elecfirst Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 606 391 048

D. Comfyfirst Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 152 881 135

E. Bblautofirst Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) ACN 647 331 262

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011..

Background

Background to the litigation

Following the hearing of this application, I made orders in the form sought by the administrators. These are my reasons for doing so.BACKGROUND Since their appointment, the Administrators have commenced the usual array of investigations into the Companies’ affairs, the detail of which is traversed in Mr Walker’s affidavit. The core business operations of the Companies comprise trade services offered to residential and commercial customers and include plumbing; heating, ventilation and air conditioning; electrical; and vehicle maintenance. Each of the Companies provides different services, and / or operates in different geographic areas: (a)Plumbfirst operates in metropolitan Melbourne and Adelaide providing residential and commercial plumbing services; (b)Firstaction provides head office support services to the Group’s business including customer service, accounts, payroll and call operations and assistance; (c)Plumbfirst NSW operated in metropolitan Sydney and provided residential and commercial plumbing services from 2020 until trading ceased in January 2023; (d)Elecfirst operates in metropolitan Melbourne and Adelaide providing residential and commercial electrical services; (e)Comfyfirst operates in metropolitan Melbourne and Adelaide providing residential and commercial air-conditioning services as well as tendering for long-term construction contracts with commercial and government entities; and (f)Bblautofirst provides vehicle maintenance services to the other Companies and general vehicle repair services and roadworthiness testing and certification as a VicRoads licensed vehicle tester. Based on their investigations to date, the administrators attribute the financial decline of the Companies and the business to a significant increase in the cost base of the business which adversely impacted the Companies’ collective financial performance; the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic from March 2020 which had a direct impact on the business; and the lockdowns imposed in Victoria in response to the pandemic; and the significant expense of setting up the New South Wales based business of Plumbfirst NSW in February 2020, which business was then also adversely affected by the lockdown imposed in response to the pandemic. APPLICABLE PRINCIPLES Section 439A of the Act relevantly provides:(1)The administrator of a company under administration must convene a meeting of the company’s creditors within the convening period as fixed by subsection (5) or extended under subsection (6).Note:For body corporate representatives’ powers at a meeting of the company’s creditors, see section 250D. (2)The meeting must be held within 5 business days before, or within 5 business days after, the end of the convening period.(5)The convening period is:(a)if the day after the administration begins is in December, or is less than 25 business days before Good Friday the period of 25 business days beginning on:(i) that day; or(ii) if that day is not a business day–the next business day; or(b) otherwise–the period of 20 business days beginning on:(i) the day after the administration begins; or(ii) if that day is not a business day–the next business day.(6)The Court may extend the convening period on an application made during or after the period referred to in paragraph (5)(a) or (b), as the case requires.(7) If an application is made under subsection (6) after the period referred to in paragraph (5)(a) or (b), as the case may be, the Court may only extend the convening period if the Court is satisfied that it would be in the best interests of the creditors if the convening period were extended in accordance with the application.(8) If an application is made under subsection (6) after the period referred to in paragraph (5)(a) or (b), as the case may be, then, in making an order about the costs of the application, the Court must have regard to:(a) the fact that the application was made after that period; and (b) any other conduct engaged in by the administrator; and (c) any other relevant matters.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The administrators sought, and are entitled to, an order that their costs of this application be their costs in the administration.CONCLUSION Accordingly, for these reasons I made orders in accordance with the administrators’ application at the conclusion of the hearing on 8 May 2023.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The rationale which informs the administrators’ application is to complete a thorough EOI campaign with a view to potentially selling the business as a going concern and more generally, to use the additional time in a way likely to enhance the return for creditors. Both these reasons are well recognised as sound bases for extending the convening period in appropriate cases: see Re Riviera Group Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 585 at [13]; In the matter of Harrisons Pharmacy Pty Limited (Administrators Appointed) (Receivers And Managers Appointed) [2013] FCA 458; and Farnsworth v About Life Pty Ltd (Administrator Appointed), in the matter of About Life Pty Limited (Administrator Appointed) [2019] FCA 11.CONSIDERATION The present status of the administration of the Companies is explained in the detailed evidence relied on by the administrators. On a consolidated basis (and subject to adjudication) the Companies have:(1)approximately $32.8 million in liabilities, comprised of (i)approximately $1.6 million in outstanding priority employee entitlements owed to 151 employees;(ii)approximately $20.7 million owed to 106 unsecured creditors;(iii)approximately $1.6 million owed to secured creditors; and (2)approximately $10.1 million in related party debts; and (3)$3.26 million in current assets (excluding related party receivables). The Companies’ financier, Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (ANZ), discharged its general security on or about 30 March 2023, and the Companies do not have any secured creditors with a security interest registered in respect of all present and after-acquired property. The Companies remaining secured creditors derive their respective interests from various asset finance arrangements. The administrators have identified 128 interests registered on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR) against certain assets owned by the Companies, relating to 156 motor vehicles and 227 items of plant and equipment. The administrators’ investigation in relation to these interests is ongoing and is anticipated to take up to three more weeks to complete. The books and records of the Companies indicate there are approximately 106 creditors of the Companies. To date, the Administrators have received informal proofs of debt from 23 ordinary unsecured creditors, together claiming a total of $20.7 million (excluding intercompany loans), which have not yet been adjudicated. The administrators anticipate that further proofs of debt will be submitted. Based on the administrators’ investigations to date, the six largest creditors of the Companies (subject to adjudication) are:(1)The Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, which claims to be owed approximately $9.6 million by the Companies;(2)The State Revenue Office of Victoria, which claims to be owed approximately $7.5 million by the Companies, on a consolidated basis;(3)Tradelink Pty Ltd, which claims to be owed approximately $980,911 by Plumbfirst and Comfyfirst, collectively;(4)Australian Air Conditioning Distributors Pty Limited, which claims to be owed approximately $852,078 by Firstaction;(5)Metal Manufacturers Pty Ltd, which claims to be owed approximately $372,772 by the Companies; and (6)ANZ, which claims to be owed approximately $121,035 by Firstaction.