Waldon v Mowen Margaret River Estate Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Waldon v Mowen Margaret River Estate Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 871

PROCEDURE – security for costs – exercise of discretion – risk that cross-claimants may not satisfy costs order if cross-claim unsuccessful – cross-claimants would be shut out of litigation if order made – impecuniosity of cross-claimants arising out of act in respect of which relief is sought – evidence making it arguable that second cross-respondents joined with applicants in principal action in working against interests of cross-claimants – motion for security for costs refused

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 56
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1335

Federal Court Rules O 28 r 2

Equity Access Ltd v Westpac Banking Ltd [1989] ATPR 40-972 applied
Hambley WD & VD & VJ & Ors v Lewis [1987] FCA 708 cited

GRAHAM WILLIAM WALDON, WILLEM BEREND VAN DER LEEST, TERENCE KEITH PITSIKAS, ALEXANDER GORDON LEGGAT, JOHN YANNIS NTOUMENOPOULOS, WILLIAM IAN MCDONAGH, BREFNI BANKS, JUDITH ANN STEWART, OWEN DAVID FERGUSON, ANTONY LEAVERSUCH, NEVILLE KNUCKEY, LEO NTOUMENOPOULOS and JOHN RADUNOVICH v MOWEN MARGARET RIVER ESTATE PTY LTD, MOWEN GRAPE MANAGEMENT PTY LTD, MOWEN GRAPE MANAGEMENT PTY LTD, TROPICAL PTY LTD and ROSS MACLEOD
W236 of 2002

RD NICHOLSON J
21 AUGUST 2003
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W236 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

GRAHAM WILLIAM WALDON, WILLEM BEREND VAN DER LEEST, TERENCE KEITH PITSIKAS, ALEXANDER GORDON LEGGAT, JOHN YANNIS NTOUMENOPOULOS, WILLIAM IAN MCDONAGH, BREFNI BANKS, JUDITH ANN STEWART, OWEN DAVID FERGUSON, ANTONY LEAVERSUCH, NEVILLE KNUCKEY, LEO NTOUMENOPOULOS and JOHN RADUNOVICH
APPLICANTS

AND:

MOWEN MARGARET RIVER ESTATE PTY LTD
(ACN 087 694 166)
FIRST RESPONDENT

MOWEN GRAPE MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
(ACN 087 671 949)
SECOND RESPONDENT

TROPICAL PTY LTD
(ACN 053 108 946)
THIRD RESPONDENT

ROSS MACLEOD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

MOWEN MARGARET RIVER ESTATE PTY LTD, MOWEN GRAPE MANAGEMENT PTY LTD, TROPICAL PTY LTD, ROSS MACLEOD & SABLERIDGE PTY LTD
(ACN 057 031 660)
CROSS-CLAIMANTS

GRAHAM WILLIAM WALDON, WILLEM BEREND VAN DER LEEST, TERENCE KEITH PITSIKAS, ALEXANDER GORDON LEGGAT, JOHN YANNIS NTOUMENOPOULOS, WILLIAM IAN MCDONAGH, BREFNI BANKS, JUDITH ANN STEWART, OWN DAVID FERGUSON, ANTONY LEAVERSUCH, NEVILLE KNUCKEY, LEO NTOUMENOPOULOS and JOHN RADUNOVICH
FIRST CROSS-RESPONDENTS

STANTON PARTNERS AUSTRALASIA PTY LTD
(ACN 948 259 529), NEIL JOYCE & KEITH LINGARD
SECOND CROSS-RESPONDENTS

ROSABROOK HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 100 553 133) & ROSABROOK PTY LTD (ACN 100 553 240)
THIRD CROSS-RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

RD NICHOLSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 AUGUST 2003

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The second cross-respondents’ notice of motion dated 19 March 2003 be refused.

2.The second cross-respondents pay the cross-claimants costs on the motion.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W236 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

GRAHAM WILLIAM WALDON, WILLEM BEREND VAN DER LEEST, TERENCE KEITH PITSIKAS, ALEXANDER GORDON LEGGAT, JOHN YANNIS NTOUMENOPOULOS, WILLIAM IAN MCDONOUGH, BREFNI BANKS, JUDITH ANN STEWART, OWEN DAVID FERGUSON, ANTONY LEAVERSUCH, NEVILLE KNUCKEY, LEO NTOUMENOPOULOS and JOHN RADUNOVICH

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waldon v Mowen Margaret River Estate Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 871
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Waldon v Mowen Margaret River Estate Pty Ltd involves a motion seeking security for costs in a complex business dispute. The applicants in the motion are Mowen Margaret River Estate Pty Ltd and Mowen Grape Management Pty Ltd, while the respondents are various Growers and individuals including Mr. Joyce and Mr. Waldron. The court was tasked with determining whether the applicants could be ordered to provide security for the respondents' costs in the event the motion was unsuccessful. This determination involved considering the financial capacity of the applicants to meet such an order, as well as the interrelation and potential collusion between the applicants and the cross-claimants.

