Wade v SA Water

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Permission to Appeal)

WADE v SA WATER

[2016] SASC 172

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Hinton

9 November 2016

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - PROCEEDINGS TO OBTAIN COMPENSATION - DETERMINATION OF CLAIMS - APPEALS, JUDICIAL REVIEW AND STATED CASES - GENERALLY

Application for permission to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court from a decision of the Full Bench of the South Australian Employment Tribunal.

Mr Wade was employed by the Engineering and Water Supply Department, the corporate predecessor of SA Water. In 1991 he made a claim for compensation under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) (WRCA) for noise induced hearing loss. He was assessed at that time to have sustained binaural hearing loss of 14.7% and received a lump sum compensation.

In 2012, Mr Wade acquired a set of hearing aids and in 2013 undertook an audiogram which revealed he had 54.6% binaural hearing loss. He claimed the cost of the hearing aids from SA Water. SA Water rejected the claim. Mr Wade disputed the decision rejecting the claim in the Workers Compensation Tribunal. The President of the Tribunal confirmed the rejection.

Mr Wade appealed to the Full Bench of the South Australian Employment Tribunal. The appeal was dismissed.

Mr Wade sought permission to appeal to the Full Court pursuant to s 68 of the South Australian Employment Tribunal Act 2014 (SA), on grounds that the Full Bench erred in concluding that the President did not invoke a test for causation that was erroneous; erred in concluding that the President had provided adequate reasons for finding that the cost of the hearing aids was not incurred in consequence of the 1991 compensable injury; and that the Full Bench erred in concluding that the President had afforded procedural fairness.

Held:

1.       Permission to appeal is granted in part.

South Australian Employment Tribunal Act 2014 (SA) ss 3, 67, 68; Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) ss 32, 43; Return to Work (Transitional Arrangements) (Dissolution of the Workers Compensation Tribunal) Regulations 2016  (SA) reg 4; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 48, referred to.
Landmark Operations Ltd v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd & Ors [2009] SASC 185; Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZGUR (2011) 241 CLR 594, applied.
WorkCover Corporation v Sherriff (unreported, South Australian Supreme Court, Full Court, 1 October 1996, Judg No S5831); Transport Accident Commission v Hoffman [1989] VR 197, discussed.
Wade v SA Water  [2015] SAWCT 48; Wade v SA Water  [2016] SAET 23; Kirk v Industrial Court (NSW) (2010) 239 CLR 531, considered.

WADE v SA WATER
[2016] SASC 172

Civil

HINTON J.

Introduction

  1. In 1991 Mr Wade suffered a compensable injury in the course of his employment with the Engineering and Water Supply Department (the E&WS), namely, noise induced binaural hearing loss of 14.7%. In November of that year he received lump sum compensation in the sum of $9,459.45 for that injury under s 43 of the Workers Rehabilitation and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wade v SA Water and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 172
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Wade sought to appeal a decision of the South Australian Employment Tribunal, which dismissed his application for workers' compensation for the purchase of hearing aids. The case concerns the interpretation and application of the relevant statutory provisions governing workers' compensation claims, particularly the requirement to demonstrate a causal link between the compensable injury and the claimed costs. The Full Bench of the South Australian Employment Tribunal had previously dismissed Mr Wade's appeal, finding that the President had not erred in law or procedure in dismissing the claim. Mr Wade now seeks permission to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The legal issues in this appeal revolve around the interpretation of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA), specifically section 32, which requires that any cost incurred by the injured worker must be a consequence of the injury. Mr Wade argued that the President of the SAET had misapplied the test for causation and failed to adequately analyse the evidence of two medical experts, which he claimed established the necessary causal link. He also argued that the President had not considered his evidence about a previous hearing aid purchase in 2002, and that this omission constituted a breach of procedural fairness.

