Walker and Moloney v CBA Corporate Services (NSW) Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Walker and Moloney v CBA Corporate Services (NSW) Pty Limited

[2012] FCA 328

Citation: Walker and Moloney v CBA Corporate Services (NSW) Pty Limited [2012] FCA 328
Parties:

PETER WALKER AND GREGORY MOLONEY IN THEIR CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATORS OF ZYX LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED (FORMERLY A.B.C. LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED) (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 079 736 664 AND OF THE COMPANIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 1 and ZYX LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED (FORMERLY A.B.C. LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED) (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 079 736 664 AND THE COMPANIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 1 v CBA CORPORATE SERVICES (NSW) PTY LIMITED ABN 25 072 765 434 AND THE COMPANIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 2

File numbers: NSD 1500 of 2011
NSD 496 of 2012
Judge: NICHOLAS J
Date of judgment: 5 April 2012
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – application for extension of time under s 588FF(3)(b) of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) – whether appropriate to grant extension and if so for how long – relevant considerations

CORPORATIONS – application pursuant to s 459A of the Act for order that companies already the subject of voluntary winding up be wound up in insolvency – where sole purpose for seeking such order is to enable liquidators to rely upon s 588FJ – relevant considerations

CORPORATIONS – whether necessary for party seeking order under s 459A to adduce evidence of insolvency as at relation-back day – relevance of lack of such evidence to exercise of discretion under s 459A

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 95A(1), 95A(2), 459A, 459P(1), 459R(1), 467B, 513A, 588FE, 588FF, 588FJ
Cases cited:

Ann Street Mezzanine Pty Ltd (in liq) v Beck (2009) 175 FCR 532
BP Australia Ltd v Brown (2003) 58 NSWLR 322
Carter v New Tel [2003] NSWSC 128; (2003) 44 ACSR 661

Commissioner of Taxation v Tull Reinforcing Pty Ltd (2006) 153 FCR 394

Green v Chiswell Furniture Pty Limited (in liq) [1999] NSWSC 608
New Cap Reinsurance Corporation Ltd (in liq) v Reaseguros Alianza SA [2004] NSWSC 787; (2004) 186 FLR 175

Date of hearing: 1 November and 2 December 2011, 23 February and 2 April 2012
Date of last submissions: 2 April 2012
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 83
Counsel for the Plaintiffs: Mr M Cashion SC with Mr J Baird
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs: Addisons
Counsel for the Defendant: Mr J Sheahan SC with Mr A McGrath
Solicitor for the Defendant: Henry Davis York

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1500 of 2011

BETWEEN:

PETER WALKER AND GREGORY MOLONEY IN THEIR CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATORS OF ZYX LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED (FORMERLY A.B.C. LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED) (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 079 736 664 AND OF THE COMPANIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 1
First Plaintiffs

ZYX LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED (FORMERLY A.B.C. LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED) (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQUIDATION)
ACN 079 736 664 AND THE COMPANIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 1
Second Plaintiffs

AND:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walker and Moloney v CBA Corporate Services (NSW) Pty Limite... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 328
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Walker and Moloney v CBA Corporate Services (NSW) Pty Limited, the plaintiffs sought orders under section 588FF(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for an extension of time to bring proceedings against the defendants. The plaintiffs also sought an order under section 459A of the Act to wind up the companies in insolvency, as they were already subject to voluntary winding up. The dispute arose from the financial dealings between the Banks and the ABC Learning Group, which included a Syndicated Multi Option Facility and a subsequent sale of assets.

The primary legal issues for the court to decide were whether it was appropriate to grant an extension of time under section 588FF(3)(b) of the Act, and if so, for how long. The court also had to determine whether it was necessary for the party seeking the winding up order under section 459A to provide evidence of insolvency as at the relation-back day and the relevance of the lack of such evidence in exercising the court's discretion. Furthermore, the court had to consider the relevant factors in deciding whether to make the winding up order under section 459A.

The court granted the Liquidators an extension of time under section 588FF(3)(b) of the Act until 15 June 2012 to bring proceedings against the defendants. The court found that the Liquidators had not adequately explained the delay in commencing proceedings and that the Banks had not suffered significant prejudice as a result of the delay. The court did not consider it necessary to make an additional order regarding the time limit for proceedings under section 588FJ of the Act. In relation to the winding up order under section 459A, the court held that it was not necessary for the Liquidators to provide evidence of insolvency as at the relation-back day, as the focus should be on the companies' insolvency at the date the application was filed and at the date of the hearing. The court granted the winding up order, appointed the plaintiffs as joint liquidators, and dispensed with the requirements to advertise, publish, and serve notices of the application under sections 465A, 470(2)(b), and 467(3)(b) of the Act.