The legal issues before the court included the interpretation and application of relevant sections of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, the Federal Court Rules, and the Corporations Act 2001. Specifically, the court needed to assess whether the applicants were likely to be unable to pay the respondents' costs if the motion failed, as required by s 1335 of the Corporations Act. Additionally, the court had to consider the broader context of the litigation, including the nature of the relationships between the parties and the potential for collusion or misuse of the legal process.

In reaching its decision, the court found that there was an arguable case that the second cross-respondents were closely associated with the applicants and controlled by Mr. MacLeod. This association and control suggested that the cross-claimants could potentially be involved in any costs order. Furthermore, the court noted that the applicants' financial situation was precarious, with limited income sources and significant mortgage obligations. Given these factors, the court concluded that it was not appropriate to exercise its discretion in favour of an order for security for costs. Consequently, the motion was refused, and the second cross-respondents were ordered to pay the cross-claimants' costs on the motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second cross-respondents’ notice of motion dated 19 March 2003 be refused.

2. The second cross-respondents pay the cross-claimants costs on the motion.

Background

Background to the litigation

The motion is brought in reliance on s 56 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and O 28 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules. In addition, so far as concerns the corporate cross-claimants, s 1335 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) is relied upon. This latter section provides that it must be established by credible testimony that there is reason to believe that the corporation will be unable to pay the costs of the defendant.BACKGROUND CIRCUMSTANCES In June 1999 Mowen Margaret River Estate Pty Ltd (‘MMRE’) and Mowen Grape Management Pty Ltd (‘MGM’) entered into 15 Lease and Management agreements with various parties (‘the Growers’). The purpose of the agreements was to develop and operate a vineyard at Margaret River. The land had been purchased by Tropical Pty Ltd (‘Tropical’) and was to be transferred to MMRE. MGM was to manage the vineyard and the marketing. Each of the Growers leased an area of the vineyard which was to be managed effectively as one unit. The marketing was to be on the basis that the produce would be pooled. The Growers had the option to purchase half of the shares of MMRE. Prior to commencement, the project was developed by Mr MacLeod with the advice of Stanton Partners Australasia Pty Ltd (‘Stanton Partners’), Mr Joyce and Mr Lingard, Stanton Partners having been his accountant since around 1991. He dealt mainly with Mr Joyce. Stanton Partners was involved in planning and implementing the project and had a number of clients who wished to participate along with Mr Joyce and Mr Lingard. In early 2002, Mr MacLeod and two other people who were involved in the ongoing operation of the vineyard, namely, Mr Larking (a solicitor) and Mr Matthews (a financier) proceeded with a purchase of another vineyard with a recognised label (‘Rosabrook’). They arranged for MMRE or nominee to execute a contract for that purchase which they regarded as advantageous. Having entered into the agreement they then placed the proposal before the Growers who agreed to a proposal that the purchaser would be two new companies in which they, along with Mr MacLeod, Mr Larking and Mr Matthews, had an interest. The agreement was to the effect that the Mowen and Rosabrook wines would be sold through Rosabrook and MGM would manage both projects. Shortly after the settlement of the purchase it is said that Mr Joyce told Mr MacLeod that he should now agree to substantial changes in the agreements cutting MGM’s management rights and fees and removing a significant part of its equity. Mr MacLeod alleges that Mr Joyce and Mr Waldron proceeded together against him. Dissident growers, including Mr Joyce and Mr Lingard, refused to proceed with the agreement for marketing through Rosabrook and terminated the management agreement of MGM. It is said on behalf of Mr MacLeod this occurred without proper cause and without observing the procedural requirements of the Lease and Management agreement.EVIDENCE FOR SECOND CROSS-RESPONDENTS Mr Joyce’s affidavit stated that he is, in addition to being one of the second cross-respondents, a director of the other cross-respondent Stanton Partners. His evidence was authorised on behalf of Stanton Partners and the third cross-respondents.