The Full Court considered Mr Wade's arguments and found that the President of the SAET had correctly applied the legal test for causation and had not erred in his evaluation of the evidence. The Court held that the President was correct to focus on the 2012 purchase of the hearing aids as the relevant frame of reference, rather than the 1991 injury. The Court found that the President had not misapplied the test for causation, nor had he failed to adequately analyse the medical evidence. Furthermore, the Court held that the President's rejection of Mr Wade's evidence regarding the 2002 hearing aid purchase did not constitute a breach of procedural fairness, as the evidence was not challenged by SA Water and its relevance to the claim was unclear. Consequently, the Full Court dismissed Mr Wade's appeal.

The Full Court granted Mr Wade's application for leave to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Court's decision was based on the conclusion that the appeal had arguable merit and that the issues raised were of sufficient public importance to warrant further consideration. The Court did not make any orders regarding the substantive appeal, as that matter was to be determined by the Full Court of the Supreme Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HINTON J
Mr Wade appealed to the Full Bench of the South Australian Employment Tribunal (the SAET).[3] He was unsuccessful. He now seeks permission to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court.[4] I determined that it was appropriate to list the application for argument. I am grateful to counsel for their assistance. I would grant permission to appeal. My reasons follow.[3] The appeal was heard by the SAET pursuant to the Return to Work (Transitional Arrangements) (Dissolution of the Workers Compensation Tribunal) Regulations 2016 (SA) reg 4(b)(ii).[4] South Australian Employment Tribunal Act 2014 (SA) s 68.The Full Bench decision Before the Full Bench Mr Wade argued that the President had erred in three respects. The first and second arguments were interrelated. Here the focus was upon the treatment, or lack of treatment, of the evidence of two ear, nose and throat surgeons, Drs Frayne and Tomich. Mr Wade’s case was that the evidence of these surgeons provided the necessary causal link between the compensable injury and the purchase of the hearing aids in 2012 such as to satisfy the requirements of s 32 WRCA. The treatment of the surgeons’ evidence by the President in his reasons was symptomatic, or at least highlighted, the first complaint, being that the President had erred in law in applying the wrong test to determine whether the cost of the hearing aids was incurred in consequence of the 1991 compensable injury. The second argument complained of inadequate reasons in that, in essence, no analysis of the doctors’ evidence as to the need for hearing aids in 1991 was undertaken. The third argument asserted a lack of procedural fairness in that the President rejected Mr Wade’s evidence of his having purchased a hearing aid in 2002, without providing any indication that he was contemplating doing so, in circumstances where the veracity of that evidence was not challenged by SA Water. As to the first argument the Full Bench decided:[5]Turning then to the approach taken by the President, he was of the view the cost of Mr Wade’s hearing aids was not a cost which was reasonably incurred in consequence of a compensable injury. His Honour specifically addressed Mr Black’s argument Mr Wade would have been entitled to the cost of hearing aids in 1991 had he purchased them then. He considered 2012 to be the relevant frame of reference, not 1991. With respect, we agree. …The President was correct to say he had to answer a question about causation. The phrase “in consequence(s) of” imports a causal connection. Assessing causation in law often involves making a common sense evaluation of the evidence as the President said. Mr Black acknowledged as much when relying upon Male v The Corporation (Target Australia).(citations omitted).[5] Wade v SA Water [2016] SAET 23 at [22]-[23]. The Full Bench noted that counsel for Mr Wade had complained that the test for causation adopted by the President focused on there being only one cause for the incursion of the cost of the hearing aids when it was more appropriate to adopt a test that accommodated multiple subsisting causes.[6] The Full Bench did not consider that the President had committed such error:[7]In having regard to Sherriff, the learned President did not apply an incorrect test and did not misdirect himself as to the law to be applied. In referring to Kooragang Cement, his Honour again directed himself to a passage which emphasised the importance of determining matters on their own facts. His Honour then made a common sense evaluation of the facts of this case to determine whether the cost of the hearing aids had been reasonably incurred. …(citations omitted).[6] [2016] SAET 23 at [26].[7] [2016] SAET 23 at [27].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HINTON J

Full text does not contain this section.