In conclusion, the court granted the Liquidators an extension of time under section 588FF(3)(b) of the Act and made a winding up order under section 459A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court also appointed the plaintiffs as joint liquidators and dispensed with certain procedural requirements. The first plaintiff's costs and expenses of the application were to be costs and expenses of the liquidation of the second plaintiffs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 588FF(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) the period within which application may be made under s 588FF(1) of the Act for an order against the defendants or any of them be the period ending on 15 June 2012.

2. The first plaintiff’s costs and expenses of this application be costs and expenses of the liquidation of the second plaintiffs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

1. Each of the second plaintiffs be wound up in insolvency pursuant to s 459A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act).

2. Peter Walker and Gregory Moloney be appointed as joint liquidators.

3. The requirements to advertise or publish notice of this application under s 465A of the Act and Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 r 5.6, and to serve the application on the second plaintiffs and serve a copy of the order on the second plaintiffs, under s 470(2)(b) of the Act be dispensed with, pursuant to s 467(3)(b) of the Act.

4. The first plaintiff’s costs and expenses of this application be costs and expenses of the liquidation of the second plaintiffs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

As well as seeking orders under s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act in proceeding number NSD 1500 of 2011 the plaintiffs also sought, in the same proceeding, an order under s 459A of the Act. After the hearing of that proceeding concluded, it became necessary for the plaintiffs to commence the second proceeding, number NSD 496 of 2012, seeking the same order under s 459A as was sought in the first proceeding: see s 459R(1) of the Act which provides that an application for a company to be wound up in insolvency is to be determined within six months after it was made. The first proceeding was commenced on 5 September 2011 and it had not been determined within six months after it was made. The second proceeding was commenced on 2 April 2012. With the consent of all parties an order was made that the evidence and submissions in the first proceeding shall stand as evidence and submissions in the second proceeding. The defendants also made an admission that there had been no material change in the financial circumstances of each of the plaintiff companies since the date of the hearing in the first proceeding. FACTUAL BACKGROUNDDealings between the Banks and the ABC Learning Group The Banks provided to the ABC Learning Group funding under a Syndicated Multi Option Facility dated 10 December 2007 (the Facility Agreement) which was on an unsecured basis, supported by negative pledge arrangements, cross-guarantees and restrictions on dealing with assets by the ABC Learning Group. Total facilities provided under the Facility Agreement in three tranches were $1.430 billion, including $1.310 billion for Tranche A. The Facility Agent for the Banks was Commonwealth Bank of Australia Limited (CBA). On 28 May 2008 ABC sought the consent of the Facility Agent on behalf of the Banks to a proposed disposal of 60% of its USA interests pursuant to a Purchase Agreement with Morgan Stanley Private Equity dated 21 April 2008 for the price of approximately US$400 million (the US Sale). The consent of the Banks was required for the US Sale, as otherwise the ABC Learning Group would have been in breach of various covenants in the Facility Agreement. The Purchase Agreement was also conditional on consent being obtained. On 29 May 2008 CBA as agent for the Banks gave such consent on terms that provided for:·the delivery of payment directions for a total of US$385,230,000 to be paid directly to CBA by two payments upon settlement of the US Sale;·the Facility Agreement being amended to provide for a substantial reduction in the facility limit and the creation of charges over the ABC Learning Group. On 24 June 2008, a Security Trust Deed (the Security Trust Deed) was executed between 16 members of the ABC Learning Group as chargors and CCS as Security Trustee, providing for CCS to hold the certain securities on trust for the Banks. On 25 June 2008 CCS offered to the 16 ABC Learning Group companies which were party to the Security Trust Deed to release them from the Facility Agreement and enter into an Amendment and Restatement Deed (the Restatement Deed). On the same date the Restatement Deed was executed between ABC Learning Group and the Banks.