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Shortly after the settlement of the purchase it is said that Mr Joyce told Mr MacLeod that he should now agree to substantial changes in the agreements cutting MGM’s management rights and fees and removing a significant part of its equity. Mr MacLeod alleges that Mr Joyce and Mr Waldron proceeded together against him. Dissident growers, including Mr Joyce and Mr Lingard, refused to proceed with the agreement for marketing through Rosabrook and terminated the management agreement of MGM. It is said on behalf of Mr MacLeod this occurred without proper cause and without observing the procedural requirements of the Lease and Management agreement.EVIDENCE FOR SECOND CROSS-RESPONDENTS Mr Joyce’s affidavit stated that he is, in addition to being one of the second cross-respondents, a director of the other cross-respondent Stanton Partners. His evidence was authorised on behalf of Stanton Partners and the third cross-respondents. In his evidence Mr Joyce asserts that the cross-claimants are closely associated with one another and are controlled by Mr MacLeod, being part of the ‘MacLeod Group’. Specifically it is stated:1. MMRE:1.1has as its directors Mr Ross MacLeod and Ms Kathleen Gay Arcus;1.2has as its secretary Mr Ross MacLeod;1.3its shares are all owned by another cross-applicant, Tropical Pty Ltd which in turn is owned and controlled by Ross MacLeod and Kathleen Gay Arcus;2. Tropical:2.1has as its directors, Ross MacLeod and Kathleen Gay Arcus;2.2has as its secretary, Ross MacLeod;2.3its shares are owned by Ross MacLeod and Kathleen Gay Arcus in equal shares;3. Sableridge Pty Ltd (‘Sableridge’):3.1has as its owners, Ross MacLeod and Kathleen Gay Arcus;3.2has as its secretary, Ross MacLeod;3.3its shares are owned by Ross MacLeod and Kathleen Gay Arcus in equal shares;4. MGM: 4.1 has as its director Ross MacLeod; 4.2 has as its secretary Ross MacLeod;4.3its shares are owned by Sableridge (as to 75%). Sableridge as stated above is wholly owned by Ross MacLeod and Kathleen Gay Arcus in equal shares, and Ocean City Investments Pty Ltd (as to 25%) which company is in turn substantially owned and controlled by Kevin John Matthews. Mr Matthews is an associate of Ross MacLeod in the Margaret River Project, the subject of this proceeding. In his affidavit Mr Joyce states that the cross-claimants are unlikely to be able to meet an order for costs in the event that the cross-claim is unsuccessful. The basis on which he makes that statement are knowledge which he obtained while acting as accountant for the cross-claimants over a lengthy period and other additional grounds referred to below. His additional grounds in relation to MMRE are that the only asset of this company is land transferred to it by Tropical, so that it has no source of income other than the rent payable under the leases between it and the Growers. However, such rents are committed to repayment of a mortgage to the Challenge Bank over the property which currently stands in the sum of $410 000. There is a dispute between the MacLeod Group and the Growers as to whether MMRE is only obliged to meet the interest component of the mortgage or is obliged to pay all of the rents so as to cover the interest and reduce the principal balance of the mortgage. Even if that is resolved, it is stated it is highly unlikely that the rental payments made by the Growers will generate funds sufficient to cover a likely costs award in the litigation. Given that, the MacLeod Group has an obligation to discharge the Challenge Bank mortgage by June 2003. MMRE is prevented from using the leased area (forming the bulk of the land in terms of value and area) as security for advance without the permission of the Growers. It is said the Growers are unlikely to consent to that because it would reduce the value of the Growers options to purchase MMRE shares, being options granted under cl 35 of the Lease and Management agreement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is a particular matter relevant to the exercise of the discretion and that is the arguable position that the second cross-respondents are closely bound up with and interrelated with the claims and cross-claims between the applicants and the Mowen Group as respondents. That is an important consideration to the exercise of the discretion. It is not necessary to make findings of fact on each of the allegations of the participation by Mr Joyce and Mr Lingard in the aggressive conduct against the Mowen Group because some if not all of those issues will fall to be made the subject of findings of fact in relation to the principal action. It is apparent, however, that for the purposes of this interlocutory application there is evidence making that position arguable. CONCLUSION In these circumstances I do not consider it is appropriate to exercise the discretion in favour of making an order for security for costs. As the motion therefore necessarily fails against the corporate cross-claimants it follows an order should not be made against the non-corporate cross-claimant. Accordingly, the notice of motion will be refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the evidence presented by Mr Joyce, a director of Stanton Partners and one of the second cross-respondents, who stated that the cross-claimants are closely associated with one another and controlled by Mr MacLeod, being part of the ‘MacLeod Group’. The court acknowledged that the second cross-respondents are closely bound up with and interrelated with the claims and cross-claims between the applicants and the Mowen Group as respondents. This is a significant factor in exercising the discretion regarding security for costs. The court found that there is an arguable position that the second cross-respondents are unlikely to be able to meet an order for costs in the event that the cross-claim is unsuccessful, based on Mr Joyce's evidence and the financial circumstances of the cross-claimants. Despite these findings, the court decided not to exercise its discretion in favour of making an order for security for costs, leading to the refusal of the second cross-respondents' notice of motion. The court ordered that the second cross-respondents pay the cross-claimants' costs on the motion.