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 27 October 2008 additional charges were granted by certain members of the ABC Learning Group to the Banks.Mr Moloney’s evidence Mr Moloney gave evidence that the companies in the ABC Learning Group were insolvent as at 2 June 2010 (the date the Liquidators were appointed) and 5 September 2011 (the date the first proceeding was commenced). The Banks did not admit the insolvency of the ABC Learning Group companies but made it clear in their submissions that, for the purposes of the present proceedings, they would not contest a finding of insolvency as at 5 September 2011 and at all material times thereafter. Mr Moloney gave evidence of the insolvency of the ABC Learning Group both as a whole and on a company by company basis. His evidence indicates that the Banks are still owed in excess of $833 million and that, allowing for asset sales which are yet to occur, the anticipated shortfall to the Banks is likely to be in excess of $800 million. Priority claims in the winding up amount to approximately $6.7 million and there are unsecured creditors (excluding the shortfall due to the Banks) of approximately $1.214 billion. The single largest unsecured creditor is Australian Executor Trustees Limited which is owed $600 million. Mr Moloney’s estimate of the overall deficiency of assets to liabilities in the winding up of the ABC Learning Group was approximately $2.19 billion as at 5 September 2011. Mr Moloney’s evidence does not deal with the solvency of the ABC Learning Group as at 6 November 2008 (the relation-back day) because, according to the Liquidators, insolvency as at that date is irrelevant to the application now before me. Mr Moloney has not yet formed a view as to whether the relevant transactions pursuant to which the Banks received moneys are voidable transactions under Pt 5.7B of the Act. Nor has he formed a view as to whether any of the moneys received by the Banks represented the proceeds of assets the subject of a floating charge which might be void as against the Liquidators in the event that s 588FJ of the Act applied. Mr Moloney gave evidence that any proceedings that may be brought against the Banks will give rise to complex factual and legal issues and will be costly to run. He also gave evidence that, at the present time, the Liquidators do not have the funds required to commence and maintain proceedings against the Banks. According to Mr Moloney, the Liquidators are presently in discussions with IMF Australia Ltd (IMF) with a view to having it fund any proceedings the Liquidators take against the Banks. IMF has already funded various public examinations which the Liquidators have conducted between December 2009 and July 2011. However, Mr Moloney says that IMF is not committed to fund any further action by the Liquidators at this time. Mr Moloney has also given evidence of difficulties encountered by the Liquidators in obtaining access to books and records of the ABC Learning Group. These difficulties are partly explained by the fact that the Receivers took possession of many documents which only became available to the Liquidators during the course of the public examinations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As I have mentioned, the Liquidators have not called any evidence addressing solvency as at that date because, in their submission, it is not a relevant consideration. The Liquidators submit that all they are required to show for the purpose of obtaining a winding up order under s 459A is that the companies against which the order is sought were insolvent at the date the application was filed and at the date of the hearing provided that there is a good reason why such an order should be made given that the companies are already the subject of a voluntary winding up. CONSIDERATIONExtension of time In support of their application for the extension of time sought, the Liquidators point to the complex structure of the ABC Learning Group. The Liquidators also point to the complexity of the relevant transactions, the problems involved in obtaining access to relevant books and records, and delays in securing funding in respect of the proposed proceedings. The Banks, in opposing the application, point to the fact that various people previously employed by the Banks have since left their employment and that others are likely to do so in the future. The Banks also point to what they say is the insufficient explanation proffered by the Liquidators for the delay in commencing any proceedings against them. I have had regard to what the Banks described as the prejudice that will be suffered by them if the extension sought by the Liquidators is granted. However, I am not satisfied that the Banks have been prejudiced in any significant way by the delay that has occurred to date. Nor am I satisfied that the Banks will be prejudiced in any significant way if the Liquidators are allowed until mid-June 2012 to commence any proceedings they may wish to commence against the Banks under s 588FF(1) of the Act. There is no doubt that the proceedings which the Liquidators are considering bringing against the Banks will be complex, time consuming and costly to run. Even so, it seems to me that by 15 June 2012 the Liquidators will have had sufficient time to conclude their discussions with IMF and to commence the proposed proceedings against the Banks if that is what they decide to do. I therefore propose to grant the Liquidators an extension of time under s 588FF(3)(b) to 15 June 2012. The orders sought by the Liquidators also included the following:To the extent that the period within which an application under s 588FJ of the Act is required to be brought within the period specified in s 588FF(3)(a) of the Act, an order pursuant to s 588FF(3)(b) of the Act that the period within which application may be made under s 588FJ of the Act for an order against the Defendants or any of them be the period ending on 5 August 2012. I do not think there is any reason to make such an order. Section 588FJ of the Act is not expressed to be subject to s 588FF(3) or any other provision to similar effect. There is therefore no need for any additional order to be made in respect of any proceeding brought under s 588FJ of the Act. Winding-up in insolvency